UM School of Social Work
About the School
Ongoing Online
 

Ongoing: Summer/Fall 2000 Summer/ Fall 2000
Other issues available online:
CONTENTS
* Features * Student News * Around the School * Alumni News *
Features:
Understanding the Relationships Between Poverty and Mental Health

photo

Director Sheldon Danziger and Associate Director Kristine Siefert

How long is five years? If you are a woman or child trying to cope with the daily stresses of depression, drug or alcohol dependence, mental illness, domestic violence, or hunger, five years can be an eternity. If you are a social work researcher gathering and analyzing data that will further understanding of these social ills, five years can pass in the blink of an eye.

Based at the School of Social Work and funded for the past five years by a grant from the National Institute of Mental Health (NIMH), the Social Work Research Development Center on Poverty, Risk, and Mental Health involves a core of social work faculty working with social work doctoral and masters students and faculty from other units at UM. The research agenda seeks to further knowledge of the relationships between poverty and mental health that can inform practice and policy.

The foundations for a program of poverty research were laid in 1988 when Professor Sheldon Danziger received funding from the UM Presidential Initiatives Fund, and later from the Ford Foundation, to establish a research training program on poverty, the underclass, and public policy. A second major thrust was added in 1995 when Associate Professor Sandra Danziger was appointed Director of the Program on Poverty and Social Welfare Policy (PSWP), a collaborative and multi-disciplinary effort of the Schools of Social Work, Law, and Public Policy. Also initially funded by the Presidential Initiatives Fund, PSWP conducts research that evaluates the effectiveness of welfare policies. The Social Work Research Development Center built on, but extended, these activities in 1995 when Sheldon Danziger, Professor Kristine Siefert, Dean Paula Allen-Meares and other social work faculty submitted a proposal to the NIMH to establish a research center on the relationships between poverty and mental health. The resulting five-year NIMH grant allowed the School to set up a separate research facility where collaborators come together in a positive research environment to share space and resources and, more importantly, to pool ideas, expertise, and findings.

Research Studies

Questions about the relationships between poverty and mental health motivate the Center's research agenda. Sheldon Danziger believes the Center has strengthened social work's mental health research capacity. "Prior to the establishment of the Center, the School had few faculty or doctoral students engaged in mental health research, and almost no externally funded mental health research. Center resources have built an infrastructure that encourages new and experienced social work faculty and students to reorient their careers and undertake research on poverty and mental health."

The range of studies conducted by Center faculty is broad, and the following is a small sample of current projects.

Domestic Violence

Associate Professor Richard Tolman thinks that his association with the Center has been an extremely positive experience and a great boon to his research efforts. He values the School of Social Work as a large institution with associated resources that allow faculty to pursue excellence, but he also sees some real advantages to the Center. "At the School, there is less focus on some issues. Here at the Center, we all work on common issues and interests and we share a common language. I have the chance to work with colleagues from other departments and other areas, as well as from the School. This is a very focused area, and the infrastructure supports our work on issues of central concern to social work. We are a community of scholars who share insights and suggestions on direction-the whole becomes greater than its parts."

Tolman's research focuses on violence against women and children, the effectiveness of interventions designed to change violent behavior, and the traumatic effects of violence on the well-being of victims. He is currently heading a team working on an NIMH-funded study that aims to identify factors that interfere with women's ability to find and keep employment, and thus leave welfare. This Mother's Well-Being Study assesses low-income, single mothers, a group that has been poorly represented in previous studies of psychiatric problems, physical disabilities, and domestic violence. Only recently have domestic violence statistics begun to include numbers of single women abused by ex-partners or non-cohabiting boyfriends, and there is little information on how physical and sexual abuse affect women's ability to work.

Tolman plans to evaluate the mental health needs of these women to ascertain if their needs are being met and if they have access to the services they require. "These woman face numerous barriers when they want to work," explains Tolman. "They can have trouble meeting deadlines or timelines imposed by the welfare system. I hope that our findings will help shape policy and practice, and will help us to give them the support they need." About 700 single mothers who were receiving cash welfare in the Detroit metropolitan area in September 1998 were interviewed by Tolman and his project team in the middle of 1999. Data gathering is now complete and the data are being analyzed.

Mental Health of Low-Income Women and Children

Professor Kristine Siefert, Associate Director of the Center, is currently involved in studies examining depression in low-income, single mothers and the impacts of food insufficiency on maternal and child health. Major depression is highly prevalent among these women, and is associated with significant impairment in social, occupational, and family functioning, as well as with increased care costs. Single mothers, mothers in poverty, and mothers with several young children are at high risk. Yet despite its prevalence, significant morbidity, and substantial cost, depression frequently remains undetected or inadequately treated.

Siefert's research team examined the relationship between social and environmental risk factors and major depressive disorder among low-income, single mothers. They found that social and environmental risk factors related to gender, race, and living in impoverished circumstances predict maternal major depressive disorder beyond traditional risk factors, and that their effects are cumulative.

