Roles, Responsibilities and Agency Implications
To what extent will e-Michigan assume responsibility or input to the processes of individual agencies? Does e-Michigan involvement focus only on Web-enabled services or does it also include the daily operations of the agency?
e-Michigan is focused on ensuring that agencies Web-enable any commonly used services that lend themselves to being delivered on-line. We are particularly focused on initiatives that cross agency boundaries. In those cases, we will work with agencies to create a standardized process for delivering commonly used services. Although we strongly encourage agencies to undertake business process improvement initiatives to maximize the use of Web-enabled services and new technologies, e-Michigan is not responsible for leading or managing these efforts.
What are the common issues other departments are facing? What are the experiences and lessons learned of these departments?
The most common issue faced by departments today is how to integrate ongoing or planned web activities into the e-Michigan initiative. We are currently organizing a repository of FAQ's and lessons learned to share amongst departments.
How does e-Michigan address the conflict that may arise between e-Michigan's objectives and agency/departments priorities?
The Governor has informed the Cabinet that "e-Michigan priorities are your priorities." This means that the Internet enablement of agency services are a priority for everyone. However, this must be done with a statewide perspective. e-Michigan will partner with state agencies to achieve this goal. Where initiatives exist that are unique to an agency we will provide support as necessary.
What are the roles/responsibility boundaries of e-Michigan with respect to the state employee services and departmental intranets?
Our current focus is on Internet based applications. However there may be instances where work on departmental intranets will limit the ability to focus on Internet services. In these instances we will work with departments to assess priorities. Actual services to employees will be enhanced primarily through the web based aspects of HRMN. Other appropriate linkages, existing departmental based intranets will not be addressed in the near future.
How will e-Michigan manage to keep abreast of the dynamic inventory of Internet applications being planned, developed, and implemented by all of the agencies and departments?
A directive was communicated to the cabinet that all new development contemplated by agencies is to be reviewed by the e-Michigan office. This includes procurement of services for these activities. In many cases we may advise the agency to go ahead with the process and include language to recognize the impact of common look and feel on the final product. In other instances we will ask the agency to continue the initiative but expand it to take a state-wide view and include other departments. However, there may be instances where we will require the agency to delay or cancel the project. Additionally the Budget Office asked e-Michigan to conduct a review of all FY02 budget requests as they relate to internet activity and provide recommendations as to their priority.
We have already started a redesign effort for our agency web site. Should we continue or wait to see the direction that e-Michigan is going as far as design?
We recommend that you wait for a little longer on the site redesign (but not content design), if you can. Much of the work required for site redesign is with the organizational approach to accessing information. This should go on as planned as it will assist in later implementations. We will be coming out with a look & feel and navigation standards that we will share with everyone sometime after the portal vendor comes on board and we have had time to develop the template in the new content management tool. Webmaster Liaisons were briefed on the look-and-feel design at the March 15 meeting. We will continue to share additional information at subsequent Webmaster, e-Technology Advisory Group and IMPACT meetings.
Should we continue to develop/refine the content of our Websites?
Yes. The layout and aggregation of this content may evolve as the new look-and-feel is rolled out to agencies and as content is incorporated into the sub-portals. However, the content should be kept up-to-date and refined, as needed, to serve your customers.
Will each site, even if hosted externally, be required to comply with the new navigation standards? If so, will additional funding be provided?
Yes. All sites, whether hosted internally or externally, will be required to comply with the new look-and-feel and navigational standards that are being established for the State. The agency CIO should contact Peyman Zand, Deputy Director of e-Michigan, to further discuss the agency's particular circumstances and funding alternatives.
Will there be any "Web work" in the State of Michigan government that is not part of e-Michigan?
No. All internet enabled activities must be coordinated with the e-Michigan Office. This will not only provide for a consistent look and feel across the State of Michigan sites, but also allow us to leverage individual agency efforts for enterprise wide use.
Policies and Standards
What are the legal and policy standards and is there a group/individual responsible for focusing on this area?
