University of Michigan - Environmental Task Force Logo

ENVIRONMENTAL TASK FORCE ADVISORY REPORT

PROPOSED ENVIRONMENTAL PERFORMANCE INDICATORS

Overview of Framework

With the objective of identifying a set of environmental performance indicators, the Task Force developed a framework to capture the impact and progress of the U-M with respect to environmental issues. The framework, which is depicted below, is comprised of: six General Categories for assessing environmental performance; a set of eight Environmental Performance Indicators for evaluating campus wide performance; and Operational Metrics to provide a more detailed assessment of specific operations and activities of the University. In addition, existing Programs and Initiatives are identified that guide environmental improvement in each General Category. Assessment, monitoring, and developing the programs and initiatives proposed for the eight environmental performance indicators have the potential to not only enhance the performance and quality of the campus, but also to engage students and faculty through courses, research projects and outreach.

Environmental Assessment and Reporting Framework


Environmental Assessment and Report Framework Diagram

 

General Categories

The first step in selecting a set of measurable and reportable environmental performance indicators was the selection of a set of General Categories that best captured the environmental footprint of the UM-AA campus. These six General Categories were chosen for their significance of impact, campus-wide applicability and availability of data. These categories are:

  1. Energy: Buildings and Transportation
  2. Water Use
  3. Land Use: Built and Natural Spaces
  4. Emissions: Air Pollutant Emissions and Water Discharges
  5. Material Use and Solid Waste
  6. Cross-Cutting and Emerging Issues

The category “Cross-Cutting and Emerging Issues” was included to classify indicators, metrics and programs that are cross cutting and to provide a means for capturing ideas that might be implemented in the future. For example, the Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design (LEED) program of the U.S. Green Building Council is a rating system for buildings that assesses energy and environmental performance. LEED addresses Categories 1 through 5. This category can also be used to report on health and safety indicators. The Global Reporting Initiative framework and the prototype U-M sustainability report classify health indicators under social sustainability rather than environmental sustainability. Health and safety indicators can be included here provisionally until a social sustainability reporting process is implemented. In the future, this category might also include indicators relating to environmental education and research at U-M.

Environmental Performance Indicators

The Task Force used the following criteria for identifying and selecting campus wide Environmental Performance Indicators:

The eight indicators were derived from the General Categories presented above, and utilize the same numbering scheme. For example the first Environmental Performance Indicator, Primary Energy Consumption, is numbered 1.1 and belongs to the General Category Energy: Buildings and Transportation (number 1 above). These eight Environmental Performance Indicators are shown in the table below. Following the table, these indicators are defined, and the basis for selection and units of measurement for each are presented.

General Category Environmental Performance Indicators
1. Energy: Buildings and Transportation 1.1 Primary Energy Consumption
  1.2 Renewable Energy Contribution
2. Water Use 2.1 Water Use
3. Land Use: Built and Natural Spaces 3.1 Impervious Surface Area
4. Emissions: Air Pollutant Emissions and 4.1 Greenhouse Gas Emissions
Water Discharges  
5. Material Use and Solid Waste 5.1 Solid Waste
  5.2 Percent of Solid Waste Recycled
6. Cross-Cutting and Emerging Issues 6.1 Building Utilization

 

1.1 Primary Energy Consumption

Basis for Selection
At the 1992 Earth Summit in Rio de Janeiro, and in a publication, which followed (Agenda 21), the United Nations Conference on Environment and Development recognized that the largest impact of human development comes from energy production, distribution, and use. Agenda 21 points out that much of the world's energy is produced and used in ways that may not be sustainable if total demand continues to increase and technology remains unchanged.[1] Environmental impacts associated with the production and consumption of energy include global climate change, acid rain, hazardous air pollution, smog, radioactive waste and habitat destruction. Similarly, energy consumption is arguably at the root of the University’s most significant environmental impacts.

Primary Energy Consumption

Definition, Units and Normalization
This indicator measures the total primary energy consumption by the University and includes the energy used in powering the campus, including U-M facilities and transportation systems. Primary energy is defined as the total energy consumed by end users, including the energy consumed by electricity generation facilities (e.g., electric utilities). In keeping with U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) convention, the units of measurement for primary energy consumption will be British Thermal Units, or BTU.[11] This indicator will be reported on a total and per capita basis, the latter of which will account for fluctuations in the campus population.[12] Along with BTU per person, this indicator may also be reported on the basis of Barrels of Oil Equivalents (BOE) per person.

