Catherine_Edit === Catherine Knight Steele: [00:00:00] So I just want to really open it up for questions. I'm happy to talk about experiences. I've had organizations I've worked with, et cetera, but also just to help think through ideas with folks. Just to give you some background on some ways that this might become relevant for you all going forward. I have not published a ton with community groups. That's not something that has been a part of my academic journey thus far, but what digital humanities more broadly tends to do, right? And so my facilitation of DH centers and labs has done, has put me in contact with a lot of researchers who have worked with community organizations and done community based projects mostly in the area of things like historical and archival work so a lot of kind of, community folks who want to work with re with the tools that researchers have access to in order to archive documents, to digitize documents to work with universities or to individual researchers in certain ways. And there are a lot of, great things that can come out of those kind of partnering [00:01:00] relationships. There are a lot of problematics that often come out of university partnerships with community organizations, as I'm sure a lot of you have heard of before. And there are problematics that come out for the community groups. I think most notably, there's also a lot of difficulty that can come out of those kind of partnerings for academics in terms of getting work published, recognized, utilized in terms of tenure promotion, dissertation research, et cetera, right? So you doing non traditional kinds of projects or doing public facing projects can have a lot of impact on folks careers depending on where they are and whether or not their departments and disciplines are amenable to that kind of work. So I can talk in broad strokes. I can talk about some examples of that, but I also I'm just curious if there's other things that you all, want to talk about research related things or publishing related things, anything like that. So I'll turn it over. If folks have questions, go ahead, Jasmine. Jasmine Banks: Okay. I don't know if you remember from when we've met, I always have a lot of questions. So this person is a lot more meta and something that I'm thinking of [00:02:00] more recently. So I have to go on job market apparently at some point. And something I've noticed from people who I've shared similar space spaces with, so like I'm in psychology, but a lot of my, like all of my work is in the digital space and something that I would love to hear your thoughts on is like ways to I guess position myself as someone who is interdisciplinary when I go onto the market and especially because I don't know if I just know I don't want to be in just a psych department, but like I could be in any of the other departments that would align but like seeing people on the market now being in spaces where they're like, Oh we love your work, but I don't know where to put you. And I'm anxious about that. So I would love to hear your thoughts about that. Catherine Knight Steele: Yeah, I think the challenge is a great question. And the challenge is that universities talk a lot about interdisciplinarity and the importance of interdisciplinarity without as many supports in place for scholars whose work is actually interdisciplinary unfortunately. So many of the hallmarks of the process of hiring and promotion, etc. are [00:03:00] very disciplinarily focused. So hiring tends to happen within a singular discipline. Joint hires can happen between a couple of different departments at a university. I'm going to say this, I'm gonna say one, always take the job, get the job, getting jobs is great things, but joint appointments are tough. So while they seem really desirable for interdisciplinary scholars, I was, when I was in grad school and I went to my advisor and I was like, I just want to be in like two departments. I want to be in like a comm department and like a black studies department. And he was like, that's great, no. Not until after tenure, are you allowed to do that. And I was like, that's ridiculous. My work isn't. It moves between these areas. I would like to be able to be in conversation with different kinds of folks doing different kinds of research. And structurally, one, the hire is always in one department. So like the tech, the line that someone gets usually goes through a particular department. What that means is that in the hiring process, again, this is usually, there can be exceptions. Usually that means that the vote on whether or not you get the job is going to happen by a certain discipline. [00:04:00] And then there's going to be like an, okay. By the other department, right? Oh, yeah, we'd like her to she's cool. But what that means if you're hired into a department is that you're also promoted through a department and through a particular discipline, which means that you're bound by the rules and policies of how they do promotions. And in that department, which means for certain fields and certain disciplines, they want you to publish in their field. Now there are some disciplines who are like, I don't care where you publish in a good journal anywhere. That's great. American studies, right? It tends to be the kind of a department, a kind of a discipline that is interdisciplinary at its core. And it's just okay, you published in psyche, you published in, so she published in comp. These are great. That's wonderful. As long as these are regarded journals. Great. Or they're a good fit for your work. There are other disciplines that are like, unless you're publishing in our fields, journals, unless you are getting books with the presses that we deem appropriate for our field. We don't regard