|
Gerald
R. Ford School of Public Policy University of Michigan Integrated Policy Exercise 2001: Guestworkers in North America Thursday, January 4 - Monday, January 8
Home Background Groups Schedule Contacts Assignments Resources
Assignment Guide
During this year's IPE, you will have the chance to develop policy proposals on behalf of a sector: business, labor, farmworker advocates, immigration restrictionists, and state/provincial governments. The evaluation of your proposal will be based on the extent to which it advances:
1. The concerns of your sector's constituency 2. The particular interests of organizations in your sector 3. An economic justification and/or a defense of its economic implications 4. Possibilities for cooperation with some or all of the other sectors 5. Answers to anticipated opposition from the other sectors.
Your sector may choose to offer a comprehensive guestworker policy, guidelines about particular aspects of guestworker policy, or a detailed proposal for one aspect of the guestworker issue. Which you choose is dependent upon your interests. Some of the policy topics that you may choose to consider are:
Should guestworkers from Mexico be admitted to the U.S. and Canada? What principles should be used to determine the right number? (You will probably be unable to offer an actual number, but you might wish to consider whether the number should be determined by economic conditions, by the number of migrants who currently enter the U.S. or Canada illegally, by an evaluation of the need for labor on the part of specific employers or business sectors, etc.)
How should guestworkers be compensated? (Is the appropriate wage rate the minimum wage in the receiving country? The minimum wage in Mexico? The prevailing wage? Whatever the market will bear? How about housing, medical insurance, retirement benefits? Should guestworkers be paid immediately, or should part of their wages be held and paid to them in Mexico?)
Should guestworkers be allowed to establish permanent residency in the receiving country? To become citizens? (Should guestworkers be treated differently from immigrants in general? Should guestworkers who want to emigrate be subject to current immigration quotas or meet immigration standards? Should they be allowed to bring their immediate families with them? How about the children of guestworkers, if they're born in the receiving country?)
How would guestworkers affect the native population? (How might the policy affect the cost of goods and services? Economic growth? Would the impact be greater for some parts of the population than others? How about non-economic consequences: what kinds of social changes, if any, would a large guestworker program cause in Mexico? In Canada or the U.S.? What kinds of tradeoffs does your policy create?)
What kind of impact would your proposal have on current immigration policies? (Is a guestworker program a good way to limit current legal or illegal immigration to the U.S.? To Canada? Does it raise issues of favoritism or inequitable treatment?)
Should guestworker policies in Canada and/or the U.S. be limited to Mexicans? (What about immigrants from the Caribbean or Central America? How about Asia or Africa? If you decide that such programs should be limited to Mexicans, how would the limitation be enforced?)
To make the IPE easier, the materials we have provided and the groups we have designated focus primarily on agricultural guestworkers. You may limit your focus to agricultural guestworkers as well. However, if you feel that it is important to consider other categories of workers specifically, that is fine too.
III. ASSIGNMENTS
This year's IPE is structured around several short assignments. Each assignment is meant to help you prepare for the next day's task, with the final goal of creating an effective and powerful argument for the policy proposals you will present at the commission hearings. Directions for the first assignment, the Personal Statement, are in a separate document in your casebook. This assignment guide specifies the form of each of the rest of the assignments and offers guidance on their content.
One per group, due Friday, 1/5, at 2pm via email attachment to IPEfaculty@umich.edu
Length: One (single-spaced) page Format: Label with your organization and simulation letter ("La Raza, Simulation "A")
Use the personal statements that the members of your organization wrote over the break as a way to start discussion of the following questions. It might be helpful for you to identify the status quo that your organization faces, before you begin to talk about possible changes.
What are our organization's goals? How do we prioritize them? What aspects of guestworker policy will best address these? What are our minimum requirements? What are some interests that we are likely to share with our sector partners? What are some potential conflicts? What are some interests that we are likely to share with other organizations from our country? What are some potential conflicts?
The memo may be written using bullet points, text, or a mixture of both, depending on what you think is appropriate. Remember that this memo is also a reference for your group as you go into the "Country" and "Sector" negotiating sessions on Friday afternoon. A representative from your group will be making an informal, 5-min. presentation of your organization's position. Try to lay out your statement in a format that helps you prepare for these presentations.
2. Country Negotiation Report:
One per country, due Friday, 1/5, at 4:15 pm; hand to Prof. Lin, Sharon Price, or Nicole Green Length: 1-2 pages, handwritten (typed is fine but not expected) Format: Label with your country and simulation letter ("Mexico, Simulation A") and include the names of everyone present and their organization.
This is primarily an information-exchange session, since each of the groups in this meeting will be testifying as a member of a different sector. But it's a good forum in which to think about the domestic policy concerns that you might share. Whether or not the groups in your country share interests, you can pick up information about potential allies: you might come away with ideas about how you can shape your presentation so as to suggest commonalties between your sector and others. You can also pick up information about opponents that could help you argue against them. This is the only chance you'll have (before the final hearing) to learn about your opponents' concerns.
