THE DRIVER SAVINGS AND LAWSUIT PROTECTION PLAN:

A PROPOSAL TO FURTHER IMPROVE MICHIGAN'S NO-FAULT AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE SYSTEM

Michigan's automobile insurance system is held up as an example in many states' insurance reform efforts. In spite of having the most generous benefit level in the country, our average mandatory premium is lower than the national average (The National Association of Insurance Commissioners "State Average Expenditures & Premiums for Personal Automobile Insurance in 1995" reports a countrywide average liability premium of $425.89, with Michigan's average reported at $343.22.), which includes many liability-only states. Although our system is obviously a successful one, we can still make changes to reduce premiums by further reducing the amount of premium dollars going to legal fees while maintaining our successful personal protection benefits package.


Michigan's Mandatory Auto Insurance Policy

The coverages Michigan residents are required to purchase are:

Personal Injury Protection A person covered by a Michigan no-fault auto insurance policy can receive, without regard to fault, unlimited medical benefits, 3 years' wage replacement or survivors' loss benefits (both of which are currently limited to $3,545 per 30-day period), 3 years' replacement services benefits of up to $20/day, and a funeral/burial expense benefit.
Property Protection Insurance This coverage pays, without regard to fault, up to $1 million for damage to the property of others in Michigan (other than vehicles) resulting from an automobile accident.
Residual Bodily Injury and Property Damage Liability (RBI/PD) The only "fault" coverage, RBI/PD pays economic (i.e. medical and wage loss) and noneconomic (i.e. pain and suffering) damages for which an insured is legally liable to another person as a result of an automobile accident.


It is the residual liability insurance premium which can be substantially reduced by making a change in Michigan's tort system (See Appendix I). This can be done without changing the economic protections provided by the other two mandatory coverages.


How Residual Bodily Injury and Property Damage Liability Insurance Works

In Michigan, Residual Bodily Injury and Property Damage Liability Insurance (referred to as RBI/PD) must be purchased in limits of at least 20/40/10. The first two numbers refer to the amount of bodily injury liability coverage and the third number refers to the amount of property damage liability coverage. For example, limits of 20/40/10 provides $20,000 of liability insurance of bodily injury an insured causes to any one person, with a maximum of $40,000 for bodily injury to more than one person in any one accident, and $10,000 in liability coverage for damage to the property of others.

Property damage liability insurance pays for damage to property of others for which an insured person is legally liable. In Michigan, damage to property is covered on a no-fault basis under the mandatory property protection insurance for up to $1 million. Therefore, for Michigan residents, property damage liability is needed only when driving outside the state. This is a small portion of the residual liability premium.

Residual bodily injury liability insurance provides coverage in the following situations:

Outside Michigan Outside Michigan, the policy pays for bodily injury to others for which an insured person is legally liable under the tort laws of the state in which the accident occurred. This could include economic as well as noneconomic damages.
Inside Michigan Residual liability insurance protects Michigan insureds in Michigan for bodily injury to others resulting in (1) expenses for a person's care, recovery or rehabilitation which exceed the limits of the injured persons's coverage; or (2) noneconomic damages (pain and suffering), if the injured person has suffered death, permanent serious disfigurement, or serious impairment of body function as defined by statute.

The premium for residual liability coverage is primarily attributable to losses which occur in the state of Michigan. Since Michigan residents have such extensive benefits for medical care, rehabilitation and wage loss, lawsuits for expenses which exceed a person's own insurance coverage are few. Therefore, the bulk of the portion of a Michigan no-fault policy premium for residual liability coverage is actually attributable to defending, and paying settlements or damages awarded as a result of, lawsuits for pain and suffering.


Recommendations for Change

One of the reasons no-fault auto insurance is perceived as a better system than the traditional tort system is that more of the premium dollars are returned to insureds in the form of benefit payments, rather than used to defray insurers' costs of defending lawsuits, or to pay damages or attorneys' fees resulting from those lawsuits. It follows, then, that the more lawsuits, and therefore attorney involvement, that can be removed from the system, the lower the overall cost of the system. A lower cost system results in lower premiums to the policyholders.

Since the bulk of the premium for residual liability insurance coverage is attributable to the costs of lawsuits for noneconomic damages, removing this tort from the auto insurance system could result in significant premium savings. For those who wish to continue to have the option to collect damages for pain and suffering resulting from an auto accident, coverage could be offered on a first party basis. That is, individuals could purchase coverage for noneconomic damages and, upon suffering such a loss, could collect benefits from their own insurer without having to actually pursue a lawsuit against the at-fault driver.


Proposal

It is proposed that the following changes be made to Michigan's system without changing the personal injury protection or property protection system currently in place.


