Research Seminar in International Economics
THE UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN
School of Public Policy/Department of Economics
Discussion Paper Abstracts
To view or down-load the papers in .pdf format (viewable by using free Adobe Acrobat
software), click on PDF below. Earlier papers and abstracts are available,
if at all, only in hard copy. For list without abstracts, click here.
493. Hallak, Juan Carlos, "The Effect of Cross-Country Differences
in Product Quality on the Direction of International Trade 2002," February, 2003.
ABS PDF
Despite considerable theoretical work predicting that product quality plays an important
role in determining the direction of international trade, there is no empirical evidence on the
existence and magnitude of such a quality e.ect on trade. In this paper, I provide a framework to
estimate the impact of cross-country di.erences in product quality on bilateral trade flows. The
model allows countries to di.er both in the quality of goods they produce and in their aggregate
demand for quality. It also takes into account other determinants of international trade, such
as di.erences in factor proportions. I estimate the model using cross-sectional data on bilateral
trade flows at the sectoral level. The empirical results confirm the theoretical prediction: rich
countries import relatively more from countries that produce high-quality goods. Even though
traditional determinants of comparative advantage are still the main driving force of trade,
quality di.erences between countries have a significant e.ect on the pattern of international
trade flows.
492. Deardorff, Alan V., "What Might Globalization's Critics
Believe?," December 19, 2002. ABS PDF
Critics of globalization object to many things, some of which can be easily understood within standard economic models, but others of which seem to reflect a view of the world that economists generally do not share. This paper attempts to identify several alternative frameworks for analysis within which some of their criticisms may be understood, with the ultimate aim of extracting testable implications that differ from standard models. Three such alternative models are suggested, all of which focus mainly on the behavior of owners and managers of corporate capital: an anti-labor model, in which capitalists are willing to sacrifice some of their own profits for the chance to make labor worse off; a labor-monopsony model in which capitalists cooperate globally to increase profits by depressing wages; and an international political economy model in which capitalists use their resources to influence the political process for more than just obtaining import protection. This third framework, which is not spelled out in any detail here, has capitalists seeking policies such as export subsidies and other means of promoting market access, and it also has them influencing the international negotiations that set the rules of international agreements and organizations, such as the NAFTA and WTO. Examples of the latter sort of influence are discussed.
491. Fukao, Kyoji, Toshihiro Okubo, and Robert M. Stern, "An
Econometric Analysis of Trade Diversion under NAFTA," October 30, 2002. ABS
PDF
We provide an econometric analysis of whether or not the tariff preferences extended to Canada and Mexico under NAFTA may have resulted in trade diversion. A review of previous studies, both descriptive and econometric, suggests that trade diversion has occurred especially as evidenced by Mexico's increased shares of U.S. imports apparently at the expense of several Asian countries. We use a conceptual framework based on a partial-equilibrium model of differentiated product industries under monopolistic competition for many countries. The model is implemented empirically using a fixed-effect panel analysis of U.S. imports at the Harmonized System (HS) 2-digit level for the period, 1992-98. Of the 70 sets of regressions that were run, the coefficients of the tariff rates were statistically significant in 15 cases. The strongest evidence of trade diversion was found mainly for U.S. imports of textile and apparel products. We also estimated regressions for selected commodities at the HS 4-digit level. The results suggest trade diversion for textiles, apparel, and some footwear products but not for trade in motor cars and vehicles and television receivers, which may have been more influenced by changes in foreign direct investment and outsourcing rather than tariff preferences.
490. Brown, Drusilla K., Alan V. Deardorff, and Robert M. Stern,
"Multilateral, Regional, and Bilateral Trade-Policy Options for the United States
and Japan," December 16, 2002. Forthcoming in The World Economy. ABS
PDF
We have used the Michigan Model of World Production and Trade to simulate the economic effects on the United States, Japan, and other major trading countries/regions of the Doha Round of WTO multilateral trade negotiations and a variety of regional/bilateral free trade agreements (FTAs) involving the United States and Japan. We estimate that an assumed reduction of post-Uruguay Round tariffs and other barriers on agricultural and industrial products and services by 33 percent in the Doha Round would increase world welfare by $686.4 billion, with gains of $164.0 billion for the United States, $132.6 billion for Japan, and significant gains for all other industrialized and developing countries/regions. If there were global free trade with all post-Uruguay Round trade barriers completely removed, world welfare would increase by $2.1 trillion, with gains of $497.0 billion (5.5 percent of GNP) for the United States and $401.9 billion (6.2 percent of GNP) for Japan.
Regional agreements such as an APEC FTA, an ASEAN Plus 3 FTA, and a Western Hemisphere FTA would increase global and member country welfare but much less so than the Doha multilateral trade round would. Separate bilateral FTAs involving Japan with Singapore, Mexico, Chile, and Korea and the United States with Chile, Singapore, and Korea would have positive, though generally small, welfare effects on the partner countries, but potentially disruptive sectoral employment shifts in some countries. There would be trade diversion and detrimental welfare effects on some nonmember countries for both the regional and bilateral FTAs analyzed. The welfare gains from multilateral trade liberalization are therefore considerably greater than the gains from preferential trading arrangements and more uniformly positive for all countries.
489. Brown, Drusilla K., Alan V. Deardorff, and Robert M. Stern,
"Computational Analysis of Multilateral Trade Liberalization in the Uruguay Round
and Doha Development Round," December 8, 2002. ABS PDF
We have used the Michigan Model of World Production and Trade to simulate the economic effects of the Uruguay Round of multilateral trade negotiations completed in 1993-94 on the major industrialized and developing countries/regions. We estimate that the Uruguay Round negotiations increased global economic welfare by $73.0 billion. The developed countries overall have an estimated welfare gain of $53.8 billion, and the developing countries an estimated welfare increase of $19.2 billion.
We have also simulated the effects of assumed 33 percent reductions in trade barriers in the ongoing Doha Development Round. There is an estimated increase in global welfare of $574.0 billion. There is a global welfare decline of $3.1 billion from agricultural liberalization due primarily to the assumed reductions in export subsidies. There are global welfare gains of $163.4 billion from reductions in manufactures tariffs and $413.7 billion from reductions in services barriers. All of the countries/regions covered in the Michigan Model show overall welfare increases, with the largest absolute gains going to the developed countries.
488. Fitzgerald, Doireann and Juan Carlos Hallak, "Specialization,
Factor Accumulation and Development," May, 2002. ABS
PDF
The Heckscher-Ohlin theory links specialization of production to relative factor
endowments. Endowments are the result of accumulation in response to economic in-centives.
Taking this into account allows us to reconcile wildly di¤erent predictions
in the empirical literature about the e¤ect of capital accumulation on manufacturing
output. We estimate the e¤ect of factor proportions on specialization in a cross-section
of OECD countries. We show that using the estimation results alone, we cannot dis-tinguish
between specialization driven by factor proportions, and specialization that
is correlated with factor proportions for other reasons. But our results are consistent
with evidence on sectoral factor intensities, which supports the H-O theory. Moreover,
our model does a good job of predicting the substantial reallocation that takes place
within manufacturing as countries grow. It explains 2/3 of the observed di¤erence in
the pattern of specialization between the poorest and richest OECD countries.
487. Deardorff, Alan V. and Robert M. Stern, "EU Expansion and
EU Growth," October 29, 2002. ABS PDF
Almost from its inception as the European Economic Community, the European Union has excited the hope if not the expectation that it would generate dynamic gains from trade, including perhaps a permanent increase in the rates of growth of participating countries. This paper examines the empirical evidence relating to this issue and then interprets the economic performance of the EU countries in terms of a simple theoretical model of economic integration with increasing returns to scale. The paper concludes that evidence for increased long-run growth rates of the EU countries is weak, and that what may have happened instead is that countries have benefited asymmetrically from the formation and the later expansion of the EU. Benefits of economic integration appear to accrue - in the form of temporarily higher growth rates leading to higher levels of per capita income - first to large countries and then to some smaller countries that entered the arrangement relatively early.
486. Brown, Drusilla K., Alan V. Deardorff, and Robert M. Stern,
"The Determinants of Child Labor: Theory and Evidence," September, 2002. ABS
PDF
We present in this paper a description and discussion of the state of scholarly debate on the supply and demand-side determinants of child labor. We first review the theoretical literature and some incidental empirical evidence concerning household decision-making and its implications for work and school choices for children. We then turn to a discussion of the empirical evidence on these and related issues based on survey research of household decision-making. The demand side of child labor is broached next, followed by a more thorough treatment of the rise and fall of child labor during the 19th century. We turn finally to specific issues thought to be important in affecting both the supply and demand for children: the conflicting effects that trade openness has on child labor; the impact of compulsory education laws; and the value of an education and the determinants of education quality.
485. Gary R. Saxonhouse and Robert M. Stern, Japan's Lost
Decade: Origins, Consequences, and Prospects For Recovery - Chapter Abstracts,
August 22, 2002. ABS PDF
484. Gary R. Saxonhouse and Robert M. Stern, Japan's
Lost Decade: Origins, Consequences, and Prospects For Recovery - Introduction,
August 22, 2002. ABS PDF
483. Brown, Drusilla K., Alan V. Deardorff, and Robert M.
Stern, "The Effects of Multinational Production on Wages and Working Conditions
in Developing Countries" August 30, 2002. ABS PDF
This paper is designed to assess the empirical evidence regarding the effects of multinational production on wages and working conditions in developing countries. It is motivated by the controversies that have
emerged, especially in the past decade or so, concerning whether or not multinational firms in developing countries are exploiting their workers by paying low wages and subjecting them to coercive, abusive,
unhealthy, and unsafe conditions in the workplace. We begin by addressing the efforts and programs of social activist groups and universities and colleges involved in the "Anti-Sweatshop" Campaign in
the United States, the social accountability of multinational firms, and the role of such international insti-tutions as the International Labor Organization and World Trade Organization in dealing with labor
standards and trade. We then consider the conceptual aspects of the effects of foreign direct investment on wages in host countries and the effects of outsourcing, subcontracting, and other forms of fragmenta-tion by multinational firms. We note in particular that available theories yield ambiguous predictions for the effects of multinational production on wages, leaving the effects to be examined empirically. We therefore, in the final section of the paper, review the empirical evidence on multinational firm wages in developing countries, and the relationship between foreign direct investment and labor rights. This evi-dence indicates that multinational firms routinely pay higher wages and provide better working conditions than their local counterparts, and they are typically not attracted preferentially to countries with weak
labor standards.
482. Friedman, Jed and James Levinsohn, "The Distributional
Impacts of Indonesia's Financial Crisis on Household Welfare: A 'Rapid Response'
Methodology," September 2001. ABS PDF
Analyzing the distributional impacts of economic crises is important and,
unfortunately, an ever more pressing need. If policymakers are to intervene to help those most
adversely impacted, then policymakers need to identify those who have been most harmed and
the magnitude of that harm. Furthermore, policy responses to economic crises typically must be
timely. In this paper, we develop a simple methodology to fill the order and we’ve applied our
methodology to analyze the impact of the Indonesian economic crisis on household welfare there.
Using only pre-crisis household information, we estimate the compensating variation for
Indonesian households following the 1997 Asian currency crisis and then explore the results with
flexible non-parametric methods. We find that virtually every household was severely impacted,
although it was the urban poor that fared the worst. The ability of poor rural households to
produce food mitigated the worst consequences of the high inflation. The distributional
consequences are the same whether we allow households to substitute towards relatively cheaper
goods or not. However the geographic location of the household mattered even within urban or
rural areas and household income categories. Additionally, households with young children may
have suffered disproportionately adverse effects.
481. Hanson, Gordon H. and Chong Xiang, "The Home Market Effect
and Bilateral Trade Patterns," June 2002. ABS PDF
We test for home-market effects using a difference-in-difference gravity specification. The home-market effect is the tendency for large countries to be net exporters of goods with high transport costs and strong scale economies. It is predicted by models of trade based on increasing returns to scale but not by models of trade based on comparative advantage. In our estimation approach, we select pairs of exporting countries that belong to a common preferential trade area and examine their exports of goods with high transport costs and strong scale economies relative to their exports of goods with low transport costs and weak scale economies. We find that home-market effects exist and that the nature of these effects depends on industry transport costs. For industries with very high transport costs, it is national market size that determines national exports. For industries with moderately high transport costs, it is neighborhood market size that matters. In this case, national market size plus market size in nearby countries determine national exports.
480. Stern, Robert M., "An Economic Perspective on Russia's
Accession to the WTO," June 11, 2002. ABS PDF
Russia's application for accession to the WTO is currently in its final phases and may be completed by the end of 2003. In this context, this paper provides some background information on Russia's recent policy and structural reforms, the composition and geographic distribution of trade, tariff rates by commodity groups, and other aspects of trade and domestic policies at issue in the accession process. The accession proce-dure and the current status of the accession process are then discussed. Using a computable general equilibrium (CGE) modeling analysis of China's WTO accession as a prototype, the potential use of CGE model-ing of Russian accession is considered as well as Russia's participation in the Doha Development Round and preferential trading arrangements. It is concluded that Russia may realize significant benefits from WTO accession and from the multilateral trade liberalization to be effected in the Doha Round.
479. Xiang, Chong, "New Goods and Rising Skill Premium: An Empirical
Investigation," May 28, 2002. ABS PDF
This paper identifies and measures new goods in the U.S. manufacturing sector in the late 1970s and 1980s, and finds that: (i) The average skilled-labor intensity of new goods exceeds that of old goods by over 40%; (ii) even within 4-digit industries, new goods are slightly more skilled-labor intensive than old goods (by about 4%); (iii) new goods can account for about 30% of the increase in the relative demand for skilled labor. Therefore, new goods help explain the rising skill premium in the U.S. Furthermore, new goods provide a direct measure of technological changes so that this paper provides new evidence that technology has shifted demand in favor of skilled labor and finds that a sizeable "between" component of the rise in the relative demand for skilled labor is due to technology.
478. Xiang, Chong, "New Goods and Rising Skill Premium: A Theoretical
Investigation," May 28, 2002. ABS PDF
This paper examines the effects of new goods on the relative wages of skilled-labor and the pattern of trade in a two-cone Heckscher-Ohlin model and shows that: (i) new goods can be a valid theoretical explanation for the rising skill premium in the U.S. (ii) the outcome depends on both domestic and international factor market effects of the new goods, and the interplay between these two effects gives rise to surprising results; (iii) new goods that are "friendly" to the abundant (scarce) factors move the relative factor prices in the direction of convergence (divergence). The setup is general in the goods dimension so that the introduction of new goods is completely unrestricted, and the results apply to any one or any combination of the relative demand shocks for skilled labor. The results also apply when non-tradable goods are present.
