EXECUTIVE ORDER
1993-6
IMPLEMENTATION OF EXPENDITURE REDUCTIONS UNDER
PROVISIONS OF ARTICLE V, SECTION 20,
OF THE MICHIGAN CONSTITUTION OF 1963
WHEREAS, Article V, Section 20, of the Michigan Constitution of 1963 states that no appropriation is a mandate to spend, and that the Governor, with the approval of the appropriating committees of the House and Senate, shall reduce expenditures authorized by appropriations whenever it appears that actual revenues for a fiscal period will fall below the revenue estimates on which appropriations for that period were based, and that reductions shall be made in accordance with procedures prescribed by law; and
WHEREAS, it appears that actual revenues for the fiscal period October 1, 1992 to September 30, 1993, will fall below the revenue estimates on which appropriations for that period were based, said estimates having been determined by the Legislature in accordance with Article IV, Section 31, of the Constitution of the State of Michigan; and
WHEREAS, under provisions of Section 391, Act 431, Public Acts of 1984, on the basis of written information from the directors of the Department of Management and Budget and the Department of Treasury, a finding has been made that actual revenue will fall below such revenue estimates; and
WHEREAS, there is an unanticipated loss of funding which the departments and agencies of state government do not expect to obtain or make up during the current fiscal year; and
WHEREAS, expenditure reductions totalling $201,066,100 are necessary; and
NOW, THEREFORE, I, John Engler, Governor of the State of Michigan, pursuant to the authority vested in me by the Michigan Constitution of 1963 and the laws of the State of Michigan, and with the approval of a majority of members of each appropriations committee, do hereby order the following reductions:
For the purposes of reducing state expenditures, the following expenditure authorizations from Capital Outlay appropriations totalling $16,342,900 are hereby reduced:
Account Number Item Amount
110-07-2741-000 Special Maintenance and Remodeling and Additions For university special maintenance and remodeling and additions projects estimated to cost more than $50,000 but less than $500,000 810,000
110-07-2771-000 Special Maintenance and Remodeling and Additions For community college special maintenance and remodeling and additions projects estimated to cost more than $50,000 but less than $500,000 140,000
110-33-3099-049 Michigan State University renovation of Michigan 1,250,000 animal and agricultural facilities to continue construction
110-33-7601-010 Alpena Community College - student community business learning resources center - to complete plans and begin construction (Total estimated cost $7,200,000 - state building authority share $3,599,000 - state general fund share $1,000 - Alpena Community College share $3,600,000)100,000
110-33-7616-005 C.S. Mott Community College - campus renovation - to complete plans and begin construction (Total estimated cost $8,100,000 - state building authority share $4,049,000 - state general fund share $1,000 - C.S. Mott Community College share $4,050,000.1,100,000
110-33-7696-010 Muskegon Community College - center for higher100,000 education - to complete plans and begin construction (Total estimated cost $10,400,000 - state building authority share $9,099,000 - state general fund share $1,000 - Muskegon Community College share $1,300,000)
110-33-7741-010 West Shore Community College - industrial skills center100,000 - to complete plans and begin construction (Total estimated cost $3,986,000 - state building authority share $1,067,000 - state general fund share $1,000 - West Shore Community College share including federal funds $2,918,000)
110-43-4999-001 Department of Social Services - upper peninsula100,000 regional detention center to complete plans and begin construction (Total estimated cost $4,255,000 - state building authority share $4,212,500 - state general fund share $42,500)
110-33-7641-004 Highland Park Community College - Educational Center 205,000 (repair/renovation of former physical education center) - to complete plans and begin construction.
110-47-1090-000 Lump Sum New Prisons 467,900
110-47-1183-000 Consent decree control account - Hadix 7,445,000
110-47-1091-000 Control account - new prisons 4,525,000
The following expenditure authorization from Capital Outlay appropriations totalling $700,000 is hereby reduced.
110-07-2762-000 Energy reduction projects - state agencies 700,000
Appropriations for the State Employees Retirement System, contained within all executive branch agency budgets are hereby reduced by an amount equal to $17,250,000 ($30,043,000 gross).
