ENGINEERING RESEARCH INSTITUTE THE UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN ANN ARBOR Progress Report STUDY OF ST. CLAIR FLY ASH IN NON-AIR-ENTRAINED CONCRETE MADE WITH PORTLAND AND PORTLAND-SLAG CEMENTS F. E. Legg, Jr. Assistant Professor of Engineering Materials and Assistant Supervisor, Michigan State Highway Department Laboratory Ralph H. Vogler Research Assistant Project 2211 THE DETROIT EDISON COMPANY DETROIT, MICHIGAN July 1956

The University of Michigan * Engineering Research Institute SYNOPSIS With increasing production and use of portland-slag cement, a study was undertaken to determine if there were any important differences between portland-slag and normal portland cement when used in concrete containing St. Clair fly ash. Due to the preliminary nature of the study, one cement content was used, namely, 4.5 sacks per cubic yard. Three fly-ash contents as well as a control mix without fly ash were used with both types of cement. The fly-ash mixes containing portland-slag cement generally show inferior strengths to those made with normal portland cement at 1 and 7 days but usually have superior strengths at 28 and 90 days. The relative-strength gain attained when using this fly ash with normal portland cement is not realized, however, when using this ash with the portland-slag cement, at least at ages up to 90 days. The observation follows that of the control mixes without fly ash, the strengths of the concrete made with the two types of cement were about equal at 1 and 7 days, but the portland-slag cement had considerably higher compressive strengths at 28 and 90 days. OBJE._.... The purpose of this investigation is to study the properties of fly ash and concrete containing fly ash, as indicated by compressive strength, workability, durability in freezing and thawing, flexural strength, and other measures of concrete quality. The phase of the investigation covered by this report is concerned with the effect on compressive strength and workability of the use of portland-slag cement with fly ash, as compared to the use of normal portland cement with fly ash.....,ii.....

The University of Michigan * Engineering Research Institute INTRODUCTION To supplement their output, cement producers are now manufacturing increased quantities of portland-slag cement to increase their production without necessity for a corresponding increase of kiln capacity. By intergrinding to sufficient fineness approximately 40% granulated blast-furnace slag (a product quite different from air-cooled slag such as that used for aggregate), a cement can be produced which is of equivalent strength to normal portland cement at ages up to 28 days. At later ages the compressive strength usually becomes superior to that of normal portland cement. Persuant to a contract between The Detroit Edison Company and the Engineering Research Institute of The University of Michigan, a study was made of the use of fly ash in concrete made with normal portland cement and with portland-slag cement. The work completed to date is of a preliminary nature, to determine if the two types of cement have pronounced difference in the effect of their reaction with St. Clair fly ash. This report covers such matters as mix proportioning and compressive strength of concrete up to 90 days of age. Some matters pertaining to test procedures which were covered in earlier reports will be omitted here to avoid repetition. This report is concerned with St. Clair fly ash in non-air-entrained concrete exclusively. It is recommended that such concrete not be used where it will be subjected to freezing and thawing in the presence of moisture. MIX DESIGN The "Recommended Practice for Selecting Proportions for Concrete" (ACI 613-54), a standard of the American Concrete Institute, was used as the basis for the design of all mixes, as in previous studies. The stone contents were as recommended by the ACI in the mixes containing no fly ash, but were increased in the fly-ash mixes, taking full advantage of the added plasticity of the mortar constituent provided by the addition of fly ash. Only one cement content, -4.5 sacks per cubic yard, was used for this 1

