FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE CONTACT: John Truscott

September 19, 1996 (517) 335-6397


State Wins Temporary Victory on Prison Issue, Potentially Saving Taxpayers Tens of Millions


Dole/Abraham legislation at issue in decision

Governor John Engler announced today that the United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit has stayed a portion of a federal district court order in the case Hadix v. Johnson, which had required the state to continue phases two and three of the costly break-up plan at the State Prison of Southern Michigan. As a result, the state is not currently required to comply with all the court mandated requirements of the break-up plan, which would have cost taxpayers an additional $41.5 million.

The stay resulted from the state's appeal of a July federal district court decision in Detroit which held that the automatic stay provision of the recently enacted Prison Litigation Reform Act (PLRA) was unconstitutional. Though only a temporary victory, it provided significant relief.

"Today is the first time in almost a decade that the Department of Corrections has not been under federal court mandates as to the construction of new facilities in place of the old Jackson prison. This would never have occurred were it not for the determined work and leadership of two key sponsors of the our PLRA, Senators Bob Dole and Spencer Abraham. Through their leadership, our state has at least temporarily obtained the ability to hold off constructing prison facilities as required by the federal courtsbuild prison facilities as deemed appropriate by our own corrections officials, rather than the federal courts," Governor Engler said.

The PLRA extinguishes federal court jurisdiction over consent decree cases when consent decrees do not meet specific standards. It also requires federal courts to decide motions like the one filed by the state within 30 days of its filing. The federal district court has refused to timely decide the states motion, and had ruled the stay provision unconstitutional, resulting in the present appeal.