477. Brown, Drusilla K., Alan V. Deardorff, and Robert M. Stern,
"Pros and Cons of Linking Trade and Labor Standards" May 6, 2002. ABS
PDF
This paper addresses the debate over whether labor standards ought to be linked to trade policy, specifically by being included in the World Trade Organization and becoming subject to trade sanctions. We first try to put the debate into context by reviewing the issues and the events that have led to the current situation. We next turn to the arguments in favor of putting labor standards into the WTO, then address the arguments against doing so. Finally we offer our own advice to developing countries as to the position that they should take in this debate, and how more broadly they should deal with this and other issues in multilateral trade negotiations.
476. Chang, Pao-Li, "Endogenous Tariff Formation with Intra-Industry
Trade," April 19, 2002. ABS PDF
Previous theoretical contributions on endogenous tariff formation have focused on trade mod-els with homogeneous goods and constant returns to scale. This paper investigates the political equilibrium of trade policy when economic structure is instead characterized by differentiated products and increasing returns to scale and there exists intra-industry trade. The result shows that endogenous tariffs are positive for all industries with non-negligible shares of world pro-duction. However, the level of protection is less than the optimal tariff that would otherwise be imposed by a benevolent government in an unorganized industry, and higher in an organized industry. The protection provided to all unorganized (organized) industries increases (falls) with the relative weight the government attaches to aggregate welfare vis-` a-vis campaign contribu-tions and falls with the fraction of the population that belongs to a lobby group. The model also indicates that the endogenous tariff level in an organized industry might be explosive. The higher is the fraction of the population represented by a lobby and the higher is the weight on aggregate welfare in the government’s objective function, the smaller is the possibility for such an explosive tariff.
475. Chang, Pao-Li, "The Evolution and Utilization of the GATT/WTO
Dispute Settlement Mechanism," April 19, 2002. ABS PDF
This paper attempts to study the usage of the GATT/WTO dispute settlement mechanism
and to explain its patterns across different regimes and decades, using a unified theoretical model. This study first explores the role of the degree of legal controversy over a panel ruling in determining countries' incentives to block/appeal a panel report under the GATT/WTO regime. The model is able to explain the surge in blocking incidence during the 1980s over the preceding GATT years and the immense frequency at which the new appellate procedure under the WTO is invoked. Furthermore, a two-sided asymmetric information framework is used to study the effects of political power on countries' incentives to use, and interactions in using, the GATT/WTO dispute settlement mechanism. It is shown that the magnitude of the political cost relative to the potential benefit that the complainant stands to gain when using this mechanism determines the pattern of filing activity and the frequency of various procedural outcomes. This result, when confronted with the statistics on disputes in different decades of the GATT regime,
provides us an indicator of how well the dispute procedure has worked during various decades, in terms of how much this procedure has been subject to potential power politics.
474. Brown, Drusilla K., Alan V. Deardorff, and Robert M. Stern,
"Child Labor: Theory, Evidence, and Policy" August 17, 2001. ABS
PDF
There is a growing theoretical and empirical literature concerning the causes and consequences of child labor. The objective of this paper is to evaluate the policy initiatives targeted on child labor in light of the newly emerging theoretical argumentation and empirical evidence. We focus in particular on programs to address child-labor practices, and we attempt to evaluate these programs, given the empirical evidence concerning the primary determinants of when and why children work. Throughout, we find it instructive to evaluate the policies that have been adopted with the intent of reducing overall child labor in terms of the impact they are likely have on the welfare of children.
473. Deardorff, Alan V., "Tariffication in Services" August
2, 2001. In Robert M. Stern, ed., Issues and Options for U.S.-Japan Trade Policies,
University of Michigan Press, 2002, pp. 107-121. ABS
PDF
In this paper I lay out the case, as I see it, for tariffication of services. I argue that the prospects for achieving significant liberalization of the international provision of services will be greatly improved if something like this proposal is followed. By amending the GATS to permit countries to tax foreign providers of services in a manner that is roughly analogous to tariffs on imported goods, countries will be encouraged to bring most categories of services under GATS discipline. Of course, that discipline will be much weakened by doing this, since the taxes may be set so high that little if any trade will occur. However, once this is done, it will become possible for countries to negotiate reductions in these service tariffs in exactly the same way that they have done for goods over the last fifty years. Considering the amount of time it has taken to achieve significant liberalization of trade in goods, we should not expect to achieve it in services any time soon. However, by starting the process with tariffication, we place services upon the same well-traveled road that has been followed before, and we can be more confident that the future negotiating process will take us where we want to go, even if we cannot know how soon we will get there.
472. Saxonhouse, Gary R., "Dispute Settlement at the WTO and
the Dole Commission: USTR Resources and Success" August 2, 2001. In Robert M.
Stern, ed., Issues and Options for U.S.-Japan Trade Policies, University
of Michigan Press, 2002, pp. 363-383. ABS PDF
At the time the Uruguay Round Agreements were passed by Congress, particular concern was expressed about their implications for U.S. national sovereignty. Concern was sufficiently great that the Clinton Administration committed its support to the creation of a commission that would review each adverse decision against the United States by the WTO. The commission was designed such that the outcome of its review process might trigger a serious Congressional consideration of U.S. withdrawal from the WTO.
While the so-called Dole Commission was never created, the Congressional controversy surrounding the ratification of the Uruguay Round Agreement has led to particular concern with USTR performance at the WTO. Curiously, enhanced Congressional concern has not gone hand in hand with more resources for USTR. Over the 1990s, USTR has rarely asked for, and, until 2000 has not received additional resources for its work.
The analysis here shows that if the USTR is concerned not only about the number of cases it wins but also about its rate of success, having more resources may have an ambiguous impact on the USTR's rate of success. Depending on how relatively promising are the additional cases that may yet be brought by USTR to the WTO, and how usefully additional resources may be applied to existing cases, it is possible that more resources can lower USTR's success rate. This is true, though for different reasons, when explicit allowance is made for the response by the other party to the dispute to a USTR commitment of additional resources.
More resources cannot explain the increased use that the USTR has made since the WTO was established, because until recently USTR has received no additional resources. Rather, a more predictable DSM may have encouraged more rather than fewer cases to be brought to the WTO in preference to further efforts at extra-WTO bilateral settlements.
471. Brown, Drusilla K., Alan V. Deardorff, and Robert M. Stern,
"Impacts on NAFTA Members of Multilateral and Regional Trading Arrangements and
Initiatives and Harmonization of NAFTA's External Tariffs" June 15, 2001. ABS
PDF
We have used the Michigan Model of World Production and Trade to simulate the economic effects on the NAFTA member countries and other major trading countries/regions of a prospective new round of WTO multilateral trade negotiations, the variety of free trade agreements (FTAs) that the NAFTA members have negotiated or are considering, and the adoption of a system of common external tariffs by the NAFTA members. We estimate that an assumed reduction of post-Uruguay Round tariffs on agricultural and industrial products and services barriers by 33 percent in a new WTO trade round would increase world welfare by $613.0 billion, with gains of $177.3 billion for the United States, $13.5 billion for Canada, $6.5 billion for Mexico, and significant gains for all other industrialized and developing countries. If there were global free trade, world welfare would increase three-fold to $1.9 trillion and the country/region gains would be similarly larger.
Regional FTAs such as an expansion of NAFTA to include Chile and a Western Hemisphere FTA would increase global and member-country welfare but much less than a new WTO multilateral trade round would. Separate bilateral FTAs negotiated or being considered by Canada, Mexico, and the United States would have positive, though generally small, welfare effects on the partner countries, but potentially disruptive sectoral employment shifts in some countries. There would be trade diversion and detrimental welfare effects on some nonmember countries for both the regional and bilateral FTAs analyzed. If the NAFTA members were to adopt a system of common external tariffs to replace their existing differentiated external tariffs, a system based on trade weights would have less distortive effects on trade and welfare than a system based on simple averages or production-weighted tariffs.
470. Stern, Robert M., "Quantifying Barriers to Trade in Services"
November 8, 2000. ABS PDF
Given the fact that international trade in services has been increasing significantly in recent decades and now is equal to about 20 percent of global merchandise trade, it is obviously important to consider the barriers that affect services trade and issues of measurement of these barriers. There has been similarly an increasing amount of foreign direct investment (FDI) in both goods and services sectors in and between advanced and developing countries. FDI is subject to a variety of barriers as well and thus merits attention in its own right. This paper reviews the literature on these barriers and presents data from several sources on what the sizes of the barriers to trade and investment in services may be.
469. Brown, Drusilla K., Alan V. Deardorff, and Robert M. Stern,
"Multilateral, Regional, and Bilateral Trade-Policy Options for the United States
and Japan" April 23, 2001. Revised as #490. ABS
PDF
We have used the Michigan Model of World Production and Trade to simulate the economic effects on
the United States, Japan, and other major trading countries/regions of a prospective new round of WTO
multilateral trade negotiations and a variety of regional/bilateral free trade agreements (FTAs) involving
the United States and Japan. We estimate that an assumed reduction of post-Uruguay Round tariffs on
agricultural and industrial products and services barriers by 33 percent in a new WTO trade round would
increase world welfare by $613.0 billion, with gains of $177.3 billion for the United States, $123.7 billion
for Japan, and significant gains for all other industrialized and developing countries/regions. If there were
global free trade with all post-Uruguay Round trade barriers completely removed, world welfare would
increase by $1.9 trillion, with gains of $537.2 billion (5.9 percent of GNP) for the United States and
$374.8 billion (5.8 percent of GNP) for Japan.
Regional agreements such as an APEC FTA, an ASEAN Plus 3 FTA, and a Western Hemisphere FTA
would increase global and member country welfare but much less so than a new WTO multilateral trade
round would. Separate bilateral FTAs involving Japan with Singapore, Mexico, Chile, and Korea and the
United States with Chile, Singapore, and Korea would have positive, though generally small, welfare
effects on the partner countries, but potentially disruptive sectoral employment shifts in some countries.
There would be trade diversion and detrimental welfare effects on some nonmember countries for both
the regional and bilateral FTAs analyzed. The welfare gains from multilateral trade liberalization are
therefore considerably greater than the gains from preferential trading arrangements and more uniformly
positive for all countries.
468. Brown, Drusilla K., Alan V. Deardorff, and Robert M. Stern,
"CGE Modeling and Analysis of Multilateral and Regional Negotiating Options" January
23, 2001. In Robert M. Stern, ed., Issues and Options for U.S.-Japan Trade
Policies, University of Michigan Press, 2002, pp. 23-76. ABS
PDF
We have used the Michigan Model of World Production and Trade to simulate the economic effects on
the United States, Japan, and other major trading countries/regions of: the Uruguay Round of multilateral
trade negotiations completed in 1993-94; a prospective new round of WTO multilateral trade
negotiations; and a variety of regional/bilateral free trade agreements (FTAs) involving the United States
and Japan. We estimate that the Uruguay Round negotiations increased global economic welfare by
$75.1 billion annually, with gains of $12.9 billion for the United States and $15.6 billion for Japan. An
assumed reduction of all post-Uruguay Round tariffs on agricultural and industrial products and of all
services barriers by 33 percent in a new WTO trade round is estimated to increase world welfare by
$613.0 billion, with gains of $177.3 billion for the United States and $123.7 billion for Japan. If there
were global free trade with all post-Uruguay Round trade barriers completely removed, then world
welfare would increase by $1.9 trillion, with gains of $537.2 billion (5.9 percent of GNP) for the United
States and $374.8 billion (5.8 percent of GNP) for Japan.
Elimination of APEC-member country bilateral post-Uruguay Round tariffs on agricultural and industrial
products and services barriers is estimated to increase world welfare by $764.4 billion, with gains of
$294.7 billion for the United States and $283.1 billion for Japan and losses of $7.0 billion for the
European Union/EFTA and $1.0 billion for South Asia. Separate bilateral FTAs involving Japan with
Singapore, Mexico, South Korea, and Chile and an ASEAN Plus-3 FTA involving Japan, China/Hong
Kong, and South Korea would have positive, though generally small, welfare effects, but potentially
disruptive sectoral employment shifts in some member countries. Depending on the agreement, there
may be detrimental welfare effects on some nonmembers. The welfare gains from multilateral trade
liberalization are therefore considerably greater than the gains from preferential trading arrangements and
more uniformly positive for all countries.
467. Deardorff, Alan V., Saul H. Hymans, Robert M. Stern, and
Chong Xiang, "Forecasting U.S. Trade in Services" March 30, 2000. In Robert M.
Stern, ed., Services in the International Economy: Measurement and Modeling, Sector
and Country Studies, and Issues in the WTO Services Negotiations, University of
Michigan Press, 2001, pp. 53-81. ABS PDF
This paper provides a set of forecasts of United States international trade in services, both at the
aggregate level and for four subcategories. These sectors are: travel, which is mostly tourist
expenditures; passenger fares, which is mostly passenger air transportation; transportation, other than
passenger transportation; and other private services, including education, financial services, insurance,
telecommunications, and business, professional and technical services. A forecasting model is
constructed and estimated, based on conventional economic forces of supply and demand, dependent
on cost variables and income variables as well as relative prices. For forecasting purposes, these
variables are taken from the Michigan Quarterly Econometric Model of the U.S. Economy, a
macroeconomic forecasting model with forecasts provided regularly by the University of Michigan
Research Seminar in Quantitative Economics.
The equations of the services trade model are reported and discussed, and the performance of
the estimated equations is evaluated. The quarterly forecast paths are provided for both aggregate and
sectoral services trade, including exports and imports, through the end of 2001. Results indicate that
imports will continue to rise over the forecast period, while exports, after remaining nearly stationary
for several quarters in some sectors in 1999, will resume their rise thereafter. This forecasting work is
to be continued, and it is suggested, in addition, that future research would be useful to explore the
determinants of the production and sales of foreign services affiliates of U.S. parent companies.
466. Dominguez, Kathryn M.E. and Linda L. Tesar, "Trade and
Exposure" January, 2001; American Economic Review: Papers and Proceedings,
May 2001, pp. 367-370. ABS PDF
Are firms that engage in trade more vulnerable to exchange rate risk? In this paper we examine
the relationship between exchange rate movements, firm value and trade. Our empirical work
tests whether exchange rate exposure can be explained by variables that proxy for the level of
international activity, firm size, industry affiliation and country affiliation. The results suggest
that while a significant fraction of firms in these countries is exposed to exchange rate
movements, there is little evidence of a systematic link between exposure and trade. Indeed,
what little evidence there is of a link suggests that firms that engage in greater trade exhibit
lower degrees of exposure. This may reflect the fact that those firms most engaged in trade are
also the most aware of exchange rate risk, and therefore are the most likely to hedge their
exposure.