The University of Michigan * Engineering Research Institute preliminary work. Three fly-ash contents, 75, 150, and 200 pounds per cubic yard, were used. Additionally, mixes with no fly ash were made for comparison purposes. These ash contents were selected to provide coverage over a wide range without an excessive number of mixes. Identical series were made with the portland cement and the portland-slag cement. MATERIALS The concrete materials were generally the same as those used previously. The coarse aggregate was 1-inch-maximum-size natural gravel, the fine aggregate was a natural sand having a fineness modulus of 3.0, and the fly ash was from the St. Clair station. The portland cement (ASTM Type I) consisted of a blend of equal amounts of Huron, Peerless, and Peninsular brands. There was only one brand of portland-slag cement (ASTM Type I-S), Huron, available at the time this program was started. As a result, there was no opportunity for blending to balance out minor variations which may result from the cementmanufacturing process. Both types of cement were non-air-entraining. The results of the physical tests on the two cements are shown in the Appendix in Table I-A for the portland cement and Table II-A for the portlandslag cement. Notice should be taken of the large gain in compressive strength of the mortar cubes made with the portland-slag cement between 7 and 28 days. This acceleration seems to be typical of this type of cement, but in concrete it is usually not evident until after 28 days of age. Properties of the fly ash are reported in Table III-A in the Appendix. FABRICATION OF SPECIMENS AND TEST PROCEDURES Methods of mixing, curing, and testing the specimens were generally the same as those used in the previous studies on concrete containing fly ash. Dry aggregates were generally used, although toward the end of the study it was necessary to use damp sand in a few of the mixes. Corrections were made in the batch weights to compensate for this moisture. Two cylinders for each age of 1, 7, 28, and 90 days and 1 year were obtained from each batch, with two repeat batches for each variation of fly-ash content or type of cement, giving a total of six cylinders for each age and condition, as in previous studies. The cylinders were stored in the moist-fog room until the time for testing. 2

The University of Michigan * Engineering Research Institute DISCUSSION OF TEST RESULTS A detailed tabulation of the conferete-mix data and compressivestrength results is shown in the Appendix in Table IV-A for the mixes with portland cement and Table V-A for the mixes with portland-slag cement. Summaries of important aspects of the data have been prepared from these tables and are presented in the body of'the report. 1. COARSE-AGGREGATE CONTENT The greater amounts of coarse aggregate which were found to be workable in previous studies of fly-ash concrete with 1-inch-maximum-size gravel coarse aggregate were used again. These amounts appeared to be about the maximum which would still yield workable concrete. Theoretically, the portland-slag cement, being much finer than the portland cement, should have permitted higher coarse-aggregate contents. No effort was made to force more gravel into these mixes since the amount which was used would already be considered too high by some users. The value Vs, denoting the dry-rodded volume of coarse aggregate per unit volume of concrete, is given in Tables IV-A and V-A in the Appendix. 2. COMPRESSIVE-STRENGTH RESULTS Average values of compressive strengths are presented in Table I. The strengths of the fly-ash mixes are presented in Table II expressed as a percent of the strength of the plain-cement control mixes, and the mixes containing portland-slag cement are also expressed as a percent of the strength of the control made with portland cement. The fly-ash mixes made with portland cement produced results- similar to those obtained previously, in that the fly ash improves the strength somewhat at all ages. There is very little difference in strength between the three fly-ash contents, but at 28 and 90 days, the larger amount (200 pounds per cubic yard) appears to produce slightly higher strengths. The addition of fly ash apparently does not benefit strength of concrete made with portland-slag cement as much as it does concrete made with the plain portland cement, At 90 days, the percentage-strength increase due to the addition of fly ash is about one-third as much for the portland-slag cement mixes as it is for the portland cement mixes. At the earlier ages of 1 and 7 days, the addition of fly ash resulted in a loss of strength with the portland-slag cement except for the lowest fly-ash addition (75 pounds per cubic yard). _

TABLE I SUYMMAR OF RESULTS Portland and Portland-Slag Cement with St. Clair Fly Ash Nominal Actual Ceme nt Cement | tFly Ash, Net Mixln Water Slump, Compressive Strength psi _' Content, Content, lb/cu jd| lb/cu yd gal/sk n.o 1 Day 7 Days 28 Days 90 Days 1 Year sk/cu yd sk/cu yd Portland Cement (Type I) 4.44 0 268 7~.15 3.8 519 1925 306 3805 4.44 75 251 6.69 3.6 701 2435 3844 5183 4.5 4.48 150 251 6.69 4.6 753 2483 3893 5379 4.48 200 -6c 6,93e 4,0 698 2385 4010 5436 Portland=Slag Cement (Type T-S) 4~ 44 0 250 6,68 2.8 568 2035 3798 5268 4.45 75 246 6.58 4.4 598 2214 4153 5902 4.5 4,47 150 258 6o87 3 7 505 2013 4058 5884 4.47 200 270 7.21 4.8 459 1864 3873 5385

