UM School of Social Work
Research & Public Service
NIMH Center for Research on Poverty, Risk, and Mental Health
 

Social Risks and Psychological Health: Strengthening Mental Health Screening in Head Start Programs: The Family Development Project (FDP)

Description:
The Family Development Project (FDP) is a community-based research and service-learning collaborative between the University of Michigan School of Social Work, Department of Psychology and the Detroit Head Start programs. Building on the resources, knowledge, and skills of Head Start professionals and parents, the project is centered on improving the mental health and mental health services for low-income, minority children and families of Head Start. In addition to our research objectives, the project has provided more than 4000 hours of community service through the School's graduate student field internship program and the University's Undergraduate Research Opportunity Program (UROP). Students work with Head Start mental health coordinators providing direct services to children and assist teachers in the classroom.

The project's research consists of several components. The first component of the project seeks to understand the conceptualization of mental health problems among Head Start parents and teachers. We utilize in-depth qualitative interviews to ask parents what preschool age children are like at their best, their worst, the origin of these problems, family, school, and community factors, and utilization of mental health services. The second component consists of large-scale quantitative analyses of Head Start enrollment data with the addition of project-initiated screeners for child behavior problems and maternal depressive symptoms. The third component consists of community-initiated projects that have emerged from our ongoing collaboration. These projects include: 1) a parent involvement and school attendance survey aimed at understanding barriers to parental involvement and bringing children to school on a regular basis; 2) a dance program aimed at enhancing children's physical and emotional development; 3) intervention program for selectively mute children; 4) a program for gifted children. These projects are developed through collaborations between UROP students, who are supervised by MSW student interns, and Head Start staff. The fourth component is development of a pilot intervention for mothers who experience depression. This pilot seeks to investigate the applicability and acceptability of an evidence-based, family intervention on maternal depression and parenting for mothers of school-age children with a sample of low-income, African American mothers of preschool children. The pilot will examine the critical components of the family intervention for this population and modify the intervention so that it is relevant, culturally competent, and best meets the needs of these mothers and their children.

Key Findings:
The following illustrate the key findings of our research:

  • Analyses of our qualitative interviews reveal inconsistencies in perceived help-seeking patterns between Head Start parents and teachers. While parents reported informal sources for seeking help with child behavior problems, teachers described more formal systems, including schools. However, parents and teachers similarly described contextual factors, including poverty, nutritional deficiencies, parenting skills, community cohesion, and neighborhood conditions, as the root causes for child behavior problems. Parents and teachers differed in their understanding of why parents do not seek help for mental health problems for their children. For example, parents were expressed concerns that they would be blamed for their children's problems if they were to seek help, while teachers felt that parent denied the problems of their children and therefore did not seek help.

  • Analyses of enrollment data are currently underway. To date, the data has been useful in describing our population. For example, our data reveal that about 90% of the families are of African American descent, 81% of the families in our sample are single parent households, 55% are teen parents, about 40% of mothers did not complete high schools, 88% of families are compliant with federal government poverty standards, and the average income for families is under $10,000. About one-third of the families have 3 or more children, 95% receive Medicaid, 8% of children have been lead poisoned, 28% are enrolled in Work First, 20% of children have a diagnosed or suspected disability, 67% of children were determined to be nutritionally at risk, 6% of families have a member who is addicted or abuses substances, and at least 5% have a parent who is involved with the criminal justice system.

  • Of the child behavior problems investigated, both parents and teachers reported high levels of hyperactivity, attention problems, and social maturity. Parents reported significantly higher levels of problems than teachers. Similarly, aggressive behaviors were reported at the lowest levels by both parents and teachers. Teachers also reported low levels of anxious and depressed behaviors among children.

  • Much has been learned through the collaborative, community-based process. The investigators have learned about the historical mistrust of community agencies like Head Start towards university researchers and their dissatisfaction with traditional models of research. Rather models of research that is responsive to the needs of staff and of tangible benefits to the children were demanded.

  • We have also examined the effect of stigma related to mental health problems among children, particularly children of African American descent. Parents and teachers expressed concerns over labeling children with mental health problems. The concern that these labels would follow children throughout their educational careers and further limit their opportunities, over and above the limited opportunities these children would experience because due to race and their low income status, was a concern.

Practice Implications:

  • The results of our research has been used to provide feedback to Head Start mental health coordinators about the mental health problems that are most prevalent in classrooms. Coordinators are able to use this information to follow up with teachers and for making referrals to services in the community.

  • Data from our screeners have also been used to develop parenting tips and strategies for Head Start families. Our strategy sheets have been distributed to families whose children scored in the upper quartile on our child behavior screener. The strategy sheets have also been made available to parents and teachers throughout the program and are available on our website.

