INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY AND INFORMATION LAW

(FORMERLY:  IDEAS AND EXPRESSION IN THE INFORMATION AGE: LAW AND POLICY)

Schools of Information and Public Policy

Winter Term 2001; Tuesdays from 4-7 PM

Instructor: Jonathan Alger, Assistant General Counsel, University of Michigan

Contact Information: 764-0304 (office phone) jonalg@umich.edu

Office Hours: By appointment (Fleming Admin. Bldg., Room 5026)

Course Description

This course will explore related and sometimes competing legal and policy frameworks for the development and dissemination of ideas and expression in the Information Age. The ways in which principles of free speech and expression compare and contrast with intellectual property rights will be explored as related to the advancement of knowledge and innovation, with particular focus on the impact of the Internet and new technology. The impact of other legal considerations and values on the development and dissemination of ideas and information (such as security, privacy, local control v. national and international considerations, competition, and the protection of minors) will also be examined. The course will draw upon the contexts of education, business, and government, with a special focus on the changing nature, roles and responsibilities of educational institutions in light of the so-called "information revolution."

Goals and Objectives

                Students will learn how to think about and apply foundational legal and policy principles (e.g., the underlying premises of the First Amendment and copyright law) in new contexts, and will explore whether and to what extent new media and technology require reconsideration of the assumptions and values underlying these principles.

Course Format, Reading and Assignments

                The course will be taught using a variety of methods including lecture, discussion, and group projects. Guest presenters will be invited to the course to speak on special topics. Assigned readings will include case decisions and briefs, actual and proposed legislation, institutional policies on issues such as intellectual property rights and free expression, contracts, legal and policy articles, other forms of commentary, and hypothetical scenarios. Students will be asked to write several short papers, including analytical and advocacy pieces, and to make group presentations to the class. Grades will be based on these written and oral assignments.

About the Instructor

Jonathan Alger is Assistant General Counsel at the University of Michigan, with primary responsibilities in the areas of intellectual property, media rights, and cyberspace law. He is currently a member of the President’s Information Revolution Commission on campus, and also recently served on the Security Architecture Task Force. Mr. Alger previously served as the chief counsel in the national office of the American Association of University Professors in Washington, DC, as an attorney-advisor in the headquarters of the U.S. Department of Education’s Office for Civil Rights, and as an associate in the Labor and Employment Law Section at the law firm of Morgan, Lewis & Bockius. He has given presentations on higher education law and policy at many conferences and campuses throughout the United States, as well as in Canada and Germany. He has also published a number of articles on various aspects of higher education law, and serves on the Author’s Committee for West’s Education Law Reporter. Mr. Alger is a member of the bars of Michigan and the District of Columbia, and a graduate of Swarthmore College and Harvard Law School.

 

 

IDEAS AND EXPRESSION IN THE INFORMATION AGE:

LAW AND POLICY

COURSE SCHEDULE

(Updated as of Nov. 14, 2000)

The Protection of "Ideas" and "Expression" --

Free Speech and Intellectual Property Principles (4 weeks)

 

An overview of foundational laws and policies that determine how ideas and expression are developed and disseminated in our society

Week 1 (Jan. 9)

  1. Introduction and overview of the course; review of course requirements
  1. Applicability of legal principles to the Internet and new technology
  2. Origins and purposes of the First Amendment; underlying assumptions of freedom of expression

Week 2 (Jan. 16)

Readings: First Amendment; excerpts from American Association of University Professors’ 1940 Statement of Principles on Academic Freedom and Tenure; Joint Statement on Rights and Freedoms of Students; and Academic Freedom and Electronic Communications; excerpts from Communications Decency Act and Reno v. ACLU; excerpts from Junger v. Daley and Bernstein v. U.S. Department of Justice (encryption cases)

Group Presentations (two groups): Discuss and debate Junger and Bernstein – Is encryption a form of protected expression?

-               Discuss the concept and purposes of academic freedom

  1. What constitutes speech in cyberspace? Should the rules in cyberspace differ from other media?

-               Note early defense of use of encryption as expression by Founding Fathers such as Franklin and Madison; discuss software, source code, etc.—should they be viewed as functional or expressive?

Week 3 (Jan. 23)

Readings: Statute of Anne; Constitution (provision relating to copyright); excerpts from Baker v. Selden, 101 U.S. 99 (1879) (discussing difference between abstract ideas and tangible expression, and holding that ideas cannot be copyrighted) and Morrissey v. Procter & Gamble Co., 379 U.S. F.2d 675 (1st Cir. 1967); portions of Intellectual Property and the National Information Infrastructure, Report of the Working Group on Intellectual Property Rights, Information Infrastructure Task Force (Bruce A. Lehman, Chair) (Sep. 1995); compare with First Amendment cases such as U.S. v. O’Brien, 391 U.S. 367 (1968) and Tinker v. Des Moines School District, 393 U.S. 503 (1969), discussing the various forms expression can take, including abstract concepts.