The University of Michigan * Engineering Research Institute TABLE II COMIPRESSIVE STRENGTH OF FLY-ASH CONCRETE EXPRESSED AS PERCENT OF PLAIN-CEMENT CONTROL MIXES Cement Content, Fly Ash, Age sk/cu yd lb/cu yd | 1 Day 7Days 28 Days 90 Days Percent of Portland Cement (Type I) Control 75 135 126 125 136 4.5 Port land Cement 150 145 129 127 141 (Type I) 200 134 124 131 143 Percent of Portland-Slag Cement (Type I-.S) Control 4.5 75 105 109 109 112 Port land-Slag Cement 150 89 99 107 112 (Type I-S) 200 81 92 102 102 Percent of Portland Cement (Type I) Control 0 109 106 124 138 4.5 Portland-Slag' 75 115 115 15 55 Cement (Type I-S) 150 97 105 132 155 200 88 97 126 142 The portland-slag cement produces a strength effect in concrete similar to that observed when fly ash or other pozzolanic material is added to portland cement; the strength of concrete made with portland-slag cement is equivalent to that of concrete made with normal portland cement through the first 7 days, but at 28 days there is some improvement in the strength of the portland-slag cement concrete. At 90 days, the improvement is more pronounced, in this case increasing the strength by 38%, or 1460 psi, over the normal portland cement. There does not appear to be much strength advantage in the use of fly ash with portland-slag cement on the basis of results so far available. -- -- ~~5

The University of Michigan * Engineering Research Institute This work has been accomplished with one lot of one brand of portland-slag cement. Investigators have found that fly ash reacts differently with cemen of varying chemical composition. No information is presently available to determine whether all portland-slag cement and fly-ash combinations produce this small amount of pozzolanic strength gain due to the fly ash, or if it is this one brand which does not have the proper chemical composition for an advantageous reaction. With the normal portland cement, three brands were combined to overcome such differences in a single cement. The compressive-strength results are shown graphically in Figs. 1 and 2 for the concrete made with portland cement and with portland-slag cement, respectively. Results of comparable mixes from a previous report (2211-5-P) are also shown in Fig. 1. The strength of the two sets of cylinders is in very close agreement although the mixes were made nearly one year apart. The strength gain is orderly in all cases. 6

The University of Michigan * Engineering Research Institute 7500 7000 6500 6000 5500 5000 200 lb 150 1 45/ fly as00 755lb 300 I / // /' Legend x Nofly ash o 75 lb fly ash per cubic yard a 150 lb fly ash per cubic yard 250C0 / o 200 lb fly ash per cubic yard N ote Pounds of fly ash per cubic yard shown on curves. Each point represents average compressive strength of six 6"x12" laboratory moist-cured test cylinders. 2000 Slump averages 3-1/2"to 4-1/2" ENGINEERING RESEARCH INSTITUTE UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN, ANN ARBOR AGE- COMPRESSIVE -STRENGTH RELATION IOOC /00~~~~~~~~~ 0. t/~ / >ST. CLAIR FLY ASH Dashed lines indicate strength of comparable mixes in report number PORTLAND CEMENT (TYPE I) /2211-5-P 4.5 SACKS PER CUBIC YARD XI!~~1 h~_~!,?L'NON -AIR - ENTRAINED CONCRETE 500 3 7 28 90 365 Age- Days Fig. 1...........7

The University of Michigan * Engineering Research Institute 7500. — ___ 7000 6500 6000 V? r T rNo fly ash 4000 75 lb fly osh per cubic rd A 150 lb fly osh per cubic yrd 250. oa 200 lb fly osh per cubic yard Nofh Pounds of fly aoh per cubic td shaOn on cunrve Each point reprents ave avmegeie swtnsgth 200t -0... of six 6"'x 12" laborawy moist- cured tet cylinder. Slump average 2 -"to 4-3-4* ENGINEERING RIMSEARCH INSTITUTE UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN, ANN ARBOR AGE- COMPRESSIVE- STRENGTH RELATION I-O-..... St. CLAIN FLY ASH PO/RTLAND -SLAG CEMENT (TYPE - S) 4.5 SACKS PIR CUBIC YARD NON-AIR- ENTRtAINED CONCRETE I 3 7 21 90 365 Ag e- Doys Fig~ 2. 8 -- -