All appropriations within each state agency for State Employees Retirement System costs attributable to funding of dental and vision benefits for the fiscal year ending September 30, 1993 are hereby reduced from a contribution rate of .6 percent to zero percent. All appropriations within each state agency for State Employees Retirement System costs related to the current statutory requirements for the amortization of unfunded actuarial accrued liabilities are hereby reduced from a contribution rate of 2.00 percent to 1.30 percent. The individual line item reductions, general fund and gross, shall be provided separately to the Department of Management and Budget for approval and entry into the accounts.
Section 38(3) of Act 240 of the Public Acts of 1943, entitled as amended, the "state employees' retirement act," being section 38.38(3) of the Michigan Compiled Laws is amended as follows:
Sec. 38(3).
(3) The contribution rate for benefits other than those provided for in subsection (2), including dental and vision benefits under section 20d, shall be computed using an individual projected benefit entry age normal cost method of valuation. FOR THE STATE FISCAL YEAR ENDING SEPTEMBER 30, 1993, THE CONTRIBUTION RATE FOR DENTAL AND VISION BENEFITS SHALL BE ZERO PERCENT. The contribution rate for service that may be rendered in the current year, the normal cost contribution rate, shall be equal to the aggregate amount of individual entry age normal costs divided by 1% of the aggregate amount of active members' valuation compensation. The unfunded actuarial accrued liability shall be equal to the actuarial present value of benefits reduced by the actuarial present value of future normal cost contributions and the actuarial value of assets on the valuation date. The unfunded actuarial accrued liability shall be amortized over the following respective amortization periods: A 50 YEAR PERIOD.
Amortization
Portion of unfunded actuarial accrued liability Period
Portion existing on September 30, 1985 50 years
Net actuarial gains or losses after September 30, 1985 15 years
Actuarial present value of benefits attributable to sections 19(3), 19b, 19c, and 19d 10 years
Portions attributable to benefit changes after September 30, 1985 other than sections 19(3), 19b, 19c, and 19d 50 years
Portions of appropriations amounting to $166,773,200 for departments and agencies contained in the following public acts and from additional accounts, as appropriate, are hereby reduced. Where the expenditure reductions of general fund-general purpose appropriations in this order reduce the restricted portions of gross appropriations and sources of financing that will be earned, the amounts to be reduced shall be provided separately to the Director of Management and Budget for approval and entry into the accounts. The reduction total includes the following appropriation items, or are predicated upon the following actions:
Public School Employees Retirement System - Act No. 148, Public Acts of 1992
The appropriations to the Public School Employees' Retirement System from the School Aid Fund, for health insurance - premium disbursement, as provided by 1992 PA 148, are hereby reduced by $115,600,000 general fund/school aid fund; health insurance benefits shall be paid from the Reserve for Health Benefits as provided by section 34 of Act 300 of the Public Acts of 1980.
