About SPP
Academics
Careers
Admission
University of Michigan School of Public Policy People
Research
Alumni
Search

Academics
Faculty profiles
MPP program
Combined degree programs

MPA program
PhD program
Ford School courses
U of M Courses of Interest
Academic calendar
Coursetools
PPIA Program
Important links
   

Contact:
Gerald R. Ford
School of Public Policy
440 Lorch Hall,
University of Michigan,
Ann Arbor, MI
48109-1220

734-764-3490 voice
734-763-9181 fax
fordschoolinfo@umich.edu

 

 

SPP 638: The 1999 Integrated Policy Exercise

The Apparel Industry Partnership

 

Introductory Speech

Poor Kathie Lee Gifford. Here she was, minding her own business, and all of a sudden she gets attacked in front of a Congressional committee for using children in Honduran factories to produce her wildly popular clothing line for Wal-Mart. The date is April 1996. By August of 1996, the White House had pulled together a high-powered task force, including representatives from businesses like Liz Claiborne, unions like UNITE, and non-profit groups like the International Labor Rights Fund, to, quote, take steps to protect workers worldwide and to give the public the information it needs to make informed purchasing decisions. This task force, known as the Apparel Industry Partnership (AIP), pulled together a document in April 1997, with a model code of conduct and principles of monitoring to make sure that code was enforced. They then set to work on creating an association to oversee the monitoring of companies, with the expectation that companies who joined the monitoring process could then state that they had done so in their publicity and on their products. But at this point, negotiations broke down. When the draft monitoring agreement was announced in November 1998, UNITE and one of the major NGO participants had left the Partnership. In the meantime, the major industry trade group, the American Apparel Manufacturer's Association, had created an alternative to the AIP, known as the Responsible Apparel Production Principles, or RAPP. And that's where we pick up the story.

A couple of things to note about this story. First, while the picture I've given you is the official picture, and it's accurate, it's not complete. The White House didn't jump on this story only because of Kathie Lee and the ensuing publicity; Robert Reich, the Labor Secretary at the time, had made sweatshop labor an interest of his and was essentially talking about a task force like the AIP before Kathie Lee gave him a policy window to launch it. The groups who signed on weren't random; many had been targeted by protests against their labor practices in the past, or had instigated those protests. But note that there's no equation between protest and signing on: neither Wal-mart nor the group that initiated the protests against it, the National Labor Committee, joined the AIP. Finally, all this domestic activity took place against a growing international backdrop of activity: in particular, the International Labor Organization (ILO), a UN-sponsored group that brings together government, employer, and labor representatives from every country, was re-examining the issue of core labor standards. In May 1995, the ILO launched an effort to get its member countries to ratify a set of labor conventions including non-discrimination and equal treatment in the workplace, the freedom of association, and the elimination of child and forced labor. At the same time, advocacy groups began suggesting that the ILO's conventions, which are non-binding, be imported into the new World Trade Organization (WTO), where they would be binding. Dan Turnquist will tell you more about that in a minute.

With this backdrop, where are you? Well, you now represent 12 policy actors who are directly or tangentially affected by the AIP. It is January 1999, a parallel universe to ours, in which. Your assignment for the next two days is to figure out where your group stands on the AIP, and what strategy your group should use to get support. Then, after the negotiation workshop on Tuesday afternoon, we will fast forward to March 1999. You will get information on what's been happening between January and March, and using that information and the strategies you've planned, you'll form coalitions, which will testify at a Congressional hearing this Saturday.

 

IPE Schedule

Updated: Monday, January 4, 1999

Notes on the Schedule:

1. People who get into Ann Arbor late for weather-related reasons should check in with their groups as soon as possible. Contact information for the groups will be available at 466 Lorch and on e-mail as soon as it is available.

2. The schedule has been designed to give you maximum flexibility in terms of where and when you’ll meet with your groups. However, you should expect to put in a full day each day in terms of actual hours as you digest information, talk it over with your group, and prepare the written and oral assignments.

  1. All SPP classes are cancelled the week of the IPE. John Chamberlin will write a note to the professor in charge of any non-SPP classes, explaining your absence from the first day of class: if you would like him to do this, please give ANN LIN (annlin@umich.edu ) the name and course number of the class(es), the name of the professor, and the time/day it meets, by Monday evening.
  2. As long as you can get your group to agree, you can go to any classes and work any hours that you need to work. However, you must attend three mandatory events: the opening assembly on Monday, the negotiation workshop on Tuesday, and the Senate hearing on Saturday afternoon.
  3. If child care is an issue for you, we may be able to arrange some group childcare alternatives that week. Please let Ann Lin know as soon as possible if you would like to try to pull something together.

