UM School of Social Work
Research & Public Service
NIMH Center for Research on Poverty, Risk, and Mental Health
 

Developmental Project: "Racial Differences in Risk and Protective Factors for Major Depression in Low-Income Women: The Role of Household Food Insufficiency"

Description:
This project focuses on understanding the relationship between epidemiologically assessed household food insufficiency and major depression in low-income women. The findings of the project will be used to develop an R01 proposal to NIMH focusing on racial/ethnic differences in the relationship between epidemiologically assessed household food insufficiency and major depression among African American, non-Hispanic Caribbean blacks, and white respondents in the National Survey of American Life.

Key Findings:
Preliminary findings support the need for further study of the relationship between household food insufficiency and major depression. Drawing on theories of the social production of health and disease (Kreiger and Zierler, 1995; Link and Phelan, 1995; Williams, 1997), research evidence linking food insufficiency poor health, and high rates of food insufficiency among welfare recipients, Siefert, Heflin, Corcoran and Williams (2001) hypothesized that household food insufficiency could be a contributor to poor health and mental health in this population. In a cross-sectional analysis of 753 welfare recipients that controlled for a wide range of other factors known to influence women's health and well-being, food insufficiency remained a significant predictor of self-rated health, limitations in physical functioning, and major depression, but did not predict generalized anxiety disorder. We then analyzed the relationship between household food insufficiency and women's health in the same sample at two points in time: fall 1997 and approximately one year later (Siefert et al., 2002). Controlling for common risk factors, we found that women who reported food insufficiency at both times were significantly less likely to report a high sense of mastery over their lives. Food insufficiency at wave 2 only was significantly associated with meeting the diagnostic screening criteria for recent major depression, as well as with a lower sense of mastery.

Since these findings may be biased due to the presence of unobserved heterogeneity and therefore, are not conclusive, we examined the effects of food insufficiency on depression and sense of mastery among respondents in the WES over a three year period of time. Using a fixed effects model and controlling for a large number of potentially common risk factors, we examined the effects of food insufficiency on respondents' meeting the CIDI SF screening criteria for major depressive disorder and on their sense of mastery. We hypothesized that household food insufficiency would be associated with higher risk of depression and with lower levels of mastery, while controlling for measured factors known to affect women's mental health and well-being and time invariant unobserved heterogeneity. Although the results of our analyses did not support the hypothesized relationship between food insufficiency and sense of mastery in our sample, the relationship between food insufficiency and respondents' meeting the diagnostic screening criteria for major depression remained highly significant even when controlling for factors known to confer increased risk of depression and time invariant unobserved heterogeneity.

Practice or Policy Implications:
If the relationship between household food insufficiency and major depression can be replicated using the state of art measures and the large, population based, multiethnic sample available in the NSAL, and if it can ultimately be replicated longitudinally, this is a potentially important finding. An increasing number of studies have found that household food insufficiency is associated with lower energy and nutrient intakes, and a recent study using data from NHANES III found that adults in food insufficient households were more likely to have diets that may compromise their health and lower serum concentrations of several critical nutrients compared with adults from food insufficient families As the authors of this study note, low intakes and concentrations of such nutrients may compromise immune function, and increase the risk of major chronic diseases. In addition to the possibility that household food insufficiency could directly affect the onset or recurrence of major depression through nutritional deprivation, the known depressogenic effects of stressful life events and conditions must be also be considered as a potential pathway to depression among women in food insecure households. Anticipatory worry about the adequacy of one's household's food supply and the actual experience of not having sufficient food in the household are stressful experiences that could plausibly contribute to disregulation of the HPA axis. Many of the risk factors for major depression are global or not readily modified. If household food insufficiency, a readily modified risk factor, is indeed a causal factor in major depression, this has important implications for reducing the public health burden of major depression in this population.

Investigators:

  • David R. Williams, Senior Research Scientist, Institute for Social Research and Harold R. Cruse Professor of Sociology, The University of Michigan
  • Colleen M. Heflin, Assistant Professor, Martin School of Public Policy, The University of Kentucky.

Funders: National Institute of Mental Health grant No. R24-MH51361

  • Food Assistance and Nutrition Research Program
  • Economic Research Service
  • United States Department of Agriculture
  • Charles Stewart Mott Foundation
  • Joyce Foundation

Project Contact: Kristine Siefert ksiefert@umich.edu

Project Update as of 10/2002:

Conference Presentations:

  • Siefert, Kristine; Bowman, Phillip J.; Heflin, Colleen; Danziger, Sheldon and Williams, David R., "Depression in Low-Income Single Mothers." Paper presented at the Joint Conference of the International Federation of Social Workers and the International Association of Schools of Social Work, Montreal, July 29, 2000.
  • Siefert, Kristine; Heflin, Colleen; Corcoran, Mary; Williams, David R., and Anderson, Nathaniel J., "Food Insufficiency and Women's Health: Findings From a Longitudinal Study of Welfare Recipients." paper presented at 2000 Small Grants Conference, Economic Research Service, U.S. Department of Agriculture, Washington, D.C., October 19, 2000.
  • Siefert, Kristine; Heflin, Colleen, Corcoran, Mary and Williams, David R., "Food Insufficiency and the Mental Health of Current and Recent Welfare Recipients: Findings From a Longitudinal Survey." Paper presented at Association for Public Policy Analysis and Management annual meeting, Washington, D.C., November 2, 2001.
  • Siefert, Kristine; Heflin, Colleen; Corcoran, Mary and Williams, David R., "Food Insufficiency and the Physical and Mental Health of Low Income Mothers." Paper presented at the 15th Annual Invitational Maternal and Child Health Leadership Conference on Translating Research into Maternal and Child Health Public Health Practice, MCHB, HRSA, U.S. DHHS and University of Illinois School of Public Health. Chicago, April 22, 2002.
  • Siefert, Kristine; Heflin, Colleen, and Williams, David R., "Household Food Insufficiency and Depression in Low-Income African American and White Women," paper to be presented the American Public Health Association Annual Meeting, Philadelphia, Nov. 11, 2002.

Publications:

  • Siefert, Kristine; Bowman, Phillip; Heflin, Colleen; Danziger, Sheldon and Williams, David R., Social and Environmental Predictors of Major Depression in Current and Recent Welfare Recipients," American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, Vol. 70 (4), 2000, pp. 510-522.
  • Siefert, Kristine; Heflin, Colleen; Corcoran, Mary & Williams, David R., "Food Insufficiency and the Physical and Mental Health of Low-Income Women," Women and Health, 2001, Vol. 32 (1/2), pp. 159-177.
  • Siefert, Kristine; Heflin, Colleen; Corcoran, Mary, and Williams, David R."Food Insufficiency and Physical and Mental Health in a Longitudinal Survey of Welfare Recipients," revise and resubmit, J. of Health and Social Behavior

 
About The SchoolProspective StudentsEnrolled StudentsAlumni & FriendsResearch and Public Service
home  site index  contact us 
© 2002 The Regents of the University of Michigan. This page was last updated on March 4, 2003.