How It Works

A Michigan insured would continue to purchase the mandatory no-fault policy in its current form, thereby maintaining protection against almost all economic loss, including medical bills, lost wages, survivors' loss, replacement services such as housecleaning and yard work, and rehabilitation. This coverage would also include residual liability insurance with a reduced premium due to the elimination of most noneconomic damage lawsuits.

With the exception of legally uninsured individuals (discussed later in this document), lawsuits for noneconomic damages (pain and suffering) would be eliminated. Michigan insureds could not sue and could not be sued for such damages.

Since the new system would eliminate practically all lawsuits for noneconomic damages, if a person wished to be able to collect pain and suffering damages should he or she be seriously injured (Michigan's tort threshold will not change under this proposal. In order to collect noneconomic damages, a person must have suffered death, permanent serious disfiguration, or serious impairment of body function.) by another driver, tort replacement coverage could be purchased. Tort Replacement Coverage would be purchased in limits chosen by the insured person, and would pay pain and suffering damages to that person if he or she was seriously injured and not at fault (As used in this document, a person is "at fault" if his or her actions or inactions are more than 50% the cause of the accident. Payment to persons considered not at fault are reduced by that person's percentage of fault, if any.) in the accident. These damages would be paid by the insurer to its insured without the need to sue the at-fault driver, thus eliminating the time delays and litigation costs associated with court actions.

Elimination of tort liability for noneconomic damages, but replacing it with an option to buy tort replacement coverage under which a person could collect under his or her own policy, provides adequate protection and options for most Michigan residents. One small exception to this, however, is the situation where the injured person is not insured under a no-fault policy.

A large number of Michigan residents are insured under a Michigan no-fault policy, either by
virtue of a policy purchased to cover an owned vehicle, or being a family member in a household with an insured vehicle. Individuals who do not have the protections of a Michigan no-fault policy are those who do not own a car, or who do not live with a family member who owns a car. When our no-fault system was developed, there was concern that these individuals who are not required to purchase a mandatory auto insurance policy still be able to collect benefits for the losses they incur as a result of an automobile accident. This was accomplished in two ways. When involved in an accident with an insured vehicle, these legally uninsured individuals collect their personal injury protection benefits from the policy covering the car(s) involved in the accident. In the event that a legally uninsured person is injured as a result of an accident with an uninsured motorist, or a hit and run driver, the Assigned Claims Facility would pay personal protection benefits to these injured persons.

Under this proposal, the ability to sue for pain and suffering is replaced with the option to purchase coverage for such losses on a first party basis. Legally uninsured individuals, however, do not have the option to purchase Tort Replacement Coverage, since they do not have a policy at all. Therefore, the proposal retains their ability to sue for pain and suffering.

Driver Savings & Lawsuit Protection Plan Reform Benefits


Accident Scenarios

Here are some examples of how the proposal would work under various accident scenarios.

Accident #l

Driver A has a mandatory no-fault policy with Tort Replacement Coverage. Driver A is at fault in the accident. Driver B has a mandatory no-fault policy with Tort Replacement Coverage.

Both drivers collect economic damages from their own policies (same as current system).
Driver B can sue Driver A for economic damages over policy limits (same as current system).
Driver B can collect noneconomic damages from own policy.

Accident #2

Driver A has a mandatory no-fault policy with Tort Replacement Coverage. Driver A is at fault in the accident. Driver B has a mandatory no-fault policy.

Both drivers collect economic damages from their own policies (same as current system).
Driver B can sue Driver A for economic damages over policy limits (same as current system).
Driver B cannot collect noneconomic damages.

Accident #3

Driver A has a mandatory no-fault policy. Driver B has a mandatory no-fault policy. Driver B is at fault in the accident.

Both drivers collect economic damages from their own policies (same as current system).
Driver A can sue Driver B for economic damages over policy limits (same as current system).
Neither driver can collect noneconomic damages.

Accident #4

Driver A has a mandatory no-fault policy. Driver A is at-fault in the accident. Pedestrian B does not own a car and is not covered by a household no-fault policy.

Both Driver A and Pedestrian B collect economic damages from Driver A's personal injury protection coverage (same as current system).
Pedestrian B can sue Driver A for economic damages over those provided by Driver A's personal injury protection coverage. These damages could be paid by Driver A's residual liability coverage (same as current system).
Pedestrian B can sue driver A for noneconomic damages. These damages would be covered by Driver A's residual liability coverage.

Driver Savings & Lawsuit Protection Plan: Current versus Proposed Law Chart


APPENDIX I

Cost Implications

1995 Premiums: Line 19.2 (Other private passenger liability)
Line 19.4 (Other commercial liability)
$889,134,000
$277,327,000
Assumptions: Approx. 77% of 19.2 premiums are RBI/PD       
Approx. 8% of 19.2 premiums are UM           
Approx. 85% of 19.4 premiums are RBI/PD       

Approx. 90% of commercial RBI/PD premiums ($212,155,155) are attributable to noneconomic losses.*

Approx. 85% of private passenger RBI/PD premiums ($581,938,203) are attributable to noneconomic losses.*

Uninsured Motorists coverage will be of extremely limited use.

