UM School of Social Work
Research & Public Service
NIMH Center for Research on Poverty, Risk, and Mental Health
 

Assessing Consumer-Centered Services

Description:
The Assessing Consumer-Centered Services (ACCS) project studies distinguishing characteristics of consumer-centered programs-consumer-run drop-in centers (CDIs) and clubhouses-in Michigan. CDIs are drop-in centers run by and for adults with serious mental illness-"consumers" of mental health services-and are intended to provide a safe place outside the traditional mental health system for consumers to socialize, relax, and share information without judgment. Clubhouses are professionally run and more vocationally oriented than drop-in centers. The purpose of the study is to develop fidelity criteria and a program manual for consumer-operated services. To this end, the project recently finished collecting data through interviews and self-administered surveys from the directors, staff, and consumers at a geographically matched set of 31 drop-ins and 31 clubhouses all over the state of Michigan-1,911 consumers completed surveys. The field research team also collected qualitative data based on structured observations taken over two-day visits to each site, and collected documents including the annual budget, attendance figures, mission statement, rules of conduct, and funding information. Telephone interviews have also been conducted with key community contacts familiar with each site.

Key Findings:
More than half of consumer-run drop-in centers are located in counties that have poverty rates higher than the state average. Of 916 consumers surveyed at 31 consumer-run drop-in centers:

  • 65% were male and 35% female
  • 70% identified themselves as White, 17% as African American, and 13% other
  • Ages ranged from 18-81 years, with the mean at 44 years
  • Average daily attendance at centers ranged from 5 to 103 with the mean at 30

    Practice or Policy Implications: Awaiting more complete data analysis and interpretation.

    Investigators: Carol Mowbray, PhD and Mark Holter, PhD
    Funder: National Institute of Mental Health (R24 F003470)
    Timeframe: Funded 03/2000-08/2003
    Participating Organizations: Justice in Mental Health Organization
    Project Contact: Chyrell Bellamy, Project Coordinator cbellamy@umich.edu

    Project Update as of 10/2002:

    Status: Data collection finished. Analysis is in process.

    Conference Presentations:
    2002 Assessing Consumer-Centered Services: Who Holds the Keys? Mowbray, Carol; Holter, Mark; Bellamy, Chyrell; Stark, Lori; Pfeffer, Carla; Lyon, Aaron. 27th Annual International Association of Psychosocial Rehabilitation Services Conference, Toronto, June.

    2002 ACCS Statewide Study of Consumer-run Drop-in Center-What's Going On? Mowbray, Carol; Stark, Lori; Pfeffer, Carla. 2002 Michigan Consumer Conference, Lansing, MI, August.

    2002 Assessing Consumer-Centered Services: Clubhouses. Mowbray, Carol; Holter, Mark; Stark, Lori; Pfeffer, Carla. 2002 Michigan Chapter, International Association of Psychosocial Rehabilitation Services Conference, Detroit, October.

    Publications:
    Mowbray, C.T., Robinson, E.L., & Holter, M. Consumer drop-in centers: Operations, services, and member involvement. Health & Social Work, in press, fall 2002.

    Holter, M., Mowbray, C.T., Bellamy, C., & MacFarlane, P. "Critical ingredients" of consumer centered services: Results of a national survey. Under development for Community Mental Health Journal, anticipated October 2002.

    Mowbray, C.T., Holter, M., Teague, G., & Bybee, D. Research methods to establish evidence-based practices: Fidelity criteria. Under development for Evaluation and Program Planning, anticipated November 2002.

    Holter, M., & Mowbray, C.T. Costs and operations in consumer-run drop-in centers. Under revision for Journal of Behavioral Health Services & Research, anticipated November 2002.

    Technical reports: None at this time
     

  • About The SchoolProspective StudentsEnrolled StudentsAlumni & FriendsResearch and Public Service
    home  site index  contact us 
    © 2002 The Regents of the University of Michigan. This page was last updated on February 12, 2003.