UM School of Social Work
Research & Public Service
NIMH Center for Research on Poverty, Risk, and Mental Health
 

Understanding Mental Health and Service Use Among Racial/Ethnic Minorities

Description:
The primary goal of this project is to examine the understanding of mental health problems and barriers to mental health service utilization among racial and ethnic minorities, specifically African Americans, Latino Americans, and Asian Americans. First, I will examine the extent to which mental health constructs (and the symptoms and assessments used to define these constructs) are uniformly understood by racial and ethnic minority groups. To accomplish this task, I will examine commonly used measures of mental health and psychosocial well being for potential source of invariance and non-equivalence across racial and ethnic groups. I will examine equivalence in several ways: conceptual, metric, and structural equivalence (Hui & Triandis, 1985). Conceptual equivalence addresses whether the meaning of concepts used in assessment are thought about in the same way across individuals and groups. Two methodological techniques, qualitative interviews (through in-depth open-ended interviews and ethnographic procedures) and cognitive interviews (the use of probes to evaluate whether health related survey items are comprehended and interpreted in the same way across all groups), will be used for examining conceptual equivalence. Metric equivalence concerns the similarity of the relationships between observed items and their respective latent concepts or factors. Exploratory and confirmatory factor analytic techniques that examine similarities of the factor patterns and factor loading of a scale's items between groups represents metric equivalence. Structural equivalence refers similarities between the causal relationships of a research concept with two or more comparison groups.

Second, I will examine barriers to service use among racial and ethnic minorities. I am particularly interested in understanding why mental health services are under-utilized by racial/ethnic populations and what socio-cultural factors affect under-utilization. I propose to examine both structural barriers to service use and delivery, including poverty and lack of health insurance, issues of access and availability, availability and use of informal service and support systems, differential sources of referral and disposition, as well as attitudinal barriers, such as stigma related to mental health problems, mistrust of institutions, past experiences with discrimination, racial/ethnic identity, attitudes towards the usefulness and effectiveness of mental health services, and attitudes of friends and family members towards mental health services. The data are from two national studies that will be made available to the public in the coming year. The two studies are the National Survey of American Life, headed by Dr. James Jackson and the National Survey on Latino and Asian Americans is led by Dr. David Takeuchi & Dr. Margarita Alegria. I plan to combine data from the two national studies and compare socioeconomic status, mental health, and service use across African Americans, Latino Americans, and Asian Americans.

Key Findings:
Data for these studies are still in the field. As I prepare for these data, I have been working on several smaller studies that will provide me with preliminary findings from which I will base future hypotheses. First, I have been involved with several national and community data sets that include extensive measures of mental health, socioeconomic status, and have adequate representation of racial/ethnic minorities. These data sets include the National Household Survey of Drug Abuse (NHSDA), the 1995 Detroit Area Study (DAS), and the Young Women's Health Study (YWHS). For example, I have conducted research on prevalence of psychiatric disorders by socio-economic status among African American, Latina American, and White American single mothers (e.g., Spencer, Jayakody, & Kunz, under review; Rosen, Spencer, Tolman, & Williams, in press). I have also examined the role of discrimination and racial identity in health outcomes (Spencer, Williams, & Jackson, 1998). Additionally, I have completed a study from the Chinese American Psychiatric Epidemiology Study (CAPES) examining the role of discrimination in mental health service use. I plan to investigate the association between socioeconomic status, mental health status, and service utilization among this sample of Chinese Americans. I will continue to examine the effects of national origin, acculturation, discrimination, and cultural values and beliefs on both formal and informal service use.

Practice Implications:
By understanding the ways in which racial and ethnic minorities conceptualize mental health problems, the extent to which assessments are universally applicable, the potential causes of mental health problems that are most relevant to racial and ethnic minorities, and the barriers that prevent appropriate service delivery, I hope to be able to present a model for cross-cultural research and practice that is relevant and effective. Competent cross-cultural practice is dependent on models of service delivery that are congruent with the experiences of communities of color and use measures that increase the validity of diagnosis of mental disorders and the assessment of service utilization for these populations.