Monday, January 4:

1:30 – 3:30 pm: Opening Assembly (Askwith Auditorium, 140 Lorch)

Ann Lin will introduce the IPE scenario and structure.

Dan Turnquist will speak on the politics of international trade standards.

Students will receive group assignments and briefing materials

Monday afternoon and evening: Students will meet with their group to read about the AIP, discuss their group’s priorities, and draft a 2-3 page memo on their objectives with respect to the AIP.

 

IPE Schedule

Updated: Tuesday, January 5, 1999

 

Tuesday, January 5:

1:00 pm: Group priorities memo due in 466 Lorch (Ann Lin’s office).

1:30 – 5:00pm: Negotiation Workshop (Askwith Auditorium, 140 Lorch)

Steven Yaffee and Julia Wollondeck of the School of Natural Resources and Environment will lead a series of negotiation exercises.

5:00 pm -- News Update: Rapidly snowballing events in the parallel world of the IPE have caused Sen. Jesse Helms to call for hearings before the Senate Foreign Relations Committee on Saturday, January 9. Groups will be issued briefing books on the events that have prompted the Foreign Relations Committee to hold hearings. Groups will attempt to form coalitions, which will issue press releases on Thursday, January 7 at noon and testify before the Committee on Saturday, January 9 (March 9 in our parallel universe).

Tuesday evening: Groups prepare for negotiations

Wednesday, January 6:

Negotiation day: Groups will be asked to keep at least one representative in Lorch from 9 am – 4 pm. (Locations TBA). Groups will try to build coalitions to support, modify, or oppose the AIP. Coalitions will create a 1-2 page press release stating their positions, for publication Thursday.

9:30 am: Optional Q and A Session, 473 Lorch. Ann Lin will take questions on the contents of the new briefing book.

10 am - 12 pm: Office hours, Dan Turnquist, 453C Lorch

4:00 pm: If you want a dispensation from joining a coalition, you need to present your request in writing by 4pm. Also leave contact information for someone in your group so that I can get an answer back to you within an hour or so.

Thursday, January 7:

Negotiation day: Groups will be asked to keep at least one representative in Lorch from 9 am – 4 pm. (Locations TBA).

10 am - 12 pm: Office hours, Dan Turnquist, 453C Lorch

2:00 pm -- Coalition Press Releases due in 466 Lorch; please turn in $25 per person to cover the cost of handouts etc for the exercise at the same time. (Checks can be made out to School of Public Policy. If you pay in cash, please attach a card with your name to the cash.)

1:45-3:45 pm: Office hours, Robert Axelrod, 409 Lorch

 

Friday, January 8:

Negotiation and testimony preparation day

10 am - 12 pm: Office hours, Dan Turnquist, 453C Lorch

1:00-2:00 pm: Office hours, Bob Stern, 413 Lorch

2:00-4:00 pm: Office hours, Kathryn Dominguez, 462 Lorch

5:00 pm: Turn in IPE evaluations and peer awards ballots to 466 Lorch.

Saturday, January 9:

1:00 pm: Senate Foreign Relations Committee Hearing (Rackham 4th Fl. West Conference Room)

7:00 pm: Awards Dinner Hearing (Rackham 4th Fl. West Conference Room)

Dessert at dinner will be a potluck; please bring a favorite treat!

Invited Participants, Saturday Hearing:

Bama Athreya, International Labor Rights Fund

Tony Freeman, International Labor Organization, Washington Office

Alan Deardorff, School of Public Policy

 

SPP 638: The 1999 Integrated Policy Exercise

The Apparel Industry Partnership

 

Strategic Considerations

 

The April 1997 Apparel Industry Partnership (AIP) agreement on a model code of conduct was also a model of cooperation. While creating a diverse coalition of clothing manufacturers/retailers, unions, non-profit advocacy groups, and government representatives was not easy, the fact that all of those groups were able to work together gave the April agreement instant credibility. But this coalition succumbed to its internal pressures over the next year and a half. When the November 1998 agreement was announced, it no longer had union backing. The advocacy community had been split down the middle, with some groups staying in and others leaving. And in the meantime, the American Apparel Manufacturers’ Association (AAMA) had announced a challenge to the April AIP agreement. Its code of conduct, known as the "Responsible Apparel Production Principles" (RAPP), did not have the broad support that the April 1997 agreement commanded, but it did have support from its manufacturing base.