Account Number Item Amount
122-31-2356 Health Insurance - Premium Disbursement 115,600,000
Department of State Police - Act No. 152, Public Acts of 1992
Account Number Item Amount
110-55-1095 Other Unclassified Positions 179,000
110-55-1101 Executive Direction 19,300
110-55-1122 Traffic Safety Data 200
110-55-1126 Secondary Road Patrol Administration 300
110-55-1501 Business Administration 1,700
110-55-1601 Personnel Division 700
110-55-2201 Training Division 900
110-55-2701 Fire Marshal Programs 56,400
110-55-2712 Fire Fighters Training Council 9,800
110-55-2731 Fire Safety Board 13,000
110-55-2733 Municipal Fire Service Classification Board 52,900
110-55-2744 Fire Investigation Training to Locals 1,300
110-55-3201 Uniform Services 117,200
110-55-3401 Investigative Services 19,600
110-55-3416 Federal Anti-Drug Initiatives 100
110-55-3710 Operational Support 300
110-55-3720 Traffic Safety Programs 700 110-55-3740 Communications
102,500 110-55-4101 Central Records Division 128,900
110-55-4115 Automated Fingerprint Identification System 164,900
110-55-4601 State Police-Management Information Systems 21,700
110-55-4621 Local LEIN Services 34,600
110-55-5114 Fleet Leasing 1,776,400
110-55-5135 Enlisted Terminal Leave Payments 183,100
Department of Commerce - Act No. 155, Public Acts of 1992
Account Number Item Amount
110-63-1022 Ombudsman Office 24,000
110-63-1023 Policy Development 35,000
110-63-1026 Washington, D.C. Office 7,100
110-63-1057 Michigan Equity Program 679,600
110-63-1201 Administration 73,700
110-63-1203 Interlochen 10,200
110-63-1204 Blue Lake Fine Arts Camp 3,000
110-63-1205 Grand Rapids Symphony 12,500
110-63-2301 Departmental Services 10,000
110-63-2304 Budget and Contract Administration 68,300
110-63-2306 Personnel Services 9,700
110-63-8201 Administrative Support 4,000
110-63-8202 Information Services 18,400
110-63-8205 Computer Operations 27,600
110-63-9411 Liquor Licensing and Enforcement 650,000
330-63-9403 Management Support Services 70,000
330-63-9404 Liquor Merchandising 300,000
Department of Labor - Act No. 155, Public Acts of 1992
Account Number Item Amount
110-67-2801 General Industry Safety Standards Commission 500
110-67-2802 General Industry Safety Standards Advisory Committees 500
110-67-2803 Construction Safety Standards Commission 500
110-67-2804 Construction Safety Standards Advisory Committees 500
110-67-2805 Board of Health and Safety Compliance Appeals 500
110-67-2901 Wage Deviation Board 1,000
110-67-4110 Administration 15,000
110-67-4120 Mediation 113,000
110-67-4135 Benefit Services 55,000
110-67-4310 Administration 50,000
Department of Agriculture - Act. No. 156 Public Acts of 1992
Account Number Item Amount
110-79-1120 Statistical reporting service 10,000
110-79-1240 Financial services-49.0 FTE positions 21,600
110-79-1260 Press and public affairs 46,900
110-79-2210 Administration 5,100
110-79-2220 Apiary inspection program 5,500
110-79-2320 Animal health and welfare 23,900
110-79-2620 Dairy products quality assurance 34,100
110-79-2420 Food product quality assurance 34,400
110-79-2440 Weights and measures program 50,700
110-79-2510 Administration 15,000
110-79-2520 Equine drug testing 34,200
110-79-2530 Laboratory support services 78,600
110-79-3210 Marketing and market development 50,000
110-79-3220 Fruit and vegetable quality control 49,900
110-79-3830 Licensing and regulation 98,600
110-79-3840 Affirmative action 47,000
110-79-3860 Promotion 20,000
110-79-3901 Southwest Michigan tourist council 3,200
110-79-3902 Future farmers of America 1,500
110-79-3908 Local soil conservation districts/clean water incentive program 49,300
110-79-3910 Purses and supplements-fairs 127,500
110-79-3912 Standardbred purses and supplements-licensed tracks 15,000
110-79-3914 Standardbred Michigan futurity 3,000
110-79-3958 Standardbred Fedele Fauri futurity 3,000
110-79-3916 Standardbred breeders' awards 46,100
110-79-3918 Light horse racing-grants to county fairs 3,700
110-79-3920 Premiums-county and state fairs 67,800
110-79-3922 Building and track improvement-county and state fairs 25,000
110-79-3924 Standardbred training and stabling 2,400
