|
|
Commission Report

What We Must Do
The challenges ahead are at once concrete and elusive. The subcommissions efforts revealed many infrastructure improvements that are needed simply to allow the University of Michigan to remain at the forefront of this emerging era. These improvements are not merely one-time upgrades in technology: they constitute a new way of thinking about the centrality of information infrastructure in the life of the University. At the same time, the subcommission members discovered changes in attitude and organization that will be required if the University is to become the living laboratory in which the needed experimentation can thrive. These changes are less obvious and simple to direct than are infrastructure improvements. They require a change in the Universitys concept of itself, with requisite mobilization, enablement, and empowerment. In this section we first discuss the immediate improvements in infrastructure required to put the University of Michigan on its new course. Then we follow with a strategy for creating the ecology of experiments necessary to create the new University.
Critical Infrastructure
The Universitys physical infrastructure has long been recognized as essential to its success. Information technology infrastructure is now as essential as the traditional physical infrastructure. The commission members heard much about how the University of Michigan has fallen behind in the deployment of information technology infrastructure. Technical vision, leadership, capital, and the will to follow through are required immediately in the following areas: (1) human capital; (2) policies and management of information infrastructure, with special emphasis on information security and intellectual property issues; and (3) the campus technical infrastructure with an emphasis on higher service capability. It is the responsibility of the Universitys senior administration and deans to ensure that the required robust, distributed but coordinated information technology infrastructure is realized throughout the University.
Key to this outcome is an increase in human capital in information technology, i.e., the skill base of the Universitys faculty, staff, and students. Without requisite skills to use information technology, the University community will not exploit the opportunities it offers. Many in the University now make routine use of electronic mail and word processing. Most are moving into the use of presentation graphics. Some are now using low-end video, analytical packages, simulations, and distance-education applications. The pace of this learning and practice needs to be accelerated. The University must invest significant additional resources in side-by-side teaching and consulting assistance for faculty, graduate students, and staff who use information technology in teaching and research. Internships, training programs, partnership programs, and transition programs must be created to move support staff quickly into roles as professional facilitators. Consideration should be given to creating a training institute, perhaps in the Center for Research on Learning and Teaching (CRLT) or another organization, that would provide workshops in discipline-specific use of information technology. Students should be encouraged to gain skill with information technology before applying to the University, and should be provided with opportunities to take non-credit workshops to build such skills after arriving. Information technology facilities should be available to graduate students in areas of their scholarly expertise to enable them to work with faculty in applying information technology in instruction and research. Special consideration should be given to new hires who show special competence in use of the technology. Innovative compensation packages should be used to reward excellence and to maintain parity with industry in recruiting and retaining skilled people.
An essential part of the Universitys human capital in the area of information infrastructure is its professional staff for the design, management, and support of information technology. Like many other institutions, the University has had difficulty adapting to both rapid growth and change in the composition of demand for personnel in this area. We strongly recommend a multifaceted approach to assuring the Universitys ability to recruit, train, develop, and promote IT professionals. One area that needs immediate attention is the articulation of the Universitys personnel policies with the IT labor market. We suggest that the Associate Vice President for Human Resources and Affirmative Action be charged with working with a small group of IT managers and professionals to revise and streamline policies and practices so that the University can provide competitive compensation packages in this rapidly changing area.
The University must strengthen its capability in policies and management of
information infrastructure, from the highest level of executive leadership to
the schools and departments. The governance structure for managing information
infrastructure should be revised. Central guidance should be provided in the
areas of financial control, legal issues such as intellectual property, security
and risk management, adherence to the academic missions of the University, and
coordination of overall services in efficient and effective ways for the collective
good. At the same time, local services should be provided whenever possible
through stronger capability and leadership within schools. Mechanisms should
be created to provide guidance at all levels of leadership in service provision
and pricing, assisted by monitoring and measurement capabilities that provide
data to inform that leadership.
As the Universitys dependence on information technology has increased,
demand has grown beyond the capabilities of the current physical infrastructure.
We find ourselves unable to provide acceptable quality of service to the
University community. Our university must successfully deploy a high-function,
heterogeneous information technology infrastructure that will support
a high level of end-to-end performance, i.e., that will permit
faculty to move data, very rapidly and in very large amounts if need be,
from their desktops and labs to other points on campus or off campus,
seamlessly and reliably. To meet this goal, we must do three things at
once: (1) upgrade in-building network infrastructure; (2) upgrade campus
backbone infrastructure; and (3) upgrade external Internet connectivity,
including provision of Internet2 capability on all parts of campus. Immediate
and continuing attention is needed to address these upgrades, which demand
a high degree of coordinated and sustained effort. In addition, the Universitys
television and radio infrastructure must be improved to keep abreast of
practice in the realm of digital broadcasting. Another important need
is to strengthen the laboratory for advanced media experimentation found
in the Media Union, and to extend that laboratory throughout the University.