The most pressing legal and policy standard being addressed is privacy. Other policy issues relate to agency versus enterprise wide ownership and roles. The e-Michigan Program Office is charged with identifying and addressing these types of issues. Additionally support is provided by the e-MI Leadership Committee and e-Technology Committee. These 2 entities, consisting of Dept Directors/Deputy Directors and State Agency CIOs, respectively, will be asked to review and approve new policies and standards necessary to realize e-MI's vision. Standards are being considered for the following areas at this time (for additional information, please refer to the Portal RFP).
  • Portal platform
  • Intelligent search engine
  • Content management
  • Personalization
  • Directory services
  • XML Implementation
  • WAP Integration
  • e-CRM
  • Policies such as privacy, security and advertising
  • Portal performance management
  • Quality management acceptance criteria
  • Advanced business intelligence
  • Security (CA/PKI issues)
  • Web design and navigation
  • Accessibility and ADA issues
  • Common data dictionaries (could tie to data warehousing)
  • Common payment module
  • Look and feel/branding
  • Middleware solutions
How do we address proprietary information such as copyrights, logos, text, and graphics that the States' web sites publish?
We intend to retain and honor all proprietary information rights. Our policies addressing such information will be published through the State portal.
How are you involving the State's Purchasing Office with respect to privacy and liability policy contract issues?
Representatives of the State Purchasing Office are significantly involved in the State portal project. We will seek their counsel and assistance on other e-Michigan procurements.
Does e-Michigan have the authority to demand/specify URL addresses for all agencies after the new portal is implemented?
e-Michigan will focus on the web address for the state portal and related sub-portals to ensure a common look and feel. Page specific URL's are not a priority. We need to ensure smooth linkage through the portal and no wrong entry point for a customer.
Who gets the revenue from a deal with a private entity for such things like information provided to that entity? Would it go back to the respective department or e-Michigan, general fund, shared?
A policy for revenue sharing has not been finalized but may be similar to the benefit sharing approach contemplated. In this model a portion of the funds will be retained by the agency and a portion applied to the ongoing operations of the portal and related sites.
With regard to "common database elements", what type of database software will e-Michigan use to set the database standard?
e-Michigan has not standardized on a particular database and it is unlikely that we will. Any portal developed should be able to run with any database platform. In fact, given the abundance of SQL servers and the fact that about 60% of current web development in the state uses Microsoft products, the integration to SQL seems likely. However, e-Michigan will not standard on database, OITS will need to do that. We will make sure we have a solution that works with industry open database standards.
Will e-Michigan provide a schedule/plan for rolling out statewide standards?
Standards are being developed in collaboration with the e-Technology Advisory Group, agency CIOs, IMPACT and other technology experts across the State. We are developing a comprehensive list of standards to be addressed that will be rolled out shortly. As standards are established, they will be communicated to agencies. At that point, a timeframe and approach for implementing the standards will be provided.
Common Look-and-Feel Across Web Sites
What impact will the new "State brand" have on the use of agency logos and brands? Will agency logos be replaced with the State brand?
At this point, the focus of e-Michigan will be to create a State brand that is used on the main portal and subportals. We are exploring options in the new look and feel to incorporate agency logos. As an example, if the Michigan brand is encapsulated in a banner at the top of the portal page (like that shown on the State home page today), the banner will be carried through to the other agency pages with the agency information placed underneath that banner.
Will customers notice a dramatic change with the new State brand or look and feel of the portal?
The Michigan State Website and agency Websites already have a large user-base. Those individuals are familiar with our current sites and are used to the current level of navigation provided. For example, many users know exactly which agency Website to visit for a particular form or piece of information. e-Michigan staff and agency Steering Committee members are taking great steps to ensure that the current functionality is not changed overnight in a way that users can no longer quickly get to the information they need. We will use a phased approach and comprehensive communications plan to introduce the new/revised functionality to our on-line community.
How will the new "look and feel" of the portal be developed? To what extent will this be used on other web sites?
Brogan and Partners is developing the look and feel and the layout of the state portal. The focus groups and the design work are underway and we should have a finished product by the end of February. Once this work is done, the portal and all sub-portals will need to follow this new look and feel. Considerable work is being done to not only have a common look and feel, but to also preserve the agency look and feel.
When will the new "look and feel" be made available to agencies?
