|
|
Commission Report

Recommendations
As mentioned above, the four subcommission reports provide detailed recommendations as to what should be done. This section highlights key aspects of those recommendations.
Critical Infrastructure
The University of Michigan has fallen behind in the deployment of information technology infrastructure. Technical vision, leadership, capital, and the will to follow through must provide the next generation of information technology infrastructure at the University. The central administration and deans must lead and nurture the creation of an effective information technology infrastructure for the Universitys research and instructional missions. The ideal is to create a distributed but coordinated information technology infrastructure support program throughout the University.
This infrastructure includes the following:
- Human capital
- Policies and management for information technology
- University-wide security and quality assurance
- Physical infrastructure, including buildings, network backbone, and Internet connectivity
- Advanced technologies and services for emerging technologies
Human capital is required for successful use of information technology in instruction, research, and administration. Faculty, staff, and students must have their skills upgraded and maintained at a high level of competence. This should be accomplished through recruitment and through in-house training. It is especially important that the University meet the challenges of recruiting, developing, and retaining qualified IT staff in the current, highly competitive market. A long-term commitment must begin immediately to hire needed professional staff and to maintain professional skill sets through ongoing training and retraining. This will require innovative compensation packages to reward excellence and to maintain parity with industry in recruiting and retaining professional staff. Internship and training programs, partnership programs, and transition programs can help to move support staff into professional IT roles.
Policy and management for information technology must be strengthened across a variety of fronts. Leadership must be provided from the highest executive levels of the University, extending down to the schools and departments. Central guidance should be provided in the areas of financial control, legal issues such as intellectual property and risk management, adherence to the academic missions of the University, and coordination of overall services in efficient and effective ways for the collective good. A governance structure for managing information infrastructure should be devised that presumes local services will be provided as often as possible by local service units.
The University increasingly faces the dual challenge of protecting systems and services from outside attacks while protecting the external Internet from attacks originating within the University. A campus-wide security and information assurance office should be created with appropriate representation from various IT administrative units. This office should assess and review campus-wide security policies and practices on an ongoing basis in order to ensure security and privacy of valuable digital records and assets across campus through rigorous and continuous assessment of policies and practices on an ongoing basis. This would ensure implementation of baseline security in the University-wide infrastructure. A crisis response team representing service providers on campus should be established to coordinate a University-wide response to potential technology-based attacks or mishaps.
The Universitys dependence on information technology has grown beyond the capabilities of the current infrastructure. We must deploy a highly functional, heterogeneous physical infrastructure to support necessary end-to-end performance. We must be able to move data very rapidly in large quantity, seamlessly and reliably, from desktops and labs to points on campus and off campus. Five classes of upgrades are immediately required:
- Upgrade in-building network infrastructure to provide the capacity
to support up to 1Gbit/s connectivity to end-user locations, with minimum
desktop performance of 100 Mbit/s. This midterm upgrade will take many
years and should start soon and be sustained until completed.
- Upgrade campus backbone infrastructure to provide backbone bandwidth capacity to support target 10 Gbit/s aggregate service. The upgrade, including fiber, electronics, and necessary physical provisioning, should begin immediately.
- Upgrade external Internet connectivity to provide sufficient level of commodity and Internet2 connectivity in light of anticipated traffic growth stemming from increased demand and removal of artificial bottlenecks as the preceding upgrades are realized.
- Equip a much larger number of classrooms than at present with network access and a significant number of classrooms across the campus with multimedia access.
- Maintain and enhance the important asset of the Media Union, which was created to facilitate advanced experimentation in the use of new media by students, staff, and faculty. It is vital that the technology in the Media Union be kept at the leading edge, and that the professional experts who can use, demonstrate, and teach the skills to apply that technology be retained.
Once specialized services have become widespread and basic, gaining experience with new technologies early in the cycle greatly facilitates their widespread deployment later in the cycle. The Universitys administration should invest in pilot projects and experimental evaluations to integrate new core and specialized services that support teaching and research needs. Focused investments should be made in the following right away, with other new initiatives to follow:
- A pilot wireless infrastructure initiative to test deployment on a large campus for the purpose of planning and evaluation of a future pervasive campus installation.
- Several prototype demonstrations of advanced information technology services underlying research and instructional applications.
- A pilot Voice over IP initiative to exploit the rapid convergence of voice and data networks into a universal network.
- A high-performance computing and networking initiative to take advantage of the full potential of emerging infrastructure and computing capabilities.
