Build Michigan II:
Repair, Reform & Responsibility
Fix the Roads
Fix the System
Fix the Funding
- More than 3,300 miles of road repaired, repaved and reconstructed yearly -- an increase
of 1,125 miles.
- $570 million annual increase in road spending for a total increase of more than $2.8
billion over five years.
- Every state road that needs repair fixed over 10 years.
- Michigan's fair share of federal transportation dollars.
- Trucks pay more in line with the damage they cause.
- Complex jurisdictions are simplified, and the state takes responsibility for heavily
travelled roads.
- Cities will receive 74% more money for their roads and counties will receive 53% more
money for their roads.
- Competition for maintenance work will reduce costs and improve service.
- Further reforms squeeze every extra dollar possible to spend on roads.
The most comprehensive and ambitious plan to improve and reform Michigan's
transportation system in nearly 50 years.
Talking Points
Governor John Engler
Thursday, May 8, 1997
The Build Michigan II Strategy
| "The goal of Build Michigan II is shared by
every Michigan driver -- repairing our roads so that our transportation system is second
to none." |
Objectives
- Dramatically increase the number of miles of roadway that are repaired and resurfaced
each year.
- Reform our transportation system to increase efficiency and accountability, while
redirecting the savings to invest in roads.
- Put responsibility for fixing our roads where it properly belongs -- no more
pointing fingers or passing blame.
The Challenge
- The old transportation system -- created at the turn of the century -- includes a
hodgepodge of jurisdictions in which cities, counties and the state are responsible for a
maze of different roads used for different purposes. This system of outdated
jurisdictional boundaries that have nothing to do with the reality of everyday life and
the transportation needs of individuals and businesses promotes inefficiency,
discontinuity, and disinvestment in our most heavily travelled roads.
| EXAMPLE: Middlebelt Road has been improved
in the communities to the north and to the south of Inkster (Garden City and Westland) but
not through Inkster. Why? Garden City and Westland chose to spend their road repair funds
on Middlebelt; Inkster did not. Build Michigan II solves this problem and repairs the
road. |
- Reforms must be enacted to improve the efficiency of Michigan's transportation system
and to maximize the dollars spent repairing roads. These include stopping frivolous and
outrageous lawsuits so that there is less money for lawyers and more money for roads,
eliminating the outdated and unnecessary "spillage" allowance and improving the
way we insure road construction projects.
- A stable, long-term source of increased funding is needed to reconstruct and repair
Michigan roads. Recently, a group of business leaders estimated the increased need at $400
million. Revenue sources include getting Michigan's fair share from Washington,
making sure that trucks pay their fair share and raising the gasoline tax.
In addition, state government is tightening its belt to provide an unprecedented $43
million from the General Fund.
The Build Michigan II Action Plan
- Expand the system of state roads from less than 10,000 miles to more than 33,000
miles by adding all roads statewide that support the growth and smooth operation of our
economy. These are also roads that are eligible for federal aid. Roads that only provide
access to homes will properly remain under the jurisdiction of counties and cities.
- Under the new system, cities will be responsible for 14 percent of Michigan roadways and
counties will maintain 58 percent, while the state will control 28 percent. However, 90
percent of the traffic in Michigan will be on state roads which are the most expensive
to maintain.
| EXAMPLE: Of the 125 worst roads in Michigan
as reported by AAA, two-thirds are under local jurisdiction today. When Build Michigan II
is implemented, 90 percent of those roads will be under state jurisdiction. |
- Under the old system, Michigan ranked 48th in the percentage of state-controlled
roads. Under Build Michigan II, we would rank 11th -- comparable to a state like
North Carolina, where roads are generally rated excellent. Other benefits of this
new definition of responsibilities include:
- Road improvements and expansions will be made based on the benefits to be derived by the
entire road system, not political boundaries, significantly enhancing
connectivity.
- Maintenance on the higher-volume roads and streets will be competitively bid out, reducing
costs and improving service. In fact, Build Michigan II creates a $360 million road
maintenance industry in Michigan. Efficient county and city road departments will enjoy
opportunities to expand the work they do.
