INSIDE TRACK: Professors take on campus protesters: MANAGEMENT OVERSEAS
WORKERS:

US academics are in conflict with student anti-sweatshop activists,
writes Nancy Dunne Financial Times ; 05-Oct-2000 12:00:00 am ; 571 words
By NANCY DUNNE

US college campuses are hardly the cauldrons of revolt that they were in
the 1960s. However, one issue has stirred thousands of students
preparing for their places in the "new economy": the plight of foreign
factory workers who toil in unhealthy conditions for minuscule wages.

 Students in the national Anti-Sweatshop Movement have urged - and
sometimes demanded - that universities adopt codes of conduct for the
companies they license to supply products bearing their logos. The
Dollars 2.5bn (Pounds 1.7bn) school-logo market yields universities
millions of dollars a year in licensing fees.

 But many of the country's most prominent economic professors are now
taking on the student activists. A letter signed by more than 250
academics has been sent to 535 college presidents warning them not to be
pressured into making hasty decisions about the conditions they impose
on licensees.

 "We often encounter news reports of sit-ins by groups of students in
the offices of university/college administrators, after which decisions
are often made without seeing the view of scholars in the social
sciences, law and humanities," the letter says. "Little attention has
been given to whether the views of the Anti-Sweatshop campaign are
representative of the views of governments, non-government organisations
and workers in the poor countries."

 The letter was sponsored by the Academic Consortium on International
Trade, a group of pro-trade academic economists and lawyers. Acit was
first proposed by Jagdish Bhagwati of Columbia Unversity after thousands
of protesters disrupted the World Trade Organisation meeting in Seattle.
The professors recognise the students' "good intentions", but their
letter contends that they "ignore the well-established fact that
multinational corporations commonly pay their workers more on average,
in comparison to the prevailing market wage for similar workers employed
elsewhere in the economy". If multinationals were forced to pay even
more, "the net results would be shifts in employment that will worsen
the collective welfare of the very workers in poor countries who are
supposed to be helped".

 The student protesters and the economists seem to talk past each other
and suspect each other's motives. The economists think that the students
are tools of the unions. The students suspect the economists are in the
pay of the multinationals.

 "Some students are motivated by ethical and moral issues. That's
absolutely good," says Aravind Panagariya, a University of Maryland
professor who serves on the Acit steering committee. "At the same time,
being captured by the protectionist interests is something else."

 Jeff Ballinger, a Harvard researcher who was a labour activist in Asia,
says the letter had "an arrogant tone that only these economists know
what's going on with developing countries. They are just flat-out wrong
in some cases. You always hear that foreign investors pay their workers
more; it is just not true".

 Eric Brakken, a representative of the Workers' Rights Consortium, which
more than 50 colleges have joined, says although the group receives some
union support, it is not protectionist.

 He says the WRC is setting up its own monitoring group because it does
not trust the audit firms who most often serve as factory watchdogs. He
points to a recent study, released last week by Dara O'Rourke, an MIT
professor who has inspected factories for the World Bank and the United
Nations.

 Mr O'Rourke accompanied PwC auditors on a recent tour of Asian
sweatshops. His presence, at the insistence of Harvard students,
provided the first opportunity for anyone to audit the auditors. Last
week, Mr O'Rourke said the inspectors had overlooked health and safety
violations, and "glossed over issues of freedom of association and other
rights in the codes of conduct adopted by the universities".

 Mr Bhagwati says the codes of conduct for companies should include
denunciations of protectionism. He thinks emphasis should be placed on
workers' dignity, and not just workers' pay. "When in Rome, don't do
what the Romans do."