FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE CONTACT: John Truscott

August 23, 1995 (517) 335-6397


Governor Hails Michigan Supreme Court Decision Not Requiring State Funding of Local Trial Courts


In a unanimous decision, the Michigan Supreme Court today in Grand Traverse Co. v. The State of Michigan held that the Michigan Constitution does not require the state to control or fund trail court operations.

"The Supreme Court's unanimous ruling came as no surprise, as it re-affirmed longstanding precedent that the state does not have an obligation to fund the court system," said Governor Engler. "The court ruled that there is neither a statutory nor constitutional basis to support the localities' claim that the state is required to fund the court system. As the Court correctly noted, funding of the court system is, and always has been, a political matter which is to be resolved in the political arena.

"The unanimous decision -- a rare occurrence indeed -- signifies a clear affirmation of the state's position. As a result, the state's budget will remain intact, being spared the disastrous depletion of hundreds of millions of dollars."

Mark A. Murray, director of the Department of Management and Budget, added, "We're very, very pleased with the decision. We think it reaffirms the very basic principle that is so important in these matters which is: spending

decisions -- the appropriations process -- belong in the Legislature. It is the right public policy because there will always be significant demands for public spending that exceed the kind of base revenues that you must have in place if you're going to have a competitive tax environment. That's where those priorities need to be sorted each year -- in the legislative arena."

The Court of Appeals, James R. Giddings, had held that the trial courts were entitled to reimbursement by the State for their operational costs.