FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE CONTACT: John Truscott

June 17, 1997 (517) 335-NEWS


Total Personal Service Contracts Reduced! Dollars Spent on Non-Human Service Contracts Hold Steady


According to the Department of Civil Service, the number of personal service contracts have decreased substantially over the last several years. The small amount of state personal service contracts to date show fiscal year 1997 will be no exception to the declining trend in these contracts that Michigan has experienced. While the total funds spent on all personal service contracts continues to rise, this is a result of increases in health services costs growing at a rate greater than inflation. Also contributing to this increase, is the shift in Medicaid from a reimbursement fee for service to multiple managed care contracts. The amount of funding spent for non-health contracting remains consistent to what was spent in the late 1980s.

"I am extremely pleased that the number of state personal service contracts has plummeted significantly in the past year," said Governor Engler. "Thanks to careful management, these contracts, which used to number in the thousands, now only number several hundred."

For the last several fiscal years, the number of personal service contracts has substantially decreased:

Fiscal year 1987 5,512

Fiscal year 1988 5,525

Fiscal year 1989 6,109

Fiscal year 1990 6,601

Fiscal year 1991 4,684

Fiscal year 1992 4,065

Fiscal year 1993 4,300

Fiscal year 1994 2,676

Fiscal year 1995 3,430

Fiscal year 1996 2,455

Fiscal year 1997 714 (as of April)

According to Civil Service, for fiscal year 1996, the total spent on state personal service contracting was $1.5 billion. Health care costs are $1.051 billion of the total. For the Family Independence Agency (FIA), the total spent on preauthorized health and human service contracting was $925 million, of which more than $182 million was spent on foster care and more than $600 million was spent on HMO or clinic services. Total spending for FIA had more than doubled for health services since fiscal year 1992. For the Department of Community Health more than $86 million was spent on group homes. For the Department of Corrections, the total for medical services and rehabilitation is $40 million; this amount has nearly doubled from fiscal year 1993. The majority of funding related to personal service contracts is for human services.

In 1991, Governor Engler initiated Executive Directive 1991-5 which limited personal service contracts for public relations, conference organization, opinion research, lobbying or promotion to ensure state government was not in the business of promoting itself.

In 1993, Civil Service rules on personal service contracting were amended to include stricter standards. A personal service contract is entered into by the State with someone outside of the state government who can perform a task that cannot otherwise be done by a state employee.

The Civil Service Rule (4-6.3) for standards on personal service contracting requires that the services are temporary in nature, cannot be provided with the expertise in state classified service, the service provides access to equipment or materials that the state does not possess, or there is substantial savings as a result of contracting rather than having the state classified work force perform the service. These standards are not changed by the new proposed Civil Service Rules.

Preauthorized personal services contracts have to meet at least one of the Civil Service Rule standards, and if more than $250,000 have to be reviewed by the State Administrative Board and competitively bid as provided by law.

Non-preauthorized contracts represent about $386 million spent in fiscal year 1996. Some examples of these are $90 million for transportation trunk-line maintenance, $18 million for the Department of Treasury in collection services, and $29 million in additional human services for FIA that were non-preauthorized. The total spent for personal services in fiscal year 1989 was about $294 million for non-preauthorized contracts. Comparing this total for fiscal year 1989 to fiscal year 1996, and adjusting for inflation, represents only a 3.7 percent difference. In fiscal year 1989, non-preauthorized contracts represented 49 percent of the total contracts. In fiscal year 1996, non-preauthorized contracts represented only 25 percent of the total contracts.