110-79-3928 Thoroughbred training and stabling 3,400
110-79-3930 Thoroughbred program 76,300
110-79-3946 Northwest Michigan horticultural research station 2,200
110-79-3960 Great Lakes draft horse show 5,200
110-79-3942 Water wonderland breeder awards 12,500
110-79-3955 Appaloosa/Arabian/quarterhorse programs 2,300
Department of Natural Resources - Act No. 165, Public Acts of 1992
Account Number Item Amount
110-75-1017 Office of the Great Lakes 60,000
110-75-1007 Communications Services 120,000
110-75-1121 Field Programs Admin. & Clerical Support Services 353,800
110-75-1138 Environmental Enforcement & Administrative Support 50,000
110-75-1410 Administration 50,000
110-75-2613 Local Government Assistance & Planning 80,000
110-75-2137 Forest Fire Experiment Station 30,000
110-75-2808 Field Project Assistance and Permitting 32,000
110-75-4801 Surface Water Compliance Program 125,000
110-75-4811 Surface Water Surveillance Program 25,000
110-75-4541 State Cleanup Implementation 325,000
110-75-4565 Superfund Cleanup 500,000
110-75-4526 Environmental Lab 80,000
110-75-4706 Hazardous Waste Permits 23,000
110-75-4716 Manifest and Technical Support 29,000
110-75-4721 Compliance and Enforcement 165,000
110-75-4726 Resource Recovery 143,000
110-75-6004 Lake Level Control Grants 17,500
110-75-6005 Farmland and Open Space Preservation 67,500
110-75-6024 Land Resource Program Grants 100,000
Department of Public Health - Act No. 166, Public Acts of 1992
Account Number Item Amount
110-35-1230 Exec. Services - Salary and wages 97,200
110-35-1231 Exec. Services - Longevity and insurance 23,800
110-35-1235 Exec. Services - Retirement 91,600
110-35-1250 Equipment 26,300
110-35-1249 Joint DNR/DPH laboratory operations 53,400
110-35-1254 Vital records & health statistics 29,700
110-35-1261 Management information systems 91,100
110-35-1263 Maternal and infant health data and evaluation 11,200
110-35-1269 Health planning 10,800
110-35-1359 School health education project 20,000
110-35-2253 Local public health infrastructure 10,300
110-35-2254 Michigan essential health care provider program 900
110-35-2256 Indian health care 3,900
110-35-2259 Primary care services 3,800
110-35-2276 Migrant health care 1,700
110-35-2279 Refugee health program 400
110-35-2330 Health Systems Admin. - Salary and wages 24,200
110-35-2331 Health Systems Admin. - Longevity and insurance 4,000
110-35-2335 Health Systems Admin. - Retirement 46,800
110-35-2340 HSA - Contractual services, supplies, and materials 1,200
110-35-2344 Health Systems Admin. - Travel 2,500
110-35-2356 Training and evaluation 1,000
110-35-2358 Emergency medical services program state staff 500
110-35-2364 Health facilities management information system 1,800
110-35-2368 Administrative hearings 1,500
110-35-2371 Local health services 6,600
110-35-3430 Substance Abuse - Salary and wages 57,000
110-35-3431 Substance Abuse - Longevity and insurance 12,000
110-35-3435 Substance Abuse - Retirement 31,000
110-35-4130 Child and Family - Salary and wages 49,000
110-35-4135 Child and Family - Retirement 41,000
110-35-4355 Medical care and treatment 3,000,000
110-35-5131 Environ. Health Admin. - Longevity and insurance 3,000
110-35-5155 Health risk assessment 58,000
110-35-5230 Community Environ. Health - Salary and wages 69,700
110-35-5231 Community Environ. Health - Longevity and insurance 7,400
110-35-5235 Community Environ. Health - Retirement 95,100
110-35-5240 CEH - Contractual services, supplies, and materials 3,300
110-35-5244 Community Environ. Health - Travel 3,400
110-35-5331 Radiological Health - Longevity and insurance 5,000
110-35-5335 Radiological Health - Retirement 20,000
110-35-5430 Occupational Health - Salary and wages 46,600
110-35-5431 Occupational Health - Longevity and insurance 22,900
110-35-5435 Occupational Health - Retirement 4,100
110-35-5444 Occupational Health - Travel 1,200
110-35-5451 Occupational health standards commission 700
110-35-5453 Asbestos abatement program 46,800
110-35-6230 Laboratory Services - Salary and wages 166,200
110-35-6231 Laboratory Services - Longevity and insurance 26,500