1.2 Renewable Energy Contribution

Basis for Selection
Renewable energy sources address major challenges of our conventional energy system including resource scarcity and security, greenhouse gas emissions and air pollution impacts. Currently, the most promising forms of renewables include wind, biofuels (fuel derived from plant material) and solar thermal and photovoltaic technologies. The University has taken several steps to increase its use of renewable energy, particularly in the transportation sector.

Renewable Energy Contribution

Definition, Units and Normalization
Renewable energy contribution is defined as the percentage of total campus energy consumption from renewable sources. The DOE defines renewable energy as &sdquo;energy resources that are naturally replenishing but flow-limited. Renewable energy resources include: biomass, hydro, geothermal, solar, wind, ocean thermal, wave action, and tidal action.”[13]

2.1 Water Use

Basis for Selection The U-M AA’s educational, research, residential, and recreational activities require the use of freshwater, a use that can impact the ecosystems from which the City of Ann Arbor obtains its water. About 80 percent of the City of Ann Arbor’s water supply is withdrawn from the Huron River at Barton Pond, while the remaining 20 percent comes from the Steere Farm wells located on the west side of town.[1] A portion of the water used by the University is returned to the Huron River following tertiary treatment by the City’s wastewater treatment plant. It is projected that the Great Lakes Region’s reliance on groundwater will increase with further population shifts, development and demands of a water dependent economy.[14] For this reason, it is important to monitor and report the University’s water usage and manage it in a way that is sustainable in the long run.

Water Use

Definition, Units and Normalization Total water use is defined as the total volume of water used in buildings, power plant operations and landscape maintenance on the Ann Arbor campus. This indicator will be measured in gallons, and will be normalized on a per capita basis to account for growth in University population.

3.1 Impervious Surface Area

Basis for Selection
In addition to this use of water supplied by the City of Ann Arbor, the Ann Arbor campus also contributes storm water and snow melt runoff into the Huron River. Storm water runs off impervious surfaces and flows via storm drains either untreated or with minimal treatment into the Huron River. This storm water may contain a variety of pollutants, including animal waste, litter, oil or pesticides, all of which can have harmful impacts on water quality and aquatic ecosystems. Green space, on the other hand, can absorb and filter the precipitation that falls upon it. Green space serves other ecosystem functions as well, for example habitat for plant and animal species as well as recreation. For these reasons, an increase over time in the ratio of impervious surface area to total surface area on campus would have negative environmental implications.[1]

Impervious Surface Area

Definition, Units and Normalization
In the SNRE Master’s Project report, the authors included the following categories in total impervious surface area: sidewalks and plazas, gravel surfaces, parking lots, ramps and stairs and game courts. Data were not available for roads and buildings, though the team did make an estimate for surface area covered by buildings. In the future, it is hoped that these two categories are included in data collection. This indicator will be measured in acres and normalized as a percentage of total campus area.

4.1 Greenhouse Gas Emissions

Basis for Selection
Atmospheric concentration of carbon dioxide (CO2) continues to increase in part due to human activities including the combustion of fossil fuels, agricultural activity and land use changes. The global CO2 concentration of 373 parts per million (ppm)[15] in 2002 was 33 percent higher than that of the preindustrial era (280 ppm), and is projected to be significantly higher by the end of the century (estimated range of 550 to 970 ppm).[16] While the effects of increased levels of atmospheric greenhouse gases are difficult to predict, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) has found that:[16]

The IPCC predicts that global average temperatures will increase from 1.4 to 5.8°C by 2100, with an average predicted increase of around 2.5°C.[16] The expected consequences of these warmer temperatures include flooding of coastal areas, more severe weather events such as hurricanes and changes in local temperature and precipitation that will shift agricultural production zones and adversely impact plant and animal species.[17] With respect to the University and the region in which it is located, evidence suggests that winters are getting shorter, average annual temperatures are increasing, the duration of lake ice cover is decreasing and heavy rainstorms are becoming more common.[18]