465. Dominguez, Kathryn M.E. and Linda L. Tesar, "A Re-Examination
of Exchange Rate Exposure" January, 2001; American Economic Review: Papers
and Proceedings, May 2001, pp. 396-399. ABS PDF
Finance theory suggests that changes in exchange rates should have little influence on asset
prices in a world with integrated capital markets. Indeed, the existing literature examining the
relationship between international stock prices and exchange rates finds little evidence of
systematic exchange rate exposure. We argue in this paper that the absence of evidence may be
due to restrictions imposed on the sample of data and the empirical specifications used in
previous studies. We study a broad sample of firms in eight countries over an eighteen-year
period. We find that firm-level and industry-level share values are significantly influenced by
exchange rates. Further, we do not find evidence that exchange rate exposure is falling (or
becoming less statistically significant) over time. Our results suggest that significant firm,
industry and country-specific differences remain even as financial markets become more and
more "integrated".
464. Kilian, Lutz and Mark P. Taylor, "Why Is It So Difficult
to Beat the Random Walk Forecast of Exchange Rates?" January 1, 2001; forthcoming
in the Journal of International Economics. ABS
PDF
We propose a stylized exchange rate model based on diversity and weight of opinion.
Our model departs from standard assumptions in that we allow for heterogeneous agents. We
show that such a model can explain both the observed volatility and the persistence of real and
nominal exchange rate movements and thus in some measure resolves Rogoff’s (1996)
purchasing power parity puzzle. Our empirical analysis reconciles the well-known difficulties in
beating the random walk forecast model with the statistical evidence of nonlinear mean reversion
in deviations from fundamentals. We find strong evidence of long-horizon predictability both in
theory and in practice. We also explain why it is difficult to exploit this predictability in out-of-sample
forecasts. Our results not only lend support to economists’ beliefs that the exchange rate
is inherently predictable, but they also help us to understand the reluctance of applied forecasters
to abandon chartists methods in favor of models based on economic fundamentals.
463. Deardorff, Alan V., "International Provision of Trade Services,
Trade, and Fragmentation," August 30, 2000. Review of International Economics
9 (May 2001), 233-248. ABS PDF
This paper examines the special role that trade liberalization in service industries can play in stimulating not only trade in services itself, but also in stimulating trade in goods. International trade in goods requires inputs from several services industries - what I call trade services, such as transportation, insurance, and finance - in order to complete and facilitate international transactions. Restriction on the ability of national service providers to provide these services across borders and within foreign countries create additional costs and barriers to international trade above those that would arise in otherwise comparable intra-national exchange. As a result, trade liberalization in services can yield benefits, by facilitating trade in goods, that are larger than one might expect from analysis of the services trade alone. This paper explores this idea using simple theoretical models to specify the relationships between services trade and goods trade.
The paper also, to make the point more forcefully, notes the role of services trade in a model of international industrial fragmentation, where production processes can be separated across locations but at some cost in terms of additional service inputs. The incentives for such fragmentation can be larger across countries than within countries, due to the greater differences in factor prices and technologies that are available. However, the service costs of international fragmentation can also be larger, especially if regulations and restrictions impede the international provision of services. As a result, trade liberalization in services can also stimulate fragmentation of production of both goods and services, thus increasing international trade and the gains from trade even further.
462. Deardorff, Alan V., "Developing Country Growth and Developed
Country Response," August 14, 2000. Journal of International Trade and Economic
Development, 10, December 2001, pp. 373-392. ABS
PDF
This paper makes a theoretical argument that growth in developing countries is likely to worsen the income distribution in developed countries and lead to a protectionist response that undermines the incentives for developing country growth. The model for this purpose is the two-cone version of the Heckscher-Ohlin (HO) trade model, in which countries have different factor prices even with free trade and in which they produce mostly different groups of goods. In that model, unlike the HO model with factor price equalization, growth by the poor country expands the output of its capital-intensive good, which is also the labor-intensive good of the other country. Regardless of whether factors are mobile or immobile across sectors, this reduces the real wages of factors that are either intensive or specific in the labor-intensive sector of the rich country. The paper argues that this will then lead to the rich country restricting trade. This in turn will lower the return to capital in the poor country and reduce the incentive for further growth.
461. Deardorff, Alan V., "Market Access for Developing Countries,"
August 14, 2000. In R. B. Porter, P. Sauvé, A. Subramanian, and A. B. Zampetti,
Efficiency, Equity and Legitimacy: The Multilateral Trading System at the Millennium,
Washington, D.C.: Brookings Institution Press, 2001, pp. 159-173. ABS
PDF
This paper argues that successful development by developing countries causes adverse consequences for some factor owners in developed countries. These in turn seek protection from imports and that protection undermines the benefits to the developing countries of their own growth. Several of the main examples of protection in the world today can be interpreted as arising from this mechanism, including protection of textiles, apparel, and steel. More broadly, current resistance to globalization may be due in part to this phenomenon. The paper concludes with a brief discussion of how policies and institutions should respond to this, including increased use and improvement of programs of trade adjustment assistance.
460. Deardorff, Alan V. and Robert M. Stern, "What the Public
Should Know about Globalization and the World Trade Organization," July 20, 2000;
published as "What You Should Know about Globalization and the World Trade Organization,"
Review of International Economics 10 (August 2002), 404-423. ABS
PDF
This paper reviews the essentials of economic globalization, as well as the major institution that has recently gotten much of the credit and blame for it, the World Trade Organization (WTO). It first defines globalization, which is just the increasing economic integration of the world economy. It then asks who gains and loses from globalization, drawing primarily upon economic theory to identify its benefits and costs, and who within and among the world's economies get them. That part of the discussion concludes by asking briefly what can and should be done about globalization.
The second half of the paper turns to the WTO, which was the focus of so much negative attention at its Seattle meeting in December 1999. For it too, we first ask what it is, trying to clarify several misperceptions about what it does and why. We then ask what groups gain and lose from the WTO, some simply as a byproduct of its role in facilitating globalization, but others from particular WTO rules and procedures. This takes us to the controversies that raged in Seattle, and we describe those events as they have been described to us by those who were there (we were not). We conclude with our suggestions as to what might be done to change both the WTO itself and the public's perceptions of it.
459. Chadha, Rajesh, Drusilla K. Brown, Alan V. Deardorff, and
Robert M. Stern, "Computational Analysis of the Impact on India of the Uruguay
Round and the Forthcoming WTO Trade Negotiations," March 28, 2000. ABS
PDF
The Indian economy has experienced a major transformation during the decade of the 1990s.
Apart from the impact of various unilateral economic reforms undertaken since 1991, the economy also
had to reorient itself to the changing multilateral trade discipline within the newly written GATT/WTO
framework. The unilateral trade policy measures have encompassed exchange-rate policy, foreign
investment, external borrowing, import licensing, custom tariffs, and export subsidies. The multilateral
aspect of India’s trade policy refers to India’s WTO commitments regarding trade in goods and services,
trade-related investment measures, and intellectual property rights. The present study analyzes the
economic effects on India and other major trading countries/regions of the Uruguay Round (UR) trade
liberalization and the liberalization that might be undertaken in a new WTO negotiating round. India’s
welfare gain is expected to be 1.1% ($4.7 billion over its 2005 GDP) when the UR scenarios get fully
implemented. The additional welfare gain is an estimated 2.7% ($11.4 billion) when the assumed future
WTO round of multilateral trade liberalization is achieved. Resources would be allocated in India to the
labor-intensive sectors such as textiles, clothing, leather and leather products, and food, beverages, and
tobacco. These sectors would also experience growth in output and exports. Real returns to both labor
and capital would increase in the economy. The scale effect (percent change in output per firm) is
positive for all the ten sectors of manufacturing, indicating that Indian firms become more efficient than
before. Finally, even if India undertakes unilateral trade liberalization of the order indicated in the WTO
multilateral scenarios, it would still benefit, although less so than with multilateral liberalization.
458. Deardorff, Alan V. "Financial Crisis, Trade, and Fragmentation,"
April 18, 2000; in Leonard K. Cheng and Henryk Kierzkowski, eds., Global Production
and Trade in East Asia, Boston: Kluwer Academic Publishers, 2001. ABS
PDF
Motivated by the Asian financial crises that began in 1997, this paper adds money to a
Ricardian model of international trade in order to explore the role of financing costs in general-equilibrium
trade. The purpose is to show not only that financing costs matter, but to argue a
potentially important effect of a financial crisis. If financial markets suddenly come to expect a
country’s currency to depreciate, as might happen if it has attempted an unsustainable peg, then
that expectation will itself force a depreciation. The depreciation will in turn make it impossible
for international traders to repay their financing, and their default will increase the costs of
financing trade in subsequent periods. Finally, this crisis-induced increase in costs of trade
financing then undermines both trade itself and the gains from trade. The paper also goes on to
argue that fragmentation – the splitting of production processes across countries – contributes to
both trade and the gains from trade, but in doing so it makes countries more vulnerable to these
effects of a financial crisis.
457. Stern, Robert M., "Labor Standards and Trade," February
17, 2000. In Marco Bronckers and Reinhard Quick (eds.), New Directions in International
Economic Law: Essays in Honor of John Jackson, Kluwer Law International, 2000,
pp. 425-438. ABS PDF
This paper explores the wide disparity of views on issues of international labor standards and the available options for addressing the issues involved. The discussion and analysis include: the definition and scope of labor standards; theoretical aspects of the economic effects of labor standards and the available empirical evidence; global, regional, national/unilateral, and other arrangements for the monitoring and enforcement of labor standards; and implications for policy in dealing with labor standards. It is argued that, because of the diversity of labor standard in countries with differing national characteristics, policies, and institutions, the case for devising WTO rules and disciplines to improve core labor standards in low-income countries cannot be convincingly made. Further, there are no compelling theoretical and empirical grounds to support the international enforcement and harmonization of labor standards.
On a global level, the International Labor Organization (ILO) is best suited to provide a multilateral forum that would serve to strengthen its role and authority in pursuing improved labor standards internationally. The policies of the United States and other industrialized countries should be directed to maintaining open markets and encouraging the economic growth of their developing country trading partners. This is the surest way to achieve higher labor standards since there is pervasive historical evidence that standards are improved with higher levels of per capita incomes. National governments in developing countries should accordingly institute pro-active policies designed to improve working conditions and workers' rights as their economies expand and more resources can be channeled toward social betterment.
456. Stern, Robert M., "Developing Country Interests in the
Forthcoming WTO Negotiations," February 16, 2000. Forthcoming in The Journal
of East Asian Affairs. ABS PDF
This paper reviews the main issues in the forthcoming WTO negotiations, including: a review of the accomplishments of the Uruguay Round and the multilateral negotiations that have since followed; identification and analysis of Uruguay Round built-in agenda issues and new issues that may possibly be considered in a new round; alternative negotiating modalities, including sectoral and broadly based negotiations and possible cross-issue linkages; dovetailing multilateral and regional negotiations; and interest-group alignments. In preparing for a new negotiating round, individual developing countries need to design with care their negotiating strategies and options. Countries have to decide what they want most to achieve from the negotiations and what they are willing to offer in return.
455. Deardorff, Alan V., "The Economics of Government Market
Intervention, and Its International Dimension," February 10, 2000. In Marco Bronckers
and Reinhard Quick (eds.), New Directions in International Economic Law: Essays
in Honor of John Jackson, Kluwer Law International, 2000, pp. 71-84. ABS
PDF
This paper uses basic economic theory to examine the circumstances in which government intervention in markets is justified, and the conditions under which the independent domestic policy choices of national governments can potentially be unambiguously improved upon by international coordination and cooperation. In a closed economy, market intervention is justified when there are "distortions" from the perfectly competitive ideal in which all market participants fully internalize the costs and benefits of their choices and also are too small to affect the prices at which they transact. Similarly, when there are multiple countries, independent policy choices will be optimal only when the distortions being corrected are local and when the effects of the individual national policies on world prices are negligible. When both of these conditions hold, then governments should be left to their own devices in setting domestic policies, and this is true regardless of what domestic objectives these government legitimately pursue. However, when either the distortions themselves or the price effects of market intervention extend across borders, then independent policy choices will not be optimal. Whether it is possible to design a mechanism for international coordination that will improve matters, on the other hand, is open to question.
454. Deardorff, Alan V. and Simeon Djankov, "Knowledge Transfer
Under Subcontracting: Evidence from Czech Firms," January 5, 2000. World Development
28, 2000, pp. 1837-1847. ABS PDF
We investigate the significance of subcontracting arrangements as a source of knowledge transfer and increased efficiency for Czech firms during 1993 through 1996. We draw on detailed enterprise surveys and interviews with the managers of 373 manufacturing firms in the Prague region. The results suggest a positive correlation between employee training and subcontracting. Subcontracting is also associated with a reduction in variable costs and a price premium on the stock market. The effect of subcontracting on other firms in the same industry is weak. A high share of subcontracting activity in a particular industry is associated with increased valuation of firms without foreign partners as investors anticipate more subcontracting arrangements.
453. Brown, Drusilla K. and Robert M. Stern, "Measurement and
Modeling of the Economic Effects of Trade and Investment Barriers in Services,"
Revised, November 24, 2000. ABS PDF
In this paper, we adapt the latest version of the Michigan Model of World Production and Trade to incorporate relationships and data for cross-border services trade and foreign direct investment (FDI) in the major developed and developing countries subsumed in the model's structure and database.
Firms are taken to be monopolistically competitive. Each firm produces a set of differentiated products. Products are differentiated both by the original R&D undertaken at headquarters that defines the basic product and by the final location of production. Each firm faces a fixed cost in the country where production occurs, and it then sets an optimal mark-up of price over marginal cost for sales from each location. Free entry guarantees that profits are zero.
Firms locate production for export or for local consumption depending on the type of barriers restraining the conduct of multinationals. In this version of the model, barriers to trade in services take two forms. First, firms may face an ad valorem tax on local capital installed. Second, foreign affiliate firms may face a policy-induced fixed cost of production for local operations..
We report the impact on welfare, trade, factor prices, sectoral output, economies of scale, and activities of multinationals that might occur following the introduction of national treatment of multinational firms in all countries of the model.
452. Barsky, Robert B. and Lutz Kilian, "A Monetary Explanation
of the Great Stagflation of the 1970s," January 27, 2000; forthcoming in the NBER
Macroeconomics Annual as "Do We Really Know that Oil Caused the Great Stagflation?
A Monetary Alternative". ABS PDF
The origins of stagflation and the possibility of its recurrence continue to be an important
concern among policymakers and in the popular press. It is common to associate the origins of the Great
Stagflation of the 1970s with the two major oil price increases of 1973/74 and 1979/80. This paper
argues that oil price increases were not nearly as essential a part of the causal mechanism generating
stagflation as is often thought. We provide a model that can explain the bulk of stagflation by monetary
expansions and contractions without reference to supply shocks. Monetary fluctuations also help to
explain variations in the price of oil (and other commodities) and help to account for the striking
coincidence of major oil price increases and worsening stagflation. In contrast, there is no theoretical
presumption that oil supply shocks are stagflationary. In particular, we show that oil supply shocks may
quite plausibly lower the GDP deflator and that there is little independent evidence that oil supply shocks
actually raised the deflator (as opposed to the CPI). The oil supply shock view also fails to explain the
dramatic surge in the price of other industrial commodities that preceded the 1973/74 oil price increase
and the fact that increases in industrial commodity prices lead oil price increases in the OPEC period.
