November 30, 1995
Honorable Larry Pressler - Chair
Honorable Ernest F. Hollings - Ranking Member
Senate Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation
Room 508 Senate Dirksen Office Bldg.
Washington, D.C. 20510
Honorable Thomas J. Bliley, Jr. - Chair
Honorable John D. Dingell - Ranking Member
House Commerce Committee
Room 2125 Rayburn House Office Bldg.
Washington, D.C. 20515
Dear Telecommunications Legislation Conferees:
Last month you received letters from the National Governors' Association and others expressing concern over the limited state roles set forth in both S. 652 and H.R. 1555. I want you to know that today I have signed legislation into law which modifies and extends the Michigan Telecommunications Act (MTA) of 1991 and further promotes competition in the State of Michigan. I strongly encourage you to include language in conference that will allow Michigan and other states to continue to boldly promote competition.
The following addition to Section 245 of your legislation, affirming state authority, would keep the overall policy goals you are establishing in place, but allow the innovative piece of legislation I have signed today to take effect:
"At any time after the enactment of this act, a state may certify compliance with the requirements of this act and immediately allow a Bell operating company or affiliate thereof in that state to provide interLATA services. The Commission may intercede and suspend a Bell operating company's authority to provide interLATA service under this subsection if a state's action is inconsistent with the intent of this act or is not in the public interest."
Of particular concern to me is the current language in both bills that would allow the interLATA "approval process" at the FCC to begin 6 months after enactment. The State of Michigan is ready for that process to proceed today. I believe it makes absolute sense to enhance Michigan's authority to immediately proceed in allowing a Bell operating company or affiliate thereof to provide interLATA services--again, so long as such actions are consistent with federal law. Arguably, granting such authority would strengthen and give my state commission greater leverage in speeding local competition.
At the same time, I applaud efforts of those in Congress who are seeking to expand competition and repair decision making from judicial and patchwork agency regulations. The actions of Congress and many state legislatures will greatly speed the competition we all desire. One of the very first bills I signed into law as Governor four years ago was a cutting edge piece of legislation designed to promote competition. That act did away with rate of return regulation and called upon the Michigan Public Service Commission (MPSC) to take all necessary steps to promote competition. We now have more than a half dozen companies such as AT&T, MCI-Metro, MFS and U.S. Signal who have received licenses to provide local phone service in our state. In fact, earlier this year, AT&T issued a press release saying they would soon provide local phone service in virtually every calling area in Michigan. The MPSC has already issued orders calling for interconnection, unbundling, number portability and dial-1 parity to facilitate local competition. I have codified these orders today, effectively ensuring compliance with the interLATA "checklist" mentioned in both S. 652 and H.R. 1555. In addition, earlier this year, I successfully urged the Department of Justice to include Michigan in a waiver order that would allow Ameritech to offer long-distance service through a separate subsidiary.
In closing, I would like to point out one particular provision included in the Michigan Telecommunications Act of 1995 that spurred my letter to you. It was designed as a challenge to both the court, who is sitting on the DOJ waiver, and the Congress. It orders Ameritech and GTE to defy the decade-old court orders prohibiting their entry into the long distance market. In part, it reads: "A provider of basic local exchange service shall provide 1+intraLATA toll dialing parity and shall provide interLATA toll service to an equal percentage of customers within the same service exchanges..." Beginning January 1, 1996 Ameritech and GTE must begin to open up their intraLATA markets to dialing parity, in 10% increments each month. At the same time, and in equal increments, they must begin providing interLATA service--in up to 50% of those same markets. Combined with the checklist items noted above, I believe this competition pilot should be allowed to move forward. Granting us the statutory authority to do so would provide some very helpful lessons for an FCC that will be looking for implementation methodologies and models.
I believe the aforementioned language would give my state the ability to speed competition in this fashion. If you have any questions or concerns, I would be happy to work with you in crafting language that might be more amenable.
Sincerely,
John Engler
Governor
JE:rlf
cc: Michigan Congressional Delegation
Michigan Public Service Commission