Yet the outlook for the AIP was not altogether bleak. The year and a half between the April 1997 and the November 1998 agreements saw increasing activity around the issue of international labor standards in government, in the media, and from numerous industry and advocacy groups. The AIP structure and the two agreements enjoyed a reservoir of good will, partly because of their early appearance, partly because of the unique partnerships behind it. So the defections from the November 1998 agreement did not doom it. What they did do, however, is simultaneously send all of the actors off searching for more support, while making them all more vulnerable to attacks.

The groups that committed to the November agreement – Reebok, the International Labor Rights Fund (IRLF), and the Department of Labor (DOL) – have each invested a good deal of organizational credibility in the success of the agreement. Despite their brave words, an agreement that goes ahead without the unions will be much more liable to attack. They need to try to bring UNITE back to the table, to get open and enthusiastic support from organizations with a good record on social issues, or both.

UNITE has the same problem, but in reverse. It has been able to convince the AFL-CIO and the Retail Workers Union to announce their support for their pull-out, and it has brought the ICCR along as well. But if it cannot convince anyone else with a credible position on social issues to join them, UNITE runs the risk of being marginalized. The mood in the country is not particularly friendly to unions; it is not clear that consumers would automatically discredit a label that did not have union support. This is particularly true since UNITE has been attacked, by both the left-leaning Village Voice and the right-wing commentator Robert Novak, for tolerating sweatshops run by its business allies, creating a top-heavy bureaucracy, and disregarding the interests of its workers. The AFL-CIO has close ties to the White House and will not be willing to countenance a campaign smearing the DOL, especially because that would open the door to the much more conservative RAPP. So if UNITE cannot bring more allies to its side, it may need to consider rejoining the AIP, especially if it can extract concessions to make its return worthwhile. At least some of these concessions need to be on the AIP. UNITE, however, might welcome help with Levi-Strauss, which has been under attack by unions for plant closing and restructuring. It might also welcome help with rebuilding its reputation more generally.

Wal-Mart also needs credibility, but its job is somewhat different. It has supported the RAPP, and defecting from it would damage its alliances with the AAMA. It could, of course, try to create a rapprochement between the RAPP and the AIP. But doing so would almost certainly force groups like the ILRF out – and keep other "progressive" groups from getting in. A more likely possibility is to create credibility by getting support from companies with a good record on social issues. An investment company like Calvert, which needs to temper its social choice activism with attention to the bottom line, or like Levi-Strauss, which has a good reputation despite its labor troubles, would be natural partners. Another possibility is to go for an entirely different set of allies: free trade groups like the USCIB and conservative politicians like Jesse Helms.

The triangular arrangement of these three positions puts a group like Save the Children in a unique position. Its lack of history with the AIP negotiations means that it can adopt any position without having to carry much baggage. Its generally positive reputation as an advocate for children makes its support valuable. It has good reasons to support any of the three major positions on the AIP: it has supported independent monitoring of the kind proposed by the AIP; like the unions, it has argued that income issues are central to any attempt to raise labor standards; and it likes to work closely with companies to establish programs – an approach that attracts companies, like Wal-Mart, which might like or need to sponsor successful pilot projects. Its new president, Annie Publicities-Fine, is eager to take a more active role in the labor standards debate in the U.S. At the same time, though, Save the Children’s lack of history on this issue also means that the value of its support is hard to predict; no one knows if its opinion will actually carry much weight. And it is not invulnerable to attack: its child labor projects in Pakistan and India have received positive press, but they have also progressed very slowly. Groups disappointed by Save the Children’s stance may try to incite a backlash.

Like Save the Children, the other "unannounced" actors face complicated choices. Most would prefer to stay on the fence as long as they could. But in the world of the IPE, they do not have that option. Representatives in the House are planning to make codes of conduct a major agenda item in the new Congress. On the Republican side, Rep. Peter Hoekstra’s (R-MI) Subcommittee on Oversight and Investigations of the House Committee on Education and the Workforce is planning to issue a report that at least tacitly favors the RAPP. On the Democratic side, the Minority Leader, Richard Gephardt (D-MO), is considering whether this is the vehicle to ride to name recognition in a race for the Democratic presidential nomination. Sens. Jesse Helms and Joseph Biden, as chair and ranking member of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, are beginning to realize that at the very least, they cannot be caught without a response to anything the House might send over. But both also see an opportunity to take a lead on an issue where there is currently a leadership vacuum.

Prospective Congressional action also raises problems for companies like Levi-Strauss and Calvert. Their reputation currently rests on what they have done and continue to do, not on support or opposition to the AIP. But once the AIP and its troubles get legislative and media attention, shareholders and customers will want to know where Levi-Strauss and Calvert stand on the AIP. They need to think now about what their response will be. They also need to find support: the more support they have, the more principled they will seem.