What We Should Teach
The information revolution is changing what it means to be an educated person. The University of Michigan must assume leadership in learning and scholarship regarding the information revolution and the use of information technology in teaching and learning. As a first step, every undergraduate program should ensure that the curriculum adequately reflects the use of information technology in, and the implications of the information revolution for, work in the discipline. This information revolution across the curriculum approach to the teaching of the information revolution and information technology should go along with hands on experience of using real computerized data banks, doing computerized modeling, using computer software to do data analysis, etc., while at the same time learning something of the larger cultural and social issues and implications of the information revolution.
The University of Michigan should enable students to learn to (a) evaluate information and its reliability in a critical fashion; (b) incorporate information into a field of knowledge so that it serves a specific purpose or intellectual goal; and (c) become aware of some of the cultural, economic, and political implications of the information revolution and to grasp the legal and ethical issues it raises.
The discussion of what we should teach regarding the information revolution must begin with a basic question: what constitutes information? The following observations provide an initial guide:
- Information is not the same as knowledge. Students need to learn that knowledge involves the use of information, but that knowledge is both personal and communal and the learning process has personal and social dimensions that information gathering per se lacks.
- Existence of information does not guarantee communication. Students need to know that the existence of web-based communication, divorced from conventional cues between speakers, can lead to miscommunication.
- Information becomes meaningful only in a context. Students need to know that context matters and how to understand context.
- Information is not necessarily reliable, accurate, or valid. The need to evaluate information in a critical fashion becomes particularly urgent with web-based information given the webs leveling of sources and its lack of structure, convention, and protocols for authentication. Students need to learn how to evaluate web-based information.
The information revolution also calls into the foreground many legal and ethical issues that students must understand, including:
- Responsbility with respect to information production and dissemination. Students need to understand their responsibility for the reliability of information that they produce and disseminate (students-as-authors), in addition to their responsibility for assessing the validity and reliability of the information that they consume (students-as-readers).
- Responsible and irresponsible use of common information resources and the burdens on public goods created by certain kinds of private actions such as MP3 downloading and spamming. Students should habitually consider whether their private actions using IT are acceptable or whether, and under what conditions they might be burdensome and negatively affect others.
- Principles governing privacy, security, and access to information. Students should be able to reason about when limits on access become censorship and who should have access to different classes of information.
- Issues regarding ownership of information, when information becomes intellectual property, and the philosophical and commercial implications of controversies such as open source vs. commercial software. Students need be aware of the bearing of such issues on their conduct in the digital world, and they should be able to engage in thoughtful discussion of the issues.
Finally, the information revolution brings new social, cultural, legal, economic, political, and psychological implications, such as:
- Cultural differences in the understanding of information content and in the use of information and information technologies. Students should be able to assess the impact of information and information technologies on particular organizations and groups within society, and the ways in which people can shape the impact of technology.
- Implications of the digital divide, the influence of information literacy on ones place in society, and its role in building social capital.
- Effects on globalization and multinationalism. Students should be thoughtful about questions such as whether the information revolution promotes cultural hegemony or enables cultural diversity, or whether it should (or can) be managed to promote particular cultural and social goals.
- Responses of power structures in an information economy. Students should understand implications for the workplace, education, and entertainment. They should understand how different people attribute value to information and what impact pricing decisions can have on access and use of information.
Most students enter the University of Michigan with some computing skills,
but those skills do not run very deep and often do not rest on a solid
conceptual understanding of information technology. When students (or
faculty) know only about computer applications, they are not
in a strong position to use information technology wisely. All students
at the University of Michigan should be armed with the conceptual skills
that will allow them to employ information technology wisely, both in
their various academic disciplines and in their personal lives. Different
academic disciplines use information technology in different ways, but
certain key concepts and skills are universally helpfulat least
in enabling people to comprehend and to adapt to ongoing, rapid technological
change.
In addition to understanding the basics of computation and information technology,
students should understand communications technology and media. Of particular
importance is multimedia communication involving combinations of different
media: video streaming, web pages, presentation graphics, photography,
and other visual forms; audio (in all its forms); and tactile feedback
(e.g., the new PC mouse that feeds back texture and touch, or fully immersive
environments). Traditional, print-based education does not prepare us
to use new multimedia capabilities effectively, critically, or with deep
understanding. Appropriate learning outcomes regarding multimedia should
address the reading, use, and production of multimedia content. They must
also address the unique properties of each medium and of multimedia combinations,
and the knowledge and skills relevant to those unique properties. Students
must learn how to engage with multimedia as a basic form of communication.
They need to know how to utilize multimedia technology when they do research,
gather data, organize information content, deliver content, and gather,
assess, and respond to feedback.