The new "look and feel" will be rolled out to agencies in the April/May time frame. First, the design must be created in the content management tool that is selected for the portal. That will help to establish the dimensions, fonts and other specifications that all agencies will use. A prototype of the design is available in the March 15 Webmaster presentation found here. This is meant as a demonstration only. The final design will depend on the formatting and development features of the new content management tool.
Why are frames being considered as part of the look and feel when this does not comply with disability standards?
Ultimately, the standard Web design will be a template that is created and managed within a content management tool. This design will be ADA compliant. e-Michigan is considering a frameset as an interim means of sharing the design across agencies until the content management tool and design template can be rolled out to all agencies.
Portal Technologies and Implementation
What is the timeline for the portal procurement?
Vendors will submit their bids by January 24. We plan to have the vendor(s) begin work by March. The State portal will be launched 90 days after the vendor(s) are on board. The standards listed on the Portal RFP will be set for all agencies, which includes items such as content management, security and portal platform.
How will e-Michigan address the potential conflicts that arise with agency/ departmental contracts that currently manage, host, maintain, etc. related Internet applications, with the e-Michigan portal solution?
The procurement for the State portal includes an option for external hosting. In conjunction with the State CIO we will work to recommend the option which is most advantageous to the State. This may include the consolidation of other departmental site hosting activities.
What are the plans for advertising the new portal upon release?
A comprehensive marketing strategy for the portal and all e-Michigan projects is being developed. If you have any marketing ideas or recommendations as to specific audiences or communications vehicles, please share them with the e-Michigan Communications Director, Janna Schmidt.
What is the plan to ensure that if someone links to a subject within an Agency, they will be able to link to similar material within the Portal? For example, if a person links to a Kid's Page within an Agency Website, how will they know there are other "Kid's Pages" available within the Portal? Will Agencies be able to link to e-Michigan content just as e-Michigan will link to Agency content?
Firstly, there will be no "e-Michigan content". Instead, the State portal will continue to be based on agency-specific content. However, it will organize that content at a statewide level by theme or customer life experience. Customers will then be able to access the agency content through these themes or by navigating directly to an agency Web site. This supports the e-Michigan goal of providing a "no wrong door" approach to all of the information on State/agency web sites. This means that customers accessing information through any entry point - State portal, agency web site, theme sub-portal - will be able to easily move around to other areas within the site. 

Secondly, agencies will be able to manage content and links across all of these different entry points using the new content management tool selected as part of the portal technology suite. In fact, this tool will automatically and dynamically offer related links to visitors who select a particular topic without the agency having to manually create and update these links. More information about this tool will be provided to CIOs and Web masters via regularly scheduled e-Michigan meetings.
Will a copy of the winning proposal for the portal vendor RFP be made available following the award of the contract?
Agency staff interested in reviewing all or part of the winning proposal should contact Peyman Zand, Deputy Director of e-Michigan.
How will the new tools, such as content management, affect agency Webmasters and Web development?
Webmasters will be trained on the use of the content management tool to make the updating, modification and approval process for changes to content go smoothly. The process will be made easy and accessible that even business experts rather than technical experts can modify content (of course the change will then go through the automated workflow process for approval before it will be posted). The centralized distribution and management of content development is still under review by e-Michigan. The way that programmers use and manage this tool in the agency will vary. E-Michigan will work directly with the Webmaster liaison, CIO and other technology representatives from each agency to determine how the tool will be implemented and the best way to manage the tool going forward for the agency.
Will all Web development be done using the new tools provided by the portal vendor or will these just apply to the portal pages?
All Web development within the State will use the new tools. This will ensure the centralization of content into a database that is easily maintained, shared and searchable so that all state agencies can provide customers with the most up-to-date and appropriate content. It will also make it easier for agency developers to share best practices, tools and experiences across the State.
Themes and Sub-Portals
State employees have been identified as one of the primary stakeholders for e-Michigan initiatives. Why aren't there any employee-specific initiatives listed on the current e-Michigan timeline?
Many Web-based services for State employees will be offered via the HRMN (Human Resource Management Network) self-service applications. For the current status of the HRMN implementation, please visit the HRMN Website at http://intra.state.mi.us/hrmn/.