  1. Origins and purpose of copyright law

-               The bundle of rights involved in copyright (ownership, use, copying, distribution, creation of derivative works, etc.)

  1. What is the difference between ideas and tangible expression? Do these terms still have distinct meaning in the digital age?

Week 4 (Jan. 30)

Readings: Copyright Act provisions on fair use; Harper & Row Publishers, Inc. v. Nation Enterprises, 471 U.S. 539 (1985) (re news magazine’s report on President Ford’s memoirs); "Guidelines for Classroom Copying in Not-for-Profit Educational Institutions" (in 1976 House Report accompanying the 1976 Copyright Act); Sega Enterprises v. Accolade, Inc., 977 F.2d 675 (1st Cir. 1967) (fair use defense applied in reverse engineering of video games to identify elements for compatibility).

Group Presentations: Discussion of hypothetical examples on fair use (with students taking on various roles as creators, users, and distributors of copyrightable works)

  1. How do the purposes of copyright law and free expression relate to each other? Does the concept of intellectual "property" make sense in a democratic society?

-               The relationship of fair use doctrine to the First Amendment

Ownership and Control of Information and Ideas (2 weeks)

How does the concept of property rights apply to the creation of ideas and expression?

Week 5 (Feb. 6)

Readings: Sample university policies on ownership and control of intellectual property (e.g., Michigan, Columbia, Stanford); Robert Gorman article, "Intellectual Property: The Rights of Faculty as Creators and Users" (Academe, May/June 1998) on ownership of scholarly work; Copyright Act Section 101 (on "works for hire"); "Principles for Emerging Systems of Scholarly Publishing" (May 10, 2000).

Group Presentations: Committee discussion of intellectual property policy (comparing and contrasting policies from the University of Michigan and other institutions)

  1. Is it possible to "own" ideas or expression? Examine marketplace ideals as applied to ideas and expression; discuss individual v. institutional interests.
  2. Discuss ideas in the employment context and other relationships (e.g., independent contractors and consultants) – discuss "work for hire" doctrine, agency theory, contracts for publishing, licensing contracts for software

Week 6 (Feb. 13)

Readings: Urofsky (addressing Virginia statute regulating use of state-owned or leased computers and its impact on state employees); NIH guidelines on acceptance of corporate funds for research; briefs in New York Times Company v. Jonathan Tasini (involving electronic posting of freelance writers’ works without their permission)

Group Presentations: Negotiation of publishing/multimedia agreement (two groups)

  1. Continuation of discussion of ownership of ideas and expression
  2. Ownership and control of research in the Information Age

-               Discuss confidentiality agreements and other restrictions on publishing and access to data; pressure to work on projects with commercial potential

Ideas and Expression as Public Goods (2 weeks)

What are the rights of the general public regarding access to and use of ideas and expression?

Week 7 (Feb. 20)

Readings: Kenneth D. Crews, "Fair Use and Higher Education," Academe (Nov./Dec. 1997); Digital Millennium Copyright Act anti-circumvention provision; excerpts from Motion Picture Association of America v. Corley (challenging DMCA provision); Library of Congress: "Exemption of Prohibition on Circumvention of Copyright Protection Systems for Access Control Technologies," 37 C.F.R. Part 201 ()ct. 28, 2000).

Group Presentations: Debate the DMCA’s anti-circumvention provision from a policy perspective.

  1. How does the concept of "fair use" apply to the Internet?

-               Discuss the special roles of universities, libraries, and museums (as contrasted with corporations, e.g.) – discuss new developments such as the University’s own Digital Library and similar efforts elsewhere; impact on archiving and other information practices.

  1. Discuss the concept of the public domain (including government documents, idea of open-source movement)

Week 8 (Mar. 6)

Readings: Recording Industry Association of America v. Napster, Metallica letter to the University of Michigan and the University’s response; background on Gnutella and the new generation of technology allowing for person-to-person transfer of information; excerpts from Whelan Associates v. Jaslow Dental Laboratory, Inc., 797 F.2d 1222 (3d Cir. 1986), cert. denied, 479 U.S. 1031 (1987) and Computer Associates International, Inc. v. Altai, Inc., 982 F.2d 693 (2d Cir. 1992) (discussing how copyright law applies to functions and purposes of computer programs).

