FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE CONTACT: John Truscott
January 29, 1997 (517) 335-6397


Engler Disagrees with AG's Opinion on Photo ID's


Governor John Engler expressed strong disagreement with an opinion issued today by Attorney General Frank Kelley against legislation requiring photo identification by Michigan voters in some circumstances.

In his opinion, the Attorney General correctly states the law related to the right to vote and the burden imposed on a state when it imposes conditions on that right, Engler said.

However, by inadequately characterizing the state's interest in the photo ID provision, the opinion comes to an incorrect conclusion, the Governor said. Protecting the integrity of the election process is a valid state interest, which the legislation addresses.

"In fact the entire state election code exists to deter fraud and the potential for fraud. Michigan's pro-active law has minimized election fraud in this state," Engler said.

"It is absurd to think that the state is precluded from refining this process until full blown election fraud has occurred.

Nine other states have an ID requirement for voting and Hawaii has a photo ID requirement. The existence of such laws contradicts the Attorney General's conclusion regarding the Michigan law.

"Furthermore, the Attorney General opinion process denies due process because, unlike a court, it affords no opportunity for the presentation of an alternative point of view prior to a decision which is binding on the state.

Since the Attorney General is also the Governor's attorney, I trust my attorney will seek opportunity for a court to review this determination at the earliest possible time."