University of Michigan - Environmental Task Force Logo

ENVIRONMENTAL TASK FORCE ADVISORY REPORT

RECOMMENDATIONS FOR FUTURE DEVELOPMENT

It is expected that campus environmental assessment and reporting will be an iterative process that is refined over time as the University follows new developments in environmental science, technology, policy and practice and receives feedback from internal and external stakeholders. With this in mind, the following issues should be considered as the University proceeds with periodic reporting:

Near Term Recommendations

Use this report to establish goals to guide improved campus environmental performance

Reporting itself is not the ultimate goal of this proposed effort, rather reporting is a means to improve campus environmental performance. Through this report, the University can track its progress on environmental stewardship and establish meaningful goals.

Revise and refine indicators based on new and improved understanding of important environmental issues

Reporting on environmental performance is a dynamic process, and indicators may need to adjust accordingly. For example, it is possible that new environmental challenges may arise in the future – challenges that impact the University and are worthy of reporting. It is also possible that the science underlying these indicators may change over time. For example, the Global Warming Potential of particular greenhouse gases has changed over time as model accuracy has improved. In these instances and others, the report should present the current indicators in a way that allows for comparison to indicators of prior reports. The advisory committee mentioned below might help in setting the University’s agenda on these issues.

Solicit feedback on report content and presentation

The authors of the report should ask themselves how and why relevant stakeholders are using the report. The Task Force may consider exploring ways to accept feedback on the report, for example surveying users on report content, relevance and transparency.

Longer Term Recommendations

Establish an assessment and reporting advisory committee

In preparing the Sustainability Report, the SNRE Master’s Project team drew upon the expertise of a steering committee comprised of representatives from industry, academia, government and non-profits. This committee held expertise in environmental reporting as well as in certain subject matters covered by the team. A similar, multidisciplinary review board might be considered for the U-M’s reporting process. Many acknowledged experts and committed stakeholders can be found on the Ann Arbor campus.

Incorporate social and economic indicators

In the corporate world, the “triple bottom line” approach to measuring the value creation and depletion is fast becoming commonplace. This approach consists of three equally weighted categories of impact: social, environmental, and economic. Like definitions of environmental sustainability, the triple bottom line framework is grounded in the recognition that the long term health and prosperity of companies hinge upon positive stocks of economic, environmental, and social resources.[1] Similarly with the University, environmental efforts are not conducted in a vacuum. The University has both social and economic impacts, and faces certain social and economic realities that can shape the University’s progress towards environmental goals. The SNRE Master’s Project team included a set of social and economic indicators in its Prototype Report – indicators which might be used to stimulate discussion as to which are the most relevant to include in a campus report. One particular topic, Health and Safety, is often considered under social indicators as it is under the Global Reporting Initiative framework. Future U-M reports might consider this topic under social indicators, or under the General Category Other, as many Health and Safety issues have environmental attributes.

Incorporate cultural and aesthetic indicators

Another dimension of environmental performance and stewardship is cultural, aesthetic and even spiritual. Although more difficult to quantify, these qualitative factors are too important to be overlooked. For instance, the physical beauty of landscape, buildings, public art, interior space, and everyday artifacts often determines people’s level of attachment, which determines the level of stewardship, which in turn determines how long and how well it is sustained. Well-designed and well-crafted buildings in beautiful settings are the hallmark of great university and college campuses, which are among the most cherished, integrated and sustained environments on the planet. In an increasingly technological and secular world, aesthetics play a critical and needed role in cultural and spiritual well-being. Accordingly, tracking the quality of landscape, architecture and design at the University through metrics such as design awards and honors, would be a sympathetic effort in addition to quantitative indicators.

Relationship to teaching and research

The goals outlined above all have the potential to be integrated with courses, research projects, and informal campus activism involving both undergraduate and graduate students. These opportunities present a chance to capture some of the idealism and energy of students and to expand the boundaries of educational experience. Based on experience at this and other college campuses, students take pride in contributing to the improvement of their school and its reputation.

Demonstrate and highlight the “business case” for environmental stewardship

If the University were endowed with unlimited financial resources, it would likely undertake most environmental initiatives that were presented. However, this is not the case, especially with the current funding reductions at the state level. It therefore may become more important for the University to demonstrate the business case for undertaking environmental programs. Certain University initiatives create tangible financial value, for example the Energy Star upgrades generate annual savings of close to $10 million.[2] Others may generate more qualitative benefits that may make the project worthwhile. For example, the University has received quite a bit of positive press on the Greening of Dana project. To be able to make the business case in the future, it will be necessary to measure and report the financial aspects of environmental stewardship at the U-M.

Track and utilize the Global Reporting Initiative framework

The Global Reporting Initiative (GRI) is “a multi-stakeholder process and independent institution whose mission is to develop and disseminate globally applicable Sustainability Reporting Guidelines.” GRI is fast becoming the standard in corporate sustainability reporting, and it is believed that there will be GRI guidelines developed specifically for colleges and universities. Given the wide use and acceptance of GRI, the U-M should monitor developments in the GRI guidelines.

Back to Table of Contents