Congressman Hoekstra and distinguished members of the committee: Thank you for inviting me to testify on "Education at a Crossroads: What Works? And What's Wasted?" I applaud this committee for traveling the country in search of the insights and experience many of us in the states have to share.
I can't help but take pleasure in the fact that we are meeting at Muskegon Heights Senior High School. We are in a building that faces a lot of the typical urban challenges you hear about. Last spring, I made an unannounced visit, and was impressed with the phenomenal principal here, Marvin Nash, and with the dedicated teachers I met. We felt safe; there was order in the classrooms we visited; no kids were wandering the halls unsupervised. The impression I got from the moment I walked through the door was: This is a school with a great sense of pride.
At the end of the visit, I was in the gym and was challenged to make some baskets. As luck would have it, I sank a three pointer -- no easy task in a business suit! But the people who deserve the credit for sinking the three pointers at Muskegon Heights High School are the dedicated staff I met. They are sinking the three-pointers that count -- academically. At the end of my last visit, the principal said, "Come back to see us; you are welcome to meet with me and my staff any time."
Well, I am back, and delighted to have this opportunity to speak about education. No issue in America is more important. This morning I'd like to raise five points, after which I will be happy to elaborate on these or any other topics you wish to pursue. The five points in my formal presentation are: (1) Washington's role in our public schools; (2) the world-class spending on public schools in Michigan; (3) the increasing safety and order in our schools; (4) the greater educational choices our families enjoy; and (5) the better performance of our students and higher test scores.
First, I'd like to address one of the key questions you raised in your initial letter to me. You asked what the federal government's role in education should be.
My answer in a word: minimal.
The underlying premise of this testimony is well expressed by my friends Bill Bennett and Lamar Alexander, who like to say: "Education is the constitutional responsibility of the states, the social responsibility of our communities, and the moral responsibility of our families." In other words, there need not be -- there should not be -- the heavy hand of the national government on the states when it comes to education.
By most estimates, Americans collectively spend more than $350 billion every year on primary and secondary education. Much of that amount, however, is diverted through Washington. Congressman Hoekstra, I was frankly stunned by your committee's findings: You have identified 760 federal education programs throughout 39 agencies spending more than $120 billion annually -- staggering numbers all. And 50 percent -- fully half -- of the paperwork we in the states have to deal with comes from Washington. In fact, one of the amazing figures you reported is that there are 487 steps you have to go through to complete the average U.S. Department of Education grant.
Here is my question: For all the billions that Washington spends on public education each year, is there proof that it is helping public schools achieve their fundamental mission, which is to improve the mind and character of American children? Is there any proof that all of Washington's involvement is really preparing our children for the work-world of the 21st century?
A lot of "federal dollars" go to bureaucrats -- but no bureaucrat ever taught our children a thing. Furthermore, bureaucracies do not respond well to market pressures and commonsense reforms. The intrusiveness and sluggishness of bureaucracies should give us pause. It has gotten to the point where, in Michigan, less than half of every education dollar we spend -- 48 cents, to be exact -- actually makes it into the classroom. A lot of the rest is going to administration and to the bureaucracies. I fear that more federal involvement will not only reduce the amount actually going to the classroom, but come with so many strings attached that we will never be able to cut through the thicket of rules and regulations. There is no way you can reform a monopoly that has become gummed up with red tape.
So let's do our children a favor. Let's cut the red tape being manufactured inside the Beltway that is streaming out and strangling the states. Let's see more of the money skip Washington altogether and go directly to our kids in the classroom.
One step in the right direction would be to simplify federal involvement through congressional utilization of block grants. Block grants have enabled the states to enact far-reaching welfare reforms, so I am confident they will give us similar flexibility with regard to education. This remedy will allow us to cut through the existing thicket of rules and regulations and stop much of the current paper chase, which is wasting so much of our public resources.
If what I've said about Washington sounds harsh, let me be quick to add that my administration practices what it preaches. What's good for the goose is good for the gander. I don't think Lansing -- or any state -- should have a heavy-handed education bureaucracy any more than Washington should. That's why, in 1994, I signed two executive orders that trimmed the size of the Michigan Department of Education (MDOE) from 2,000 to under 1,000 staff. Now, due to our retirement program, the MDOE has fewer than 500 staff.
