EXECUTIVE ORDER

1991-33

MICHIGAN ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE BOARD

WHEREAS, there is a need for the Governor and others in state government to have the advantage of scientific and technical expertise with respect to important matters relating to environmental protection and natural resources management; and

WHEREAS, it is therefore necessary to create a Michigan Environmental Science Board as an independent autonomous entity within the Department of Management and Budget.

NOW, THEREFORE, I, John Engler, Governor of the State of Michigan, pursuant to the powers vested in me by the Constitution of the State of Michigan of 1963, do hereby establish as an independent, autonomous entity within the Department of Management and Budget a Michigan Environmental Science Board (the "Board").

1. The Board shall consist of nine individuals who have expertise in one or more of the following areas:

a. Engineering

b. Ecological Science

c. Economics

d. Chemistry

e. Physics

f. Biological Sciences

g. Human Medicine

h. Statistics

i. Risk Assessment

j. Geology

k. Other disciplines as necessary

2. A member of the Board shall be appointed by the Governor and shall serve at the pleasure of the Governor. The Governor shall appoint one member of the Board as Chairperson and such member shall serve as Chairperson at the pleasure of the Governor. The Governor may appoint other members of the Board as officers and such members shall serve as officers at the pleasure of the Governor. The Board shall be administered by an executive director who shall be appointed by the Governor.

3. The Board shall have the following general duties:

a. To advise the Governor, the Commission of Natural Resources, the new Michigan Department of Natural Resources and other state agencies on issues affecting the protection and management of Michigan's environment and natural resources, as may be requested by the Governor.

b. To assist the Governor in reviewing state or federal environmental impact statements and to coordinate the reviews of other state agencies.

c. To review the establishment of new environmental standards for permits or operating licenses, as may be requested by the Governor.

d. To review the methodology for establishing permit or operating license conditions that contain environmental standards that have not been established by administrative rule, as may be requested by the Governor.

e. To review staff recommendations for the approval or denial of permit and license applications, as may be requested by the Governor.

4. The Board shall have the following specific duties:

a. Upon receipt of a request from the Governor to review a particular issue, the executive director of the Board shall convene a portion of the Board, consisting of Board members with relevant expertise, to provide recommendations on the issue.

b. Upon receipt of an environmental impact statement from the Governor, the executive director of the Board shall convene a portion of the Board, consisting of Board members with relevant expertise, to review the environmental impact statement. The executive director shall also coordinate the review by other state agencies of the environmental impact statement.

c. Upon request by the Governor, the director of the new Michigan Department of Natural Resources shall submit proposed or existing environmental standards for permits or operating licenses to the Board. (For purposes of this Order, a standard shall include, but shall not be limited to, a proposed or existing rule, regulation, guideline, form with instructions or policy.) Upon receipt of a standard, the executive director shall convene a portion of the Board, consisting of Board members with relevant expertise, to review the standard. The scope of the review by the Board shall include, but shall not be limited to the following factors: (i) sound, objective, scientific reasoning; (ii) relative risk to human health and to the environment; and (iii) economic reasonableness, where appropriate. The Board shall report its findings to the director of the new Michigan Department of Natural Resources. Upon receipt of the Board's findings, the director may propose modifications to the standard. Such review shall be conducted concurrently with any rule-making proceeding and shall not delay such proceeding.

d. Upon request by the Governor, the Board shall review the procedure for establishing permit or operating license conditions that contain environmental standards that have not been established by rule. Upon receipt of such a request, the executive director shall convene a portion of the Board, consisting of Board members with relevant expertise, to review the procedure. The scope of the review by the Board shall include, but shall not be limited to the following factors: (i) sound, objective, scientific reasoning; (ii) relative risk to human health and to the environment; and (iii) economic reasonableness, where appropriate. The Board shall report its findings to the director of the new Michigan Department of Natural Resources. Upon receipt of the Board's findings,the director may propose modifications to the procedure for establishing the permit or license conditions.

e. Upon request by the Governor, the Board shall review staff recommendations for denial or approvals of permit and license applications. Upon receipt of such a request, the executive director shall convene a portion of the Board, consisting of Board members with relevant expertise, to review the recommendations of the staff. The scope of the review by the Board shall include, but shall not be limited to the following factors: (i) sound, objective, scientific reasoning; (ii) relative risk to human health and to the environment; and (iii) economic reasonableness, where appropriate. Upon receipt of the Board's findings, the director shall make the final determine as to whether to approve or deny the application, taking into account the recommendations of the Board. The director may modify permit or license conditions consistent with the recommendations of the Board.

5. The Commission of Natural Resources, the director of the new Michigan Department of Natural Resources and other department directors and autonomous agency heads may request the Governor to request the review by the Board of a matter.

6. As appropriate, the Board may make inquiries, studies and investigations, hold hearings and receive comments from the public. As appropriate, the executive director may call upon experts who are not members of the Board to assist the Board in its various deliberations.

7. All departments, boards, commissions or officers of the state, or of any political subdivision thereof, shall give to the Board, or to any member or representative thereof, any necessary assistance required by the Board, or any member or representative thereof, in the performance of the duties of the Board so far as is compatible with its, his or her duties; free access shall also be given to any books, records or documents in its, his or her custody, relating to matters within the scope of the inquiry, study or investigation of the Board.

The provisions of this Executive Order shall become effective upon 60 days after the filing of this Order.

Given under my hand and the Great Seal of the State of Michigan this _____ day of November, in the Year of our Lord, One Thousand Nine Hundred Ninety-One, and of the Commonwealth, One Hundred Fifty-Five.

____________________________________

GOVERNOR

BY THE GOVERNOR:

_____________________________

SECRETARY OF STATE