110-35-6235 Laboratory Services - Retirement 107,300
110-35-6330 Biologic Products - Salary and wages 45,400
110-35-6335 Biologic Products - Retirement 54,600
110-35-6751 Tuberculosis aid 67,400
110-35-6755 AIDS surveillance and prevention program 96,200
Department of Mental Health - Act No. 167, Public Acts of 1992
Account Number Item Amount
110-39-1191 Department Administration and Management 1,200,000
110-39-1793 Developmental Disabilities Dental Program 310,000
110-39-2955 Family Support Subsidy 100,000
110-39-3134 Omnibus Reconciliation Act Implementation 7,668,400
110-39-1780 Worker's Compensation and Staff 500,000
110-39-1706 Equipment 30,000
110-39-2733 Community Residential Services for the developmentally disabled 3,000,000
110-39-4500 Caro Regional Mental Health Center-Psychiatric Services Unit 773,000
110-39-5400 Clinton Valley Center 3,588,400
110-39-4300 Detroit Psychiatric Institute 702,300
110-39-4600 Kalamazoo Regional Psychiatric Hospital 1,367,100
110-39-5200 Northville Regional Psychiatric Hospital 4,364,100
110-39-4100 Reuther Facility-Wayne County 2,283,600
110-39-4000 Center for Forensic Psychiatry 1,673,500
110-39-3500 Detroit Psychiatric Institute-Children's Program 142,000
110-39-3400 Fairlawn Center at Clinton Valley Center 739,600
110-39-4200 Hawthorn Center 889,400
110-39-3600 Pheasant Ridge Children's Center at Kalamazoo 229,000
Department of Attorney General - Act No. 175, Public Acts of 1992
Account Number Item Amount
110-11-1001 Salaries and wages 62,500
110-11-1002 Longevity and insurance 25,000
110-11-1003Retirement37,500
Department of Civil Rights - Act No. 175, Public Acts of 1992
Account Number Item Amount
110-15-1000 Civil Rights Operations 200,000
Department of Civil Service - Act No. 175, Public Acts of 1992
Account Number Item Amount
110-19-1000 Civil Service operations 1,000,000
Executive Office - Act No. 175, Public Acts of 1992
Account Number Item Amount
110-01-0139 Executive Office 110,400
Department of Management and Budget - Act No. 175, Public Acts of 1992
Account Number Item Amount
110-07-1101 Departmentwide Services 247,100
110-07-1401 Statewide Administrative Services 294,800
110-07-3801 Statewide Support Services 43,100
110-07-1601 Grants Administration Services 28,700
110-07-1636 Reimbursement to Counties for Escaped Prisoner Prosecution 158,100
Department of State - Act No. 175, Public Acts of 1992
Account Number Item Amount
110-23-1204 Contractual services, supplies, and materials 5,000 University of Michigan-Dearborn Auto Engineering Education grant, $2,500; Michigan Geographic Alliance grant, $2,500;
110-23-1102 Longevity and Insurance 100,000
110-23-1106 Travel 62,000
110-23-1109 Rent1 13,000
110-23-3401 Salaries and Wages 100,000
Department of Treasury - Act No. 175, Public Acts of 1992
Account Number Item Amount
110-27-1601 Department services 100,000
110-27-2301 Enforcement 116,600
110-27-4201 Supervision of the general property tax law 200,000
335-27-1000 Lottery operations 172,900
Comprehensive Transportation Fund
Appropriations of automotive-related general sales tax receipts, distributed to the Department of Transportation for comprehensive transportation purposes in accordance with Section 25 of Act No. 167 of the Public Acts of 1933, as amended by Act No. 440 of the Public Acts of 1982, being sections 205.75 of the Michigan Compiled Laws, are reduced as follows, commencing on the effective date of the Executive Order reducing such expenditures:
Account Number Item Amount
120-59-7200 Administration 200,000
120-59-7300 Comprehensive transportation planning 40,000
120-59-7517 Local bus operating 3,335,500
120-59-7520 Bus capital 953,000
120-59-7740 Intercity bus service development 476,500
Amended subsection (4)(a) of Section 25 of Act No. 167 of the Public Acts of 1933, as amended by Act No. 70 of the Public Acts of 1991, being section 205.75 of the Michigan Compiled Laws by "HOWEVER, FOR THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING SEPTEMBER 30, 1993, ONLY, THE AMOUNT TO BE DEPOSITED IN THE COMPREHENSIVE TRANSPORTATION FUND SHALL BE REDUCED BY $5,005,000 COMMENCING ON THE EFFECTIVE DATE OF THIS EXECUTIVE ORDER."