One of the ways to reduce the risk of major depression in low-income women may be to eliminate household food insufficiency. Food and dietary insufficiency, to which poor women and children are particularly vulnerable, can have both immediate and long-term negative health and mental health consequences. Health and mental health problems include retarded growth, anemia, diabetes, respiratory disease, heart disease, schizophrenia, and affective disorders. Children classified as hungry or at risk of hunger are twice as likely to be described by parents and teachers as psychologically and academically impaired, making hunger a likely contributing factor in later aggressive behavior and school dropout in adolescence.

Yet, despite a long period of economic growth in the United States, food insecurity and hunger are a substantial and persistent problem; among 733 women sampled in a study by Siefert, Mary Corcoran, and Colleen Heflin from the welfare rolls in an urban county in Michigan, 25 percent reported that their household sometimes or often did not have enough to eat.

Siefert credits the Center with providing the support and resources she has needed to further her research. It has also enabled her to collaborate with other mental health researchers both inside and outside the University. "The Center has brought all of us together in one place to do collaborative studies, including many other disciplines with a social work focus. Another benefit is that previously there was little funding available to do this kind of research. The NIMH funding we receive has changed that."

Supported Education and Mental Health

Professor and Associate Dean for Research Carol Mowbray first began her studies on supported education in 1992 with an innovative community-based program in Detroit that helps people with psychiatric disabilities restart their education and their lives. The Michigan Supported Education Program (MSEP) was designed to provide assistance, information on school entry and financing, and support to people with mental illnesses who want to attend college or receive vocational training. This experimental program, which began in 1993, has expanded and become an ongoing service of the Detroit-Wayne County Community Mental Health Services Agency, serving approximately 200 enrollees each year.

There is some resistance to supported education in educational institutions and also among social workers, who may still hold negative attitudes about the potential for rehabilitation and recovery. Yet the results of Mowbray's research indicate the program's effectiveness: for those who participated, educational enrollments rose three-fold, from less than 10 percent to about 25 percent in about a year. Mowbray stresses the importance of education as both a normalizing process for people in recovery and as a way out of the poverty and dependency frequently associated with mental illness. Mowbray says she is "very pleased that a number of SSW doctoral students who have worked on MSEP have gone on to do their own research and/or dissertation work on psychiatric rehabilitation. Deborah McGivern, for example, just received an NIMH dissertation grant award."

The MSEP has met with such success that Mowbray has received two grants from the Center for Mental Health Services to replicate the supported education program in three other Michigan sites: Kalamazoo and Lansing, which have already begun providing services, and Flint, which is in the implementation phase and is planning to work with UM-Flint as its academic partner. Mowbray reports that grant-funded staff are also providing strategic planning and technical assistance to several other Michigan communities hoping to do their own local adaptations.

Assistant Professor Mark Holter, who had a one-year postdoctoral fellowship at the Center and is now a faculty member at the School and a faculty associate at the Center, is working with Mowbray on several related research projects. One is a long-term cost/benefit analysis of supported education, measuring outcomes for participants five years after completion. A second project is a study he and Mowbray are conducting on consumer-run mental health programs in Michigan. These programs are a fairly recent innovation, and few studies measuring their operations or effectiveness have been done.

Training Future Researchers

Projects sponsored by the Center on Poverty, Risk, and Mental Health have provided a rich training ground for doctoral and masters students through research assistantships, Center-sponsored dissertations, and field placements on Center projects. Daniel Rosen, a recent graduate of the Joint Doctoral Program (Social Work and Sociology), has benefited from his relationships with Center faculty. Rosen's MSW field placement was at a local adolescent health clinic, which then hired him. Through his employment there, he became interested in the relationship between partner violence and teenage pregnancy. Rosen, who was taking doctoral seminars at the time with both Danzigers, was sponsored by the Center to pursue his dissertation "Partner Violence in the Lives of Low Income Teenage Mothers." Working directly with Professor Tolman, Rosen interviewed thirty-five low-income, new teenage mothers and four social workers to examine the role of violence in the young women's lives and the factors that contributed to their pregnancies.

Rosen found this to be a difficult project. "It was hard to get past the easy answers as to why these girls had become pregnant. Hearing their experiences was painful, but it was also a wonderful and unique opportunity to learn." His interviews revealed that 64 percent of his sample, in their lifetime, experienced severe partner violence or sexual coercion in their intimate relationships. Thirty-two percent experienced severe partner violence in the last year. Those adolescent mothers who were in or had been in an abusive relationship had higher rates of mental health disorders than those never abused. Furthermore, this abuse negatively affected a teenage girl's ability to control decisions regarding contraceptive use.

Rosen is particularly proud of the fact that the clinic, which previous to his research didn't even have partner violence screening questions in place, now has intake forms with specific questions that can help social workers to identify patterns in abusive relationships and appropriate interventions. "I have been extremely lucky to be involved in an environment where I had the resources to discuss my findings and apply that knowledge at the clinic."