We've also cut reels of red tape at the state level. The number of state forms for reporting has dropped from 217 to 149. Of the 149 forms, 67 are required, and 82 are voluntary.
I am especially proud of this next fact: In the last two years, my administration has rescinded one-third of all MDOE regulations. At this time in 1995, the MDOE had 771 rules; today they have only 507. Of all the rule reductions in our state departments, that's the best we've done in terms of percentage.
I should also mention that, just last year, the Michigan Legislature -- with my promptings and blessings -- eliminated more than 200 sections of the School Code.
Finally, there are a number of programs we have not abolished but have reorganized to better serve our customers -- the students, workers, and taxpayers of Michigan. Take for instance our vocational rehabilitation program. By means of an executive order, I moved voc rehab in 1994 from the Michigan Department of Education to the Michigan Jobs Commission. Whereas before there was a maze of agencies that citizens with disabilities had to negotiate, now there is no wrong door.
There is a seamless system to coordinate job-training services. We've reduced the assessment time of citizens with disabilities from 54 days in 1993 to 29 days in 1996.
A survey this past June revealed that four of every five individuals served by our program were "very satisfied" with the results of their rehab program. So this is a reform that has worked, and it has worked because we got rid of a lot of the cumbersome bureaucracy and put the focus back on where it should be -- the people of Michigan.
Now to my second point. Since you are here to gather a Michigan perspective, permit me to give you a fiscal overview that will show how seriously we take public education in this state. In the 1997-98 school year, state and local spending on public schools will climb to more than $11.5 billion -- that's some $500 million more than the $11.0 billion we spent last year. The $11.5 billion is considerably more than we spent in Michigan the year before I took office. Back in the 1989-90 school year, we spent $7.9 billion on our public schools. So there has been a 46 percent increase thus far in the 1990s. Moreover, the 1997-98 School Aid budget represents the first time in state history that the K-12 budget will exceed the entire general fund budget for the state. That's a fact I'm proud of, because education always has been -- and remains -- my top priority.
Recall, ladies and gentlemen, that back in 1991 when I took office state government was $1.8 billion in the red. Recall also that Michigan was the only state in the nation that balanced our budget without ever once cutting education or raising taxes. To put that achievement in historical perspective, consider this: The two previous administrations -- Governor Blanchard's and Governor Milliken's -- cumulatively issued 15 executive orders that cut School Aid by a total of almost $400 million. Despite that historical tendency, at no time in the 1990s has public education in Michigan had to suffer any cut from the state.
Not only are we spending more money; we are spending it more fairly. And that is due to Proposal A, which was passed by 70 percent of Michigan voters in March of 1994. Proposal A is closing the "equity gap" that had plagued our state for decades prior to 1994.
One way to grasp the benefits of Proposal A is to compare the spending ratio between the highest and lowest spending district since 1980. In 1980 the wealthiest district was spending almost three times more than the lowest spending district. The problem was not addressed during the entire decade of the `80s. On the contrary, the gap grew throughout the decade: the rich were getting richer; the poor, poorer. By 1990 the ratio was getting out of hand.
My administration and the Legislature began to address the problem, and the ratio came down from a peak of 3.33 in 1990 to 3.07 prior to passage of Proposal A -- but it was still much too high, as the wealthiest district was spending more than three times the lowest spending district in the state. That is why we needed Proposal A, to remedy the situation as quickly and as fairly as possible. Almost four years after passage of Proposal A, the results have been dramatic. The ratio is now down to almost 2 to 1 -- the lowest it's been in decades. As a result of our success, Michigan has not had a federal court impose a settlement on us, as many other states have. In other words, Proposal A has definitely "worked," to recall the title of this hearing.
It is not just students who have benefited from Proposal A; school districts have too. School boards are no longer millage committees; they are freed up to be what they were meant to be -- education committees. Two measures of the "fiscal health" of a school district are how much money is in its fund balance -- or savings account -- at the end of the year, and whether that fund balance is getting bigger or smaller. What was the impact of Proposal A on school district savings accounts?
Now, have the balances of these savings accounts been getting larger or smaller?