The USCIB is in a similar position. It has not been active in debates such as the one over the AIP in the domestic arena. But because it represents U.S. employers at the ILO, it must take some position on any high-profile action in the U.S. Its December position paper takes a hard line on codes of conduct: they reject efforts at standardization, at independent (non-company sponsored) monitoring, and at holding companies responsible for the actions of their subcontractors. Of course, if it can keep its position from being undercut by high-profile employers and industry groups or by federal legislation, it will have much more impact. And since it is joined at the ILO by representatives of the AFL-CIO, it has an interest in keeping open the possibility of compromise with the unions. Thus it is in a good position to act as a mediator between the various groups in the simulation, although of course it has more credibility with business and with free trade supporters in Congress.

The IRRC also has an interest in acting as a mediator. While it does not officially take sides or join coalitions in debates such as these, it has to decide what to include in its evaluation of the AIP for its customers. Although it tries to evaluate impartially, it knows that any analysis it produces will have political consequences, intended or not. The other groups in the simulation will lobby the IRRC to make its analysis more favorable to those groups. They might also consider discrediting the IRRC if its evaluation hurts them, or misrepresenting the IRRC’s analysis to make their own positions look better. Thus the IRRC has an interest in creating as much agreement as possible between the groups, so it can minimize, or at least anticipate, the attacks and misrepresentations its analysis might call forth.

By Tuesday at 1 pm, your group should decide on its own strategic goals for the simulation and write a memo explaining them. Your memo, addressed to the "group contact" listed on your participants background sheet, should include:

the position you suggest taking on the AIP (including any modifications you would like to see);

the specific goals you wish to achieve, especially if they are different from your stand on the AIP;

the problems/obstacles that you anticipate might block the achievement of your goals; and

the strategy you intend to pursue to achieve those goals and/or overcome those problems, including the coalition partners you will target (and/or those you will avoid).

The importance of these sections will vary depending on your group, but each of them must be covered. This is a confidential memo, so be as blunt as you like; no other group will see it. The memo will be judged on the quality of the analysis and the realism of your strategy. Creative modifications to the AIP will also be recognized.

By Wednesday at 5 pm, you should have located at least some coalition partners and put together a press release that all the groups in your coalition can agree to. The press release should:

state a position on the AIP (although you need not mention the agreement by name if your coalition deems it unwise);

justify your position in ways that will appeal to the general public and to their members of Congress;

list (on a separate piece of paper) the coalition partners who have given their open or tacit support to the coalition, and write a few lines explaining why each partner is part of the coalition. If a group has chosen to be a silent member, explain why as well.

This press release WILL be distributed to everyone in the simulation, along with the list of coalition partners (but not their reasons for joining). So remember that you are writing for a public audience, one that includes your opponents. The press release will be judged on its audience appeal and its ability to balance the different interests of the coalition members. The coalition will be judged separately, on its breadth, its depth, its novelty, and its cohesion.

Ground rules:

  1. You can only build coalitions with groups that are in this simulation. In other words, don’t bring in Nike, UNICEF, the Catholic Bishops, or the Chamber of Commerce.
  2. You can decide to weight some considerations (discussed here, in the briefing information, or with your contact person) more or less heavily, but you cannot discard any of them. In other words, you cannot invent a president for Wal-Mart who suddenly decides that her company is now going to adopt the same policies as Reebok’s.

SPP 638: The 1999 Integrated Policy Exercise

The Apparel Industry Partnership

 

Simulation Participants: Background Sheet

 

Wal-Mart Calvert Group

Reebok Investor Responsibility Research Center

Levi-Strauss U.S. Department of Labor

Sen. Jesse Helms International Labor Rights Fund

Sen. Joseph Biden Save the Children International

U.S. Council for International Business United Needle and Industrial Trade

Employees (UNITE)

 

Wal-Mart: With 2,399 stores and annual sales of just under $118 billion, Wal-Mart is the world’s largest retailer. Its visibility, its size, and its corporate pride in programs like "Support American Made" have made it a constant target of labor rights activists. In 1996, the National Labor Committee attacked its "Kathie Lee Gifford" line of clothing, charging that the clothes were made by Honduran factories that exploited its under-aged workers. The ensuing publicity encouraged the White House to launch the "White House Apparel Industry Partnership." But Wal-Mart did not participate in the AIP negotiations, preferring instead to aggressively defend itself against charges of using sweatshop labor. While it has not announced a position on the AIP, it has its own "Standards for Vendor Partners" and supports a set of standards written by the American Apparel Manufacturing Association.