  • We have been able to provide consultation to mental health coordinators and teachers through our presence in Head Start classrooms. In addition to providing consultation as part of our regularly scheduled meetings with the coordinators, students report back on activities in the classroom and the investigators are able to provide strategies for working with children exhibiting specific problems.

Policy Implications:

  • Our screening tools have been incorporated as part of Head Start's regular enrollment procedures. Our child behavior screen has been utilized in the Detroit Public Schools and New Saint Paul Head Start programs, serving nearly 2000 children in the Metro Detroit area. This year, our screen for maternal depressive symptoms is being used by the Detroit Public Schools Head Start program. We also collected child behavior screens from teachers for children who scored in the upper quartile on the initial parent report. This provides greater accuracy in identifying children, flags children experiencing difficulties in two domains (home and school), which has greater predictive validity for problems, and allows the project to more effectively design and implement referral procedures.

  • Prior to our collaboration with the Detroit Public Schools (DPS), children's enrollment data were not kept electronically. This presented a major problem in terms of generating reports required by the federal government and limited DPS's ability to use the information for planning and development. In the past year, we have worked with DPS to develop an Access database for their enrollment data. The database also includes our screeners, as well as commonly used reports that can be quickly generated by DPS administrators.

  • Recently, our research was cited as part of DPS's testimony to the state legislature to support the need for social work services in DPS system. The proposed budget had recommended deep cuts for social work services, but those funds were at least partially reinstated as a result of the testimony.

Investigators: Michael S. Spencer, Ph.D. and Laura P. Kohn-Wood, Ph.D.
Funder: W. K. Kellogg Foundation Global Program on Youth
Timeframe: October 2000 to October 2004
Funder: Edward Ginsberg Center for Community-Service Learning
Timeframe: June 2002 to June 2003

Participating Organizations:
Detroit Public Schools Head Start
New St. Paul Tabernacle Head Start Agency
City of Detroit Department of Human Service

Project Contact:
Michael S. Spencer, P.I., spencerm@umich.edu
Laura P. Kohn-Wood, lpkohn@umich.edu
Stacey Teller, Project Manager, steller@umich.edu

Project Update as of 10/2002:

Status:

  • Qualitative data collection and analysis completed. Manuscript in preparation for submission to the Journal of Behavioral Health Services and Research.

  • Statistical analysis of enrollment data and mental health screen from 2001-2002 academic year in progress.

  • Access database for DPS completed and implemented.

  • Data collection and entry for 2002-2003 enrollment data and mental health screen in progress, including our maternal depressive symptoms screener (CES-D).

  • Student-led projects on parental involvement, school attendance, selective mutism, dance movement, and gifted students in progress.

  • A pilot project for developing an intervention for maternal depression was submitted as part of an NIMH proposal to establish a developing center for psychosocial rehabilitation.

Conference Presentations:
Spencer, M. S., Kohn L. P., Teller, S. L., Rush-Keli, J., Akakpo T., & Ludwa A. (2002, May) The Family Development Project: University of Michigan-Detroit Head Start Partnership. Poster presented to the 6th Annual Community-Campus Partnerships for Health, Miami, FL.

Kohn, L. P., Spencer M. S., Teller, S. L., Cooke, S., & Celaya A. K. (2002, March). The Family Development Project: Improving Mental Health Services in Detroit Head Start. Poster presented to the 15th Annual Research Conference, A System of Care for Children's Mental Health: Expanding the Research Base, Tampa, FL.

Spencer, M. S., & Kohn, L. P. (2001, August). The Family Development Project: Integrating community-based research and academic service learning. Paper presented to the 2001 American Psychological Association Annual Conference, San Francisco, CA.

Kohn, L. P., Spencer, M. S., Gutierrez, L., & Teller, S. L. (2002, October). The Detroit Initiative-Family Development Project: Learning about diversity through academic service learning. Fourth Biennial Association of American Colleges and Universities Conference, St. Louis, Missouri.

Publications:
Kohn, L. P., Spencer, M. S., Teller, S. L., McCall, J., & Jankowski, R. (In progress). Parent perceptions of preschooler's emotional and behavioral problems: Implications for service utilization. Journal of Behavioral Health Sciences & Research, anticipated October 2002.

Spencer, M. S., Kohn L. P., & Barbarin, O. (In progress) Integrating community-based research and academic service-learning: Improving mental health services for children in Head Start. Journal of Community Practice, anticipated December 2002.

Spencer, M. S., Kohn, L. P., & Woods, J. R. (in press). Labeling vs. Early Identification: The Dilemma of Mental Health Service Utilization Among Low-Income African American Children. African American Perspectives.

Technical Reports Available: None at this time
 

About The SchoolProspective StudentsEnrolled StudentsAlumni & FriendsResearch and Public Service
home  site index  contact us 
© 2002 The Regents of the University of Michigan. This page was last updated on January 28, 2003.