FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE CONTACT: John Truscott
February 10, 1997 (517) 335-6397
In light of findings that almost half of the nearly 2,000 child deaths in Michigan in 1995 may have been prevented, the Governor's Task Force on Children's Justice has released Keeping Kids Alive, the first annual report on child death review in Michigan. The review includes preventable deaths from Sudden Infant Death Syndrome, motor vehicle accidents, fires, drowning and violence.
Keeping Kids Alive presents an overview of the Child Death Review program and the experiences of seventeen pilot teams representing urban, mid-sized and rural counties. The Task Force established the pilot program to help communities better understand how and why children die, and to help catalyze community action to prevent subsequent child deaths.
"The Child Death Review Teams allow us to examine all the facts related to a child's death, including those not known at the time of death," Governor John Engler said. "This look back allows us to examine and refine our child welfare and criminal justice systems with one goal in mind reducing the number of children who die unnecessarily in Michigan."
The Task Force provided $244,000 in federal Children's Justice Act funds for the pilot in 1995 and 1996 and, with program support from the Department of Community Health (DCH) and the Family Independence Agency (FIA), funded the Michigan Public Health Institute to develop a pilot program to determine how to best implement a Child Death Review in Michigan and to manage the program.
"The mission of the child death review teams is of the highest priority to this administration and we've added money to the budget for expansion to other counties," said Engler. The proposed FIA budget for Fiscal Year 1998 includes $500,000 for child death reviews.
Seventeen counties volunteered to participate in the pilot. These counties have
established multi-disciplinary teams in their communities and are now meeting regularly to
review child deaths in their counties. Each team consists of a core group of members which
must include local representatives from the Medical Examiner's office, the Prosecuting
Attorney's office, law enforcement, the local health department and the Family
Independence Agency. Teams may include additional members representing the medical
community, clergy, schools, etc.
During the first nine months of 1996, 309 child deaths were investigated at 92 Review Team
meetings. There have been four cases in which in-depth reviews have led to the
identification of homicides. In one, a natural death from several years past was brought
to the review at the request of a law enforcement officer who "never felt right about
the case." Following the review, additional toxicology was conducted, high levels of
antidepressants were discovered, and the parent is now being prosecuted for murder. In
another case, a death that had appeared to be an accident has now been ruled a homicide
and the mother and her boyfriend have been charged. During the review, FIA reported that
the boyfriend had prior felony child abuse convictions and prison terms in two other
states prior to the child's death. This led to a more intensive investigation and charges
being filed.
The report recommends expansion of the program throughout the state, and echoes a
report released by Lieutenant Governor Binsfeld's Children's Commission last July, which
recommended the development and implementation of county or regional child death review
teams to cover all counties statewide. Plans are underway to expand from seventeen to
thirty sites in 1997 with an emphasis on recruiting major, urban areas. In 1998, the teams
will be expanded to the remaining areas of the state, possibly using a regional approach
in rural areas.
The report also recommends establishing a multi-agency, multi-disciplinary, state-level
advisory team. The advisory team would identify and address policy issues, guide statewide
prevention, education and training efforts, and assist in preparation of the annual report
to the Governor and Legislature.
One particular positive outcome of the pilot is the commitment to create a data base to collect comprehensive information about child deaths. This data base, scheduled for implementation this year, will provide a more accurate profile of child fatalities and ensure easy access to data collected at the state and local levels in order to better understand trends in child mortality in Michigan.
"No child should die unnecessarily in our state," Engler said. We must learn from the results of these reviews and take the steps necessary to make the changes needed to avoid needless tragedies in the future."
Advisory to the media: The following counties participated in the Child Death Review pilots: Berrien, Calhoun, Chippewa, Clinton, Eaton, Genesee, Kalamazoo, Kent, Luce, Mackinac, Mason, Oakland, Sanilac, St. Clair, Tuscola, Washtenaw and Wayne.