Group contact: Betsey Reithmeyer, Sr. Manager Corporate Affairs

Reebok: Reebok is an international manufacturer of athletic wear and gear, with over $3 billion in sales (in 1996) in over 140 countries. Reebok was a founding member of the AIP and has signed on to both the April 1997 and the November 1998 agreements. Its active role is at least partly due to the attacks upon it: in 1995, it and other soccer ball manufacturers came under attack when it was discovered that Pakistani children between the ages of 4 and 14 were employed in its factories. Reebok actively participated in the ensuing ILO project, known as the Sialkot project, to end child labor in its factories and provide education and income replacement to the displaced child workers. This has not, however, prevented it from coming under fire for other alleged problems, most recently in its factories in China.

Group contact: Douglas Cahn, Vice-President, Human Rights Programs (sent information)

Levi-Strauss: Levi-Strauss is the world’s largest producer of brand-name clothing, with sales of $6.9 billion in 1997. In 1991 and 1992, accusations of contractor misconduct at factories in Saipan and China led Levi-Strauss to develop the first corporate code of conduct, its "Business Partner Terms of Engagement." Its code and its "Country Assessment Standards" are a model for the industry, and it was named to the DOL’s "Trendsetter List" in 1995 and 1996. However, it has not been a formal member of the AIP and has not publicly signed on to either agreement. It has also come under attack by the International Confederation of Free Trade Unions (ICTFU) for closing and consolidating its factories during restructuring, and for alleged anti-union practices.

Group contact: Michael Kobori, Government Affairs (now at Business for Social Responsibility)

Sen. Jesse Helms (R-NC): Jesse Helms was first elected to the Senate in 1972. His conservatism is legendary and, as chair of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, he has not hesitated to put it into action. He single-handedly held up the nomination of Gov. Weld of Massachusetts as Ambassador to Mexico because of (Republican!) Weld’s positions on drugs. He has used confirmations of White House appointees to other posts as bargaining chips, actions that have led him to be known as "Senator No." He supported giving the president fast-track trade authority, but his fierce anti-communism led him to abandon free trade positions in the case of Cuba and China. Helms represents a state with an important textile industry. He has not, however, taken any public role (or shown much interest) in international labor standards.

Group contact: Rick Hall

Sen. Joseph Biden (D-DE): Joseph Biden became the ranking member on the Senate Foreign Relations Committee at the beginning of the 105th Congress. The move surprised many: as chair and then ranking member on the Senate Judiciary Committee, Biden managed several high-profile bills, including the 1994 crime bill. But Biden saw the move as an opportunity to make a name for himself in foreign policy. First elected in 1972 at the age of 29, Biden is a consistently liberal senator from a moderate state. Delaware is known for DuPont, the chemical company, and for liberal business incorporation rules that have led numerous companies to establish headquarters there. It is not known for textiles, and despite his service on the International Economic Policy, Export, and Trade Promotion Subcommittee, Biden has not taken any public position on international labor standards.

Group contact: Rick Hall

U.S. Council for International Business (USCIB): The USCIB is the official representative of U.S. employers to international organizations like the ILO. It issues temporary duty-free import licenses (ATA Carnets) and engages in advocacy: it is a membership organization as well as an official spokesperson for the US business community abroad. The USCIB has stayed aloof from the AIP process, but has issued its own statement on codes of conduct. While it supports codes that are voluntarily adopted by business, the USCIB is extremely opposed to attempts to hold companies to an externally imposed standard, to allow monitoring that companies do not contract for themselves, and to make companies responsible for the actions of their subcontractors.

Group contact: John Ritchotte, Manager, International Labor Affairs

Calvert Group: The Calvert Group, a mutual-fund company, offers the largest family of socially-screened mutual funds in the U.S. It manages around $5.5 billion in assets and actively uses its institutional influence to affect the practices of companies in which it invests. It also provides information to fund holders about different social issues, including labor standards, or what it calls "corporate human rights policies." Calvert endorsed the April 1997 AIP but has taken no position on the November agreement. It is in a difficult position because the head of its outside Advisory Council on social responsibility is the executive director of the Interfaith Center on Corporate Responsibility, the NGO that pulled out of the November agreement.

Group contact: John Likerman, Director, Social Research Division

Investor Responsibility Research Center (IRRC): The IRRC provides research and consulting on social issues to subscribers, mostly institutional investors, who want to take an active role in corporate governance. Founded in the wake of Vietnam-era reforms that gave stockholders the power to challenge the social policies of corporations, IRRC does not take official positions but usually provides information suggesting the need for activity in one area or another. In the course of its research, it can also play an unofficial mediating role between other organizations. The IRRC published a book, The Sweatshop Quandary, in 1998, summarizing information about sweatshop working conditions around the world.

