|
|
Child Poverty, The Labor Market and the Welfare
State The living standards and social well being of children
throughout the industrialized world improved remarkably between the
end of World War II and the mid 1970s. However, child welfare is now
at a turning-point, most clearly in Eastern Europe, but also in the
West. While economic and social progress continues in many domains
in many countries, deteriorations in social safety nets have emerged.
Uncertainties about the future of the welfare state that has helped
protect children and families from the vicissitudes of the economy
in the past 50 years raise concerns that the beginning of the twenty-first
century may represent an era of retrogression and inequality. Economic and Political Changes In the advanced Western economies , the ramifications
of these events are still working themselves through the international
economic and political systems. The collapse of communism has already
contributed to political system changes (as in Italy), recessionary
trade shocks (as in countries such as Finland that were heavily dependent
on trade with the socialist bloc), frictional unemployment increases
associated with reductions in military expenditures (as in California,
resulting from reductions in defense contracting and military personnel),
and large fiscal effects entailing increased taxes and declining real
wages (as in Germany, where huge subsidies were required to integrate
the former East German economy and to support large numbers of migrants
and refugees from beyond the former 'iron curtain'). The fall of communism has also undermined public support
for governments in general and social policies in particular. Critics
of the 'social welfare state' have equated it ideologically with the
'failed socialist state' and have challenged the credibility of policies
which rely on the state, rather than the market, to promote social
needs. We do not defend the status quo in welfare states.
Indeed, we believe that the welfare state in some countries should
become more market-oriented. None the less, the sharp decline in living
standards and the rapid increase in poverty in the East following
the demise of communism demonstrates that market mechanisms cannot,
on their own, alleviate poverty. The Welfare State and Child Poverty Given the broad variations across the industrialized
countries of the East and West in economic conditions, the nature
of the welfare state, societal norms, and ideological orientations,
there are no universal lessons that can be applied in all countries
to reduce child poverty. What is feasible in Sweden may be ideologically
impracticable in the USA and economically impossible in Russia. Therefore,
we suggest several key policy agendas for industrialized countries: Labor market policies. Much of the recent
increase in child poverty is due to technological changes that have
reduced the demand for less-skilled relative to more-skilled workers
and to the increased globalization of the market economies. These
changes caused rising unemployment in many high-wage European countries,
especially those with less-flexible labor market institutions (e.g.,
France and Germany) and increased work at low wages in economies with
less labor protection and more wage flexibility (such as the USA).
As a result, most children in low-income families have parents who
can not be expected to earn enough to keep their families out of poverty.
Thus, active labor market policies are needed to augment the skills
of the long-term unemployed, to encourage employment in the private
sector, and to create jobs of last resort when structural unemployment
is high. Some countries might increase the minimum wage, whereas others
need more flexibility in their labor market institutions Strengthening social safety nets. Remarkable
progress has been accomplished in most industrialized countries over
the last fifty years in the areas of old-age pensions and unemployment
compensation. In contrast, implementation of child and family policies
has been less complete. In many countries this has contributed to
dramatic declines in the birth rate, with the number of people under
20 years of age falling below that of the elderly. Life-cycle events
like divorce, birth or illness of a child are typically associated
with a high risk of falling into poverty. Benefits promoting child
well-being, such as paid maternity leave, child allowance, ensured
child support, and free health care are either non-existent, means-tested,
or insufficient in amount. Thus, many countries need to formulate or preserve
a comprehensive social welfare policy for children and families. The
necessary resources can be obtained by reordering public spending
priorities, and in countries where recent tax changes have been regressive
and income inequality has increased, through higher taxation of the
rich. In several of the formerly centrally-planned economies, this
requires the establishment or redesign of the entire system of taxation. Child support policies. In an era of increased divorce and out-of-wedlock child-bearing, there is also great need for increased private transfers from absent parents (usually fathers) to the custodial parent because, in most countries, single-mother families are among the poorest groups.
The Future of Child Poverty
*Giovanni Andrea Cornia is Director of the United
Nations University's World Institute for Development Economic Research
in Helsinki. Sheldon Danziger is Henry J. Meyer Collegiate Professor
of Social Work and Public Policy at the University of Michigan. This
point of view is based on the editors' introduction to Child Poverty
and Deprivation in the Industrialized Countries, 1945 - 1995,
which they coedited (Oxford University Press, 1997).
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
ABOUT THE FORD SCHOOL - ACADEMICS - CAREERS - ADMISSION - PEOPLE - RESEARCH - ALUMNI - SEARCH Contact information |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||