Although the Center's financial support has been very valuable, Rosen is equally grateful for the collegial support he has received. "The Center is a wonderful community where I have had the opportunity to work on interesting studies, give presentations, and bounce ideas off of co-workers, and I've had access to data that I can build a career on. One of the advantages of us all being in the same place is that everyone knows what the others are working on and there is always someone available when I need support. The attitude at the Center is 'What can we do to help you?' "

Now that he has completed his PhD, Rosen is continuing his relationship with the Center as a postdoctoral fellow. "I want to focus on research and writing articles, and am still heavily involved in two studies examining the links between health, mental health, domestic violence, and work among welfare recipients. Here I am treated as a colleague, and can continue to do meaningful research linked to practical solutions in the community."

Another student who highly values her relationship with the Center is Amelia Gavin, a joint doctoral student in Social Work and Political Science who first became involved with the Center in 1998 as part of her MSW field placement. Gavin's project began when the Family Coordinating Council of Muskegon County (FCC) approached the Center for help in identifying impacts of federal and state welfare reform in their community.

A collaborative initiative between the FCC and the Program on Poverty and Social Welfare Policy was set up. This initiative, called Vital Signs, assembled a database on aggregate indicators of well-being (such as school records, public assistance administration data, and county vital statistics), analyzed the information, and prepared a report for local human service executives to assist in their planning of new community initiatives.

In addition, Gavin helped design a survey of eighty-seven low-income families from six community agencies that covered such topics as economic needs, family functioning and social service support, health and wellness, and safety and stability of housing. The survey was administered by local social service agency staff.

Gavin was drawn to this project because it offered the opportunity to follow its progress from inception through to completion. "I was able to help organize the survey, train FCC staff in survey administration methods, analyze data to identify strengths and weaknesses, and then present the findings," says Gavin.

When she first started on the project, Gavin felt overwhelmed by her lack of experience, but she quickly learned how to apply the theory she had learned in class in a real world setting. She gives a good deal of credit to Sandra Danziger, her field supervisor and PSWP Director. "Sandy was a leading force on the project and her expertise was invaluable to me. I felt that she was my partner, and it was important for the community to see me as a member of a team rather than just a student."

The Vital Signs project was such a success that the FCC is planning to do a second round of the survey, this time focusing on mental health issues and taking over most aspects of conducting the survey. In the meantime, Gavin is working as a research assistant to Professor Siefert on research related to maternal and child health, an area upon which Gavin may base her dissertation.

When asked how her relationship with the Center has benefited her personally, Gavin praises the mentorship she receives. "I always have the feeling that a lot of people are looking out for me, people who are interested in my professional and academic development. I always have someone who cares." These are gratifying words for Sandra Danziger, who says, "We try at the Center to provide a climate that supports our students in their work and allows them to do their best."

Informing Public Policy

The Michigan Program on Poverty and Social Welfare Policy conducts interdisciplinary applied research on policy questions and translates research findings for public policy decision makers. Director Sandra Danziger is confident that the Program is meeting both its goals. "I believe we are fulfilling the mission of the program," says Danziger. "We have maintained constructive ties with state and local agencies, we have continued the University's involvement in state, local, and national welfare policy debates, and we have generated grants involving multi-school teams of faculty and students."

An important PSWP study involves multiple face-to-face, in-depth interviews with about 700 single mothers who were expected to leave welfare for work. (A portion of this study is described above in the section on Tolman's research.) The project is among the first in the country to develop longitudinal data on welfare recipients and how they are faring after the 1996 welfare reform. It has achieved a remarkably high response rate (nearly 90 percent) from participants in each of the first three rounds of interviews conducted in Fall 1997, 1998, and 1999.

Researchers developed questions to determine the prevalence of a broad range of barriers to employment, including labor market, health, and mental health problems. They found that 85 percent of the women had one or more barriers to employment at the first interview, and multiple barriers were common: 37 percent had two or three, 24 percent had four to six, and 3 percent had seven or more. Chances of being employed dropped dramatically as the number of barriers increased. "We didn't expect to find the prevalence of barriers that we've found," Danziger said.

Danziger reports that several papers describing study findings and implications for policy have been published and read widely around the country. "Internet sites have posted reports on it and the paper has been widely downloaded. Summaries have appeared in poverty advocacy newsletters and poverty centers across the nation."

In addition to the demand for the reports, PSWP is receiving numerous requests to replicate their measures and methods. The questionnaires used in the three surveys performed to date and a series of papers are on the School's Web site: www.ssw.umich.edu/poverty/pubs.html. "We spend a lot of time helping people to understand our measures and how to use them," says Danziger. "I see that as a good thing."

The Next Five Years

Much has been accomplished in the Center's first five years, but much remains to be done. Director Sheldon Danziger, Associate Director Siefert, and Dean Allen-Meares have received official confirmation that NIMH will extend funding through 2005.

The research agenda for the next five years builds on the Center's accomplishments to date and extends them in new directions. According to Sheldon Danziger, "Our goal is to deepen our understanding of the complex relationships among poverty and mental health so as to enrich poverty research and mental health research and to aid social workers and others who deliver mental health services to design and implement more effective interventions."

Suzan Alexander


 
About The SchoolProspective StudentsEnrolled StudentsAlumni & FriendsResearch and Public Service
home  site index  contact us 
© 2002 The Regents of the University of Michigan. This page was last updated on December 4, 2001.