> This article from The Chronicle of Higher Education
> 
>    From the issue dated September 29, 2000
> 
>    Economists Take College Presidents to Task for Joining
>    Anti-Sweatshop Groups
> 
>    By JULIANNE BASINGER
> 
>     About 200 scholars, including a Nobel laureate in economics,
>    have signed a letter criticizing college and university
>    presidents for working with two anti-sweatshop groups.
> 
>    The letter was written by a half-dozen academic economists and
>    lawyers who specialize in international trade policy and
>    economic law. The group,  the Academic Consortium on
>    International Trade, began circulating the letter in July
>    among other scholars to collect signatures, and plans to send
>    it this month to college presidents.
> 
>    The scholars' letter expresses concern over colleges'
>    decision-making processes in establishing codes of conduct for
>    American companies. Such decisions "should be made only after
>    careful research, discussion, and debate," it adds.
> 
>    The letter criticizes colleges' participation in two
>    anti-sweatshop groups: the Fair Labor Association and the
>    Worker Rights Consortium. The association's members include
>    141 colleges and universities and a dozen
>    apparel-manufacturing companies. The consortium, which formed
>    this year, has more than 50 colleges but no manufacturers
>    among its members. The former has the backing of many
>    higher-education groups, and the latter has more support among
>    student activists, but the economists argue that both groups
>    are misguided.
> 
>    The signers of the letter include Robert Lucas, a Nobel
>    laureate in economics and a professor at the University of
>    Chicago. The document accuses college administrators of making
>    decisions on the basis of students' sit-ins and other campus
>    protests, rather than first seeking the views of academic
>    experts and others on campuses.
> 
>    Robert M. Stern, an economics professor at the University of
>    Michigan and one of the leaders of the letter-writing effort,
>    said that the protests of the World Trade Organization's
>    meeting in Seattle last year had prompted his group to act.
>    "We felt that most of the protest is really being
>    misdirected," he said.
> 
>    The scholars' letter criticizes the two anti-sweatshop groups
>    for urging companies to raise the wages of their workers in
>    developing countries above the prevailing market average for
>    those nations. The letter intimates that paying higher wages
>    would limit the number of jobs in those countries and "worsen
>    the collective welfare of the very workers in poor countries
>    who are supposed to be helped."
> 
>    Michael Posner, executive director of the Lawyers Committee
>    for Human Rights, one of the Fair Labor Association's
>    founders, disagreed. "It's not legitimate to say companies
>    know best," he said, and the question of living wages needs
>    further study.
> 
>    The association has sought to involve scholars who are experts
>    on the issues, he added. "I find a lot of the criticism in the
>    letter a bit baffling and off-base."
> 
>    Eric Brakken, one of the leaders of United Students Against
>    Sweatshops, a member of the consortium's board, also disagreed
>    with the letter. "There's a tremendous lack of understanding
>    about what the W.R.C. really is and how much careful study
>    students have done about this issue," he said.
> 
>    Moreover, many of the campus committees that colleges formed
>    to decide whether to participate in the consortium included
>    scholars from various disciplines, he added.
> 
>    The letter questions the "monitoring mechanisms established by
>    both the Worker Rights Consortium and Fair Labor Association,"
>    saying they "may prove uneven and ineffective." The letter
>    urges colleges to consider alternatives.
> 
>    The consortium's leaders said their group hasn't developed a
>    monitoring agenda yet and has no plans to do so. Instead, the
>    group will focus on verifying workers' complaints in
>    individual factories, said Maria A. Roeper, the consortium's
>    interim director.
> 
>    The association released its monitoring benchmarks in July.
>    Mr. Posner said those benchmarks were similar to the standards
>    advocated by the letter writers.