For Immediate Release Contact: John Truscott (517) 335-6397
December 14, 1999
After 22 years of litigation, one of the states most demanding federal mandates has ended, Governor John Engler announced today.
The Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals today affirmed a previous ruling by a lower court to end federal oversight required since 1979 as a result of the Glover case. Under Glover, a case involving the state and private prisoner plaintiffs, a federal court entered an order mandating a raft of programming for female prisoners in state lockups. In 1989, the Blanchard Administration was held in contempt of court for not complying with the federal mandates.
"This court opinion clearly demonstrates that we have brought programs for Michigans female prisoners into parity with male prisoners and I am pleased to finally have this lawsuit behind us," Governor Engler said.
The Glover case is named for prisoner Mary Glover, a prisoner serving a life sentence for second-degree murder. As a plaintiff, Glover argued that Michigans vocational, educational and other types of prisoner programming were not equal to those provided to men. The suit was joined by other female prisoners and became a class action against the state.
The Court of Appeals' opinion noted that attorneys for prisoners tried to dispute the lower courts findings in four areas. But the appellate court rejected those arguments and in one noted: "The structure of the district courts opinion makes clear that it found that the evidence submitted by the defendants (State of Michigan) demonstrated parity, while the plaintiffs (prisoners) attacks on this evidence was unpersuasive."
MDOC Director Bill Martin said that courts should not be arbiters of correctional practices.
"This administration worked very hard to reach this point, to alleviate the taxpayers of Michigan from an unfunded federal mandate," Martin said. "I am very proud of the men and women of the department in achieving this extraordinarily difficult task."
The Glover matter represents the latest in a number of legal predicaments for the State of Michigan created under the previous administration and resolved by the Engler administration.