- Local governments will be relieved of the costly regulatory and administrative burden
of maintaining high volume roadways.
| "The bottom line is that the quality of
Michigan roads shouldn't change at the county line. Build Michigan II will restore our
transportation system so that roads are good in Monroe or Marquette, in Detroit or Grand
Rapids." |
Getting Michigan's Fair Share From Washington
| FACT: Michigan has been consistently
shortchanged by the federal government when it comes to getting back our fair share of
federal gas tax dollars paid by the driving public. Michigan ranks 46th in rate of return,
receiving only about 78 percent of what the average state gets back from the federal
government. |
- With Congress expected to act this year to renew federal transportation legislation,
Michigan has a perfect opportunity to increase its rate of return on federal gas tax
dollars. Alternatives include:
- The federal government could significantly increase the overall level of funding
for transportation by either spending at least the amount raised through gas taxes each
year, spending some of the interest earned by the highway trust fund, or taking advantage
of some of the $20 billion surplus currently in the fund.
- The 4.3 cents per gallon federal gas tax increase enacted in 1993 that has been
diverted for deficit reduction could instead be used for our roads, dramatically
increasing the funds available for distribution to the states.
- A more equitable distribution formula based on vehicle miles, road use and/or
weather conditions would generate increased funding for Michigan. Efforts to reform these
outdated distribution formulas are gaining momentum because the 21 "donor"
states control more than 60% of the votes in the U.S. House of Representatives.
- Greater flexibility from the federal government as to how transportation funds
can be spent would both streamline the process and allow Michigan to qualify for more
federal funding programs, especially with transit dollars where our rate of return is even
lower.
- A plan supported by both Michigan Senators -- Spencer Abraham and Carl Levin -- repeals
12 cents of the federal gas tax and allows states like Michigan to levy it themselves,
increasing Michigan's rate of return to 100 percent.
| FACT: There are five bills introduced in
Congress that change the distribution formula for federal gas tax dollars. The average
increase for Michigan is $209 million! |
Raising Additional Revenue for Michigan Roads
- Build Michigan II also includes a number of fundamental and system-wide reforms that
provide additional revenue. For example, increasing the commercial truck registration fee
to keep pace with inflation raises $38 million. Combined with the elimination of the
diesel discount (already enacted), elimination of the "spillage" allowance and
the overweight truck fee, trucks will pay more in line with the damage they do to our
roads. These changes combine to provide an additional $130 million to invest in Michigan
roads.
- Tort reform provides another $10 million while a new plan to "wrap-up"
-- or bundle -- insurance on construction projects statewide will save as much as $30
million.
- Build Michigan II includes a 4 penny increase in Michigan's gasoline tax to provide
another $200 million in revenue. By increasing the current 15 cent tax to 19 cents,
Michigan's tax is still below the national average, the same as Illinois and below
every Great Lakes state except Indiana.
- The sum total of all of these reforms (more federal money, Michigan reforms, and
increased gas tax) is an additional $570 million each year to invest in repairing,
resurfacing and repaving Michigan roads, plus new construction.
- Over the next five years, Build Michigan II represents a $2.8 billion increase in
transportation spending. In terms of capital investment in road improvement and
expansion (not maintenance or other road spending), this is a $1.9 billion increase over
Build Michigan I.
- A new State Gas Tax fund is created in which all 19 cents of state gas tax will
be deposited. Cities and counties will share 9 cents, while the state's share is 10 cents.
Build Michigan II guarantees, for the first time, that every penny of the gas tax will
be spent on roads -- no diversions allowed. Every dollar, every dime, every penny will
be spent on improving Michigan roads.
- The revenues per mile available for county and city governments to spend on their
local roads is increased dramatically. Counties will see their revenues per mile climb
53 percent and cities will see their revenues per mile climb 74 percent.
| "Not one penny will be spent to increase the
number of employees at MDOT. Build Michigan II is not a plan to build government. It
is a plan to build and repair Michigan's roads into the next century. We can't fix the
roads unless we fix the system" |
Build Michigan II -- Where the Rubber Meets the Road
- Build Michigan II will repair, reconstruct and repave an additional 1,125 miles
of road each year. This is 1,000 miles over and above what county and local
governments would have done under the old system and another 125 miles over and above
what would have been done on state roads.
