Governor John Engler
Governor's (MASB) Education Summit
Lansing -- Lansing Center
Tuesday, September 19, 1995
I'd like to thank Justin King and the Michigan Association of School Boards' Foundation for Education Leadership for the tremendous effort it took to coordinate an event of this scale and to bring together such a fine slate of speakers and panelists.
I'd also like to thank all of you for attending. Whether you are a school board member, community leader, employer, PTA member, principal, teacher, or concerned parent -- I am delighted that you could be here today to hear about some of the dynamic changes that are taking place in Michigan public education.
Since you are a knowledgeable audience, you know that 1995 is a critically important year in education reform around the nation. And 1996 will prove to be even more important because of the presidential race. Education reform will be a "hot topic" -- and it should be.
Already around the nation we see that the debate has been joined -- in Milwaukee, Cleveland, New York City, Jersy City, Pennsylvania, and right here in Michigan -- where there are bipartisan, grassroots efforts to give children, families, and educators more freedom to reform our public schools. Increasingly people are demanding greater accountability and better performance for the tax dollars they invest in public education.
No one can doubt that our education system is in need of urgent, fundamental reform. Lloyd Reuss, former president of General Motors, now devotes his life to training young people for high-tech careers. In April, he testified before our State Board of Education that in GM factories, the functional illiteracy rate is 25 percent. By contrast, Reuss said that in Japanese auto factories the rate is one percent. To overcome this disadvantage, American companies spend $25 billion each year for remedial training of their employees. That's $25 billion off the bottom line, and it erodes America's competitive edge.
Not just business demands change. A recent State Board of Education survey shows that over 70 percent of the public believes schools are not improving, and half gave their neighborhood school a grade of C or lower.
What does this tell me? While we have outstanding success stories around the state, we do not have enough of them. That is why, here in Michigan in recent years, we have taken a national leadership role and have passed a number of laws to improve our public schools. Look back over the past several years, and you see:
By the way: Wasn't it great to see every Michigan public school open its doors on time in recent weeks? This fall, not one strike kept our kids out of their classrooms.
Over the past several years, we have pushed for far-reaching, systemic change.
Yes, we've moved rather quickly -- too quickly for some. But I make no apologies. I am not content to rest on our reforms to date, nor am I content to tinker around on the margins of the status quo, because the clock is running out for the present generation. There is urgency in our mission. We must continue to push for reform that will improve more of our public schools, and improve them more quickly. As Al Shanker, president of the American Federation of Teachers notes, our public schools more resemble the command-and-control economies of the former Eastern Bloc than our free political and market system, which in tandem have built up the greatest nation on earth. The system has got to change.
The question is: How do we break up a monopoly of mediocrity? The answer is assuredly not more top-down federal or state mandates. Just the opposite. If there is a unifying theme to my administration's reforms, it is freedom. Creating an environment of responsible freedom is the rationale behind my administration's reforms.
As I mentioned just a minute ago, we took an important step forward in 1993 when Michigan became a pioneer in the creation of public school academies, which are commonly known as charter public schools. Charter schools are different from most other kinds of public schools because they have both the authority and the accountability they need to deliver a first-class education to our kids.
Just the possibility of charter schools is already stirring things up. In one Michigan district, the superintendent wrote and told me that the potential of charter schools was the impetus his district needed to refocus on quality and to be more responsive to students and parents. A principal in another district said -- I quote -- "Charter schools are to education what Japanese cars are to the auto industry. For years, we all bought Fords, Chevys, and Oldsmobiles even though they kept getting more expensive and the quality went down. Nothing changed until the Japanese cars entered the market."
When you look at the 55 schools that have been chartered in Michigan -- and 25 of these have already opened their doors -- their most outstanding characteristic is diversity. There are charters for schools that cater to pregnant teen girls; to Hispanic students who at risk of dropping out; to young people with learning disabilities; to Native American children on reservations; to kids with an aptitude in the creative arts. There are charters for technical trade academies, for schools with an environmental focus, for math and science centers -- the possibilities are as endless as the needs and demands of our citizens.