Group contact: Peter DeSimone, Labor Analyst

Department of Labor (DOL): Under the leadership of Robert Reich, the DOL moved aggressively into the area of sweatshop labor. DOL stepped up its enforcement of wage and hour laws, raiding factories such as one in El Monte, CA, that confined its Thai immigrant workers behind a barbed-wire fence and withheld their wages. It also established a program, "Trendsetters," to recognize companies with progressive stands on labor issues, and initiated the White House Apparel Industry Partnership negotiations. Secretary Herman has continued this effort, although she is not as given to publicizing it as Reich. The DOL has published a series of reports on child labor abroad and will be funding some of the ILO’s projects in this area.

Group contact: Sonya Rosen, Director, International Child Labor Study Office (TBA)

International Labor Rights Fund (ILRF): The ILRF was started as the advocacy and monitoring arm of a coalition of religious, labor, human rights and academic groups. It works to link trade policies to the enforcement of internationally accepted worker rights. It has been active in monitoring the Rugmark program, an effort to end the use of child labor in the production of Indian hand-knotted rugs. It has also sought the enforcement of a new law banning the import of goods made with bonded (enslaved) child labor. It was a founding member of the AIP and one of the drafters of the November 1998 agreement. Its decision to stay within the AIP framework earned it a good deal of criticism from UNITE, which tried to influence the union members on ILRF’s board of directors to reverse the ILRF’s support for the November agreement. The ILRF’s critics also suggest that its willingness to stay within the AIP negotiations may be based on the possibility of earning compensation as a corporate monitor in the future.

Group contact: Bama Athreya, Program Officer

Save the Children International/USA: Save the Children International, a British organization, has a long history of working for children’s rights. It was the primary NGO participant in two ILO programs: the Sialkot soccer ball project and Rugmark. It is known for taking a very cautious approach to codes of conduct, fearing that child workers will simply be fired by companies eager to purify their image. This, they argue, would leave the children and their families in an even worse position than before. Critics of Save the Children reply that it is simply trying to protect its control over international child labor initiatives and the budget it receives for administering programs like Sialkot and Rugmark.

Notably, in the United States, the Save the Children USA affiliate has focused more on other issues -- health, education, rural development -- than on child labor, either domestic or international. It is best known for its corporate and celebrity sponsors: Denny’s has a partnership with Save the Children, and Sally Field makes appeals for their child sponsorship program. This work, however, is not unique and does not give the group a distinctive niche. In the world of the IPE, a new president at Save the Children (Annie Publicities-Fine), has decided to take a more active role in the U.S. politics of labor standards.

Group contact: Ann Lin

UNITE: UNITE is the nation’s primary garment workers’ union, with a long history of fighting for workers’ rights and against Communists. It was a founding member of the AIP and endorsed the April 1997 agreement. By spring of 1998, however, UNITE began to raise questions about the direction of the negotiations. It refused to endorse the November 1998 agreement, arguing that the failure to consider a living wage, the refusal to enforce free and fair unions in China, and the lack of strong monitoring arrangements made the November 1998 AIP agreement one without teeth. Its opponents charge, however, that UNITE’s leadership has become too isolated from the best interests of workers, and point to recent media coverage of abuses in UNITE-organized factories. UNITE’s exit from the AIP was strengthened by the departure of a leading NGO, the Interfaith Center for Corporate Responsibility, at the same time. It is now engaged in an attempt to convince the boards of the other major NGO’s to abandon the AIP as well.

Group contact: Ann Hoffman, Legislative Director

 

 

SPP 638: The 1999 Integrated Policy Exercise

The Apparel Industry Partnership

 

News Updates: February-March, 1999

 

 

Associated Press (Belmont, North Carolina) February 5, 1999. Modern Industries announced today that it would close its three factories here, causing a loss of 400 jobs. The maker of the wildly popular "Street Smart," "Simply Street," and "Classic Street" clothing lines, Modern's profits were the second highest in the retail clothing industry last year. But Modern's spokeswomen, Laura Allison, defended the decision by citing competitive pressures. "In order to offer the best clothing at the best prices, we need to constantly streamline our production process and put our designers in closer touch with manufacturers. Our factories in North Carolina are simply too isolated from world fashion trends and the most up-to-date manufacturing technology to allow us to continue to stay at the cutting edge of fashion." Allison did not say where Modern would move its production.