451. Melitz, Marc, "When and How Should Infant Industries Be
Protected," October 11, 1999. ABS PDF
This paper develops and analyzes a welfare maximizing model of infant industry protection.
The domestic infant industry is competitive and experiences dynamic learning effects that are
external to firms. The competitive foreign industry is mature and produces a good that is an
imperfect substitute for the domestic good. A government planner can protect the infant industry
by using domestic production subsidies, tariffs, and quotas in order to maximize domestic
welfare over time. As protection is not always optimal even though the domestic industry
experiences a learning externality), the paper shows how the decision to protect the industry
should depend on the industry’s learning potential, the shape of the learning curve, and the
degree of substitutability between domestic and foreign goods.
Assuming some reasonable restrictions on the flexibility over time of the policy instruments,
the paper subsequently compares the effectiveness of the different instruments. The economics
literature has mainly explained the widespread use of quantity restrictions by appealing to
non-welfare-maximizing behavior of governments or strategic interactions between firms and/or
governments. In this work, quantity restrictions have been mostly interpreted as more distorting
than other trade instruments such as tariffs or domestic production subsidies. This paper
demonstrates that, under the model’s assumptions, the quota almost always yields higher welfare
than the tariff. In some cases, the dominance of the quota is so pronounced that it compensates
for any amount of government revenue loss caused by practical considerations involved in the
administration of the quota. (This is true even in the extreme case of a voluntary export
restraint, where no revenues would be collected.) It is further shown that the quota may even
be preferred to a domestic production subsidy. The paper thus introduces a new argument to
explain why quantity restrictions may create less distortions than tariffs or subsidies and can
potentially be welfare enhancing.
450. Kilian, Lutz and Tao Zha, "Quantifying the Half-Life of
Deviations from PPP: The Role of Economic Priors," October 5, 1999. Forthcoming
as "Quantifying the Uncertainty about the Half-Life of Deviations from PPP," Journal
of Applied Econometrics. ABS PDF
The half-life of deviations from purchasing power parity (PPP) plays a central role in the
ongoing debate about the ability of macroeconomic models to account for the time series behavior of the
real exchange rate. The main contribution of this paper is a general framework in which alternative priors
for the half-life of deviations from PPP can be examined. We show how to incorporate formally the prior
views of economists about the half-life. In our empirical analysis we provide two examples of such
priors. One example is a consensus prior consistent with widely held views among economists with a
professional interest in the PPP debate. The other example is a relatively diffuse prior designed to capture
a large degree of uncertainty about the half-life. Our methodology allows us to make explicit probability
statements about the half-life and to assess the likelihood that the half-life exceeds a given number of
years, without taking a stand on whether the data have a unit root or not. We find only very limited
support for the common view in the PPP literature that the half-life is between three and five years.
449. Hanson, Gordon H. and Antonio Spilembergo, "Political Economy,
Sectoral Shocks, and Border Enforcement," July, 1999. Canadian Journal of Economics,
forthcoming. ABS PDF
In this paper, we examine the correlation between sectoral shocks and border enforcement in
the United States. Enforcement of national borders is the main policy instrument the U.S. government
uses to combat illegal immigration. The motivation for the exercise is to see whether border
enforcement falls following positive shocks to sectors that are intensive in the use of undocumented
labor, as would be consistent with political economy models of how enforcement policy against illegal
immigration is determined. The main finding is that border enforcement is negatively correlated with
lagged relative price changes in the apparel, fruits and vegetables, and slaughtered livestock industries
and with housing starts in the western United States. This suggests that authorities relax border
enforcement when the demand for undocumented workers is high.
448. Hanson, Gordon H. and Matthew J. Slaughter, "The Rybczynski
Theorem, Factor-Price Equalization, and Immigration: Evidence from U.S. States,"
April, 1999. Forthcoming as "Labor Market Adjustment in Open Economies: Evidence
from U.S. States," Journal of International Economics. ABS
PDF
Recent literature on the labor-market effects of U.S. immigration tends to find little
correlation between regional immigrant inflows and changes in relative regional wages. In this
paper we examine whether immigration, or endowment shocks more generally, altered U.S.
regional output mixes as predicted by the Rybczynski Theorem of Heckscher-Ohlin (HO) trade
theory. This theorem describes how regions can absorb endowment shocks via changes in output
mix without any changes in relative regional factor prices. Treating U.S. states as HO regions, we
search for evidence of regional output-mix effects using a new data set that combines state
endowments, outputs, and employment in 1980 and 1990. We have two main findings. First,
state output-mix changes broadly match state endowment changes. Second, variation in state unit
factor requirements is consistent with relative factor-price equalization (FPE) across states, which
is a sufficient condition for our output-mix hypothesis to hold. Overall, these findings suggest
that states absorb regional endowment shocks through mechanisms other than changes in relative
regional factor prices.
447. Hanson, Gordon H., Raymond Robertson, and Antonio Spilembergo,
"Does Border Enforcement Protect U.S. Workers from Illegal Immigration?," February,
1999. Review of Economics and Statistics, forthcoming. ABS
PDF
In this paper, we examine the impact of government enforcement of the U.S.-Mexico
border on wages in the border regions of the United States and Mexico. The U.S. Border Patrol
polices U.S. boundaries, seeking to apprehend any individual attempting to enter the United
States illegally. These efforts are concentrated on the Mexican border, as most illegal immigrants
embark from a Mexican border city and choose a U.S. border state as their final destination. We
examine labor markets in southern California, southwestern Texas, and Mexican cities on the
U.S.-Mexico border. For each region, we have high-frequency time-series data on wages and on
the number of person hours that the U.S. Border Patrol spends policing border areas. For a range
of empirical specifications and definitions of regional labor markets, we find little impact of
border enforcement on wages in U.S. border cities and a moderate negative impact of border
enforcement on wages in Mexican border cities. These findings are consistent with two
hypothesis: (1) border enforcement has a minimal impact on illegal immigration, or (2) illegal
immigration from Mexico has a minimal impact on wages in U.S. border areas.
446. Levinsohn, James, Steven Berry, and Jed Friedman, "Impacts
of the Indonesian Economic Crisis: Price Changes and the Poor," June 22, 1999.
ABS PDF
The recent financial crisis in Indonesia has resulted in dramatic price
increases. Using very recent data, we investigate whether these price
increases have impacted the cost-of-living of poor households in a
disproportionately harsh way. We find that the poor have indeed been hit
hardest. Just how hard the poor have been hit, though, depends crucially on
where the household lives, whether the household is in a rural or urban area,
and just how the cost-of-living index is computed. What is clear is that the
notion that the very poor are so poor as to be insulated from international
shocks is simply wrong. Rather, in the Indonesian case, the very poor appear
the most vulnerable.
445. Levinsohn, James and Amil Petrin, "When Industries Become
More Productive, Do Firms?: Investigating Productivity Dynamics," January 27,
1999. ABS PDF
This paper investigates two explanations for why industries might become
more productive over time. The first explanation, termed the real productivity
case,' is one in which firms become more productive and this leads to more
productive industries. The second explanation, termed the rationalization
case,' is one in which firm productivity is constant, but productive firms
expand while less productive firms either shrink or exit. Each case has very
different implications for factor markets, long term growth prospects, and
public policy regarding productivity. Further, one can only distinguish
between these two cases with plant- or firm-level data. We investigate the
empirical relevance of the two cases using the Chilean manufacturing census.
We find that the rationalization case explains much of the measured increase
in industry productivity. When industry productivity fails, the rationalization
case appears much less important. We also contribute to the applied
econometric literature on productivity estimation as we show that the
value-added production function is especially well-suited to a simple
extension of recent methods developed by Oiley and Pakes.
444. Caner, Mehmet and Lutz Kilian, "Size Distortions of Tests
of the Null Hypothesis of Stationarity: Evidence and Implications for the PPP
Debate," July 30, 1999; forthcoming in Journal of International Money and Finance.
ABS PDF
Tests of the null hypothesis of stationarity against the unit root alternative play an increasingly important role in empirical work in macroeconomics and in international finance. We show that the use of conventional asymptotic critical values for stationarity tests may cause extreme size distortions, if the model under the null hypothesis is highly persistent. This fact calls into question the use of these tests in empirical work. We illustrate the practical importance of this point for tests of long-run purchasing power parity under the recent float. We show that the common practice of viewing tests of stationarity as complementary to tests of the unit root null will tend to result in contradictions and in spurious rejections of long-run PPP. While the size distortions may be overcome by the use of finite-sample critical values, the resulting tests tend to have low power under economically plausible assumptions about the half-life of deviations from PPP. Thus, the fact that stationarity is not rejected cannot be interpreted as convincing evidence in favor of mean reversion. Only in the rare case that stationarity is rejected do size-corrected tests shed light on the question of long-run PPP.
443. Deardorff, Alan V., "Patterns of Trade and Growth across
Cones," July 23, 1999. De Economist 148, June 2000, pp. 141-166. ABS
PDF
This paper examines the implications of the Heckscher-Ohlin (HO) Model for the patterns
of production and trade that will emerge as a country grows. It focuses primarily on world
equilibria that include two or more cones of diversification. Starting with the textbook model of
two factors and two goods, growth paths for production and trade are derived in terms of a
country’s capital-labor ratio relative to that of the world. With additional goods and countries,
multiple cones create a ladder of comparative advantage that a country will climb as it
accumulates capital relative to the world. With additional factors as well, more complicated
patterns can emerge. In a three-factor model based on Krueger (1977), a country with fixed land,
growing labor, and faster growing capital can first work its way down the ladder of comparative
advantage before climbing back up. Using a graphical representation of a more general three-factor
model due to Leamer (1987), cones of diversification with large numbers of goods take the
form of polygons that a growing country may pass through, then cross between. In all cases, the
lesson of the HO Model is that growth causes repeated and extreme changes in patterns of
specialization and trade over time.
442. Deardorff, Alan V., "Economic Implications of Europe-Maghreb
Trade Agreements," July 17, 1999. ABS PDF
This paper reviews the various economic effects on Algeria of accepting the European Union's invitation to enter into an economic partnership, as has already been done by two other countries of the Maghreb, Morocco and Tunisia. These Euro-Mediterranean partnerships consist primarily of the formation of free trade areas, FTAs, including the EU and the country involved, so my analysis is devoted primarily to the economic effects of an FTA. However, the occasion of forming an FTA also provides an opportunity to undertake several additional steps toward integration, which I also examine. These are 1) deeper integration, 2) extension of the FTA to include other neighboring countries, and 3) reductions in tariffs on imports from the rest of the world. The paper concludes that an EU-Algeria FTA would probably be good for Algeria, but the benefits can be substantially enhanced and the costs reduced by pursuing also one or more of these additional steps.
441. Deardorff, Alan V. and Robert M. Stern, Table of Contents
and Chapter 1 of Social Dimensions of U.S. Trade Policy, June 7, 1999.
Volume published Ann Arbor, MI: The University of Michigan Press, 2000. ABS
PDF
Proceedings of a Conference held in Washington, D.C., April 16-17, 1998. The contributors include members of the trade policy
community who analyze and discuss the salient social dimensions of U.S. trade
policies. These issues include the effects of trade on wage inequality; trade and
immigration policy; U.S. trade adjustment assistance policies; the effects of NAFTA
on environmental quality; the role of labor standards in U.S. trade policies; the
economics of labor standards and the GATT; issues of child labor; and the role of
interest groups in the design and implementation of U.S. trade policies.
440. Deardorff, Alan V., "Policy Implications of the Trade and
Wages Debate," May 26, 1999. Review of International Economics 8, (August
2000), 478-496. ABS PDF
This paper examines the choice of policies to redistribute income in response to an increase in inequality caused by a rise in the differential wage paid to skilled labor compared to unskilled labor. The main issue is whether the appropriate policy response depends on the cause of the increased differential. In particular, should policies respond any differently if the rising differential is due to "trade" – shorthand for greater openness in global markets and/or greater participation in those markets by developing countries abundantly endowed with unskilled labor – or due to technological changes that have favored skilled labor over unskilled labor. The analysis is conducted within the context of a two-sector Heckscher-Ohlin trade model augmented to allow endogenous determination of the level of skill. Utility possibility frontiers are constructed for various policies, then shifted as a result of changes in trade and technology. The conclusion is that the usual trade economists' argument against the use of trade policies applies in this context as well, regardless of the source of the worsening income distribution. If trade is the best available tool for dealing with a trade-induced increase in inequality, then trade policy will also be best for dealing with inequality induced by technology. But more likely, the preferred policy will be a tax/subsidy focused more directly on factors employed, and this preference too will hold regardless of the relative contributions of trade and technology to causing the problem being addressed.
439. Hanson, Gordon H., "Market Potential, Increasing Returns,
and Geographic Concentration," May, 1999. ABS PDF
Figures (large file - 2.5M)
In this paper, I examine the spatial correlation of wages, employment, and consumer
purchasing power across U.S. counties to see whether regional product-market linkages contribute
to spatial agglomeration. First, I estimate a simple market-potential function, which is a reduced
form for several economic geography models. This specification resembles a spatial labor
demand function, as it is proximity to consumer markets that determines nominal wages and
employment in a given location. The estimation results indicate how far demand linkages extend
across space and how income shocks in one location affect other locations. Second, I estimate
a more elaborate market-potential function derived from the Krugman model of economic
geography. The parameter estimates reflect the importance of scale economies and transport
costs, the stability of spatial agglomeration patterns, and how these features evolve over time.
438. Hanson, Gordon H., Raymond Robertson, and Antonio Spilimbergo,
"Does Border Enforcement Protect U.S. Workers from Illegal Immigration?" February,
1999. ABS PDF
In this paper, we examine the impact of government enforcement of the U.S.-Mexico
border on wages in the border regions of the United States and Mexico. The U.S. Border Patrol
polices U.S. boundaries, seeking to apprehend any individual attempting to enter the United
States illegally. These efforts are concentrated on the Mexican border, as most illegal immigrants
embark from a Mexican border city and choose a U.S. border state as their final destination. We
examine labor markets in southern California, southwestern Texas, and Mexican cities on the
U.S.-Mexico border. For each region, we have high-frequency time-series data on wages and on
the number of person hours that the U.S. Border Patrol spends policing border areas. For a range
of empirical specifications and definitions of regional labor markets, we find little impact of
border enforcement on wages in U.S. border cities and a moderate negative impact of border
enforcement on wages in Mexican border cities. These findings are consistent with two
hypothesis: (1) border enforcement has a minimal impact on illegal immigration, or (2) illegal
immigration from Mexico has a minimal impact on wages in U.S. border areas.