What is striking about these schools is the enthusiastic involvement of parents, and their sense of ownership in our public schools. You should listen to their response when asked why they are sending their kids to Michigan charter schools. One mom called the Academy of Casa Maria in Detroit "a salvation."[1]
That reflects the message of a recent Oakland Press editorial that called Michigan charter schools "a godsend for a lot of parents." This editorial goes on to say:
"These are the parents who have repeatedly seen public school officials turn a deaf ear to the parents' pleas for a learning environment that promotes their own family values and is safe for their children. . . . The bottom line? . . . Charter schools are long overdue because parents, not public school officials, should have the final say on how their children are educated."[2]
Clearly, charter public schools are responding to the wants and needs of our citizens. And I hope many of you here today will respond in kind. Every time I speak on education reform, I renew my challenge to business and community leaders who are worried about our young people's future. I say: Take the initiative to sponsor a charter public school. Imagine a General Motors Academy of Engineering, or a Whirlpool Academy of Science, or a Comerica Academy of Finance. Don't just tell us what you want; show us. Be a leader in Michigan's education renaissance.
And while you are playing your part, here in Lansing I am going to keep building on the momentum of our reforms to date. This fall, I am proposing legislation to strengthen our path-breaking charter schools by:
Which brings me to the most important point in this whole debate -- our children. Whatever the reforms we champion, whatever the vision we subscribe to, whatever the benchmarks for progress we use, the well-being of our children must be our number one priority. A lot of organizations are involved one way or another in education. But not every organization has our children's best interests -- or even education -- as its top priority. Sometimes their attitude toward parents and children reminds me of what Samuel Goldwyn used to tell others: "If I want your opinion, I'll give it to you."
Later this afternoon, Clark Durant -- the mild-mannered, soft-spoken president of the Michigan Board of Education -- will be speaking to you. But let me say here that I am extremely impressed with the policies outlined in the State Board of Education's plan, which focuses on mission, choice, freedom, and quality.
Before wrapping up, I'd like to spend just a moment discussing the quality component in the State Board's plan -- because freedom without quality is an empty choice. Board members are absolutely right to insist on raising education quality through model content standards, state assessment, accreditation, and an annual report. These long-overdue changes will also raise accountability.
Look at it from the taxpayer's perspective. If we are going to invest almost $11 billion in public K through 12 education -- and that's the figure we are approaching -- then Michigan taxpayers are entitled to know what the returns on that investment are. My friends, the bottom line is performance -- the ability of Michigan graduates to live, work, and compete in a global marketplace.
Later this year, I will be chairing the National Education Goals Panel. One of our top priorities will be to find better ways of measuring our children's academic performance in such core areas as reading and writing, math and science. It is vital that we assess how much Michigan students know, not only compared to each other, but compared to students in other states. The fifty states are extremely competitive with one another. No Michigan mom or dad wants to wake up to a morning paper that says Ohio children are scoring better on standardized tests than Michigan children. Such an unflattering report could -- and undoubtedly would -- have a negative impact on our state's economy.
While chairing the Goals Panel, I will be examining a number of other factors that bear on how successfully we measure and assess our students' performance:
I want to conclude with a little parable about change, and how important it is for all of us to recognize that the world is changing, and education had better adapt.
A newly promoted captain in the U.S. Navy was very proud and wanted to take his warship out on some maneuvers -- just for the thrill of it. Through the pitch-black night, the captain sees a light dead ahead on a collision course with his ship. He sends a signal: "Change your course ten degrees east."
The light signals back, "Change yours ten degrees west."
Taken aback, the captain signals: "I'm a Navy captain. Change course as ordered."
"I'm a seaman, second class," comes the reply. "Change your course."
Now the captain is really mad and sends the signal: "I'm a battleship and I'm not changing course."
The reply that came back: "I'm a lighthouse."
There's a lesson in that little story for all of us. Sometimes it is absolutely essential to change course to avert disaster. We live in such a time, and I want to welcome you -- welcome your ideas and your energy -- in the effort to "change course" in the way we deliver public education here in Michigan -- so that our children will be prepared to live, work, and compete in the world of the twenty-first century.
Thank you.
[1]
Phil Linslata, "Survival of School for At-Risk Kids No Longer a Worry," Detroit Free Press, August 29, 1995.[2] "Charter Schools Put Parents First," Oakland Press editorial, August 26, 1995.