 |
Evaluating Multiple Family Group Psychoeducational Intervention Program for Parents of Youth with Serious Emotional Disturbance
Description:
This R29 study had two primary goals: 1.) To develop a multiple family group psychoeducational intervention program (MFGPI) for parents of youth with serious emotional disturbance (SED) and 2.) To compare the relative effectiveness of this new multiple family group psychoeducational intervention program with "treatment as usual" within the New York State Children and Youth Intensive Case Management Program (CYICM) based in Onondaga and Oneida counties. Both of these goals were accomplished.
The multiple family group psychoeducational intervention model developed in the R29 study incorporates the key components of support, education and empowerment and is appropriately named S.E.E. (Support, Education & Empowerment). It used a highly structured session format with each component of the session timed. S.E.E. employed an open group process with parents joining and ending group based on their own specific needs. The group met 2 times a month for a minimum of 2 hours each time. Childcare on site, transportation support and refreshments were provided for sessions. Parents met separately from their children. This format addressed the perceived need for respite as identified by parents in the focus groups. Parents participated in the group sessions for a minimum of 6 months. The leadership model for the group incorporated a professional/parent team. Parents whose children were enrolled in the CYICM program but were no longer active were invited to serve as parent leaders. The team leadership model served as a role model for group members of partnership building and collaboration between professionals and parents. Each group operated with CYICM leaders and parent leaders as partners. Professionals and parent leaders were trained together and were encouraged to talk about their shift in roles from expert and parent to partners and how that influences the team process. The training of the group leaders involved an all day session with group role plays and booster sessions every 3 months.
Besides developing the intervention model, the R29 grant compared the relative effectiveness of the S.E.E. model with "treatment as usual" within the CYICM Program. The research questions addressed included:
- Is intensive case management with a multiple family group, psychoeducational intervention program (CYICM plus S.E.E.) more effective than "treatment as usual" intensive case management for families of children with SED in decreasing parental caregiving burden and stress, increasing social support resources, parental problem solving skills and coping behaviors?
- To what extent are parent(s) satisfied with the CYICM plus S.E.E. compared with "treatment as usual" CYICM program?
- Do parent outcomes differ when measured at 9 months and 18 months? Social support resources, parental problem-solving skills and coping behaviors?
Key Findings:
- Recruitment of subjects for the treatment effectiveness phase of the R29 lasted from March 1995 until April 1998. Ninety-four (94) subjects were randomly assigned to the treatment conditions, completed the baseline interviews, and agreed to participate in the study. Some subjects (N=38) who completed the baseline interview were eliminated from the active study pool due to leaving CYICM service (active less than 6 months), not attending the S.E.E. group if assigned to this condition, or because they declined the second interview. Wave 2 (9 months) interviews were completed in April 1999 and Wave 3 (18 months) interviews were completed in October 1999. The S.E.E. group sessions ended in September 1998. Each S.E.E. group was taped to check for treatment fidelity and supervision needs.
- The primary variables measured in this study included: parent support network use (Arizona Social Support Scale), parent problem solving skills (F-COPES), parent management skills (Parental Locus of Control Scale), parent satisfaction with services (New York Children and Youth Case Management Satisfaction Scale) and youth functioning/behavior (CBCL).
- No significant differences were found between the two treatment conditions at baseline or between those families that completed the three research interviews and those who were dropped from the study at baseline.
- Selected Baseline Descriptive Information of Total Sample (N=94): 80% of the parents are white/ 15% black; at the time of intake, 66% of the families had used 4 or more mental health services in the 6 months prior to enrollment in the ICM programs; 76% of the referred youth in this sample are male/24% female; 65% of the families use Medicaid as their primary health insurance; 83% live with biological parent(s) at the time of intake; 68% of the youth are white/ 24% are black/ 8% other; the primary DSM diagnosis at the time of admission for the youths: Attention Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder, Conduct Disorders, Adjustment Disorders, Bipolar Disorders, and Depressive Disorders; 61% of the youth at the time of admission were on medications for a psychiatric condition; 48% are in special classes for students with handicapping conditions; 60% of parents described their relationship as their child was worse than average and 59% of parents reported that their youth's relationship with other kids was worse than average on the CBCL; CBCL scores at baseline for youth (Clinical T Score Mean 76); and the mean age of the youth at the time of intake was 11.68 years. The range was from 5 to 17 years.