You may address other questions as well or choose to emphasize some more than others. Please be sure, however, to address all of the following questions in your report.
What interests do we share? If none, do subsets of the groups from our country share interests? What kinds of conflicts do we have? How might these conflicts be resolved through domestic politics or policy initiatives? What advantages (money, reputation, conflict displacement, knowledge, international support) could North American discussion/policy bring to our national interests/conflicts? What difficulties could North American discussion/policy create for our national interests/conflicts? What new options are created by North American discussion/policy? What options are foreclosed in this multilateral framework?
This statement is handwritten (please make sure we can read your handwriting!) and can be informal. Be careful, though, to avoid abbreviations and fill in shorthand phrases that might not be obvious to people who weren't in the room.
3. Sector Memorandum of Understanding (MOU)
One per sector, due Friday, 1/5, at 4:15 pm; hand to Prof. Lin, Sharon Price, or Nicole Green Length: 1-2 pages, handwritten (typed is fine but not expected) Format: Label with your sector and simulation letter ("Farmworker Advocates, Simulation A") and include the names of everyone present and their organization.
This session is the first of three negotiation sessions you will have with the other organizations in your sector. It is meant to help you discover points of agreement and disagreement, and thus to help direct your future negotiations. Use the questions below to structure your discussions and to organize the MOU.
What interests do we share? What options can we brainstorm for meeting those interests? What kinds of conflicts do we have? What advantages are there to resolving each conflict? What costs are there to leaving each conflict unresolved? What new options are created by North American discussion/policy? What options are foreclosed in this multilateral framework? Based on the answers to these questions, what is our agenda for Saturday? Will we divide into working groups to consider these questions, or negotiate in one large group? Remember that there will be many more people in the room during the negotiation sessions on Friday. Thus, while it's not required, we strongly urge you to consider forming working groups. If you do decide to negotiate in one large group, consider establishing some rules of the game for moderating and organizing the discussion.
4. Policy Proposal and Appendix on Economic Implications
One per sector, due Saturday, 1/6, at 6 pm via email to IPEfaculty@umich.edu Length: Policy Proposal -- 2 pages, typed Appendix on Economic Implications: 1 page, typed Format: Label with your sector and simulation letter ("Farmworker Advocates, Simulation A")
The policy proposal is a 2-page document explaining your sector's main objectives with respect to guestworker policy, and presenting proposals which address those objectives. Remember that unlike the other assignments, this is a public document. It will be seen by all the other groups and by the judging panel as well.
The appendix on economic implications is a 1-page discussion of the economic reasoning behind your proposals. You can promote and justify the economic benefits of your proposals and/or defend and justify their costs; alternatively, you might choose to show how the economics of guestworker programs (or of something else you care about) favor your proposal.
You do not need to make a full argument for your position. That will come in the formal speech, the preparation for rebuttal, and the press releases. Thus the policy proposal simply outlines your position as clearly and succinctly as possible.
5. Testimony, Rebuttal, and Press Releases
Testimony: 5 minute formal speech (Three speakers, one per hearing)
Rebuttal: Handled by the speaker and at least one other representative from the sector. There is no formal presentation, but anyone on the rebuttal team may answer the questions posed by the judges.
Press releases: Four one-page press releases, each responding to one of the other sector proposals. Email these to IPEfaculty@umich.edu by 12 noon on Monday, 1/8.
Each sector will be responsible for sending representatives to testify and answer questions at three hearings. It is also responsible for writing press releases that address each of the other sector's policy proposals. Thus, on Sunday, the sector should assign people to fulfill each of the following tasks:
At least 3 people (one per hearing) will write the formal speech to the commission. The speech is the only opportunity you will have to present an uninterrupted argument for your position; there is no other written testimony. Thus the speech needs to frame the argument for the judges, present the proposals and the reasoning behind each, and address any major objections that the other groups might make.
At least 3 people (at least one per hearing) will prepare rebuttal answers. They will take the lead in responding to questions that the judges pose during the hearing, immediately following the sector's presentation (5 minutes) and also during the Q and A period after all the presentations (30 minutes). During the question period, anyone on the rebuttal team, including but not limited to the presenter, has the right to speak.
At least 2 people (but as many as necessary) will write press releases commenting on the other sector proposals. Each of the other sector proposals must be met with a separate response from the sector. That response, of course, can be favorable or critical. These press releases can be issued at any time, up to 12:00 pm (noon) on Monday, 1/8.
Home Background Groups Schedule Contacts Assignments Resources |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
ABOUT THE FORD SCHOOL - ACADEMICS - CAREERS - ADMISSION - PEOPLE - RESEARCH - ALUMNI - SEARCH Contact information |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||