FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE: CONTACT: John Truscott

September 25, 1996 (517) 335-6397


Governor Engler Says Reno Disregards Federal Law

Testifies Before Senate Judiciary Committee on Prison Litigation Reform

In testimony today before the U.S. Senate Judiciary Committee, Michigan Governor John Engler said Attorney General Janet Reno has flouted the will of Congress with regard to the Prison Litigation Reform Act (PLRA). Michigan Senator Spencer Abraham was instrumental in passage of the PLRA which was signed by President Clinton earlier this year.

"The PLRA strikes the constitutionally correct balance between a state's right to operate its own prison system and a federal court's responsibility to preserve constitutional rights of prisoners," said Governor Engler. "That's why the actions of the President's own attorney -- Attorney General Reno -- and the U.S. Justice Department to subvert the PLRA have been so frustrating."

The PLRA was enacted to relieve states like Michigan from the costly burden of lengthy prison litigation in which federal courts tried to micromanage administration of state prisons. In the early 1980s, Governor Engler's predecessor had signed two consent decrees that state officials appealed to terminate under the new law.

"The Clinton Justice Department has made Michigan a test case in its efforts to undermine our ability to run our prisons," said Engler. "With their zealous support of the frivolous claims of prison inmates, they reveal an obsession with putting the rights of violent convicted criminals over the rights of law-abiding citizens."

Governor Engler explained that when the federal court -- the same court that has intervened repeatedly in Michigan's prisons, costing taxpayers millions -- tried to circumvent the PLRA, Attorney General Reno and the U.S. Justice Department did nothing to stop them.

"In fact, Reno's response to the federal court made matters worse," said Engler. "The Attorney General actually claimed that any consent decree condition was a `federal right' under the terms of the PLRA -- the exact opposite of the intent of Congress. Convicted felons have never had it so good."

The Justice Department retracted that position, but then acted again to exacerbate the problem of federal judges who overstep their constitutional authority. The latest position of the Attorney General is that to decide a motion to terminate a consent decree under the PLRA it is necessary to hold evidentiary hearings, allow prison tours by Justice Department attorneys and experts, and review innumerable prison conditions.

As a result, the Attorney General has sent attorneys and experts to scour Michigan's prisons. Justice Department representatives are examining the temperature of prison food, the quality of the laundry service, and have even questioned why prisoners have to buy their own toiletries.

"This intrusion is not only contrary to the will of Congress but is also a clear attempt to victimize a state that wants the federal court to apply the law as written by this Committee, passed by Congress and signed by the President. That's not too much for Michigan to ask," said Engler. "Indeed, it is our obligation to law-abiding, taxpaying citizens that we demand the Prison Litigation Reform Act be followed to the letter of the law."

Governor Engler closed his testimony by requesting that the Committee ask the Attorney General whether or not she supports the PLRA.

"Does she support the PLRA as she claims or does she intend to continue to flout the will of Congress as evidenced by the Justice Department's pleadings in Michigan?" asked Governor Engler. "Attorney General Reno cannot have it both ways and the American people deserve a straight answer."