your work as important. That's [00:05:00] very unfortunate, but it is a reality of certain departments. I have had that experience, and this isn't across the board, true. Psychology tends to be one of those places. Political science tends to be one of those places. Sociology tends to be one of those places where they are very keen on you publishing within your discipline and because you're going to be reviewed by people who are within your discipline. So when you're on the market and you're thinking ahead to what kind of discipline do I want to find myself in or what kind of department do I want to find myself in? You really need to think through what is the like kind of trajectory of the career that I want to have. Do I want to continue in this lane? Do I want to be able to keep working with different folks publishing across different areas? Or am I really content to stay in this space and be like a vanguard in sociology, right? There aren't a lot of folks publishing digital sociology. So the folks who are doing it are very well regarded in that discipline. But there are a lot of people publishing in digital in communication, for example, right? So it's maybe a little bit more difficult to be like, we're good. So if that doesn't matter to you, you have to think about those [00:06:00] things up front. In terms of positioning yourself for different places, the thing that I would suggest is one conferencing with folks that you see yourself publishing with and working alongside, right? So finding the conferences that either are in the disciplines that you see yourself potentially applying in. Or are interdisciplinarily focused. So for digital studies, you've got SCMS, you've got AOIR both of which are interdisciplinary conferences. It's not just one kind of scholar that's going to be there. Then disciplinarily for digital studies, you've got ASA, you've got American Studies, you've got National Communication Association to some degree, but you've got International Communication Association as well. There are, and there are more but You want to think, who am I in conversation with now in graduate school? Who am I going to be writing alongside as I move through? Then you can start to train your focus as you get closer to the market and think about where you're sending off your publications for press. So for example, if you think you're going to be [00:07:00] applying to American Studies departments, you're going to want to publish in some of their disciplinary journals so that you have a way to say when the job call says we want a scholar who does digital say that at a time and they also have to be able to teach our core course in X. You can be like, Oh, yeah, here's the thing. I know that. And here's how I can show you that. I know that thing. So you need your CV to have a trail of plausible ways that you are connected to that discipline, but then you also need to do your homework on the schools you're applying to, to see what their tenure and promotion process is like. If I'm applying to Maryland in their comm department, do all their faculty have comm PhDs? That's a good, that's a thing we can find out from websites, usually. Where are their faculty publishing? And these are, again, things we can find out from websites. So when we're getting ready to apply to that school, I can say, Oh, wow, you know what? I would have applied. That seemed like a perfect call for me, but their sociology department only hires people with sociology PhDs. They only publish [00:08:00] in sociology journals. I don't think I'm gonna be a good fit. Now, I'm not saying that means, that doesn't mean apply. Because the thing that we know about the application process is that white men tend to, this is research, white men tend to apply for everything. And we tend to look at applications and go, I'm not a right fit. I'm not going to apply for that. And it's just taking ourself out of the pool. So if and when you do apply to those places, just understand that folks on the other side on the committee have a rubric and one of the things on the rubric might say, are they a fit for the discipline, right? Are they publishing in X journals? So if that's something that you want to be able to say yes to, think about it early in your process. How do I get, place something here, place something there so that I'm visible and understandable in those places. And the first place to start is conferencing. Jasmine Banks: No, that was great. I'm definitely going to get a job now. David Tortolini: Thinking about community facing work. I'm just thinking about like methods, because right now I'm in like, I'm preparing for comps, [00:09:00] it's the methods classes methods world, this semester I'm writing the questions is when you're doing your work, how transparent, are you with methods when you're public facing compared to like on the academic side and also like the language you use, I'm trying to find a happy middle between language for everybody language for us. Catherine Knight Steele: That's a great question. You mean in terms of publishing the work and sharing the work. Yeah, that's a great question. So I'll answer it this way. It's, it is dependent right on what exactly you mean by public facing work, there is some, there are some kinds of public facing work that are more closely aligned to things like policy, for example, and white paperwork, where appendices of methods are incredibly important because people are still interested in like how you got to where you got to there, are some of us who try to write for example, in our book writing in ways that have appeals in both worlds. Like we want scholars to read our work. It's important to us, but we'd also like the people were writing about to be able to pick up the book and read [00:10:00] it. In that version, the methods become so shrunken. They don't, it's not that they don't exist and it's not that they aren't rigorous but they become such a small part of the actual book itself. Like the public press book has usually does not have a method section. If anything, it might mention it in an appendix. I didn't have a methods appendix in my book, for example, but another book that I always point to as doing this really was Sarah Florini's book which has this really lovely methods appendix. I didn't find it as useful for what I was trying to accomplish in my introduction to spend concerted effort in one section talking about what I did. And so I answer a lot of questions about that from academics when I'm now talking about it because it's not in that place. And so it's a give and take because you could spend a great deal of time writing about it, and you could avoid that kind of question from other folks. Or you can write in such a way where you meld what you did [00:11:00] into the work itself. And I think that there is some level of transparency that is always going to be required if you want the work to do double duty. So if you expect to do public facing work that still is going to help you professionally that it has to be readable by the professionals that are going to assess your work. If you want to do public facing work and you don't care, if your university gives you credit for it, then you have a little bit more freedom in terms of how you write it. But know that scholars on the other side are going to be looking at that work and going, is this academic work? Is this research? Is this opinion writing and I think Jessica, were you in class with me when we had this conversation? I think a little bit last semester about some academics who have fully crossed into public scholarship and how publics read this work so differently than academics do. It's really beautifully written work. It's doing important stuff, right? It's bringing folks into conversations. And then you have academics who read it and go, that's not what they're, that's not even what their PhDs in. [00:12:00] Or they go what's the. Where did that come from? Is there data for that? Or is that kind of just our thoughts on things? How are we doing this? And again, it really is a personal thing. What do I care? Do I genuinely want academics? I wanted academics to read my book. I wrote the book thinking, I really hope the people I'm writing about read it, but I really hope grad students read it. I really hope that graduate students who are studying Black feminism and digital scholarship and Black women online can use this effectively. So it mattered to me that it read in ways that was replicable. There were products that they could take out of it and put it into research. So trying to balance those items out. But there are honestly sometimes where it's just not appropriate to write a long method section. If you're a grant writing, you're going to still have to do that, right? Cause your grants that you're getting are still going to be very interested in how you're carrying out the work because ultimately many organizations want replicability, right? Like we're giving you this [00:13:00] money. Yes. So you can carry out this thing, but so that other people can read this and also do that work. NEH, Melon, et cetera. They want you to do activities that other scholars could do also later. I know that's not like a direct, do this or don't answer , but it is very specific in that way. David Tortolini: No, I appreciate it. It's like a conundrum sometimes for me when I write. Catherine Knight Steele: It is I think that it took me, I would say it took me a lot of years to actually find a voice in writing that felt genuine and also did multiple layers of work. I think that when I was writing in graduate school, particularly I was absolutely only writing in like for an academic audience. It didn't even occur to me that like anyone besides an academic would read what I was writing in a journal. It was probably not until I got closer to book writing that I thought, other people might want to read this book because I'm writing about things, [00:14:00] that are of interest to other people. And I could write it in a way. And for me at that stage, I picked a person and I always talk about I picked a person that I. I picked a couple people. So I had a graduate student in mind that I knew at that time. And I was like, I want them to find this book useful. I picked like somebody who I would need to rely on for promotion. Like somebody who could write an external letter. It's I would want them to find this book rigorous. And then I picked my sister in law and I said, I want my sister in law to be able to pick this up and be like that was interesting. I got that, that made sense to me. And my sister in law is a very smart person. She wasn't able to finish school for lots of reasons and doesn't sit in academic circles and libraries and read, scholarship, but I wanted her to be able to pick up the book and not feel like, ugh what are you, this isn't even how you talk, what are you writing here? So trying to find that place where those three people would get something out of it, even though I knew there would be sections of it that each one of them would not like. But I knew when I was writing the section on ashiness and [00:15:00] Cardi B, that like, there would be folks in my discipline at the full level who'd be like, what is she talking about? And why? Like, why was that necessary? But likewise, there would be these sections on, like deep theory pieces of it that I would be like, ah, this is going to be the part where people kind of brush past who aren't, in my field, they're going to like scroll and I'm okay with that. Yeah.