About SPP
Academics
Careers
Admission
University of Michigan School of Public Policy People
Research
Alumni
Search

Academics
Faculty profiles
MPP program
Combined degree programs

MPA program
PhD program
Ford School courses
U of M Courses of Interest
Academic calendar
Coursetools
PPIA Program
Important links
   

Contact:
Gerald R. Ford
School of Public Policy
440 Lorch Hall,
University of Michigan,
Ann Arbor, MI
48109-1220

734-764-3490 voice
734-763-9181 fax
fordschoolinfo@umich.edu

 

 

Gerald R. Ford School of Public Policy

University of Michigan

Integrated Policy Exercise 2001:  Guestworkers in North America

Thursday, January 4 - Monday, January 8

 


Home   Background   Groups   Schedule   Contacts   Assignments  Resources


 

Scenario

 

 

President Vicente Fox, the newly-elected president of Mexico, has proposed that the United States provide 250,000 visas a year to Mexican nationals as guestworkers.  Unlike the H1B guestworker program for technical workers, this program does NOT envision a provision allowing Mexican guestworkers to become permanent residents of the United States.  Fox sees this plan as the first step towards an eventual customs union, including the free movement of people, among Canada, the U.S., and Mexico.  

 

Neither Canada nor the U.S. is very enthusiastic.  Canada currently has a limited guestworker program for agricultural workers from Mexico and the Caribbean; it’s happy with the program and sees no reason to expand it. Canada, unlike the U.S., also has a very targeted immigration policy that favors skilled labor and investors.  Any movement towards the free movement of labor in North America would upset its immigration policies, and also cause it to lose skilled workers to the U.S.  Canada does not attract a large number of illegal immigrants from Mexico. 

 

By contrast, the U.S. attracts up to 150,000 illegal immigrants from Mexico annually.  While a guestworker program would be one way to legalize this population, it could also depress U.S. wages and increase cultural conflict.  Mexican immigrants currently work in many agricultural and food processing companies, and these companies are strong advocates of a guestworker program.  Advocacy groups that work with Mexican immigrants, however, are not.  They fear that guestworkers would be exploited, and they insist that all new immigrants enter the U.S. with the right to become permanent residents and then citizens.  They also want legalization of all immigrants currently in the U.S.

 

But the federal governments of the Canada and the U.S. are caught in a political bind.  Both countries want to encourage Mexican democracy and show their support for Fox.  Thus they need to avoid publicly rejecting his overtures for greater coordination between the three countries.  At the same time, both governments are in a politically sensitive period.  The new U.S. president won in a contested and unprecedentedly close election, in which Hispanic voters were very important.  The U.S. Congress is almost evenly divided between the two parties. The returning Canadian premier, Jean Chretien, has more political room to maneuver, given his landslide victory in November 2000.  But immigration is not currently a hot topic in Canada and he doesn’t have much incentive to make it so. 

 

The three governments decide to appoint a trilateral blue-ribbon commission to consider a coordinated North American policy on guestworkers.  They ask the commission to assess support for guestworker programs among different sectors of society.  They also ask the commission to examine the operation of the current (small) agricultural guestworker programs in the U.S. and Canada, to see if these could be used as models for more extensive legislation.

 

As a first step, the commission invites important sectors of civil society – business groups, unions, advocacy groups, and border states/provinces -- to testify about their support or opposition to guestworker programs and to evaluate current programs as a model for future legislation.  They also invite these groups to propose other blueprints for future legislation. They strongly encourage these groups to coordinate across the countries – that is, they would like to see proposals from business that take into account business interests in all three countries, proposals from non-governmental organizations that represent the views of these groups across all three countries, and the like.  

 

The commission has scheduled open hearings in multiple locations.  At each location, five sector coalitions have been asked to testify.  One sector represents the views of business groups:  the American Farm Bureau, represented by the Michigan Farm Bureau; the Canadian American Border Trade Alliance; the Ontario Vegetable and Fruit Growers Association; and the Guanajuato World Trade Commission.  A second sector represents the views of labor:  the United Farm Workers, the United Food and Commercial Workers of Canada, and the Frente Autentico del Trabajo (FAT).  A third sector represents advocacy groups opposed to increased U.S. immigration:  the Center on Immigration Studies and the Federation for American Immigration Reform (FAIR).  A fourth sector represents advocacy groups that work with immigrants:  the Farmworker Justice Fund/National Council of La Raza, and Sin Fronteras.  Finally, a fifth sector represents the interests of states/provinces with a large population of immigrants and/or migrant workers:  Arizona, Ontario, and British Columbia. 

 


Home   Background   Groups   Schedule   Contacts   Assignments  Resources


 

top of page