How We Should Teach
There are many teachers at the University of Michigan who use information technology in creative and highly effective ways. They have not simply updated traditional courses by using computer-generated slides or by relying on electronic rather than paper documents. Rather, they have taken to heart the ideas of truly effective education: their students are engaged, active learners; they demand that students think critically and then argue for and defend their ideas; their students learn by teaching; they present challenging problems that relate theory to the real world. And then they use technology to provide greater engagement, deeper involvement, more complex or challenging problems, or fuller exchange of ideas. Unfortunately, these individuals are not in the majority, and there is little cross-fertilization between units. Many faculty could be inspired and enabled to adopt new approaches and methods in their teaching if provided with access to relevant and stimulating examples, plus specific advice and encouragement. There must be added emphasis on adapting or transferring successful applications across disciplines, with concomitant attention to providing adequate support structures such as side-by-side consulting expertise.
Good teaching is a high priority at the University of Michigan; however, faculty recognize that promotion and tenure committees place a high premium on strong research, often evaluated by long-entrenched metrics. Heavy personal investment in instructional technology has little or no automatic payoff in academic performance review. The time required to experiment with new technologies in teaching is time taken from activities that seem more likely to lead to tenure, promotion, and merit increases. Moreover, lack of clarity about issues of intellectual property is another likely inhibitor of some faculty efforts in these directions. College and school executive committees should accept innovative and effective teaching, pedagogical research, and research with instructional technologies as a positive aspect of tenure or promotion files. Policies for intellectual property in courses developed by faculty and delivered by means of information technology should be clarified in ways that respect the interests of the faculty and the University.
Graduate students are especially well positioned to connect potential applications of information technology to emerging developments in their fields. As the next generation of teachers, researchers, and skilled practitioners, they are expected not only to master the basic contours of their discipline, but to contribute to its latest advances. The prominence of new technologies in helping to reshape many of these disciplines requires graduate students to be trailblazers in realizing unsuspected possibilities for information technology in their field. Cases of reverse mentoring, where graduate research assistants guide and instruct faculty in this area, are familiar in the sciences and humanities. Graduate students should therefore be given numerous and wide-ranging opportunities, including in their roles as GSIs, to work with faculty in developing uses of information technology in courses and in developing courses/curricula about the information revolution.
Our Research Agenda
The information revolution, spurred by research, is also transforming
the pursuit of knowledge and understanding in virtually all fields of
research, and is fostering exciting new interdisciplinary collaborations.
Ubiquitous, high-performance computing and communication are connected
by distributed operating systems, linking people with vast collections
of multimedia information, tools for analysis and synthesis, and collections
of facilities and instruments on a global scale. Supercomputers and immersive
visualization facilities augment both individual and team-based creativity
and discovery. These linkages are relaxing the barriers of time and distance
in support of broader participation in research and inquiry-based learning.
They are putting powerful new toolsnew lenses, in a manner of speakingin
the hands of communities of scholars, changing their research landscape
from one of relatively isolated, self-contained experiments, texts, and
analyses to a vast potential network of data and interpretations. This
network of information and knowledge, continually evolving, represents
a dynamic field for exploration. In this environment, the very nature
of research is changing: where there was once analysis, there is now also
integration and synthesis; where there was once observation, there is
now also modeling and structured querying of vast amounts of information;
where there was once the static record of phenomena, there is now also
the real-time accumulation and compilation of data. To advance research
in this environment, the University should aggressively invest and build
leadership in a broad set of integrated technical and social initiatives
to understand and use these new tools more profoundly in its mission of
knowledge creation, dissemination, preservation, and application.
The required strategy has three elements: 1) increasing research about information
technology and the information revolution, 2) increasing research using
information technology, and 3) exploiting the synergy between these two
modes. In the last forty years, the explosive growth of knowledge in information
technology has led to new fields (e.g., computer science), new interdisciplinary
domains (e.g., complex systems), and advances of all sorts within existing
fields (e.g., computational linguistics). Such knowledge continues to
grow at a staggering rate. The University of Michigan can and must play
a key role in expanding and utilizing this knowledge or it consigns itself
to a secondary position in American education. A coordinated approach
to theory and practice of information technology across research areas
is required for the University to be a laboratory for the ecology of experiments
that will define the research university of the future.
A key area of need is an improved means to deal with the explosion of data in many research areas. Gigabyte databases are increasingly common in the humanities, as well as the social, life, and medical sciences. Terabyte and even petabyte databases are becoming common in some areas of physical science. The research infrastructure of the University must be ready to handle this expansion and to help support the capture, analysis, delivery, and access of data-rich research. Data visualization, data mining, and data storage and retrieval are key areas of potential improvement. Improved data visualization is needed to present and manipulate large quantities of data to take advantage of the inherent ability of researchers to process visual data and detect patterns through inspection. Automated techniques are required to mine the data, looking for hidden quantitative and qualitative regularities and patterns. Advances in data mining and data manipulation promote discovery of unexpected regularities and thereby the development of new theories in many fields, including the physical sciences, the life sciences, the social sciences, and the humanities.