General Questions about e-Michigan
Citizens often define "Government" as including both State and local services. Are e-Michigan initiatives going to encompass local services and agencies, as well?
Not at this time. For the next two years, e-Michigan will focus on developing the State portal and brand, and will lead State agencies in e-enabling their services. Eventually, the State will try to expand its partnerships with local government entities and offer guidance to those who don't have a Web presence or would like to improve the one they have. If they are interested in the experience and best practices of the State around e-enabling government services or would like to see certain pages link to their Websites, we will be happy to respond to any questions they have.
Will the portal provide links to local and federal government Web sites?
Currently e-Michigan is focused on aggregating and organization State government service offerings on the portal. Links to local or federal governments and agencies may be used when these organizations are key to the customer's ability to find desired information or complete a State government transaction. A linkage policy is currently being developed by e-Michigan and other State technology leaders. Although not focused solely on linkage to other government organizations, this policy will address this issue.
What will become of e-Michigan after May 1, 2002, when Executive Order 2000-6 (Go to the Executive Order) expires?
Throughout this project, the e-Michigan Office will capture the best practices and experiences of the State in portal development and e-enabling government services. In this capacity, the e-Michigan Office is functioning as a Center of Excellence (COE) for State Web development efforts. This is a long-term, continuous effort. The information and resources developed within this COE are expected to remain intact for the future, but it is has not yet been decided where (e.g., as a separate entity or within an existing agency) the COE will actually reside or how it will be maintained.
Data processors and Web developers across the State have had frustration with sharing knowledge and experience between departments and agencies. Will e-Michigan be addressing this issue?
The e-Michigan Office is functioning as a Center of Excellence (COE) for State Web development efforts. The dissemination and sharing of this information will be critical to the success of all e-initiatives at the State and agency levels. To this extent, we will develop a knowledgebase to which all State experts can contribute and from which they can build their own knowledge and skills. Prior to the launching of a formal knowledgebase, if you have any ideas or concerns (e.g., regarding standards, federal regulations, unfamiliar technologies) please contact us directly via e-mail so that we can help to address those issues.
Is e-Michigan considering/identifying creative/unique business models as funding alternatives for initiatives?
e-Michigan has received an appropriation from the Legislature to perform many of the initiatives necessary. However we realize additional funds will be required to complete our mission. We have begun to develop criteria for accepting funds for advertising, gifts donations or contributions to assist in underwriting the costs of state web activities. Other revenue, such as transaction fees, will be considered on an individual basis. Additionally a benefit capture approach is being developed to share the savings realized from implementation of electronic government initiatives.
Some citizens do not currently have access to the Internet. Is e-Michigan going to address this issue?
Increasing the accessibility of the Internet to a broader population in the State will remain a challenge for the foreseeable future. However, organizations other than e-Michigan are leading this effort. For more information, view the Universal Service Fund Website at http://www.fcc.gov/ccb/universal_service/welcome.html. Additionally, Governor Engler has asked the e-Michigan Office, the MEDC and the PSC to study and make recommendations to increase access to the Internet.
What process was used to identify "your customers"? Who are our customers?
A consumer research initiative was conducted by Public Policy Associates to examine how the State could organize information and services to better meet customer needs. Additional work with Deloitte Consulting was performed during the strategic planning process to further clarify customer orientation and needs. Each theme was represented in the strategic planning process. Additional delineation of customer segments can be conducted by theme leadership.
Who can provide the criteria used for the e-Michigan Web Functionality Assessment Summary on each of the Departments? Will copies be made available?
This information has been compiled and sent to the Agency Directors. Please contact Agency Directors for this report.
What other states are or have undertaken similar initiatives?
Many states have undertaken significant electronic government initiatives. Some of these include Florida, Pennsylvania, North Carolina and Washington. Many others are in the development stage. Our goal is to become the leading state in providing trusted electronic government services to all customers.
In the Cabinet Briefing presentation and other presentations to e-Michigan stakeholders, there is a "Where are We Going" slide that shows progress from the current "Interaction" web phase to the "Transformation" phase. Is there a timeframe established for this transition?
It is the intent of e-Michigan to propel the state into the transaction stage within one year and to start the transformation into the final personalization phase in 2001 as well.