Policy Implications:
Knowledge of barriers to service use due to access and availability has implications for policies related to health care and health care insurance, including accessibility of Medicaid, coverage of mental health services, racial disparities in service use due to lack of coverage, and uninsured immigrant populations.

Investigator: Michael S. Spencer, Ph.D.
Funder: National Institute of Mental Health
Timeframe: January 2003 to January 2006
Project Contact: Michael S. Spencer, P.I., spencerm@umich.edu

Project Update as of 12/2002

Status: A K-01 Award to NIMH is currently under development

Conference Presentations:

Spencer, M. S. (1998, March). Race-related stress, identity, and mental health. Paper presentation to the 1998 Council on Social Work Education Annual Program Meeting, Orlando, Florida.

Spencer, M. S., Jayakody, R., & Kunz, J. (1999, November). Race, welfare, and psychiatric disorders among single mothers. Paper presentation to the American Public Policy and Management (APPAM) Annual Meeting, Washington, D.C..

Kunz, J. & Spencer, M. S. (2002, January). Welfare, race, and psychiatric disorders among single mothers. Paper to be presented to the 2002 Society for Social Work Research Conference, San Diego, CA.

Spencer, M. S., Rosen, D., & Tolman, R. (2001, March). Uncovering the hard to place: Mental illness and welfare status. Paper presented to the 2001 Council on Social Work Education Annual Program Meeting, Dallas, TX.

Muroff, J., Spencer, M. S., Neighbors, H., & Williams, D. R. (2001, January). Faces of fear: The socio-cultural meaning of anxiety. Paper presented to the 2001 Society for Social Work Research Conference, Atlanta, GA.

Spencer, M. S. (2002, October). Discrimination and mental health service use among Chinese Americans. Poster presented to the Jacobs Foundation Ethnic Variations in Intergenerational Discontinuities in Psychosocial Features and Disorders Conference, Zurich, Switzerland.

Spencer, M. S., Ruffolo, M. C., Rushton, J., & Bares, C. (2002, June) Examining Mental Health Service Needs in Pediatric Primary Care Settings. Paper presented to the National Institute of Mental Health Division of Services and Intervention Research Social Work Research: Moving Forward Meeting, Bethesda, MD.

Chen, J. & Spencer, M. S. (2002, June). Barriers to mental health service utilization among Chinese Americans. Paper presented to the Hawaii International Conference on Social Sciences, Honolulu, HI.

Forthcoming, In Press, or Published Papers:

Williams, D., Spencer, M. S., & Jackson, J. (1998). Race, stress, and physical health: The role of group identity. In R.J. Contrada & R.D. Ashmore (Eds.) Self and Identity: Fundamental Issues. New York: Oxford University Press.

Spencer, M. S., Kohn, L. P., & Woods, J. R. (2002). Labeling vs. Early Identification: The Dilemma of Mental Health Service Utilization Among Low-Income African American Children. African American Perspectives, 8 (2).

Rosen, D. Spencer, M. S., Tolman, R., & Williams, D. R. (2002). The prevalence of psychiatric disorders among low-income women. Health and Social Work.

Spencer, M. S., Jayakody, R., & Kunz, J. (under review). Race, welfare, and psychiatric disorders among single mothers. Cultural Diversity and Ethnic Minority Psychology.

Spencer, M. S., & Chen, J. (under review). Discrimination and mental health service use among Chinese Americans. American Journal of Public Health.

Spencer, M. S., Ruffolo, M., Rushton, J., & Bares, C. (under review). Assessing pediatric mental health needs and service use. Social Work Research.
 

About The SchoolProspective StudentsEnrolled StudentsAlumni & FriendsResearch and Public Service
home  site index  contact us 
© 2002 The Regents of the University of Michigan. This page was last updated on January 28, 2003.