Horse Race Revenue Funds
Appropriated horse race revenue funds used for programs in accordance with Act 327, of the Public Acts of 1980, as amended, being Section 431.73 of the Michigan Compiled Laws are reduced by the amending the following:
Account Number Item Amount
110-79-3934 Standardbred sire stakes program 37,500
110-79-3936 Grants to cities with racetracks 91,900
110-79-3944 Thoroughbred sire stakes program 18,900
Amend subsection (2) of Section 13 of Act 327 of the Public Acts of 1980, as amended, being Section 431.73 of the Michigan Compiled Laws by "HOWEVER, FOR THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING SEPTEMBER 30, 1993 THE AMOUNT OF $1,837,500 APPROPRIATED IN 1992 PA 156 TO IMPLEMENT THIS SUBSECTION SHALL BE REDUCED BY $91,900 OVER THE REMAINDER OF FISCAL YEAR 1993 COMMENCING ON THE EFFECTIVE DATE OF THE EXECUTIVE ORDER REDUCING SUCH EXPENDITURES, AND THE AMOUNTS REDUCED SHALL BE CREDITED TO THE GENERAL FUND."
Amend subsection (9) of Section 13 of Act 327 of the Public Acts of 1980, as amended, being Section 431.73 of the Michigan Compiled Laws by "HOWEVER, FOR THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING SEPTEMBER 30, 1993 THE AMOUNT OF $748,800 APPROPRIATED IN 1992 PUBLIC ACT 156 TO IMPLEMENT THIS SUBSECTION SHALL BE REDUCED BY $37,500 OVER THE REMAINDER OF FISCAL YEAR 1993 COMMENCING ON THE EFFECTIVE DATE OF THE EXECUTIVE ORDER REDUCING SUCH EXPENDITURES, AND THE AMOUNTS REDUCED SHALL BE CREDITED TO THE GENERAL FUND."
Amend subsection (10) of Section 13 of Act 327 of the Public Acts of 1980, as amended, being Section 431.73 of the Michigan Compiled Laws by "HOWEVER, FOR THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING SEPTEMBER 30, 1993 THE AMOUNT OF $377,700 APPROPRIATED IN 1992 PUBLIC ACT 156 TO IMPLEMENT THIS SUBSECTION SHALL BE REDUCED BY $18,900 OVER THE REMAINDER OF FISCAL YEAR 1993 COMMENCING ON THE EFFECTIVE DATE OF THE EXECUTIVE ORDER REDUCING SUCH EXPENDITURES, AND THE AMOUNTS REDUCED SHALL BE CREDITED TO THE GENERAL FUND."
Expenditure reduction amounts and associated sources of restricted financing shall be transferred in accordance with provisions of Section 391, Act 431, Public Acts of 1984, as amended.
The Director of the Department of Management and Budget is hereby authorized to take any and all actions necessary to implement the provisions of this order so that expenditures authorized by appropriations shall be reduced as specified above for the fiscal year October 1, 1992 - September 30, 1993.
Given under my hand and the Great Seal of the State of Michigan this _______ day of February, in the year of Our Lord, One Thousand Nine Hundred Ninety Three, and of the Commonwealth, One Hundred Fifty-Seven .
_______________________________
GOVERNOR
BY THE GOVERNOR:
_______________________________
SECRETARY OF STATE