Additional technical details and minimal acceptable future targets are
provided in the Infrastructure Subcommission report.
The University as an Ecology of Experiments
To be educated today is to be able to swim easily in the
world of the information revolution. It is to know something about the
information evolution of the last fifty years and of its social,
cultural, economic, political, legal, and psychological implications.
It is to be able to use information technology wisely, strategically,
ethically, and effectively. It is to be able to read contemporary
information produced or presented by means of this technology. It is to
be able to deal with data sets using this technology. In a world of multimedia,
it is to be visually and aurally literate. It is to be able to manage
the vast amounts of information now available, to be able to think about
information systems, and to be able to make accurate judgments
about the accuracy and value of any particular information.
To be an educator in a world in which the technologies and effects of
the information revolution are ubiquitous is to go well beyond the information
technology skills training that characterizes much of the
public call to higher education around questions of information technology.
It is to reach for learning outcomes that are an integral part of our
disciplines and our curricula. It is also to reach for learning outcomes
that address the subject of the information revolution in its own right,
approaching it with the same rigorthe same attention to historical
evidence, empirical data, and discourse analysisthat we demand of
the rest of our research and teaching. It is to create a campus environment
open to, comfortable with, and intellectually excited by innovative uses
of information technology and their ensuing consequences, intended and
unintended. It is to create an environment in which pedagogical and research
experiments relating to the information revolution thrive.
Technology can facilitate effective learning: it can improve details of course management, methods of course presentation and delivery, and the processes of discovery and practice in the laboratory and the classroom. Hence, we must experiment with the technologies that underlie the information revolution within the context of learning. However, we must remember that these technologies can lock in poor pedagogical practices, block student-faculty interaction, and encourage research and scholarship that is too narrowly focused. It is imperative, therefore, that we evaluate the use of information technology with the same qualitative and quantitative rigor that we use to evaluate other innovations in teaching and research. To justify adoption, a technological innovation should either make learning more efficient, for example by freeing up time for critical tasks and requiring less emphasis on routine business, or more effective, for example by increasing the depth or breadth of investigation and incorporating more people in the learning process. Technological innovations that improve learning merit wide adoption; those that inhibit learning should be abandoned.
We need not only to teach about the information revolution but also to advance
research into information technology itself, in areas such as high-performance
computing, embedded and mobile computing, and security. When research
discoveries in these areas lead to new capabilities, the focus shifts
from fundamental research to ongoing refinement and extension of the advances
into new applications. This kind of research is as important as fundamental
research, because it helps to build the capacity for research in the broad
sense. It is important that the University pursue research into the application
of information technology to acquisition, storage, manipulation, and visualization
of information, as well as to communications of data and ideas. New capabilities
in areas such as collaboration technology, digital libraries, and improved
human-computer interaction offer special promise of breakthroughs. The
successful application of information technology has strengthened and
will continue to strengthen scholarship and creative activity in the arts,
business, engineering, humanities, life and health sciences, physical
sciences, and social sciences. Beyond this, we need to scrutinize, with
all the rigor a research university can bring to bear, the political,
legal, economic, social, psychological, and cultural implications of the
information revolution.
As a consequence of the information revolution, the physical, economic, and intellectual boundaries of the University are being extended to new venues, new audiences, new collaborations, and new modes of action. The ability to function well in this new University will be developed through learning by doing. Thus, we must engage in an aggressive program of experimentation in the area of location-independent instruction or distance learning. This experimentation should take advantage of the potential of the new technology to support us as we reach out to previously underserved communities, both to extend the Universitys benefits and to increase the valuable diversity of views within the University itself. The emergence of Internet-based ventures for disseminating knowledge products, such as Fathom.com and UNext.com, might provide important new mechanisms for people to engage in an ongoing learning process in a rapidly changing world. When appropriate, the University should partner with such ventures, or undertake them on its own. Important experiments in these areas are already underway at the Flint and Dearborn campuses, and should be expanded. New technology can be applied to all aspects of the Universitys business, including routine business transactions, information services for the public, and expansion of social networks among faculty, staff, students, alumni, and the people of Michigan. Special attention should be given to more effective use of the University of Michigans communications assets in radio and television, which have not been fully exploited.
back to top
|
|
 |