FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE CONTACT: John Truscott

October 23, 1996 (517) 335-6397


Gov. Engler Requests Amicus Brief for Upper Peninsula Lake Dispute with Feds


Governor John Engler today announced that he has asked the Pacific Legal Foundation to prepare and submit an amicus curiae brief in support of a petition filed with the United States Supreme Court in Thrall, et al. v. United States, et al.

The case involves a lawsuit filed by private landowners, led by Kathy Stupak-Thrall, on Crooked Lake in Michigan's Upper Peninsula against the U.S. Forest Service, which also owns part of the lake. The landowners have a dispute with Forest Service regulations that prohibit the use of sailboats, house boats and the use of non-burnable containers on Crooked Lake. They claim the regulations prevent their use and enjoyment of the lake, which is located near Watersmeet in Gogebic County.

"The federal government should not be allowed to trample the rights of property owners on Crooked Lake," Engler said. "This case appears to be yet another example of federal bureaucrats running roughshod over the rights of citizens."

The dispute revolves around the statutory construction of the Michigan Wilderness Act (MWA) and the Wilderness Act of 1964, and what property rights under state law were preserved by Congress in enacting the two statutes. Like the petitioners, Engler believes that the plain language of the MWA and Wilderness Act preserved all property rights which petitioners had in the use of the lake at the time the MWA was passed, and such language precludes the Forest Service from implementing regulations that abridge those rights.

In letter dated October 22 to the Pacific Legal Foundation of Sacramento, Ca., Chris Murray, Deputy Legal Counsel for Governor Engler, warned of the effect an earlier U.S. District Court ruling would have on all other wilderness lands in Michigan, which comprise approximately 91,891 acres.

"If the lower court decision remains intact, the Forest Service will have nothing more than carte blanche to issue similarly restrictive regulations that detrimentally affect Michigan residents who own property near or adjacent to federal wilderness lands," Murray wrote.

The brief is due on November 25, 1996.