APPENDIX

The University of Michigan ~ Engineering Research Institute TABLE I-A PROPERTIES OF PORTLAND CEMENT 56C-108 (Type I) PHYSICAL PROPERTIES Specific surface, air permeability test) sq cm/gram 3116 Autoclave expansion, percent 0.07 Normal consistency, percent 24.8 Time of set, Gilmore Initial 4 hr, 5 min Final 6 hr, 5 min Compressive strength, psi 7 days 3263 28 days 4863 Air in mortar, percent 11 3 TABLE II-A PROPERTIES OF PORTLAND-SLAG CEMENT 56C-lll (Type I-S) PHYSICAL PROPERTIES Specific surface, air permeability test, sq cm/gram 4030 Autoclave expansion, percent 0.02 Normal consistency, percent 27.2 Time of set, Vicat 5 hr, 5 min Compressive strength, psi 7 days 3104 28 days 6150 Specific gravity 3.06 Air in mortar, percent 8.7 10

The University of Michigan * Engineering Research Institute TABLE III-A PROPERTIES OF FLY ASH ASTM Physical Properties St. Clair Requirement Fly Ash C3550-54T Specific surface, air permeability test, sq cm/gram 3012 2800 min Compressive strength, 20% by weight of portlandcement addition, hand mixing, 73~F cure, percent of control 7 days 114 28 days 119 90 days 129 Water requirement, percent of control 112 Compressive strength, 25% by weight of sand, sand replacement, machine mixing, 73~F cure, percent of control 7 days 162 28 days 167 90 days 204 Water requirement, percent of control 115 Compressive strength, 25% by weight of cement, sand replacement, machine mixing, 73~F cure, percent of control 7 days 148 100 min 28 days 143 100 min 90 days 150 Water requirement, percent of control 100 Drying shrinkage, 28 days, percent 0.08 0.10 max Soundness, autoclave expansion, percent 0.o06 0.50 max Specific gravity 2.47 Percent by Weight, Moisture-Free Basis Chemical Properties ASTM Requirement St. Clair Fly Ash C550-54T Silicon dioxide, Si02 36.9 40.0 min Magnesium oxide, MgO 1.3 3.0 max Sulfur trioxide, SO3 0.9 3.0 max Loss on ignition 8.6 12.0 max Moisture 0.3 3.0 max 11

TABLE IV-A 4.5 SACKS PORTLAND CEMENT (TYPE I) PER CUBIC YARD REGULAR CONCRETE - ST. CLAIR FLY ASH Fly Ash, Actual Material Proportions W/C, Weight of Slump, Compressive Strength, psi Batch Cement Fresh No. Content, s Concrete, lb/cu yd sk/cu yd Sand Stone Net Water gal/sk lb/cu ft in. 1 Day 7 Days 28 Days 90 Days 1 Year 545 5-5-56 0 4.4o 0.64 1525 1815 277 7.59 148.1 2 500 1855 5090 5745 475 1855 2970 5605 360 5-19-56 0 4.47 0.64 1491 1815 270 7.20 148.9 2.5 570 2140 5305 4525 550 2065 5745* 4240 -o 568 5-26-56 0 4.46 0.64 1500 1815 257 6.85 148.4 7 610o 1855 2895 5250 500 1800 2510* 3465 Average 0 4.44 0.64 1505 1815 268 7.15 148.5 3.8 519 1925 5065 5805 346 3-5-56 75 4.35 0.72 1250 2041 255 6.81 146.4 5.75 610 2280 5885 5140 o 630 2420 5870 5140 353 3-12-56 75 4.5o 0.72 1256 2041 245 6.54 150.8 3 820 2490 1945* 5125 800 2490 3835 5090 3 561 5-19-56 75 4.48 0.72 1256 2041 252 6.73 150.4 4 665 2510 5780 5500 680 2420 5850 5500 Average 75 4.44 0.72 1241 2041 251 6.69 149.2 3.6 701 2455 5844 5185 m 354 5-12-56 150 4.50 0.78 977 2212 256 6.85 150.5 5.75 660 2330 5640 5335 650 2120 5425 5035 562 5-19-56 150 4.47 0.78 1000 2212 252 6.75 150.4 4.5 655 2440 4030 5655 670 2580 4205 5335 369 5-26-56 150 4.48 0.78 1000 2212 245 6.52 150.5 670 2580 4205 5555 150.3 3.5 920 2720 4205 5510 a 960 2705 5850 5405 Average 150 4.48 0.78 992 2212 251 6.69 150.4 4.6 755 2483 3895 5579 555 5-12-56 200 4.48 0.81 855 2296 267 7.15 150.0 5.5 585 2245 5920 5535 595 2350 3850 5555 33 365 3-19-56 200 4.50 0.81 825 2296 262 6.99 150.1 4 670 2295 4155 5830 660 2525 3445* 5620 570 5-26-56 200 4.47 0.81 835 2296 250 6.68 149.0 4.5 840 2490 5995 5335 835 2405 4150 5160 Average 200 4.48 0.81 852 2296 260 6.95 149.7 4.0 698 2585 4010 5436 *Not included in average. **Denotes volume of dry-rodded coarse aggregate per unit volume of concrete.