To sum up the point about funding, Michigan is spending more money on education than ever before, and spending that money more fairly. Our school districts have the fiscal resources they need. Today, every child in our state has the opportunity to receive a world-class education.
Another priority of my administration has been safe schools -- and this is my third major point. We have focused on restoring order and discipline in the classroom, so that our children can concentrate on physics rather than on physical survival, and our teachers and staff don't have to come to work afraid for their well being.
Since January of 1995, when the no-weapons-in-schools legislation went into effect, 568 kids who brought knives and guns to school have been expelled.
In addition, in my last State of the State, I proposed legislation that would expell any student who assaults teachers or school employees. Passing this bill is one of my top priorities this fall.
This year, I have also required each school district, as a prerequisite for receiving drug and violence prevention funding, to adopt concrete plans to ensure the safety of its students, teachers and other school staff. The safe school plans to be submitted to my Office of Drug Control Policy requires the review and endorsement of parents, juvenile court judges, and local law enforcement. I will have my Safe and Drug Free Schools advisory committee publish the best safe-school plans on the internet so that we can share our experiences. We must restore civility to our schools and have zero tolerance for the few that come to school bent on disrupting the learning of the many. Again, these measures work, for our children are in safer classrooms.
As I've often said, I want our education renaissance to be as strong as our economic renaissance has been. Our unemployment rate is down to a record low 3.7 percent. But to have an economy second to none, we must have a workforce second to none, and that means having public schools second to none.
As you know, I strongly believe that one key to improving schools is by giving families more freedom. You do that by introducing competition and market forces into public education -- this is my fourth major point.
Today one of the best alternatives going is the charter school movement, which has support from a broad coalition including the President of the United States. In Michigan alone, there are more than 100 charter public schools enrolling more than 20,000 children.
These are not elitist institutions, as some critics claim. On the contrary, Michigan leads the nation in the number of minority students enrolled in charter schools -- 53 percent. And 47 percent of the kids in these schools are African American, and school and after school has long waiting lists. We can't meet the demand fast enough, especially in cities like Detroit, where the school board has been reluctant to issue charters -- yet there is tremendous unmet demand.
One of the most striking poll results over the summer was the report that, demographically, the African-American community is most supportive of choice. This is especially true of young urban parents. Because of charter schools and schools of choice, the system is finally responding to their needs. And that's how it should be, because education is the number one indicator of success in life.
In addition, nearly 8,000 families took advantage of the schools of choice initiative in the first year alone -- proving that this is an idea whose time has come.
Besides higher funding, greater discipline, and more choices, I take great pride in the fact that our children are performing better -- and that's my fifth and final point. I have served on the National Education Goals Panel, and believe that benchmarking our children's progress to the best in the world is critical to the future of our state and nation. Sure, the kids in my state are competing with kids from Ohio and Indiana, but they are also competing with kids around the world. We dare not fail to prepare them for the economy of the 21st century.
I am one who would like to see voluntary performance standards adopted by the states, especially in mathematics, science, reading, and writing.
Some people seem to get all caught up in the content and method of the testing.
While well intentioned, I believe such discussions unnecessarily distract us. Every year I talk to a lot of plant managers and CEO's. They know what skills are needed in the workplace. The sum of two plus two is the same in Michigan as it is in Texas. The Second Law of Thermodynamics is the same in Connecticut as it is in California. I am not aware of a "Mississippi version" of the quadratic equation that conflicts with a "Minnesota version." The ability to write a coherent paragraph in English -- with a topic sentence, descriptive language, and adequate supporting evidence -- is a skill that is as valued as much in Florida as it is in Oregon. This is not a mystery.
Something else that is not a mystery is that test scores are up in Michigan. By any standard measure -- ACT, SAT, and MEAP -- our children are performing better. Late last winter, just before President Clinton addressed the Michigan Legislature, Secretary Riley announced that, over the past six years, Michigan 8th-grade math scores have shown the second greatest improvement in the nation. There is a causal relationship at work.
When you address funding, order in the classroom, and giving families more choices, you can expect better performance. We demand it -- and are getting it.
On this good note I shall close. Allow me to take this opportunity to thank you, once again, for coming to Michigan to hear our perspective. I pledge to give you any help that I can, as you seek to learn more about what works and what is wasted in education.