437. Stern, Robert M., "Dynamic Aspects of the Euro-Mediterranean
Agreements for the MENA Countries," April 14, 1999. In Sebastien Dessus, Raed
Safadi, and Julia Devlin (eds.), The Dynamics of New Regionalism in MENA: Integration,
Euro-Med Partnership Agreements and After, OECD, Paris, forthcoming. ABS
PDF
This paper addresses the variety of static and dynamic impacts that the Euro-Med Agreements (EMA) may have on the MENA economies. It first considers options for trade and domestic policy reforms, including the context in which policies are designed and implemented and the range of policy options spanning unilateral measures, multilateral measures, and preferential arrangements such as the EMAs. It then sets out the comparative static and dynamic-growth frameworks for analyzing the effects of alternative policies. This is followed by a review of ex ante assessments of existing and proposed EMAs using CGE modeling and qualitative analysis and the potential dynamic effects that EMAs may bring about. Because EMAs are limited in scope, there is no guarantee that the MENA economies will realize significant dynamic benefits. Nonetheless, if EMAs result in enhancing policy credibility, the MENA economies might well improve their dynamic-growth prospects by instituting effective unilateral domestic-policy reforms and aligning their foreign trade and investment policies more closely on a multilateral basis with the global trading community.
436. Hanson, Gordon H. and Matthew J. Slaughter, "The Rybczynski
Theorem, Factor-Price Equalization, and Immigration: Evidence from U.S. States,"
April, 1999. ABS PDF
Recent literature on the labor-market effects of U.S. immigration tends to find little
correlation between regional immigrant inflows and changes in relative regional wages. In this
paper we examine whether immigration, or endowment shocks more generally, altered U.S.
regional output mixes as predicted by the Rybczynski Theorem of Heckscher-Ohlin (HO) trade
theory. This theorem describes how regions can absorb endowment shocks via changes in output
mix without any changes in relative regional factor prices. Treating U.S. states as HO regions, we
search for evidence of regional output-mix effects using a new data set that combines state
endowments, outputs, and employment in 1980 and 1990. We have two main findings. First,
state output-mix changes broadly match state endowment changes. Second, variation in state unit
factor requirements is consistent with relative factor-price equalization (FPE) across states, which
is a sufficient condition for our output-mix hypothesis to hold. Overall, these findings suggest
that states absorb regional endowment shocks through mechanisms other than changes in relative
regional factor prices.
435. Davis, Donald R. and David E. Weinstein., "An Account of
Global Factor Trade," October 16, 1998. American Economic Review, forthcoming.
ABS PDF
A half-century of empirical work on the factor proportions theory has identified
“paradoxes” and “mysteries,” but has failed to devise simple amendments that bring theory and data
into reasonable congruence. Our study considers standard and novel hypotheses regarding the failures
of the Heckscher-Ohlin-Vanek formulation and is the first to examine these directly on the technology
and absorption data of interest. We show how a few simple and plausible amendments, verified
directly by this data, suffice for a striking confirmation of the HOV theory. Countries export the
services of abundant factors and in approximately the right magnitude. HOV works.
434. Xiang, Chong., "The Sufficiency of the 'Lens Condition'
for Factor Price Equalization in the Case of Two Factors," January 11, 1999. Journal
of International Economics 53, 2001, pp. 463-474. ABS
PDF
Factor price equalization (FPE) is a central theme in trade theory, for which Dixit and
Norman (1980) establish the necessary and sufficient condition (the FPE condition).
Deardorff (1994) provides a more intuitive condition (the lens condition) and establishes
its necessity in general, as well as its sufficiency for the case of 2 countries. In this paper,
I prove that the lens condition is sufficient for FPE in the case of 2 factors. This theorem
has implications for empirical work.
433. Brown, Drusilla K., Alan V. Deardorff, and Robert M. Stern,
"U.S. Trade and Other Policy Options and Programs to Deter Foreign Expoitation
of Child Labor," February 19, 1999. In Magnus Blomström and Linda S. Goldberg,
eds., Topics in Empirical International Economics: A Festschrift in Honor of
Robert E. Lipsey, University of Chicago Press, 2001. ABS
PDF
The purpose of this paper is to explore issues of child labor exploitation in developing countries and the variety of trade and other policy options and programs that are available to the United States and other major industrialized countries to deter such exploitation. We begin with a discussion of the determinants of child labor and selected information on the global, national, and sectoral employment of children. We then discuss the range of policies and programs used in the United States to help effect a reduction in foreign child labor. With the foregoing as background, we turn to conceptual considerations, examining first the process of monitoring of child labor, and second the economic determinants of child labor and the expected consequences of alternative measures that are designed to reduce child labor. The paper concludes by drawing out the implications of the discussion for policy.
432. Brown, Drusilla K., Alan V. Deardorff, and Robert M. Stern,
"Computational Analysis of the Accession of Chile to the NAFTA and Western Hemisphere
Integration," October 16, 1998. The World Economy 23, (February 2000),
pp. 145-174. ABS PDF
Complete Tables
We present the results based on the Michigan computational general equilibrium model of Western
Hemisphere economic integration. It is shown that tariff elimination will have beneficial effects for most
countries involved, although the benefits as well as the costs of liberalization are small. However, if a
hemispheric treaty were to stimulate an increase in the capital stocks of the major South American
economies, the welfare gains would be substantial. Sensitivity tests reveal that the model exaggerates the
likely gains from economies of scale due to liberalization. But the error is small in this context because
the impact of trade liberalization is small. When econometric estimates of scale economies are
incorporated into the model, the welfare gains due to capital flows nevertheless remain robust. A
comparison of results for Chile using different databases indicates that the impact of regional
liberalization using a 1980 database may overstate the impact on the nonferrous metals sector in particular
and manufacturing more generally. Nonetheless, when using a 1990 database, the change in output of the
nonferrous metals sector remain larger than for any other sectors in the Chilean economy.
431. Deardorff, Alan V., "Does Growth Encourage Factor Price
Equalization," August 10, 1998. Review of Development Economics, forthcoming.
ABS PDF
This paper first notes the importance of “one-cone” versus “multi-cone” equilibria in the
Heckscher-Ohlin Model of international trade, then asks whether the process of economic growth
as modeled in neoclassical growth models tends to lead the world more toward one or the other.
The one-cone model has been the workhorse of international trade theory for many years. It is
characterized by a single set (cone) of relative factor endowment combinations within which
countries can diversify their production of all goods. If all countries’ factor endowments are
within that cone, then there is global factor price equalization (FPE) under free trade. The multi-cone
model has received attention more recently, and includes separate cones of diversification
within each of which there is FPE, but across which factor prices differ. There are several
important differences between these two models. The paper examines several neoclassical models
of trade and growth, distinguished by their assumptions about the determinants of saving, to see
what they imply about the convergence or non-convergence of country factor endowments into a
single cone. None of the models suggest convergence, while some of them strongly imply that
different countries will end up in different cones. This therefore suggests that the multi-cone
version of the Heckscher-Ohlin model should be preferred.
430. Stern, Robert M., "Labor Standards and International Trade,"
January 16, 1998. Published in Institute for the Integration of Latin America
and the Caribbean, Integration and Trade, May/June 1999, in English and
Spanish. ABS PDF
There is a wide disparity of views on issues of international labor standards. Labor and social activists are concerned about the increased imports from countries in which labor standards are ostensibly not enforced at a sufficiently high level. They fear that these imports will be detrimental to wages and working conditions in the industrialized importing countries. The purpose of this paper is to explore these different views and the available options for addressing the issues involved. The paper begins with the definition and scope of labor standards, then turns to theoretical aspects of the economic effects of labor standards. These are followed by a summary of the available empirical evidence. Global, regional, national/unilateral, and other arrangements for the monitoring and enforcement of labor standards are then discussed.
429. Debaere, Peter, "'Endowments Do Matter': Relative
Factor Abundance and Trade" June, 1998. ABS PDF
A test of the Heckscher-Ohlin-Vanek [HOV] hypothesis for the cases when factor price equalization does not hold is developed. For all the possible country pairs of the BLS (1987) and Trefler (1995) data set, I test whether trade reveals the relative factor abundance of one country compared to another. For the factor pairs capital-labor, labor-land and land-capital, I investigate whether the higher endowment ratio of one country compared to another is reflected in their multilateral trade. A strength of the method is that technology differences, measurement error or home bias are allowed for, but do not have to be estimated. For the hundreds of country pairs, the relative abundance of two countries is revealed in trade in about 75 percent of the cases. In other words, endowments do matter. The more different are country endowments, the stronger are the results. I explicitly study North-South trade and find that it reflects the North's relative capital abundance in over 90 percent of the cases. The obtained sign test results are also analyzed with a probit model. A probit analysis helps to detect empirically other factors than endowment differences that affect the performance of the HOV prediction.
428. Deardorff, Alan V., "Technology, Trade, and Increasing
Inequality: Does the Cause Matter for the Cure?" June 17, 1998. Journal of
International Economic Law, September 1998, pp. 353-376. ABS
PDF
This paper addresses an issue that has received a great deal of attention in recent years, both from international trade economists and from labor economists: What has caused the relative wage of skilled labor compared to unskilled labor in the United States to increase through the 1980s and 1990s? Prime candidates for causing this change have been "trade" – the increased competition of U.S. workers with unskilled workers abroad – and "technology" – new products and processes that may have increased the productivity of skilled workers or skill-intensive industries relative to their unskilled counterparts. The paper reviews what has happened to relative wages and the explanations that have been suggested. A brief look at the empirical evidence from this literature is suggestive, but hardly conclusive. But the paper then asks whether the answer to this question really matters. It turns out that the appropriate policies for dealing with this change in relative wages do not depend on whether the cause of the change has been trade or technology. The paper concludes with an argument about the first-best policy for dealing with the increased wage differential, but also with some skepticism that any policy at all is needed.
427. Deardorff, Alan V., "Fragmentation across Cones," August
7, 1998. In Sven W. Arndt and Henryk Kierzkowski, eds., Fragmentation: New
Production Patterns in the World Economy, Oxford, 2001. ABS
PDF
This paper examines the effects of fragmentation across cones of diversification in the Heckscher-Ohlin model of international trade. Fragmentation is defined as the splitting of production processes into parts that can be done in different countries. Such fragmentation may occur in a world of factor price equalization (FPE) only if it is costless, and even then it is uninteresting. It becomes more important in a world without FPE, where countries operate in different diversification cones. In that case even costly fragmentation (which uses more resources than the original) may be able to produce a good at a lower cost than the original unfragmented technology, if it can take advantage of different factor prices in different countries. The paper shows when this will be the case, then goes on to examine the effects of fragmentation on factor prices. It is already known that introduction of fragmentation can lead to FPE when FPE did not obtain initially. But it need not do so, and the paper explores the directions of the effects on relative factor prices when they do not become equalized. It turns out that factor prices may actually be driven further apart by fragmentation. This is suggested diagrammatically, and also shown more formally for the case of Cobb-Douglas preferences and technologies.
426. McAusland, Carol, "Learning by Doing in the Presence of
an Open Access Renewable Resource: Is Growth Sustainable?" February 13, 1998.
ABS PDF
This paper focuses on the impact of technological progress (modeled as
learning by doing) on economic growth when one of the inputs in production
is an open access renewable resource. Technological progress is found to indi-
rectly induce resource depletion, such that sustainable growth will not occur in
autarky under certain preferences, and is possible in trade only if the resource
sector contracts over time or shuts down completely. Comparisons of steady
state welfare in autarky and free trade reveal that for very high or low world
prices of the resource-based good, it is possible for the economy to gain from
trade. However if the price is intermediate, it will instead lose.
425. Rowland, Patrick F. and Linda Tesar, "Multinationals and
the Gains from International Diversification" August 24, 1998. ABS
PDF
One possible explanation for home bias is that investors may obtain indirect international diversification
benefits by investing in multinational firms rather than by investing directly in foreign markets. This paper
employs mean-variance spanning tests to examine the diversification potential of multinational firms and
foreign market indices for investors domiciled in Canada, France, Germany, Italy, Japan, the United
Kingdom and the United States. We find that in most countries and most time periods, the portfolio of
domestic stocks spans the risk and return opportunities of a portfolio that includes domestic and
multinational stocks. However, there is weak evidence that U.S. multinationals provided global
diversification benefits in the full 1984-92 sample and in the post-1987 subsample. We also find that the
addition of foreign market indices to a domestic portfolio - inclusive of multinationals - provides
diversification benefits. The economic importance of the shift of the portfolio frontier - measured as the
utility gain from diversification - varies considerably from market to market and often reflects the benefits
of large short positions in certain markets.
424. Stern, Robert M., "The WTO Trade Policy Review of the United
States, 1996" February 3, 1998. The World Economy, August 1998. ABS
PDF
This paper assesses the major developments in U.S. trade policies since the creation of the WTO in 1995. It is based in large measure on the fourth biannual (1996) WTO Trade Policy Review of the United States and updated through 1997. The discussion and assessments include in particular: the major U.S. multilateral trade-policy issues and activities centered in the WTO: issues and activities relating to NAFTA; U.S. bilateral trade relations with its major trading partners; administration of U.S. trade laws and regulations; and U.S. agricultural trade policies.
423. Deardorff, Alan V., "Benefits and Costs of Following Comparative
Advantage" January 12, 1998. The Sweetland Inaugural Lecture, in Department of
Economics, The Economic Outlook for 1998, Forty-Fifth Annual Conference
on the Economic Outlook, Ann Arbor, MI, 1997. ABS PDF
This paper is the text of a lecture given on November 20, 1997 to inaugurate the John W. Sweetland Chair in International Economics, in the Department of Economics of the University of Michigan. Its message is that international trade theory, and in particular the theory of comparative advantage, is really just an application of benefit-cost analysis. This is true both of many of the tools of trade theory, which are familiar as the same tools by which benefit-cost examines all sorts of public projects and policies, and of the implications of the theory. Trade theory does not say, as sometimes claimed, that international trade is necessarily and always good for everyone. On the contrary, the theory of comparative advantage identifies both winners and losers from international trade, and the subtlety of the argument, much like many applications of benefit-cost analysis, consists of quantifying and comparing the gains and losses. The paper works through both the partial and the general equilibrium analyses of trade under a range of assumptions from implausibly perfect to realistically messy. It discusses who gains and who loses from trade in each case, as well as the strength of the argument that the gains outweigh the losses.
422. Deardorff, Alan V., "Fragmentation in Simple Trade Models"
January 7, 1998. North American Journal of Economics and Finance, forthcoming.
