FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE CONTACT: John Truscott

September 26, 1995 (517) 335-6397


Settlement Reached on Nordhouse Dunes

State to Save $20 Million


Governor John Engler announced today that he has resolved a longstanding legal battle with the majority interest holder regarding hydrocarbon exploration in the Nordhouse Dunes area, pending final action by House and Senate Appropriations Committees.

"My Administration inherited a multi-million dollar obligation," Governor Engler noted. "A Court of Claims ruling in July of this year effectively increased the state's potential liability to $100 million. I am determined to resolve these kinds of cases, rather than drag them out and pass them on to my successor."

"The settlement negotiated, in the amount of $59.5 million, is as good a deal as the state was going to get. We will accept this and move on," Engler said, noting that the state lost the case at every level.

DNR Director Roland Harmes said, "I commend Governor Engler for his diligence in bringing this case to closure. Clearly, the tab was continuing to mount, and the Governor's action saves taxpayers over $20 million."

The claim goes back to March 1986, when a proposed hydrocarbon development plan was submitted to the DNR by Miller Brothers Oil Corporation, which owned a block of leaseholder mineral interests located within the boundaries of the Nordhouse Dunes area. In April 1987, former DNR Director and Supervisor of Wells Gordon Guyer issued a Conclusive Findings and Determinations (CFD) report, prohibiting hydrocarbon exploration or production in the Protected Area. It became known as the "Guyer Order."

An inverse condemnation action was filed in the Court of Claims in May 1988. Judge Peter Houk issued Opinions and Orders holding the State liable in the amount of $71 million for "taking" Plaintiffs' property without compensation plus judgment interest from the April 1987 "takings" date. In February 1994, the Court of Appeals determined the taking to be temporary, rather than permanent, and remanded the case back to the Court of Claims for a redetermination of compensation.

In January 1995, DNR Director and Supervisor of Wells Roland Harmes issued a First Amendment to the CFD, authorizing directional drilling beneath the Protected Area from surface locations outside the area. A Second Amendment to the CFD, issued in March 1995, reduced the size of the Protected Area.

Subsequent Court of Claims actions reaffirmed the State's liability in the amount of $71 million. Additionally, the Court ruled that Plaintiffs were entitled to compensation worth nearly $2 million for the "rental value" temporary taking of a portion of their remaining leaseholder interest. Mineral rights owners were also awarded rental value as compensation for temporary taking of their property interests.

The settlement requires the state to pay $59.5 million on or before October 3, 1995.

Legislative Appropriations Committees will be requested to temporarily transfer funds from the Budget Stabilization Fund (BSF) to the State's General Fund, in order for the DNR to issue a check and settle the lawsuit. Funds will be returned to the BSF as future budget surpluses are identified.