Reuters (Shenzhen, Guangdong Province) February 13, 1999. A fire swept through a factory complex in this southern Chinese industrial city today, killing over four hundred young female sewers in five factories. The factories all made clothing for U.S. and European retailers, including Modern Industries, the maker of the popular "Street Smart" label. Early reports suggest the death toll was high because supervisors, intent on keeping the production line moving, refused to allow the workers to leave their machines until it was too late for most of them to escape. Other workers, locked into dormitories on the factory grounds, could not get out before the buildings burned to the ground. The women, mostly 18-30 year old migrants from China's interior provinces, lived on site and sent their wages home to their families. Investigations are continuing.

Washington Post (Washington, DC) February 15, 1999. In an unlikely alliance, conservative members of Congress and the AFL-CIO called today for a temporary moratorium on clothing imports from China, pending an investigation into factory subcontractors located there. John Sweeney, president of the AFL-CIO, said, "The tragic Shenzhen fire shows that no one -- not the Chinese workers with no unions to protect them from the deadly demands of their employers, nor the American workers whose safer workplaces cost employers money -- wins when American manufacturers export jobs overseas. Congress must find a way to stop this kind of exploitative subcontracting." Rep. Christopher Cox (R-CA), a longtime critic of the Chinese government, added, "A Communist dictatorship that imprisons its citizens when they attempt to form political parties, and condemns its young women to work in firetraps for profit, is not a government that the United States should deal with. Our principles are worth more than cheap Chinese imports that put our own people out of work."

CNN (Newark, DE) February 20, 1999. Delaware's outlet centers usually attract a weekend crowd thronging to take advantage of the state's tax-free shopping. This Saturday, however, store managers are struggling with a different crowd -- protestors calling on the brand-name retailers here to stop their dealings with China. Well over 750 protestors, many bused in from Catholic and evangelical Protestant churches in the area, many of them teenagers, blocked store entrances with signs denouncing Chinese imports. "I just don't think it's right that girls my age should die to make the clothing I wear," said Maryellen Roberts, 16. Her friend, Cindy Anderson, carried a sign proclaiming, "Get Smart. Dump Street Smart." The factory fire that killed 494 women in Shenzhen, China earlier this month ignited a storm of protest that has taken the Clinton administration by surprise. While President Clinton has continued to argue that engagement with China is the best way to improve conditions for the Chinese people, his arguments mean little to these earnest young people. "The pictures of those girls in the fire -- I cried for days," said Jill Rogan. "I cut up all my Street Smart clothing and all my friends are doing the same thing." Those friends brought bags of rags to the protest. Protest leaders say those bags will be mailed to Modern Industries, the manufacturer that contracted with many of the Shenzhen factories, to their members of Congress, and to the White House.

Reuters (Beijing, China) February 22, 1999. Chinese leaders today struck back at international criticism that followed in the wake of deadly factory fires in Shenzhen last month. "American companies violated Chinese labor laws and caused this horrible tragedy. But to protect its companies, American politicians are now blaming their negligence on us," said Zheng Hong, a spokesman for the Ministry of Labor. He condemned American concerns as hypocritical. "People who wish to spread lies about China have said that young girls were working in the Shenzhen factories. In reality, the country where young girls work without protection or help is the United States." He cited a study, authored by two Rutgers University economists, which showed that in an average week, 147,700 children and teenagers work illegally in the U.S. "The U.S. government's own occupational safety and health experts found that a child is killed at work every five days in the U.S. 200,000 children are injured at work each year," said Zheng. "Let America correct the practices of its own companies before blaming us for deaths they have caused."

Zheng also cited the case of Wu Quin-Rong, an 11 year-old Chinese immigrant girl murdered in New York last May. An investigation found that she had been working in a Chinatown sweatshop before her death. The incident was publicized as part of an investigation of UNITE, the garment-workers union in the U.S. "We have no 11 year-olds working in factories in China. Yet this is how the American government and American unions treat our people. We demand justice for Wu Quin-Rong's family and for our workers in Shenzhen."

Washington Times (Washington, DC) March 1, 1999. Sen. Jesse Helms (R-NC) announced today that he would hold hearings on the relationship between Chinese subcontractors and American apparel companies before the Senate Foreign Relations Committee. The hearings, scheduled for March 9, will examine sanctions proposed by conservative groups and the AFL-CIO, but Helms made it clear that he is also interested in re-examining the White House's efforts to promote standards for American apparel manufacturers abroad. "The White House created the so-called Apparel Industry Partnership three years ago. But just like other Washington boondoggles, it's spun its wheels. If the White House's efforts are constructive, we want to support them. But if it's just a way to polish up the reputation of some large Democratic donors, well, we'll just have to go around the White House to protect the American people, and the Chinese people too," said Helms.