ABS PDF
This paper examines the effects of "fragmentation," defined as the splitting of a production process into two or more steps that can be undertaken in different locations but that lead to the same final product. Introducing the possibility of fragmentation into simple theoretical models of international trade, the paper finds the effects of fragmentation on national welfare, on patterns of specialization and trade, and on factor prices. Models examined include the Ricardian Model and the Heckscher-Ohlin Model, both for small open economies and for a two-country world. Results are as follows: 1. If fragmentation does not change the prices of goods, then it must increase the value of output of any country where it occurs and that of the world. 2. If fragmentation does change prices, then fragmentation can lower the welfare of a country by turning its terms of trade against it. 3. Even in a country that gains from fragmentation, it is possible (but not necessary) that some factor owners within that country will lose. 4. To the extent that factor prices are not equalized internationally in the absence of fragmentation, fragmentation may be a force toward factor price equalization.
421. Deardorff, Alan V., "Diverging Populations and Endogenous
Growth in a Model of Meaningless Trade" December 31, 1997. Review of International
Economics, 7, August 1999, pp. 359-377. ABS PDF
The endogenous growth literature raises the possibility that countries may grow without bound in terms of per capita income, and that they may do so at different rates. This possibility also exists in neoclassical growth models with diverging populations – populations that grow at different rates. In both cases, however, this means that international inequality of per capita incomes will not only exist but also get worse over time. This paper examines that possibility within a very simple one-sector model that allows for both diverging populations and endogenous growth. The model also allows for "meaningless" trade and international direct investment, in the sense that these occur at random across countries when traders and investors are indifferent among locations. The model suggests that if people behave as needed to generate endogenous growth, then international per capita income inequality is likely to increase without bound over time, along with increases in apparent importance of international trade and investment in the world economy, a result that may suggest increasing resentment and friction across countries. The simple model, including its odd approach to trade and investment, is argued to be robust to several more conventional and complex specifications. However, the results, including endogenous growth itself, depend on behavioral parameters that may not be empirically relevant or therefore a serious cause for concern.
420. Horn, Henrik and James Levinsohn, "Merger Policies and
Trade Liberalization" June 11, 1997. Economic Journal 111, April 2001,
pp. 244-276. ABS PDF
This paper is about the interactions between what is traditionally considered trade policy and a narrow but important aspect of competition policy, namely merger policy. We focus on links between merger policies and trade liberalization. Interpreting merger policy as a choice of degree of industrial concentration, we investigate how the merger policy that is optimal from the point of view of an individual country is affected by restrictions on the use of tariffs and export subsidies. Two general points emerge. First, merger policies are indeed associated with international externalities in open economies. And second, we argue that one should not expect to find any particular relationship between trade policy and merger policy. In particular, there seems to be no presumption that international trade liberalization induces countries to pursue merger policies that have more of a beggar-thy-neighbor flavor.
419. Jackson, John H., "Dispute Settlement in the WTO: Policy
and Jurisprudential Considerations" February 9, 1998. ABS
PDF
This paper explores the rule system of the World Trade Organization (WTO) as reflected mainly in the new and innovative WTO dispute settlement procedures. It begins with a retrospective look at the history of GATT on this subject. The goal of the rest of the paper is then not just to describe the procedures and the practice under them, but also to probe a number of fairly fundamental jurisprudential questions about these procedures, some of which have been apparent for some time, while others have only begun to emerge during the early years of actual application of the WTO Agreement.
418. Pahre, Robert, "Domestic Politics, Trade Policy, and Economic
Sanctions: A Public Choice Model with Application to United States-Chinese Relations"
April 10, 1998. ABS PDF
Economic sanctions are not only a foreign policy tool but a form of trade policy. Like other kinds of trade policy, sanctions attract domestic political support from both protectionists and the human rights lobby. Sometimes the human rights lobby can piggyback on protectionists to encourage policy-makers to demand sanctions, while protectionists can also hijack the human rights issue for their own ends. Two variables, WTO membership and an independent legislature, affect both the likelihood and the form of sanctions in this domestic political environment. WTO membership, like MFN treatment in general, mobilizes export interests against a trade sanctions policy. Congress's more hawkish preferences on both trade policy and human rights mean that when the United States imposes sanctions against a WTO member, it is likely to do so under congressional leadership and perhaps against the will of the president. These variables color Sino-American trade relations today.
417. Saxonhouse, Gary, "Trade Policy, Constituent Interests
and Politics in US-Japan Economic Relations" February 11, 1998. ABS
PDF PS
To date, virtually all the equity market literature analyzing the consequences of trade policy changes has assessed only the impact on the home country. Almost no attempt has been made to use equity-market data to assess simultaneously the impact of policy changes on the welfare of trading partners. Nor has this equity market literature attempted to evaluate the impact of trade negotiations. This paper attempts to work in both these neglected areas by assessing the impact on the value of selected equities in the United States and Japan of: (1) the enactment of the so-called "Super 301" legislation; (2) the inclusion of a significantly strengthened Dispute Settlement Mechanism in the final Uruguay Round Agreement; and (3) the Japan-U.S. Automobile Agreement of June 1995. In addition, the domestic political impact of operating in the post-Uruguay Round international economic environment is examined by evaluating the results of the Japan-U.S. Automobile Agreement using evidence from the Iowa Presidential Stock Market.
416. Stern, Robert M., "Constituent Interest Group Influences
on U.S. Trade Policies Since the Advent of the WTO" December 4, 1997. ABS
PDF
This paper assesses the major developments in U.S. trade policies since the creation of the WTO in 1995.
It is based in large measure on the fourth biannual (1996) WTO Trade Policy Review of the United States
and updated through 1997. The discussion and assessments include in particular: the major U.S. multilat-eral
trade-policy issues and activities centered in the WTO: issues and activities relating to NAFTA; U.S.
bilateral trade relations with its major trading partners; administration of U.S. trade laws and regulations;
and U.S. agricultural trade policies.
415. Deardorff, Alan V. and Richard Hall, "Explaining the Role
of Interest Groups in United States Trade Policy" November 11, 1997. ABS
PDF
This paper provides an alternative analytical view of the mechanism by which interest groups influence trade policy. In contrast to other economic models in which trade policy is essentially "bought" by industrial interests, this model views interest groups and legislators as possibly sharing the same objectives, which they then work together to pursue. The legislators have a limited budget of their own and their staff members' time to work on many issues, and the interest groups influence the process by helping with the work. By selecting legislators who are in closest agreement with their own objectives and then by assisting them in a way that, in effect, subsidizes their efforts, interest groups achieve a role in policy making that is potentially more important than if they merely used financial transfers. In the context of international trade policy, we view this model as applying not only to industries seeking protection, but also to many other interest groups who view restrictions of imports or other trade intervention as useful for their purposes. The latter need not have abundant financial resources in order to be effective, since their assistance can consist primarily of their members and volunteers' time, as well as the expertise that they have accumulated from experience in dealing with an issue.
414. Dominguez, Kathryn, "The Dollar Exposure of Japanese Companies"
Revised October, 1998. Journal of the Japanese and International Economies
12, 1998, pp. 388-405. ABS PDF
The bulk of Japanese exports and imports are denominated in dollars rather than
Japan's local currency, the yen.The consequences of dollar invoicing depend
importantly on whether Japanese companies hedge their dollar exposures. If
Japanese companies are able fully to hedge their dollar exposures either by
using derivative products, locating production in the United States or matching
dollar revenues with dollar costs then the choice of invoicing currency will
not influence the yen profits of Japanese companies. This paper estimates the
degree to which Japanese companies are exposed to movements in the dollar using
Japanese stock market data and an international version of the CAPM model to
estimate the extent to which Japanese company returns are correlated with
changes in the yen-dollar exchange rate. Presumably, if Japanese companies
fully hedge their dollar exposures, then their stock price changes should not
be correlated with movements in the dollar. Alternatively, if Japanese
companies cannot or choose not to hedge fully their dollar exposures, then
yen-dollar exchange rates will be correlated with stock prices.
413. Chadha, Rajesh, Sanjib Pohit, Alan V. Deardorff, and Robert
M. Stern, "Analysis of India's Policy Reforms" October 29, 1997. The World
Economy, March 1998. ABS PDF
The process of major economic reforms undertaken in the Indian economy has now completed six years
of implementation. The unilateral reform measures in the industrial and trade policies of India along with reforms
in the tax regime represent a significant departure from the policy framework of the preceding decades. Our paper
evaluates the comparative static effects of selected trade and domestic policy reforms on trade, output, domestic
prices, economic welfare, and the intersectoral allocation of resources using a computable general equilibrium
(CGE) model of the Indian economy.
The results indicate that the import liberalization enhances the welfare of the economy, and that the effect
gets further enlarged if exports are also liberalized simultaneously. This is particularly true of the agricultural
sectors. The freeing of prices in the sectors which were under some form of administered price controls in the
base year (1989-90) adds noticeably to the welfare effect. The economy becomes more efficient through
reallocation of land, labor and capital across different producing sectors with increases in the returns to each of
the factors of production. The rationalization of the existing structure of indirect taxes (mainly excise) and
subsidies is expected to further benefit the factors of production and enhance overall welfare. Though such ex-ante
analysis may not be replicated ex-post due to various macroeconomic and other factors that our model does
not capture, the positive results nevertheless go a long way in establishing the credibility of the reforms process.
412. Dominguez, Kathryn, "The Market Microstructure of Central
Bank Intervention" July, 1997. ABS PDF
One of the great unknowns in international finance is the process by which new
information influences exchange rate behavior. Until recently, data constraints
have limited our ability to examine this issue. The Olsen and Associates
high-frequency spot market data greatly expand the range of testable hypotheses
regarding the influence of information. This paper focuses on one important
source of information to the foreign exchange markets, the intervention
operations of the G-3 central banks. Previous studies using daily and weekly
foreign exchange rate data suggest that central bank intervention operations
can influence both the level and variance of exchange rates, but little is
known about how exactly traders learn about these operations and whether
intra-daily market conditions influence their effectiveness. Using
high-frequency data, this paper will examine the relationship between the
efficacy of intervention operations and the "state of the market" at the moment
that the operation is made public to traders.
411. Morck, Randall and Bernard Yeung, "Why Investors Sometimes
Value Size and Diversification: The Internalization Theory of Synergy" September
5, 1997. ABS PDF
For most firms, size and diversification are correlated with lower value. However, for firms
possessing substantial information-based asset, geographical diversification, line of business
diversification, and growth in general, add value. This is consistent with information-based
assets being a critical prerequisite for synergy, as postulated in internalization theories of
synergy.
410. Morck, Randall, Bernard Yeung, and Wayne Yu, "The Information
Content of Stock Markets: Why Do Emerging Markets Have So Little Firm-Specific
Risk?" August 8, 1997. Forthcoming as "The Information Content of Stock Markets:
Why Do Emerging Markets Have Synchronous Stock Price Movements?" Journal of
Financial Economics, 1999. ABS PDF
Stock prices in emerging economies move in step much more than in advanced economies.
Emerging markets’ prices capitalize less firm specific information, and appear subject to more
economy-wide fluctuations. Measures of this consonance of stock returns are positively correlated
with indicators of poor property rights protection, inefficient legal systems and corrupt government.
Lax accounting standards strengthen these correlations, but do not have an independent effect. We
argue that property rights, judicial efficiency, clean government and meaningful accounting
information let stock markets process information and allocate capital better, and thus contribute
to economic growth. The absence of these factors may discourage informed trading and foster noise
trading.
409. Deardorff, Alan V., "Factor Prices and the Factor Content
of Trade Revisited: What's the Use?" August 8, 1997. Journal of International
Economics 50, February 2000, pp. 73-90. ABS PDF
This paper examines the usefulness of a result of Deardorff and Staiger (1988), who showed that the factor content of trade can be interpreted under certain assumptions as indicating the nature of the factor price adjustments that can, in a specified sense, be attributed to that trade. This paper elaborates on the sense in which this result says anything about the factor market effects of trade. It also examines several of the assumptions that were used by Deardorff and Staiger to determine whether they can be relaxed. These include the assumption, used for only one of Deardorff and Staiger's several results, of Cobb-Douglas technology, which is shown to be easily extended to Constant Elasticity of Substitution. Also examined is the assumption of nonspecialization, or that all imported goods are produced or producable in the domestic economy. With Cobb-Douglas technology that assumption is shown not to be needed. With more general technology, however, the presence of non-competing imports requires a reinterpretation of the factor content of trade. Whereas without noncompeting imports, trade itself is analogous, in terms of its effects on factor markets, to a change in factor endowments equal to the factor content of trade, with noncompeting imports trade has an additional effect analogous to a Hicks-neutral technological improvement enabling those noncompeting imports to be produced competitively.
408. Dominguez, Kathryn, "Monetary Interdependence and Coordination"
October, 1996. ABS PDF
This paper examines the interdependence and coordination of monetary and
exchange rate policies among the G-3 countries over the period 1977 through
1993. The results in the paper suggest that the international monetary
transmission mechanism is important, and that, among the G-3, US policies are
the most influential. Further, it suggests that the G-3 generally honor
international monetary policy commitments, although in the case of Germany the
commitments seem to have coincided with domestic policy objectives.
407. Morck, Randall and Jungsywan Sepanski and Bernard Yeung,
"Habitual and Occasional Lobbyers in the US Steel Industry" February 21, 1997.
Published as "Habitual and Non-Habitual Lobbyists in the US Steel Industry: An
EM Algorithm Approach," Economic Inquiry, 1999. ABS
PDF
Using firm level data from the U.S. steel industry, we find that lobbying for import protection is habit forming, as suggested in
the rent-seeking literature. Controlling for firm performance and other factors, past lobbying increases the likelihood of
current lobbying in our full sample. Because addicted firms should behave differently from other firms, we let an EM
algorithm to sort our firms into groups with differing propensity to lobby. A two pools model consisting of occasional and
habitual rent-seekers emerges. Occasional rent-seekers' lobbying depends on their market performance.
Habitual rent-seekers' lobbying is unrelated to the market performance of the firm, and only depends on previous lobbying.
The evidence is consistent with political rent seeking having dynamic economies of scale: rent-seeking makes further
rent-seeking easier and more lucrative.
406. Debaere, Peter and Ufuk Demiroglu, "International Saving,
Investment, and Trade" March 24, 1997. ABS PDF
Feldstein and Horioka (1980) observed that saving and investment move
closely together in the major
OECD countries. This finding is a puzzle if national economies are
characterized by one sector production
functions of the form F(K,L). In that case, in a high saving country,
the high rate of investment and
capital accumulation would result in a decline of the marginal product
of capital, leading to an incentive for
exporting capital. In this paper, we show that this incentive disappears
in a multi-sector world. National
capital can be absorbed domestically without a decline in its marginal
product through a shift in the sectoral
composition of national production towards capital intensive sectors.
