The Federal Telecommunications Act of 1996 is the first major overhaul of telecommunications law in almost 62 years. The Act has the potential to change the way we work, live and learn. It will affect telephone service--local and long distance, cable programming, and other video services, broadcast services and other services provided to schools and libraries. The Federal Communications Commission was given the authority by Congress to develop rulemaking that would carry out the Act including developing Federal Universal Service mechanisms which will promote Universal Service to rural and urban areas. A special amendment to the Act calls for providing discounted services to schools and libraries to ensure affordable access to advanced telecommunications services. The FCC set discounted rates from 20% to 90% on interstate services for schools and libraries. Governor Engler signed legislation on August 6, 1997, which sets rates at the same 20% to 90% levels for intrastate services.
The Universal Service Fund (USF) program, popularly known as the E-rate program, authorizes schools and libraries to be eligible to receive discounts on the purchase or lease of many telecommunications services, including local telephone and long-distance service, Internet access and internal connections. Applicants must adhere to specific criteria such as having an approved technology plan. Once federal procedures are set, applications will be processed on a first-come, first-served basis for the first $2 billion of the $2.25 billion in discounts available in 1998.
While there are no fixed allocations among states, it is estimated that Michigan schools and libraries could receive between $50 million and $110 million a year in discounts. Note that as this FAQ went to press, there were clarifications due and program changes possible from the Federal Communications Commission (FCC).
Q 1: How does a school know if it is eligible to receive a discount?
A: A school is eligible if it meets the definition of an elementary or secondary school found in the Elementary and Secondary Education Act (1965), and does not operate as a for-profit business nor have an endowment that exceeds $50 million. In Michigan, the program is open to public and non-public schools, including public school academies, that meet these criteria.
Q 2: What about eligibility requirements for libraries?
A: A library must operate as a not-for-profit business and be eligible for assistance from a state library administrative agency under the Library Services and Technology Act (LSTA). The FCC also requires that for a library to be eligible, it must be funded as an independent entity.
Q 3: How much money can each school or library that applies hope to receive?
A: No dollars change hands between a school or library and the federal government, or between a school or library and providers of telecommunications services. The USF program is a discount program, not a grant program.
Q 4: Are there advantages for eligible schools and libraries to form consortia and file a joint USF application?
A: Yes. The general rule in a competitive market such as telecommunications is the greater the demand for service, the lower the price. The FCC encourages eligible schools and libraries to aggregate demand by creating a consortium with sufficient buying power to attract competing service providers and negotiate lower pre-discount rates prior to applying the Universal Service Fund discounts.
Q 5: What types of services are eligible for USF discounts?
A: All commercially available telecommunications services, Internet access, and internal connections. The FCC did not recommend a standard telecommunications package because it believed it would be more efficient for schools and libraries to determine the services they needed or wanted.
Q 6: What are the rules related to discounts for Internet access?
A: Eligible schools and libraries can receive discounts on non-content Internet access (including e-mail), both dial-in access and dedicated connections, but discounts cannot be applied to the "content" that some information service providers bundle in a package with Internet access unless the bundled service is the most cost-effective conduit to the Internet.
Q 7: What portions of a school or library's internal connections are eligible for discounts?
A: The installation and maintenance of internal connections will be eligible for discounts. Schools and libraries may select both the specific technology and the provider(s) that best meet their needs. Included are items such as routers, hubs, network file servers (and necessary software), wiring and wireless local area networks.
Q 8: What services and equipment are NOT eligible for USF discounts?
A: Computers in particular (with the exception of network file servers), plus other hardware, software (with the exception of software needed to operate network file servers), fax machines and modems are not eligible. Upgrades to an electrical system and the removal of asbestos are not eligible. The same is true for teacher and staff training. However, schools and libraries can dedicate dollars saved thanks to the USF program toward expenditures such as these.
Q 9: Will the FCC release a list of services that are eligible and ineligible for USF discounts?
A: Probably not. The FCC gives examples, but no complete list. A spokesperson indicated that it is difficult to compile a definitive list when technology changes so rapidly.
Q 10: What is the percentage discount available to schools and libraries?
A: The percentage varies from 20% to 90% depending on: 1) whether the institution is located in a high-cost or low-cost area for telecommunications services; and 2) the institution's "level of economic disadvantage."
Q 11: How are low-cost areas distinguished from high-cost areas?