Greenhouse Gas Emissions

Definition, Units and Normalization
This indicator will inventory the greenhouse gas emissions resulting from campus activities. The six greenhouse gases identified for inclusion in the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change are carbon dioxide (CO2), methane (CH4), nitrous oxide (N2O), hydrofluorocarbons (HFCs), perfluorocarbons (PFCs) and sulfur hexafluoride (SF6). Each gas differs in its ability to absorb heat in the atmosphere – the so-called Global Warming Potential (GWP).[19] For example, methane traps over 23 times more heat per molecule than CO2, and SF6 is 22,200 times more potent than CO2.[20] Estimates of greenhouse gas emissions are often presented in units of metric tons of carbon equivalents (MTCE), which weights each gas by its GWP. Using this convention, CO2 accounts for over 83 percent of GHG emissions, while methane and nitrous oxide contribute roughly 9 and 6 percent respectively.[20]

The University will report greenhouse gas emissions in both million tons of CO2 equivalent and millions tons of carbon equivalent (MTCE). As was the case with the SNRE Master’s Project, the University will measure and report emissions of three of the six gases identified above:CO2, methane and nitrous oxide. This indicator will be reported on an aggregate basis to assess the University's total GHG footprint, as well as on a per capita basis to normalize for fluctuations in campus population.

5.1 Solid Waste

Basis for Selection
Waste generation by Americans has increased at a significant rate. In 1960, Americans produced an average of 2.7 pounds of municipal solid waste (MSW) per capita per day. By 2001, that figure reached 4.4 pounds per capita per day.[21] The generation and disposal of solid waste poses several environmental problems, including land use for landfills and groundwater contamination through leaching. Closer to home, the Michigan Department of Environmental Quality estimates that the state of Michigan has 15-17 years of landfill disposal capacity remaining at current rates of solid waste disposal. Compounding this problem is an increasing volume of imported waste from New York and Toronto.[22]

Percent of Solid Waste Recycled

Definition, Units and Normalization
Solid waste generated at the University consists of a mixture of everyday items such as paper, packaging, yard clippings, bottles and food scraps. The inventory of solid waste will report the quantity of non-hazardous waste from the University including the medical facilities. This solid waste will be measured in tons, and normalized on a per capita basis.

6.1 Building Utilization

Basis for Selection
Campus buildings are major source of environmental impacts ranging from raw material and energy consumption to air emissions. In the United States, buildings account for 30 percent of raw material use, 36 percent of total energy use and 30 percent of greenhouse gas emissions.[23] More efficient utilization of buildings can reduce resource requirements and other environmental impacts related to building construction, operation, and maintenance. This can also translate into capital and operating cost savings.

Definition, Units and Normalization
This indicator measures the total area of conditioned buildings per person. A less area intensive building footprint per capita would generally reflect a greater efficiency in the use of resources for construction, operation and maintenance of campus facilities. One approach to improving this indicator is to focus on better utilization of existing space rather than construct new facilities.

Operational Metrics

Complementing the Environmental Performance Indicators is a set of Operational Metrics that provide greater detail on campus environmental performance. Certain Operational Metrics are directly linked to the eight Environmental Performance Indicators, while others address additional environmental issues. For the indicator Primary Energy Consumption, Building Energy Consumption is an example of the former, while Campus Bus Ridership is an example of the latter (see the table “General Category: Energy – Buildings and Transportation” below for an example of how Operational Metrics are linked with Environmental Performance Indicators).

Programs and Initiatives

Also associated with each General Category is a series of Programs and Initiatives underway at the U-M that address a particular environmental impact. For example, Programs and Initiatives associated with Primary Energy Consumption include Energy Star, the Greening of Dana, and the University’s bio-diesel and ethanol fuel programs. A complete list of programs and initiatives is included in the Appendix.