Massive databases must be stored, maintained, and accessed. Fundamental
research issues in storage, access, reliability, and security must be
addressed before networks of knowledge can be built at global scale; and
emerging modes of information technologysuch as embedded and highly
mobile computingmust be developed and better understood. Some of
these issues, such as security and reliability, are inherent to data,
computation, and communication. Security is an especially important area
in which the University of Michigan has the potential to become a national
leader.
At the same time that we engage in research that enables us to maintain leadership in the information technology area, the University must also take leadership in research that analyzes the effects of the information revolution. Such research should advance our understanding of the many social and psychological consequences of the information revolution; it should enable us to understand how the information revolution affects economic and political and labor relations; it should address the many legal and intellectual property issues around information technology; and it should further our understanding of the capacities of this technology in cultural production and our ability to read the theatre, music, dance, visual, and performance art produced using this technology. Effective research about these large implications of the information revolution would make the University of Michigan a national and international leader in scholarship and policy setting with reference to the information revolution. To do this we will have to embark on a program that hires new faculty and trains new graduate students.
Outreach and the New Learning Community
The University must use collective vision and foresight to fulfill its institutional mission in the age of the information revolution and in the dynamic and still unstable information- and knowledge-based economy that is emerging. This requires reexamination of relationships with critical learning communities. As people become lifelong learners, the Universitys challenge will be to maintain a lifelong relationship with an extended community consisting of prospective students, current students, and alumni. In addition, the Universitys community is increasingly global. The University must assert its core missions in the light of dramatically new modes for the generation, preservation, and dissemination of knowledge. As a public institution operating in the new knowledge economy, the University of Michigan has special responsibilities to the concept of community. It must help shape the new economy by wise preservation and dissemination of its knowledge assets, striking a balance between commercialization opportunities and the needs and values of service and scholarship. It must reach out to those on the other side of the digital divide, in an effort to lessen that divide. The University should take advantage of the collaboration support potential of the new technology to reach out to previously underserved communities, both to extend the Universitys benefits and to increase the valuable diversity of views within the University itself. It must work to understand globalization, and to ensure that globalization is not tantamount to cultural imperialism, inside academe or out. The opportunities that the University seizes in this environment should fit with the mission of the University and be in keeping with the free interchange of ideas and the Universitys tradition of commitment to diversity and access.
The Universitys central administration has special obligations with respect to these challenges. It must facilitate, leverage, and occasionally initiate outreach activity. It must coordinate activities among the various units, facilitating their electronic outreach activities with appropriate infrastructure, incentives, and policy clarification. It must leverage opportunities where individual units lack sufficient leverage and promote University-wide partnerships in an environment of experimentation and innovation for electronic outreach. It must provide an enlightened institutional environment that deals effectively with intellectual property, conflict of interest and commitment, advertising and endorsement opportunities such as the use of University name/marks, terms of agreement and legal resources, and restrictions related to digital material and broadcasts and external partnerships and agreements. It must accelerate its development of information technology for the conduct of routine business transactions, for providing information to the public, and for extending the social networks of its faculty, staff, students, and alumni. Finally, the central administration must develop effective mechanisms for evaluating all outreach initiatives in terms of finances, legal constraints, academic mission, contributions to educational and research capabilities on campus, and impact on other units and on the University as a whole.
The University should engage in an aggressive program of experimentation
in the area of location-independent instruction or distance learning and
should develop mechanisms for institution-wide sharing of experiences
gained from ongoing experiments. The University will only learn how to
carry out effective distance education by doing distance education; it
must be prepared to make mistakes and to share its experiences across
the institution. The University as a whole, both centrally and within
the schools and colleges, must develop, coordinate, and maintain high-end
production capabilities and a robust structure of distribution channels.
This means building upon the substantial assets it already holds, as well
as creating new capabilities. The skills and infrastructure must be in
place to exploit presentation graphics, video, simulations, full-blown
distance-education courses, and digital dissemination that can compete
for the attention of the public-high-end production. The University also
must improve its capabilities for distribution of media to compete effectively
with other service providers and deliver quality content. It is particularly
important that the University assess and enhance its distributed broadcast
capabilitiesits television, radio, and Internet broadcast capabilitiesin
light of impending digitization, and develop means for more effective
and coordinated use of those broadcast capabilities as a major and irreplaceable
e-outreach asset.
back to top
|
|
 |