$684,633,180
$ 71,130,720
$235,727,950

*It is assumed that a higher percentage of commercial liability insurance is for noneconomic damages, since worker's compensation would be a primary source of recovery for economic damages.

Savings from private passenger (RBI)
Savings from private passenger UM
Savings from commercial

Total Savings

$581,938,203
$ 71,130,720
$212,155,155

$865,224,078

This represents the total savings which could be realized from residual liability coverages. Individuals choosing to purchase Tort Replacement Coverage would incur the cost of that coverage, thus reducing the overall savings to the system.

Savings Estimate Development

There are four lines on page 15 of insurers' annual financial statements in which mandatory no fault automobile insurance premiums are reported.

Line 19.1
Line 19.2
Line 19.3
Line 19.4
Private passenger auto no-fault (personal injury protection)
Other private passenger auto liability
Commercial auto no-fault (personal injury protection)
Other commercial auto liability

Since lines 19.1 and 19.3 are personal injury protection premiums, lines 19.2 and 19.4 must contain all other auto coverages including residual bodily injury and property damage liability, property protection insurance, and uninsured motorists coverage.

Because it is proposed to eliminate practically all noneconomic damage lawsuits, an attempt was made to determine the amount of premium attributable to those losses.

The percentages of premium reported in line 19.2 attributable to RBI/PD and UM were determined through discussions with representatives of the private passenger auto insurance companies. From those estimates, a "best guess" estimate of the percentage of commercial auto insurance attributable to RBI/PD was developed.

After separating the premium attributable to RBI/PD, estimates from industry representatives of the percentage of RBI/PD attributable to noneconomic losses were applied.

The savings developed in Appendix I assumes no losses for noneconomic loss and elimination of the need for uninsured motorists coverage for the most part. It is recognized that the savings may be a slightly generous estimate, however the amount of tort left in the system should be extremely small.


APPENDIX II

Motorcycle/Automobile Accidents

Motorcycles are not "motor vehicles" under Michigan's no-fault auto insurance law, and are therefore not required to be covered by a no-fault policy. Motorcyclists are required to purchase only residual liability insurance with the same minimum limits as motor vehicles. Insurers that write motorcyclist liability coverage are required to offer motorcyclists first party medical coverage in increments of $5,000, but it is not a required purchase.

In the event a motorcyclist is involved in an accident that does not involve a car, the motorcyclist can collect medical benefits from the first party medical coverage, if any, or from health insurance, if any. A motorcyclist involved in an accident with a car collects personal injury protection benefits from the insurer of the car.

Because a motorcyclist is not required to purchase a no-fault policy, there would be no opportunity to purchase Tort Replacement Coverage if the cyclist wanted to be able to collect pain and suffering damages in the event of an accident with an automobile. Therefore, under this proposal, motorcyclists should be treated in the same manner as legally uninsured individuals. That is, motorcyclists should have the right to sue the negligent driver for noneconomic damages which, if awarded, would be paid by the driver's residual liability insurance coverage.


APPENDIX III

Out-of-State Drivers

Under the proposal, Michigan drivers would, for the most part, be immune from liability for noneconomic damages resulting from an automobile accident. This could be problematic for tourists and others traveling in Michigan from other states who may be involved in an accident with a Michigan driver, since, like legally uninsured drivers, they did not have the opportunity to purchase Tort Replacement Coverage.

When Michigan's no-fault system was developed, the difficulties which could be experienced by out-of-state drivers involved in accidents with Michigan residents was recognized. Although the problems could not be solved for all out-of-state drivers, the law provides the majority of non residents the same rights and immunities as Michigan insureds. Under Section 3163 of the Insurance Code, all auto insurers licensed to do business in Michigan are required to file a certification with the Insurance Bureau which provides that any accidental bodily injury or property damage occurring in Michigan which arises from the use of a motor vehicle by an out-of-state resident is subject to Michigan's no-fault system. In other words, the auto insurance policy of a nonresident insured with a company licensed in Michigan essentially converts to a Michigan no fault policy when the nonresident is driving in Michigan. Thus, even though unable to sue a Michigan driver, the nonresident is given the same limited immunity and is able to collect economic damages from his or her own policy. Like a Michigan resident, however, a nonresident currently retains the right to sue for noneconomic damages.

When the right to sue for noneconomic damages is removed, nonresidents will be left without a source of recovery for pain and suffering losses since the certification filed under Section 3163 does not include Tort Replacement Coverage. It is recommended that Section 3163 be amended to add Tort Replacement Coverage, in limits equal to the nonresident's residual liability limits, to the coverage provided by the certification filed by licensed insurers.