- Each year, more than 3,300 miles of state roads and highways will be repaired,
reconstructed and repaved or receive preventive maintenance.
- Over ten years, Build Michigan II will improve every single mile in the new state
road system that needs improvement -- a system that will handle 90 percent of the traffic
statewide.
- With an additional $570 million per year for Michigan roads, Build Michigan II
guarantees a stable, long-term source of revenue to improve and expand our
transportation infrastructure.
- Build Michigan II focuses on fairness -- a fair return from Washington, trucks
paying their fair share and a more fair distribution of responsibility among cities,
counties and the state.
- The 4 penny increase in the gasoline tax amounts to about $22 per year for the average
driver (15,000 miles per year/550 gallons). That amounts to less than 50 cents a week.
"We don't have until the next century -- or even
next year -- to get moving.
I urge the legislature to enact this plan before they leave for summer break so that the
new system can be in place by October 1st."Get it done by
July 1 because Build Michigan II is a win-win proposition -- for cities, for counties, for
the state and for our families." |
The Build Michigan Record
| "Build Michigan I rebuilt, repaired and resurfaced
more roads and bridges than any comparable period in state history. In fact, we spent $1.5
billion more on capital investments than was spent during the last half of the
1980's." |
- 1,000 miles of highways were improved each year -- for a total of 5,000 miles
of state roads resurfaced, repaired, or given preventive maintenance. During the last half
of the 1980s, less than 3,000 miles of roads were repaired.
- Of particular note to freeway travelers, 52 miles of I-96 were improved as were 70
miles of I-75 and 145 miles of I-94. That means about one of every three total
miles of these roads was improved.
- From 1991 to 1997, the Michigan Department of Transportation streamlined and reorganized
its operations, trimming the bureaucracy by 25 percent and eliminating waste. As a
result, more than $400 million has been saved in administrative costs and every penny was
invested in our roads, including a 40 percent increase in funding for local roads.
- A Preventive Maintenance program was implemented, extending pavement life on
nearly 2,500 miles of Michigan's trunkline.
- Construction is nearing completion on major road and bridge improvements all across
Michigan, including:
- 9th Street Bridge in Kalamazoo, complete this summer.
- Davison Freeway will be completed this fall.
- 1 Desperately needed passing lanes are being built in northern Michigan and
the UP.
- Five sections were completed last year with five more to be competed in 1997.
- 1 Three more segments of M-59 will be completed this year and the final leg
connecting to I-94 will be complete next year.
- 1 Haggerty Connector will be complete by the end of 1998.
- 1 The US-27 freeway will be completed next year.
- 1 M-20 will be completed this year.
- 1 Widening of M-37 in Grand Rapids will be completed this year.
- Build Michigan brought a critical new focus on bridge repair. In fact, MDOT has
worked on nearly 1,300 bridges since 1991. In 1997 alone, more than 285 bridges will be
repaired.
- Build Michigan improved more than 450 railroad grade crossings and installed reflective
pavement markers on more than 1400 miles or rural freeway.
NewsPaper Articles Discussing the Proposed Build Michigan II Plan
Detroit Free Press
ROAD FIX:
Changing the system is important part of repairs
Finally,
Engler takes lead on roads
Fix
Michigan roads by fixing system, funding methods
Detroit News
Finishing
the Road Equation
Cutting
Auto Insurance Costs
Engler:
No gasoline tax increase without road reforms
Now
we'll see who has 'courage' on road issues
Engler
puts himself in driver's seat on road issue
Average
Revenue Per Mile Analysis - Provided by M*DOT DEAD LINK
Build Michigan II: Repair, Reform &
Responsibility - Speech by Governor Engler DEAD LINK
Governor Engler's Bold Plan to Fix
Michigan's Roads - Press Release