Group Presentations: Find and discuss some legal uses of Napster; explain Gnutella, Freenet, and other similar technologies

  1. The role of online service providers (universities, corporations, and others) – should they be regulating expression, access to web sites, etc. on the basis of content or possible illegal uses? Is there a relevant public/private distinction here?
  2. What is the difference between regulating conduct and content? How does the law distinguish function and structure from purpose and ideas?
  3. Review recent litigation and controversies involving fair use and music and other forms of expression—what are the implications of new technology (e.g., allowing for person-to-person file sharing) for regulation?

Restrictions on Access to Information:

Privacy, Security, and Protection of Minors (2 weeks)

When and why is it appropriate to regulate access to information because of other considerations? How should principles of privacy, security, and protection of minors be taken into account in regulating online communications?

Week 9 (Mar. 13)

Readings: Recent actions brought by Michigan Attorney General and others v. Double-Click and other services that collect information about consumers over the Internet using cookies and other means; excerpts from Fred H. Cate, Privacy in the Information Age (1997); Alexander C. Gavis, "Access: An Orphan in the Privacy Debate" (Electronic Banking Law and Commerce Report, Jul./Aug. 2000); portions of Freedom of Information Act; articles on firings by Dow Chemical Co. and others based on review of e-mails.

Group Presentations: Debate hypothetical scenarios re anonymous e-mail (e.g., rating faculty performance); regulation of cookies from a policy perspective

  1. Privacy – Discuss how this concept applies in cyberspace; expectations at home and at work and how technology blurs these distinctions; impact of "sunshine" statutes such as FOIA on e-mail and other electronic communications.

Week 10 (Mar. 20)

Readings: Excerpts from University Security Architecture Task Force Report and background articles.

Group Presentations: To be determined

  1. Security – Discuss the rights and responsibilities of individuals, network providers, etc.
  2. Protection of Minors – include discussion of the special role of libraries

               

Authenticating Information in Cyberspace (Quality Control)

and New Forms of Education/Information Dissemination (3 weeks)

How can the quality and reliability of information be assessed in the digital environment? How will changes in technology affect the ways we teach, learn, and interact?

Week 11 (Mar. 27)

Readings: Ticketmaster Corp. v. Tickets.com (on legality and regulation of hyperlinks); more to be determined

Group Presentations: As a result of Internet research, groups will demonstrate some hyperlinks they found to the class that could cause confusion because of uses of other entities’ names, marks, etc.

  1. Hyperlinking and other forms of directing traffic on the Internet (e.g., metatags)

 

 

 

Week 12 (Apr. 3)

Readings: Excerpts from reports of the American Council on Education, Association of American Universities, and American Association of University Professors on online education (including discussions of copyright in this context; read and compare with, for example, AAUP’s 1969 Statement on Instructional Television); portions from new accreditation guidelines (from CHEA and other accrediting organizations); review web sites of Fathom.com and other web-based educational ventures

Group Presentations: Discussion of the advantages and disadvantages of online education

  1. Online education and the virtual university

-               How can one assure quality in distance education programs? What are the business models for the branding of content (e.g., of Fathom, UNext, Universitas 21, the University of Phoenix, and others)? What is the impact of relationships between commercial entities and traditional education providers?

-               What are the implications for society from the use of such technology in education (e.g., concept of lifelong learning; concern with the digital divide on the basis of socioeconomic status, race, gender, etc.; questions on the importance of face-to-face interaction for the expression of ideas)?

Week 13 (Apr. 10)

Readings: "A. Miller’s Tale: Free-Agent Faculty" (Academe, May/June 2000); "Classroom Capitalism" (Academe, Jan./Feb. 2000); report on commercial note-taking at the University of Michigan; excerpts from M. Deflem of Purdue.

Group Presentations: Discussion of Arthur Miller example between students in roles of professor and dean

  1. Continued discussion of online education
  2. Students and faculty as entrepreneurs of ideas (e.g., student note-taking services over the Internet)

Concluding Thoughts and Themes (1 week)

Week 14 (Apr. 17)

Readings: Jonathan Zittrain, "Balancing Control and Anarchy on the Internet" (Chronicle of Higher Education, Oct. 13, 2000); "It’s a Small World, After All" (Academe, Jul./Aug. 1999); excerpts from "Intellectual Property Needs and Expectations of Traditional Knowledge Holders" (World Intellectual Property Organization 2000).

Group Presentations: Review of book by Lawrence Lessig, Code and Other Laws of Cyberspace

  1. How to regulate cyberspace in light of rapidly evolving technology—who should do it? (federal government, international law, private contracts)
  2. Contrast the speed of technological changes with the processes of legislation, litigation, regulation, and policy development (examine laws that are technology-dependent v. more general and adaptable principles)
  3. Trying to predict the future—how can law and policy shape the flow of ideas (e.g., by providing incentives or disincentives to creators)?

_______________________________

Other Materials to be disseminated (on Coursetools site):

Web sites of interest

Listing of additional readings, including optional book and web site reviews