- Using Proc Mixed analyses in SAS, controlling for time and group condition, youth in both conditions improved significantly over time with treatment as measured by the CBCL Clinical T scores. A statistically significant difference at the .05 level emerged on social support network use between the groups at Time 2. The number of mental health services used decreased significantly (.001) over time for both groups. Parents/ primary caregivers in the S.E.E. condition used social supports more and increased their support networks from Time 1 to Time 2 when compared to non-group parents/primary caregivers. While not statistically significant a greater improvement was noted on the parent problem solving and parent management measures for the parents in the S.E.E. group then for the parents in the treatment as usual condition. Using Proc Mixed Analyses in SAS, no statistically significant findings on the F-Copes measures and the parenting locus of control measures were found for Group 1 or Group 2 when controlling for time and group and the interaction between time and group.
- In the semi-structured interviews at 9 and 18 months, over 97% of the parents/primary caregivers in the S.E.E. condition reported: improvement in their relationships with their youth with SED (e.g., yell less, don't fear my youth's reaction); they viewed themselves as better parents (e.g., calmer, stronger, more in charge, more patient, not crazy); they were less isolated (e.g., not alone anymore, other parents understand, others are supportive), and they had learned new ways to handle problem situations (e.g., understand discipline/choices more, power as parent restored, listen then act).
- Parents/primary caregivers in the nongroup condition did not report any major changes in their relationship with their youths with SED, their parenting style or their overall management skills at the 9 month and 18 month semi-structured interview. A majority (60%) of the parents/primary caregivers in the nongroup condition reported high levels of stress, frustration with their youths and feelings of hopelessness about anything changing for the positive in their lives. Parents/primary caregivers in the S.E.E. condition reported more perceived positive changes in themselves, their social networks and in their youths with SED. Parents in both conditions reported overall satisfaction with services. The youth who improved the most had a mean age of 12.35, their families were in the group condition (63%), almost half were on medications (45%), most were in special school placements (63%) and 89% were male. The youth who did not demonstrate improvement over the 18 month time period had a mean age of 10.48 and 80% were in the treatment as usual condition.
Practice Implications:
Youth enrolled in the New York State CYICM program demonstrated improvement over time using the CBCL Clinical T scores as a measure of positive change regardless of intervention condition. For families in the intervention condition the trend was toward positive changes in social support resources, parental problem solving skills and coping behavior when compared to the treatment as usual group although these results were not statistically significant. A larger study with greater power might find significant differences on these measures. Parents in both conditions reported high levels of satisfaction with the CYICM services. Multiple family psychoeducation intervention for parents of youth with SED shows promise as an emerging intervention.
The S.E.E. group model has been implemented in a juvenile justice setting in Michigan and is currently being disseminated in a mental health program in West Virginia.
Investigators: Mary Ruffolo, Ph.D., Mary Kuhn, ACSW and Mary E. Evans. Ph.D.
Funder: National Institute of Mental Health Grant No. R29-MH52899
Time Frame: 1994-2001
Project Contact: Mary Ruffolo (mruffolo@umich.edu)
Status: Completed Study
Conference Presentations:
None in the past 12 months. This study has been presented at over 10 professional conferences since 1994.
Publications:
None since 2000. Two articles currently under review.
Technical Reports Available:
Final Report: R29-Evaluation Multiple Family Group Psychoeducation for Parents of Youth with SED (2001)
Support, Empowerment and Education: A Multiple Family Group Psychoeducation Training Manual (Revised 2002)
|