This is nothing but the well-known
Rybczynski effect. We present a modified version of the standard
Heckscher-Ohlin (HO) Model to show
that very small barriers to capital mobility are enough to force
national savings to stay within the country of
origin. We also argue that, while the assumptions of this model may
appear special, they are not
unrealistic for the developed countries in the Feldstein Horioka study.
405. Deardorff, Alan V., "International Externalities in the
Use of Domestic Policies to Redistribute Income" July 19, 1997. In Mordechai E.
Kreinin, Michael G. Plummer, and Shigeyuki Abe, eds., Asia-Pacific Economic
Linkages, Amsterdam: Pergamon, 1999. ABS PDF
Policies to redistribute income between high- and low-income groups are
well known to distort factor supply decisions and thereby to generate
deadweight losses incidental to income redistribution. This paper
examines the effects that these same distortions may also have on factor
supplies themselves, and thus on the implied patterns of production and
international trade. The point is not just that redistribution policies
may matter for trade, however, but that, through their effects on world
market prices and associated factor prices, the distributional effects
of redistribution policies spill over into the markets of a country's
trading partners. Using a standard two-factor, two-good Heckscher-Ohlin
Model with endogenous factor supplies of skilled and unskilled labor,
the paper derives the effects of a redistributive tax on factor
supplies, production, trade, world goods markets, factor markets, and
income distributions at home and abroad. One result is that a
redistributive tax by a large country is to some extent undermined in
its effects on its own income distribution by changes in world prices,
and also that such a policy tends to worsen the income distribution
abroad at the same time that it improves it at home. Another result is
that a redistributive tax will affect a country's terms of trade in ways
that will sometimes reinforce, other times offset, the incentive to
redistribute income. Both results have implications for the need for,
and desirability of, international coordination of policies for domestic
income redistribution. In particular, it is argued that high income
countries will tend to go too far in redistributing income, while low
income countries will not go far enough. Both could be better off if
they coordinated on changes in their distribution policies.
404. Demiroglu, Ufuk and Kwan Koo Yun, "The Lens Condition for
Factor Price Equalization" June 15, 1997. Journal of International Economics
47, 1999, pp. 449-456. ABS PDF
Deardorff (1994) provides a condition that is necessary for factor price
equalization across countries. That condition is a generalization of
"country endowments contained in the diversification cone" from the
standard 2x2x2 Hecksher-Ohlin model to the case of many goods, countries and
factors. He also shows that this condition is sufficient in the case of two
countries, and conjectures that sufficiency might hold in general. In this
paper we establish sufficiency in some further cases. However, we show by a
counterexample that the sufficiency does not hold in general.
403. Davis, Donald R. and David E. Weinstein, "Does Economic
Geography Matter for International Specialization" June, 1997. ABS
PDF
There are two principal theories of why countries trade: comparative
advantage and increasing returns to scale. Yet there is no empirical work
that assesses the relative importance of these two theories in accounting
for production structure and trade. We use a framework that nests an
increasing returns model of economic geography featuring "home market"
effects with that of Heckscher-Ohlin. We employ these trade models to
account for the structure of OECD manufacturing production. The data
militate against the economic geography framework. Relatively few sectors
match its theoretical predictions. Moreover, of the explainable variation
in production patterns, endowments account for 90 per cent, economic
geography but 5 per cent.
402. Deardorff, Alan V., "Rich and Poor Countries in Neoclassical
Trade and Growth" June 29, 1997. Economic Journal 111, April 2001, pp.
277-294. ABS PDF
A neoclassical growth model is used to provide an explanation for a
"poverty trap," or "club convergence," in terms of specialization and
international trade. The model has a large number of countries with
access to identical constant-returns-to-scale technologies for producing
and trading three goods using capital and labor. If initial factor
endowments of these countries are sufficiently diverse, then initial
equilibrium will not involve worldwide factor price equalization.
Instead, there will be two cones of diversification, and countries within
the lower of these cones will share identical factor prices and produce
relatively labor-intensive goods, while countries in the upper cone will
produce capital-intensive goods. If savings is determined only by wages,
then it is quite possible, perhaps even likely, that there will be
multiple steady states. Therefore over time, the poorer group of
countries will converge to a low steady-state capital-labor ratio and
hence remain poor, while the initially rich countries will converge to a
high steady-state and remain rich. This occurs even though all countries
share identical technological and behavioral parameters, and it is
therefore an example of club convergence. The model is also suggestive
of how patterns of growth may respond to changes in these parameters for
particular countries, including an increase in the savings rate and the
use of tariffs.
401. Kilian, Lutz, "Exchange Rates and Monetary Fundamentals: What
Do We Learn From Long-Horizon Regressions?" May 28, 1997. Journal of Applied
Econometrics 14, September 1999, 491-510. ABS PDF
Long-horizon regression tests are widely used in empirical finance,
despite evidence of severe size distortions. I propose a new bootstrap
method for small-sample inference in long-horizon regressions. A Monte
Carlo study shows that this bootstrap test greatly reduces the size
distortions of conventional long-horizon regression tests. I also find
that long-horizon regression tests do not have power advantages against
economically plausible alternatives. The apparent lack of higher power
at long horizons suggests that previous findings of increasing
long-horizon predictability are more likely due to size distortions than
to power gains. I illustrate the use of the bootstrap method by
analyzing whether monetary fundamentals help predict changes in four
major exchange rates. In contrast to earlier studies, I find only weak
evidence of exchange rate predictability and no evidence of increasing
long-horizon predictability. Many of the differences in results can be
traced to the implementation of the test.
400. Deardorff, Alan V. and Robert M. Stern, "An Overview of
the Modeling of the Choices and Consequences of U.S. Trade Policy," May 28, 1997.
In Deardorff and Stern, eds., Constituent Interests and U.S. Trade Policies,
Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press, 1998, pp. 29-55. ABS
PDF
Our paper is designed to provide the context for the theme of the
conference, "The Representation of Constituent Interests in the Design
and Implementation of U.S. Trade Policies." We begin by reviewing the
normative and political economy approaches to the modeling of trade
policies. We identify the major limitations of these approaches and then
discuss what Dixit (1996) has referred to as the "transaction-cost
approach," which may provide a middle ground between the other
approaches and enable us to address some hitherto imperfectly understood
issues of trade policy. We also include a brief discussion of the
empirical literature pertinent to the normative and political economy
approaches. We then turn to a sketch of the main features of the U.S.
trade-policy process, focusing in particular on the roles played by the
agencies of government together with the important constituent interest
groups in the U.S. economy. We consider how these can be interpreted in
the light of the modeling approaches, and we also ask what can be
learned from the past half-century of U.S. trade policy experiences.
399. Deardorff, Alan V. and Robert M. Stern, "Table of Contents"
and "Introduction" to Representation of Constituent Interests in the Design
and Implementation of U.S. Trade Policies: The Sweetland Conference, May 28,
1997. In Deardorff and Stern, eds., Constituent Interests and U.S. Trade Policies,
Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press, 1998, pp. 9-27. ABS
PDF
This chapter introduces the proceedings of a conferences held on
November 8-9, 1996, in Ann Arbor, MI, honoring John Sweetland and his
late wife, Gayle, for the generous gift commitments that they have made
to the Michigan Department of Economics. The academic purpose of the
conference was to examine how constituent interests in the private
sector, non-profit sector, and government interact to determine United
States international trade policy. The conference brought together
authors and discussants from academic institutions, the private sector,
and the Ways and Means Committee of the U.S. House of Representatives.
In setting forth the aims of the conference, those involved were asked
in particular to address: (1) the objectives of trade policy sought by
the various interest groups who were the subject of their paper or
comments; (2) how each group1s interests are identified and promoted and
what means are used for these purposes; (3) the extent to which the
objectives and behavior of each group conform to how the political
economy of trade policy is treated in the economics and political
science literatures; and (4) how effective each group has been in
achieving its objectives.
398. Brown, Drusilla K., Alan V. Deardorff, and Robert M. Stern,
"Issues of Environmental and Labor Standards in the Global Trading System," May
19, 1997. In Stanley W. Black (ed.), Globalization, Technological Change, and
Labor Markets, Kluwer Academic Press, 1998, pp. 235-276. ABS PDF
There have been increasing calls in recent years in the United States
and other major industrialized countries for actions designed to
harmonize domestic policies, institutions, and practices especially with
regard to trade-related environmental and labor standards. As pointed
out by Anderson (1996) and Bhagwativx!flhqf| lq ixuwkhu fdvhv1 Krzhyhu/ zh vkrz e| d f (1996), these calls for action have
been motivated by a host of moral, economic, structural, and political
factors. The purpose of our paper is to investigate the analytics,
empirical evidence, institutional arrangements, and available policy
options for address-ing the issues involved. The paper deals first with
the definition and scope of environmental and labor standards and then
with the rationales that have been put forward calling for their.
Theo-retical aspects of the economic effects of environmental and labor
standards are considered, and a summary of the available empirical
evidence is provided Finally, the monitoring and enforcement of
environmental and labor standards are discussed, followed by conclusions
and implications for policy.
397. Chakrabarti, AvikKhfnvfkhu0Rkolq prgho wr wkh fdvh ri pdq|
jrrgv/ frxqwu, "The Distribution of Foreign Direct Investment and the Excluded
Economies," April 14 , 1997. ABS PDF
The paper takes as its objective context the growing disparity in the
distribution of Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) among the developing
nations. While FDI in the developing world has grown fairly rapidly
since the late 1980s, a disaggregated analysis demonstrates a
considerable imbalance at the macro level. While China stands out as the
largest recipient, the Sub-Saharan African (SSA) countries and the
countries of Middle East and North Africa (MNA) are experiencing a
continuous drying up of inbound FDI. The goal of this paper is to first
develop a theoretical model of the economic determinants of FDI and
then use the structutral model to identify empirically the causes of and
suggest potential remedies for, the disparity in the distribution of
inward FDI among the developing economies.
396. Stern, Robert M., "Conflict and Cooperation in International
Economic Policy and Law," April 17, 1996. Journal of International Economic
Law 17, 1996. ABS PDF
This paper explores a number of conceptual issues that are germane to
the analysis of conflict and cooperation in international economic
policy and law. The focus is on issues involving conflict and
cooperation that have been treated in the theory of international trade,
in particular departures from the free trade optimum that is the centerpiece
of the theory of comparative advantage and the gains from trade.
Also considered are situations stemming from departures from full
employment and external balance that figure importantly in international
macroeconomic theory. Some concluding remarks are also made
with regard to the use of the Michigan Model of World Production and
Trade in providing quantitative analysis of potentially conflictual and
cooperative international economic actions and policies. While the
paper is written from an international economic perspective, it
hopefully will be informative to international legal analysts and policy
makers as well.
395. Deardorff, Alan V. and Robert M. Stern, "Measurement of
Nontariff Barriers," Excerpt: Table of Contents and Chapter I, March 17, 1997.
Published: Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press, 1998. ABS
PDF Complete text available from OECD
as Working Paper No. 179
In this study, done for the OECD, we assess currently available
methods for
quantifying nontariff barriers (NTBs) and make recommendations as to those
methods that
can be most effectively employed. We focus both on the conceptual
issues arising in the measurement of the different types of NTBs and on
the applied research that has been carried out in studies prepared by
country members of the OECD Pilot Group and others seeking to quantify
NTBs.
The paper begins with a a typology of NTBs and their
salient economic characteristics, then considers conceptual aspects
and selected applications of both general and specific purpose methods for
measuring the presence and size of NTBs. We provide an overview and
assessment of the methods and numerical results of the measurement of
NTBs drawn mainly from the OECD Pilot Group studies, and we highlight the
major lessons to be drawn from these studies. Finally, we conclude by
presenting our own guidelines for measuring NTBs, followed by detailed
recommendations of procedures to be used in individual cases and under
specific assumptions. Algebraic formulas pertinent to the recommended
procedures for measuring particular NTBs under varying assumptions are
presented and motivated in an appendix.
394. Brown, Drusilla K., Alan V. Deardorff, and Robert M. Stern,
"Trade and Labor Standards," March 14, 1997. Open Economies Review, 1998.
ABS PDF
There is a wide disparity of views on issues of international labor
standards. The purpose of this paper is to explore these different
views and the available options for addressing the issues involved. We
conclude that there is no convincing case for incorporating labor
standards into the WTO and into U.S. trade agreements. The surest way
to improve labor standards is instead for the United States and other
industrialized countries to maintain open markets and to encourage the
growth of their developing country trading partners. Steps should also
be taken to support the activities of the International Labour
Organization to provide inducements and technical assistance to
help developing countries raise their labor standards.
393. Berry, Steve, James Levinsohn, and Ariel Pakes, "Voluntary
Export Restraints on Automobiles: Evaluating a Strategic Trade Policy," March
19, 1997. American Economic Review 89, June 1999, pp. 400-430. ABS PDF
In May, 1981, a voluntary export restraint (VER) was placed on exports
of automobiles from Japan
to the United States. As trade policies go, this one was important. The
automobile industry is the
largest manufacturing industry in the United States and the initiation
of the VER captured head-
lines in the popular press. At about the same time, though to much less
fanfare, international trade
theorists were obtaining (then) startling results from models of
international trade in imperfectly
competitive markets. These models suggested that in imperfectly
competitive markets, an activist
trade policy might enhance national welfare. In this paper, we provide
some empirical evidence on
whether the these new theoretical possibilities might actually apply to
the policy of VERs.
392. Levinsohn, James, "Productivity in the U.S. Auto Industry:
Evidence from Multiple Perspectives," January 28, 1997. ABS
PDF
Discussion and measurement of productivity in the U.S. auto industry are
made difficult by a variety of issues: heterogeneous outputs, big fixed
costs, heterogeneous inputs, multi-product plants, and exchange rates.
One of the goals of this paper is to highlight some of these
difficulties. Another goal is to investigate whether the application of
recent econometric methods can inform the productivity discussion. There
have been recent advances in estimating the demand and cost of
differentiated products using product-level data. Can these methods be
used to further our understanding of productivity in a differentiated
product industry? And do these methods give rise to a view of
productivity that is consistent with or at odds with the related
(non-econometric) literature on productivity in the auto industry? This
paper outlines an econometric framework for investigating productivity
using product-level data and present the results of applying this
approach to data on cars sold in the U.S. from 1971 to 1994. The paper
concludes with a summary of what one can and cannot learn from the
various approaches to measuring productivity in the auto industry.
391. Naito, Hisahiro, "Tariffs and Production Subsidies as Devices
to Relax the Incentive Problem of a Progressive Income Tax System," November 13,
1996. ABS PDF
This paper shows that tariffs and production subsidies can
Pareto-improve welfare in a small open economy when a government is
concerned with income redistribution under asymmetric information.
