UM School of Social Work
Research & Public Service
NIMH Center for Research on Poverty, Risk, and Mental Health
 

Mothers' Well-Being Study

Description:
The major aim of this study was to assess the prevalence of psychiatric disorders, physical health problems, and domestic violence among low income single mothers, and to examine the relationship of these problems to unemployment and dependence on welfare. The study population was all Wayne, Oakland and Macomb African-American and Caucasian women ages 18-54 who were receiving welfare as of September 1998. Non-citizen, non-English speaking, and/or two parent households were excluded. The sample of women was selected from a list of September 1998 welfare recipients provided by the State of Michigan Family Independence Agency (FIA). Of the 900 women randomly selected from FIA, 859 were deemed eligible (i.e., residing in the three-county Metropolitan area, English-speaking) and 668 were interviewed. Of the 668 respondents, 275 were white and 391 were African-American. Response rates are consistent across race and age categories, with an overall response rate of nearly 78%. When properly weighted the MWS data is generalizable to the welfare caseload in the three-county Detroit metropolitan area. MWS interviews were conducted April-October 1999.

We created the Detroit Service Provider Database (DSPD) for the year 2000. The DSPD represents the most comprehensive listing of all relevant service providers operating in the three-county area available for that year. Combined with MWS data, these data allow us to assess the spatial disparities in the service sector and to test hypotheses about the impact of these disparities on outcomes for welfare recipients.

Subsequently, women who had not yet developed major depression at wave 1 were reinterviewed by telephone in 2002 to explore prospectively temporal comorbidity of PTSD and depression.

Key findings:

  • Most disorders have higher prevalence among women in our sample.
  • employment variables seem more strongly associated with life disorders rather than 12-month disorders
  • We found extensive comorbidity of PTSD and other disorders.
  • Retrospectively, prior PTSD was significantly associated with the first onset of Major Depressive Disorder
  • Despite high prevalence of many disorders, many MWS respondents do not use mental health or substance abuse services
  • Our data has revealed obstacles to service access for this population, including spatial disparity of service location

Practice or Policy Implications:
We chose this set of problems because the literature suggests that each may significantly influence employment of low-income single mothers. We focused on low income single mothers because of recent changes in the welfare policy that increase pressure for single mothers to rapidly seek and maintain employment. To the extent that psychiatric disorders, physical health problems and domestic violence are overrepresented among single mothers who do not find or sustain employment, they may represent key targets for efforts to influence the employability of single mothers who must enter the work force to support their families.

Service utilization findings show the need to increase access to services for this vulnerable group. Comorbidity analyses may shed light on etiology of depression, as well as provide needed data to better serve low-income women.

Principal Investigator: Richard M. Tolman
Co-Investigators: Mieko Yoshihama, Sandy Danziger, Sheldon Danziger, Scott Allard (Syracuse University), Daniel Rosen (University of Pittsburgh), James Abelson (UM Dept. of Psychiatry), Israel Liberzon (UM Dept. of Psychiatry)

Funders:
National Institute of Mental Health (R24 MH51363-01a1)
Assistant Secretary for Planning and Evaluation, Health and Human Services (for service utilization study)
UM Depression Center (for temporal comorbidity of PTSD and depression)

Time Frame of Funding:
NIMH 3/01/98-2/28/02
ASPE: 09/01/00- 6/30/02
UM Depression Center 8/01- current

Publications:
Allard, Tolman, and Rosen (under review). Proximity to Service Providers and Service Utilization Among Welfare Recipients: The Interaction of Place and Race. Journal of Policy Analysis and Management.

Allard, S., Rosen, D. and Tolman, R.M. (under review). Welfare Recipients' Access to Mental Health and Substance Abuse Services in Detroit, Urban Affairs Review

Yoshihama, M., Gillespie, B., Hammock, A. C., Belli, R. F., & Tolman, R. (under review). Does the Life History Calendar method facilitate the recall of domestic violence victimization?: Comparison of two methods of data collection. Psychological Assessment.

Presentations:
Tolman, R.M., Rosen, D. & Allard, S. Barriers to mental health, substance abuse, and domestic violence service utilization by welfare recipients. National Association for Welfare Research and Statistics, Baltimore, MD, August, 2001

Allard, S., Rosen, D., & Tolman, R.M. (2001). Linking the spatial distribution of social service providers to service utilization rates. Association for Public Policy Analysis and Management (APPAM) Conference, Washington, D.C. November, 2001

Rosen, D., Allard, S., & Tolman, R.M. Using Geographical Information Systems to evaluate access to mental health and substance abuse services as part of the symposium on Innovative methodologies: The application of social work and social science theory and methods in substance abuse research. Society for Social Work Research, San Diego, CA January 17, 2002.

Tolman, R. M. , Rosen, D. and Allard, S. Prevalence of Psychiatric Disorders and Use of Mental Health Services by Women Receiving Welfare. Moving Forward:Building on Social Work Contributions to Mental Health Research, June 10-11, 2002, Rockville, MD.
 

About The SchoolProspective StudentsEnrolled StudentsAlumni & FriendsResearch and Public Service
home  site index  contact us 
© 2002 The Regents of the University of Michigan. This page was last updated on March 4, 2003.