 |
From Welfare to Jobs and Independence: Developing a Preventive Intervention
Description:
Since Fall 2000, researchers at the University of Michigan have engaged in a research and development project to provide training and technical assistance to welfare-to-work service providers in Michigan to implement a research-based job search program and to examine the feasibility of operating this program in the welfare system. The program is based on extensive previous research and development of the JOBS program by the Michigan Prevention Research Center (Institute for Social Research), the Women's Employment Study and a set of welfare reform implementation studies of the Michigan Program on Poverty and Social Welfare Policy (Ford School of Public Policy).
The original job search program to be adapted, called Winning New Jobs (WNJ), is a weeklong job-search skill enhancement workshop for welfare recipients. The model has the dual goals of 1) promoting employment, and 2) enhancing coping capacities for the unemployed. Previous randomized trials have shown that this program returns unemployed workers to new jobs more quickly, produces reemployment in jobs that pay more and reduces mental health problems associated with prolonged unemployment, particularly among those most vulnerable to mental health problems, compared to control group participants.
WNJ sessions to be adapted to this high risk group focus on identifying effective job-search strategies, improving participant job-search skills, increasing self-efficacy and the participants' motivation to engage and persist in job-search activities until they become employed, and preventing set backs in well-being once employed. Staff from two Michigan welfare-to-work agencies have been trained to conduct the workshop, to use the techniques associated with it, and to participate in the development of new workshop modules. The challenge of this project is to successfully adapt the WNJ program to the welfare population and to enhance the program to include job retention and life skills.
Key Findings:
Although clients respond well to the workshop and staff at both agencies express optimism about the workshop's effectiveness and appreciate differences the workshop training produces in their own jobs as well as in clients' behavior, there were many challenges to fully implementing the workshop. Staff perceptions about clients, the nature of the agencies' contractual relationships, and policy and paperwork issues are some of the predominant challenges we examine.
Practice or Policy Implications:
There is a fundamental conflict between the orientation of behavioral science based and proven program innovations such as Winning New Jobs and the current policy and practice culture of the welfare-to-work agencies. The prevailing culture in the welfare to work practice and policy arena focuses on client compliance and conformity with rules and legal requirements. The objective of most programs is to prepare clients for the world of work by didactic teaching of set workplace behaviors that program developers believe is the key to job retention. Thus most welfare to work programs imitate a work culture that emphasizes discipline and rules rather than promoting mastery of a repertoire of transferable workplace skills that would lead to a career and self-sufficiency. Many of the traditional welfare-to-work curricular materials emphasize that employers have expectations regarding timeliness, absenteeism, doing what a supervisor asks, and getting along with coworkers and customers. For these agencies, meeting job placement goals and contract performance measures conflict with the desire to help clients improve their abilities and self-efficacy.
By contrast, the WNJ training program is designed to teach skills for working with employers to create successful and mutually supportive work relationships from both the point of view of employers and employees. WNJ training requires that staff be able work in a supportive and motivating way with clients and view them as persons with the potential to master a range of work and life skills. The challenge is to search for mutual adaptations of policy and practice so that innovations such as Winning New Jobs can be successfully implemented and disseminated in the welfare to work system. We analyze the constraints and opportunities for changing staff behavior with clients and perceptions in the welfare reform context, and how innovation that is client-centered can be successful in the welfare system.
Investigators: Sandra Danziger, Richard Price
Funders: National Institute of Mental Health Center and The Joyce Foundation
Timeframe: September 2000- August 2003.
Participating Organizations: University of Michigan Program on Poverty and Social Welfare Policy (Ford School of Public Policy), Michigan Prevention Research Center (Institute for Social Research), and two non-profit welfare-to-work services providers in Southeast Michigan
Project Contact: Kristin Seefeldt (615-3802) or Sarah Marsh (615-5389)
Project Update as of 10/2002:
Status: Data analysis, writing findings.
Publications:
Danziger, S.K. (2002). Can welfare to work significantly reduce poverty levels? Yes. In H. Karger, J. Midgley, & B. Brown (Eds.), Controversial Issues in Social Policy, 2nd Edition (Forthcoming), Allyn and Bacon.
Friedland, D. & Price, R.H. (in press). Underemployment: Consequences for the Health and Well-being of Workers. American Journal of Community Psychology
Price, R.H., Choi, J., & Vinokur, A.D. (In press). Links in the chain of adversity following job loss: How financial strain and loss of personal control lead to depression impaired functioning and poor health. Journal of Occupational Health Psychology.
Price, R.H. (In press). Personal control: Mediation, measurement, malleability. In L.I. Pearlin, S.H. Zarit & K.W. Schaie (Eds.), Societal impacts on personal control. New Jersey: Earlbaum.
Price, R.H. (In press). Understanding and improving the mental health of populations. In J.S. House, R.L. Kahn, F.T. Juster, H. Schuman & E. Singer (Eds.), A telescope on society: Survey research and social science in the twentieth and twenty-first centuries. Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press.
Waldfogel, J., Danziger, S.K., Danziger, S., & Seefeldt, K. (2001). Welfare reform and lone mothers' employment in the U.S.: Lessons from the states. In J. Millar & K. Rowlingson (Eds.), Lone Parents, Employment and Social Policy: Cross-national Comparisons, Bristol, UK: Policy Press (pp. 37-60). Also reprinted as CASE Paper 47, Centre for the Analysis of Social Exclusion, London School of Economics.
Conference and Other Presentations:
Danziger, S.K. Panelist, Michigan Devolution Conference, sponsored by The Council of Michigan Foundations and The Skillman Foundation. East Lansing, MI, October 8-9, 2001.
Danziger, S.K. Invited Panelist, ASPE/DHHS Roundtable on Measuring Material Hardship, Washington, D.C., February 20, 2002.
Danziger, S.K. Rapporteur, Final Session Panelist. Joint Center for Poverty Research Conference on the Hard-to-Employ and Welfare Reform. Washington, D.C., Feb.28-March 1, 2002.
Danziger, S.K. Keynote Speaker, Community Foundation of Greater Flint annual luncheon, Flint, MI., April 11, 2002.
Marsh, S.K., Seefeldt, K.S., & Danziger, S.K. "Barriers to implementation of new approaches to employment services: An interim report." Presented at the Annual Meeting of the National Association of Welfare Research and Statistics, Albuquerque, NM, August 2002.
Price, R.H. "Socioeconomic inequality, new jobs and health." Keynote address, Future of Work and Health, California Wellness Foundation and Rockefeller Foundation, San Francisco, CA, March 15-16, 2001.
Price, R.H. "Accountability for our own Successes: Lessons in Replicating and Disseminating Model Programs." Keynote address, Council of Foundations 2001 Annual Conference - Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, April 30, 2001.
Price, R.H. "The Winning New Jobs Program: A Person-environment Intervention designed to reduce the mental health problems in the unemployed." Symposium, Annual Convention of the American Psychological Association, San Francisco, California, August 25, 2001.
Technical Reports Available:
None at this time
|