In international trade theory, free trade is optimal if the government
can use lump-sum taxes and transfers. However, in reality the government
cannot use lump-sum taxes and transfers due to asymmetric information
between the government and individuals. In this case, the government is
restricted to use a non-linear income tax system for income
redistribution due to the incentive compatibility problem. This paper
shows that in such a situation, even if the government is using a
Pareto-efficient non-linear income tax system under free trade, tariffs
and production subsidies can Pareto-improve welfare. That is, tariffs
can complement a Pareto-optimal progressive income tax system under
asymmetric information.
390. Levinsohn, James, "Firm Heterogeneity, Jobs, and International
Trade: Evidence from Chile," October 29, 1996. Published as "Employment Responses
to International Liberalization in Chile," Journal of International Economics
47, April 1999, pp. 321-344. ABS PDF
This paper is about jobs and international trade. It is about what
researchers can learn of the relationship between the two using
firm-level data. It is about the particular experience of Chile
following a broad trade liberalization and spanning significant
macroeconomic contraction and expansion. Finally, this paper is about
discerning patterns in the data that might later influence how
internatinal economists model the interaction between international
trade and employment.
389. Levinsohn, James, "CARWARS: Trying to Make Sense of U.S.-Japan
Trade Frictions in the Automobile and Automobile Parts Markets," March 25, 1996.
In Robert Feenstra, ed., The Effects of U.S. Trade Protection and Trade Promotion
Policies, University of Chicago Press, pp. 11-32, 1997. ABS
PDF
This paper tries to make sense of the recent trade dispute between the
U.S. and Japan in autos and auto parts. The paper argues that there are
structural differences between the way that the auto industries are
organized in the U.S. and Japan, and that these differences have
contributed to the growing bilateral trade deficit in auto parts. The
paper also provides econometric estimates of what would have happened
had the threatened 100 percent tariff on Japanese luxury cars not been
withdrawn by the U.S.
388. Deardorff, Alan V., "An Economist's Overview of the World
Trade Organization," November 4, 1996. In Korea Economic Institute, The Emerging
WTO System and Perspectives from East Asia, Joint U.S.-Korea Academic Studies
Vol 7, 1997. ABS PDF
The paper provides a brief overview of the new World Trade Organization,
successor to the GATT as the arbiter of cooperation in matters of
international trade policy. The approach taken is to look only at its
main features, asking how they contribute to the end of permitting
countries to cooperate in the use of policies that they often have
strong incentives to use against each other. Noting that many of the
problems of trade policy can be understood in a framework loosely based
on the prisoners' dilemma in game theory, the paper examines four
aspects of the WTO in terms of their contribution to resolving such
prisoner's dilemma problems. These are: first, the various ways that
the WTO fosters communication among countries about what they are in
fact doing with their trade policies; second, the many requirements that
the WTO imposes on country policies in defining cooperative behavior;
third, a number of exceptions to these rules that permit, but do not
require, countries to deviate from some of these requirements; and
fourth, the new dispute settlement mechanism that provides the incentive
for countries to conform with all of the rules. In the end, the WTO is
viewed as a remarkably well-conceived solution to the complex problems
of international cooperation in international trade.
387. Stern, Robert M., "Issues of Trade and International Labor
Standards in the WTO System," September 11, 1996. In Korea Economic Institute,
The Emerging WTO System and Perspectives from East Asia, Joint U.S.-Korea
Academic Studies Vol 7, 1997. ABS PDF
The purpose of this paper is
to explore the different views and the available options for
addressing the issues of labor standards in international trade,
and in particular the view that labor standards ought to be placed high
on the agenda of the World Trade Organization (WTO). The paper begins
with the definition and scope of labor standards, followed by
a summary of theoretical aspects of the economic effects of labor
standards and the available empirical evidence. The monitoring
and enforcement of labor standards are also discussed, concluding with
implications for policy.
386. Stern, Robert M., "The GATT's Trade Policy Review of Japan,
1994," April 29, 1996. In "Global Trade Policy 1996," The World Economy,
1996. ABS PDF
This paper is a summary of the 1994 Trade Policy Review of Japan done by
the GATT. This was the third review of Japan's trade policies conducted
as part of the Trade Policy Review Mechanism (TPRM) that was initiated in
1989. The previous reviews covered 1990 and 1992. Under the TPRM, Japan,
the United States, the European Communities, and Canada are to be
reviewed every two years, with other countries to be reviewed every four
to six years or longer. The paper first addresses some of the main
features of Japan's recent domestic and external economic performance.
It then focuses on Japan's trade policies and practices, which constitute
the bulk of Vol. I of the TPRM review. Finally, it summarizes the
current sources of concern about Japan's trade policies.
385. Brown, Drusilla, Alan V. Deardorff, and Robert M. Stern,
"Some Economic Effects of the Free Trade Agreement Between Tunisia and the European
Union," July 22, 1996. In Ahmed Galal and Bernard Hoekman (eds.), Regional
Partners in Global Markets: Limits and Possibilities of the Euro-Med Agreements,
London/Cairo: Center for Economic Policy Research and Egyptian Center for Economic
Studies, 1997. ABS PDF
We use a specially constructed version of the Michigan
Brown-Deardorff-Stern (BDSvkrzv wkdw wklv frqglwlrq lv vx!flhqw lq wkh fdvh ri wzr) Computational General Equilibrium (CGE)
Model of World Production and Trade to estimate the potential economic
effects on the Tunisian economy that may result from the free trade
agreement (FTA) between Tunisia and the European Union (EU) that was
concluded in July 1995. We find that the static welfare benefits for
Tunisia of the FTA range from slightly negative to somewhat positive,
depending on what is assumed about intersectoral capital mobility in
Tunisia. Further, depending on the length of time allowed for the
phasing in of the FTA, Tunisia could experience significant adjustment
problems in connection with the intersectoral movements of labor and
capital that the FTA would induce. Finally, while our computational
scenarios are subject to the difficulties of integrating foreign direct
investment (FDI) into a CGE trade modeling framework, we find that the
FDI inflows into Tunisia that might result from the FTA would not
materially increase Tunisian economic welfare. Our results suggest
therefore that Tunisia may not have much to gain economically from the
FTA. Reducing its trade barriers multilaterally and reinforcing these
actions with further liberalization of its foreign investment policies
and maintenance of macroeconomic and political stability might in the
end be the best path for Tunisia to follow.
384. De Arcangelis, Giuseppe, "Monetary Policy and Exchange-Rate
Regimes in Europe: A Structural Approach," Nov. 22, 1995. ABS
PDF
This paper proposes an empirical framework to analyze monetary
policies in a small open economy under fixed exchange rates. First, the
analysis proposes a semi-restricted VAR model with the lowest number of
restrictions to focus on the effects of the center-country and the
Rest-of-the-World monetary policies. Next, we use a fully structural
VAR approach where the identifying restrictions are imposed on the
short-run behavior of the variables.
The model is applied to the EMS experience of France, Italy and the
Netherlands by considring Germany as the center country and
the US as the Rest of the World. The
presence of
imperfect capital mobility allows us to attribute partial monetary
independence to the domestic monetary authorities. Innovations in the
German monetary policy are found to be highly important for the Dutch
monetary policy, but much less for France and especially for
Italy. Instead, the US
shock plays a particularly relevant role for the French monetary
policymaking. There is also evidence of stronger recessionary impact of
restrictive German monetary policies on France and Italy rather than
the Netherlands. This may explain why the former two countries
devalued so many times.
383. Deardorff, Alan V., "International Externalities in the
Use of Pollution Policies," Nov. 11, 1995. International Review of Law and
Economics 16, March 1996, pp. 53-59. ABS PDF
The paper examines a simple partial equilibrium model of a
polluting industry in a world economy. Optimal pollution taxes are
derived and compared for the countries individually and collectively.
Objective functions of governments are permitted to give different
weights to producers than to other interests, in recognition of
distributional, political economy, or other objectives. It is shown that
if 1) pollution does not spill across national borders, and if 2)
countries are too small to affect world prices with their pollution
policies, then the pollution taxes that countries set independently
cannot be improved upon by international cooperation. If these
conditions are not satisfied, however, then independently set pollution
policies will not be optimal. If pollution spills across borders, this
will cause countries to set pollution taxes too low. In contrast, if
countries are large enough to affect world prices, then exporting
countries will set pollution taxes too high and importing countries will
set them too low. However, if the two conditions are satisfied, then
pursuit by governments of political-economy or other distributional
objectives does not interfere with their achieving policies that cannot
be improved upon -- in terms of these objectives -- by international
cooperation.
382. Deardorff, Alan V., "Determinants of Bilateral Trade: Does
Gravity Work in a Neoclassical World?" Nov. 7, 1995. In Jeffrey A. Frankel, ed.,
The Regionalization of the World Economy, NBER, Chicago: University of
Chicago Press, 1998, pp. 7-28. ABS PDF
This paper derives equations for the value of bilateral trade from two
extreme cases of the Heckscher-Ohlin Model, both of which could also
represent a variety of other models as well. The first case is
frictionless trade, in which the absence of all impediments to trade in
homogeneous products causes producers and consumers to be indifferent
among trading partners. Resolving this indifference randomly, expected
trade flows correspond exactly to the simple frictionless gravity
equation if preferences are identical and homothetic or if demands are
uncorrelated with supplies, and they depart from that equation
systematically when there are such correlations. The second case is of
countries that each produce distinct goods, as in the H-O Model with
complete specialization or a variety of other models. Expressions are
derived for bilateral trade, first with Cobb-Douglas preferences and then
with CES preferences. The standard gravity equation with trade declining
in distance continues to be a central tendency for these trade flows,
with departures from it that are easily understood in terms of relative
transport costs. The main lessons from the paper are two. First, it is
not all that difficult to justify even simple forms of the gravity
equation from standard trade theories. Second, because the gravity
equation appears to characterize a large class of models, its use for
empirical tests of any of them is suspect.
381. Brown, Drusilla, Alan V. Deardorff, and Robert M. Stern,
"The Economic Effects of an East Asian Trading Bloc," Jul. 7, 1995. In G. Boyd
and A. Rugman (eds.), Euro-Pacific Investment and Trade: Strategies and Structural
Interdependencies. London: Edward Elgar Publishing, Ltd., 1997. ABS
This paper uses a specially constructed version of the University of
Michigan Brown-Deardorff-Stern Computational General Equilibrium Trade
Model to estimate the potential economic effects of an East Asian
Preferential Trading Bloc including Japan, South Korea, Taiwan, and
Singapore. Effects are computed on trade, output, and employment by
sector as
well as the real returns to capital and labor and the economic welfare of
members of an East Asian bloc, the United States, and the rest-of-world
major trading countries/regions.
380. Brown, D. K., A. V. Deardorff, S. D. Djankov, and R. M.
Stern, "An Economic Assessment of the Integration of Czechoslovakia, Hungary,
and Poland into the European Union," Oct. 3, 1995; forthcoming in Stanley Black,
ed., Europe's Economy Looks East. In Stanley Black, ed., Europe's Economy
Looks East: Implications for Germany and the European Union, Cambridge University
Press, 1997. ABS PDF
This paper is a study of the economic effects of the integration of the
Central European Countries (CECs) into the European Union (EU). Our
analysis of EU-CEC integration is based on a specially constructed
version of the University of Michigan Computational General Equilibrium
(CGE) Trade Model. We use this model to calculate the economic effects
of EU-CEC integration on the trade, output, and employment by sector as
well as the real returns to capital and labor and the economic welfare of
the CECs, the EU members, and the other major trading country aggregates
included in the model.
379. Brown, D. K., A. V. Deardorff, A. K. Fox, and R. M. Stern,
"Computational Analysis of Goods and Services Liberalization in the Uruguay Round,"
August 23, 1995. Published as "The Liberalization of Services Trade: Potential
Impacts in the Aftermath of the Uruguay Round," in W. Martin and L. A. Winters,
eds., The Uruguay Round and the Developing Countries, The World Bank, New
York: Cambridge University Press, 1996. ABS PDF
In this paper, we use a specially constructed version of the Michigan
Brown-Deardorff-Stern (BDSvkrzv wkdw wklv frqglwlrq lv vx!flhqw lq wkh fdvh ri wzr) Computational General Equilibrium (CGE) Model
of World Production and Trade to estimate the potential economic effects
of the reductions in tariffs on industrial products that were negotiated
in the Uruguay Round of Multilateral Trade Negotiations as well as the
effects that might be realized from services-sector liberalization in the
post-Uruguay Round period. The model provides measures for individual
countries/regions of the effects of liberalization on the trade, output,
and employment for the goods and for the services sectors. We also
calculate the effects on economic welfare and on real returns to labor
and capital for the individual countries/regions.
378. Brown, Drusilla, Alan V. Deardorff, and Robert M. Stern,
"Modelling Multilateral Trade Liberalization in Services," Jul. 6, 1995. Asia-Pacific
Economic Review, April, 1996. ABS PDF
We examine the importance of various characteristics of services for the
modelling of the effects of trade liberalization in services. We
consider first the characteristics that our own computable general
equilibrium (CGE) modelling framework has been designed to address:
variety, scale, and competition. Modifying it somewhat so as to
distinguish the separate roles of these characteristics, we find the
characteristics to be relatively unimportant for the conclusions that one
reaches about the effects of trade liberalization on the economy. We
then consider other characteristics that may distinguish services from
goods, and ask whether these also need to be taken into account in such
modelling exercises. With one exception we conclude that these
characteristics are unlikely to play an important role in future models
of trade liberalization. The one exception is a characteristic
identified by Ethier and Horn (1991), who saw producers of services as
specializing their products to the particular needs of their customers.
While it does not seem feasible at this time to incorporate this feature
into a manageable CGE framework, we believe that it could have
interesting and important implications for our understanding of the
effects of trade liberalization if it were ever done.
377. Pahre, Robert, "Integration and the European Union: A Public
Goods Analysis," May 30, 1995. Published as "Wider and Deeper: The Links between
Expansion and Enlargement in the European Communities," Chapter 6 in Towards
a New Europe: Stops and Starts in Regional Integration, edited by Gerald Schneider,
Patricia A. Weitsman, and Thomas Bernauer, pp. 111-136 (Praeger/Greenwood, 1995).
ABS
Contemporary research on the European Union examines how actors of
varying preferences negotiate bargains or participate in decision-making
through existing institutions. All such studies take actors'
preferences over EU policies as given and outside the analysis. This
paper seeks to explain some of the crossnational and intertemporal
variation in these preferences by capturing part of the structural
background for EU Politics. The hypotheses of the model depend on three
variables: the aggregate resources of all EU members, the resources of
each EU member, and the number of members. Bringing them together in a
single theory is surprisingly fruitful for being able to understand
variation in integration and preferences over integration. This
structural background is analytically prior to decision making theories
or accounts of intra-elite bargaining, and helps explain some features of
negotiation over cost-sharing.