SPP 638: The 1999 Integrated Policy Exercise

The Apparel Industry Partnership

 

Guidelines for Testimony

 

 

  1. Only coalitions are invited to testify at the committee hearing. In other words, your coalition will select one representative to carry the ball -- to speak and respond to questions -- for all of the groups in the coalition.
  2. Groups who do not join a coalition run a real risk of being disinvited to testify, unless they receive a special dispensation from the keeper of the parallel universe (ie, Ann). If you're going to request this dispensation, you need to explain your position in writing by 4pm Wednesday. This will give you enough time to beg your way into a coalition if your request is denied.
  3. The one exception to (1) and (2) is the two members of Congress. Sen. Helms and Sen. Biden will actually sit on the committee and question witnesses, just as the invited outside participants will. Thus they do not need to join a coalition, although they may be silent partners. Obviously, a coalition that has the chair or ranking member on its side will be a little better prepared at the hearing. A senator who joins a coalition also has more of an opportunity to shape the outcome of the hearings.

    Because senators need to be "on" for such a long period of time, the two Senate teams will be allowed to change senators in midstream. Currently I don't anticipate more than two speaking senators per Senate team, but this could change depending on how many coalitions we end up with.

  1. Each presenter will have 5 minutes for testimony, followed by 20 minutes for questions from the committee. These times may change depending on how many coalitions we end up with.
  2. You may use overheads if you wish; powerpoint will most likely be available as well.
  3. Take a look at Marina Whitman's memo on testifying, and on the sample testimony she's included. In the same way, each coalition will be asked to prepare an oral statement and a somewhat more expansive written statement. The written statement cannot exceed 8 double-spaced pages, not including exhibits or the answers to the committee's questions.
  4.  

  5. The committee asks the witnesses to respond to the following questions in their testimony:

Question 1: What are the advantages and disadvantages of using trade sanctions as a policy tool, especially in China?

Question 2: What is the extent to which ILO conventions should guide the activities of American companies who subcontract in foreign countries?

Question 3: What are the advantages and disadvantages of the White House AIP?

 

SPP 638: The 1999 Integrated Policy Exercise

The Apparel Industry Partnership

 

IPE "Scoring"

 

The IPE isn't graded, but your team will be competing for awards. These include:

  1. Best group position paper (based on the quality of the analysis and the realism of your strategy; extra points given for creative modifications to the AIP)
  2. Best press release (based on audience appeal and the balancing of the different interests of the coalition members)
  3. Best coalition (based on breadth (members from different sectors), depth (number of members), novelty (unlikely or difficult partners), and cohesion (balance of different interests)

    è Your coalition may include "silent members": groups that don't publicly declare their membership, but who work with the coalition behind the scenes. These groups should be included on your list of members; include the reason for their "silence."

  1. Best presentation (based on the judgment of the non-student members of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee)
  2. Best testimony (based on the written testimony)
  3. Most successful group (based on the match between the group position paper and the group's subsequent coalition-building activity)

You will also have the chance to decide upon peer awards. These include:

  1. Most important contribution (individual on your team)
  2. Most impressive team (team in the IPE other than your own)
  3. Special mention (nominations of other students or groups that deserve special mention for their work on the IPE)

In order to cast your vote for the peer awards and to help us evaluate the exercise, please fill out the evaluation below. These are anonymous, but please identify your team.

 

Evaluation: 1=strongly disagree

2=disagree

3=mixed

4=agree

5=strongly agree

 

The IPE was a valuable learning experience. 1 2 3 4 5

I used knowledge and skills from several

different courses in the IPE. 1 2 3 4 5

The negotiation workshop on Tuesday taught

me valuable skills. 1 2 3 4 5

I used skills from the negotiation workshop

during the IPE. 1 2 3 4 5

Working with the members of my team was

a valuable experience. 1 2 3 4 5

 

Please identify and comment on the most valuable aspect of the IPE.

 

Please identify and comment on the least valuable aspect of the IPE.

 

Please comment on changes you would like to see to the IPE

 

Please identify your team (UNITE, Helms, etc.) This will help us discover if different teams had different experiences.

 

Peer Awards Selection:

Please identify the person(s) on your team who contributed the most to your work as a group. Explain, in one sentence, his/her/their contribution.

 

Please identify the team(s), other than your own, whose work most impressed you during the IPE. Explain, in one sentence, what made its work impressive.

 

Please name any other student or group that deserves special mention for their work on the IPE. Explain, in one sentence, your reason for the nomination.

 

Please submit ballots and evaluations to 466 Lorch by 5 pm Friday evening

 

 

top of page