Example of General Category Energy – Building and Transportation

To demonstrate how General Categories, Environmental Performance Indicators, Operational Metrics and Programs and Initiatives fit together, below is an example of the General Category Energy – Buildings and Transportation.[24]

General Category: Energy – Buildings and Transportation

 

Units

Normalization

Environmental Performance Indicators (2)

Total Energy Consumption

BTU

BTU/person Barrels of oil equivalent/person

Renewable Energy Contribution

Percent renewable

 

 

 

 

Operational Metrics (15)

Building Energy Consumption

BTU

BTU/ft2 BTU/person BTU/ft2/person

Total Electricity Consumption

MWh

 

Electricity from Renewable Sources

Percent

 

Transportation Energy Consumption

BTU

BTU/person

Bus Energy Consumption

BTU

BTU/passenger mile

Fleet Vehicles Energy Consumption

BTU

 

Fleet Fuel Economy

MPG by vehicle class

 

Renewable Percentage for Transportation Energy

 

 

Campus Bus Ridership

Total passengers Passenger miles

 

Car/Van Pooling (U-M pool vehicles only)

Vehicle miles traveled *Passenger miles traveled

 

AATA Bus Passes

Number of passes

 

AATA Bus Ridership

Total number of rides

 

*Bicycle Ridership

Number of bike racks

 

*Vehicular Commuting

Vehicle miles traveled Passenger miles traveled BTU

 

*Air Travel

Passenger miles traveled BTU

 

 

 

 

Programs and Initiatives (examples)

Energy Conservation

Energy Star, Green Lights, Poster Campaign

Renewable Electricity Purchases

 

Combined Heat and Power

 

Biodiesel and Ethanol Fuel

 

Plant Extension Office Design Guidelines

80 strategies for all new construction and retrofits

Greening of Dana

Radiant cooling system, insulation of building envelope

*Data is not yet collected for this indicator.

11. One British Thermal Unit is the amount of energy required to raise the temperature of one pound of water by one degree Fahrenheit.
12 The SNRE Master’s Project team defined “campus population” as the sum of students, faculty and staff.
13 U.S. DOE Energy Information Administration. Energy Glossary (http://www.eia.doe.gov/glossary/glossary_main_page.htm)
14 Institute of Water Research (1999) Michigan State University. Michigan’s Drinking Water: What is Groundwater? from Rodriguez et al (2002)
15 Keeling, C.D. and T.P. Whorf (2003) Atmospheric CO2 records from sites in the SIO air sampling network. In Trends: A Compendium of Data on Global Change. Carbon Dioxide Information Analysis Center, Oak Ridge National Laboratory, U.S. Department of Energy, Oak Ridge, Tenn., U.S.A. (http://cdiac.esd.ornl.gov/trends/co2/sio-mlo.htm)
16 IPCC (2001) Climate Change 2001: The Scientific Basis. Contribution of Working Group I to the Third Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change [Houghton, J.T.,Y. Ding, D.J. Griggs, M. Noguer, P.J. van der Linden, X. Dai, K. Maskell, and C.A. Johnson (eds.)]. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, United Kingdom and New York, NY, USA, 881pp. (http://www.grida.no/climate/ipcc_tar/wg1/005.htm)
17 U.S. EPA. Global Warming – Impacts. (http://yosemite.epa.gov/oar/globalwarming.nsf/content/Impacts.html)
18 Kling, G.W., K. Hayhoe, L.B. Johnson, J.J. Magnuson, S. Polasky, S.K. Robinson, B.J. Shuter, M.M. Wander, D.J. Wuebbles, D.R. Zak, R.L. Lindroth, S.C. Moser, and M.L. Wilson (2003). Confronting Climate Change in the Great Lakes Region: Impacts on our Communities and Ecosystems. Union of Concerned Scientists, Cambridge, Massachusetts, and Ecological Society of America, Washington, D.C.
19 As defined by the U.S. EPA, “the global warming potential of a greenhouse gas is the ratio of global warming, or radiative forcing, from the emission of one unit mass of a greenhouse gas to that of one unit mass of carbon dioxide over a specified time horizon.”
20 U.S. EPA (2003) Inventory of U.S. Greenhouse Gas Emissions and Sinks 1990 – 2001.
21 U.S. EPA (2003) Municipal Solid Waste Basic Facts (http://www.epa.gov/epaoswer/non-hw/muncpl/facts.htm)
22 Michigan Department of Environmental Quality (2000) Report of the Solid Waste Importation Task Force to Governor John Engler and Department of Environmental Quality Director Russell J. Harding. Cited in Rodriguez et al (2002).
23 U.S. Green Building Council. Why Build Green? (http://www.usgbc.org/AboutUs/whybuildgreen.asp)
24 Matrices for the other General Categories are included in the Appendix of this report

Back to Table of Contents