TABLE V-A 4.5 SACKS PORTLAND-SLAG CEMENT (TYPE I-S) PER CUBIC YARD REGULAR CONCRETE - ST. CLAIR FLY ASH Fly Ash, Actual Material Proportions W/C, Weight of Slump, Compressive Strength, psi Batch Cement Fresh Date Made Vs* * lb/cu yd No. Date Made Content, Vsb/cu yd Concrete, lb/cu yd sk/cu yd Sand Stone Net Water gal/sk lb/cu ft in. 1 Day 7 Days 28 Days 90 Days 1 Year 348 3-7-56 0 4.51 o.64 1513 1815 245 6.55 150.0 3.5 645 2100 4205 5705 650 2175 3850 6040 356 3-14-56 0 4.42 0.64 1548 1815 251 6.69 148.5 2.5 525 1945 3445 4770 505 2085 3850 4770 364 3-21-56 0 4.40 o.64 1548 1815 255 6.81 148.3 2.5 525 1960 3570 5160 560 1945 3870 5160 0 Average 0 4.44 O. 64 1536 1815 250 6.68 148.9 2.8 568 2035 3798 5268 S 349 3-7-56 75 4.45 0.72 1240 2041 244 6.52 149.2 5 705 2525 4540 6450 665 2280 4715 6150 357 3-14-56 75 4.46 0.72 1266 2041 246 6.56 150.4 3.5 550 2120 3730 5760 550 2120 3570 5230 >K 365 3-21-56 75 4.44 0.72 1256 2041 249 6.65 149.6 4.75 550 2120 4365 5920 570 2120 3995 5900m Average 75 4.45 0.72 1254 2041 246 6.58 149.7 4.4 598 2214 4153 5902 C 350 3-7-56 150 4.49 0.78 966 2212 249 6.64 149.7 2.5 515 1980 4295 6345 4 535 2050 4045 6115 ( 358 3-14-56 150 4.43 0.78 980 2212 268 7.15 148.8 3.75 450 1960 3920 5740 485 2030 4045 5300 366 3-21-56 150 4.49 0.78 971 2212 256 6.83 150.0 4.75 535 4240 4945* 510 1995 3800 5920 Average 10 4.47 0.78 972 2212 258 6.87 149. 5 3.7 505 2013 4058 5884 351 3-7-56 200 4.50 0.81 784 2296 269 7.18 148.7 5 445 1800 3960 5300 450 1820 3765 5740 f 359 3-14-56 200 4.46 O. 81 825 2296 272 725 149.0 4. 5 1855 4860 460 1890 2630* 5475 367 3-21-56 200 4.45 O. 81 825 2296 270 7.20 148.8 5 490 1945 3920 5370 475 1875 3885 5565 -" Average 200 4.47 0.81 811 2296 270 7.21 148.8 4.8 459 1864 3873 5385 ~*Not included in average. * *Denotes volume of dry-rodded coarse aggregate per unit volume of concrete.