A: Low-cost areas are identified as urban counties according to the federal government's Metropolitan Statistical Area (MSA) classification.
Urban counties in Michigan are: Allegan, Bay, Berrien, Calhoun, Clinton,
Eaton, Genesee, Ingham, Jackson, Kalamazoo, Kent, Lapeer, Lenawee,
Livingston, Macomb, Midland, Monroe, Muskegon, Oakland, Ottawa, Saginaw,
St. Clair, Van Buren, Washtenaw and Wayne. All others in Michigan are categorized as rural.
Q 12: How is a school or library's level of economic disadvantage determined?
A: A school's level of economic disadvantage is defined by the percentage of its students eligible for either a free- or reduced-price lunch under the national school lunch program. A school does not have to participate in the lunch program, however. It may determine the percentage of its students who would be eligible for the program and use that figure, or it can use a federally approved alternative mechanism to determine its level of economic disadvantage. A library uses the percentage of students eligible for the lunch program in the school district in which the library is located. A matrix of discount possibilities for schools and libraries is as follows:
| School Lunch Eligible | Estimated schools in category (nationwide) | Discount for Urban Locations |
Discount for Rural Locations |
| <1% | 3% | 20% | 25% |
| 1%-19% | 31% | 40% | 50% |
| 20%-34% | 19% | 50% | 60% |
| 35%-49% | 15% | 60% | 70% |
| 50%-74% | 16% | 80% | 80% |
| 75%-100% | 16% | 90% | 90% |
Other USF information is available on the World Wide Web (WWW) from the Merit Network (http://www.merit.edu/k12.michigan/usf/).
Q 13: Which date should schools and libraries use in determining the percentage of students eligible for the national school lunch program?
A: A date has not been specified. If one is not identified by the FCC or the USF administrator, schools and libraries can pick any reasonably current month for which data is available. Statistics from October 1996 might be best. Figures are available on the web pages of both the Michigan Department of Education (http://www.mde.state.mi.us) and the Merit Network.
Q 14: When will USF discounts become available?
A: Discounts will be able to be applied on services received after January 1, 1998. The funding year for the USF program is the calendar year.
Q 15: What must schools and libraries do before they can apply for discounts on eligible telecommunications services?
A: Schools and libraries must have a technology plan that covers both the near term and the future. Plans should specify how the technology will be integrated into the curriculum. The FCC requires that plans receive independent approval. In Michigan, the Michigan Department of Education (MDE) and the Library of Michigan are performing that task.
Q 16: Is a technology plan required if the school or library only intends to apply for USF discounts on its local and long-distance phone service?
A: This is not yet clear. A report to the FCC by the E-rate Implementation Working Group suggests that certain services, such as telephone or paging services, should not require a technology plan.
Q 17: Where should a local school district submit its technology plan?
A: There is a two-step review process. To assist MDE in processing literally hundreds of technology plans in a short time, the agency created a working relationship with intermediate school districts (ISDs) and regional educational media centers (REMCs). Local districts first submit their plan to their ISD/REMC contact person (names listed at http://www.merit.edu/k12.michigan/usf/action/k12.html). If the plan includes all necessary components, it will be forwarded to MDE, which is committed to a two-week turnaround time for providing formal approval.
Q 18: Is there a model technology plan that schools can use as a guide?
A: A model plan that includes the required elements was prepared by experts in the field. It is accessible on the WWW (http://remcen.ehhs.cmich.edu/tech_plan/).
Q 19: What about technology plans for libraries?
A: In most cases, libraries submit technology plans to the Library of Michigan. School libraries are an exception. They apply for USF discounts through their school, with school technology plans to be approved by MDE.
Q 20: Where can schools and libraries get more information about components of and the submission process for technology plans?
A: Information is available on the WWW, as follows:
Schools: http://www.merit.edu/k12.michigan/usf/action/k12.html
Libraries: http://www.merit.edu/k12.michigan/usf/action/lib.html
Q 21: What is the actual application process for schools and libraries?
A: The USF program will feature a competitive bidding process. Schools and libraries will be required to complete an application that includes a description of the services requested, as well as a technology inventory. Also part of the application are a number of self-certifications, including a statement that the institution will not resell discounted services.
Q 22: What procedures are used to link schools and libraries with service providers?
A: Applications will be filed with the USF administrator, who will post them on a website dedicated to this purpose. Competing service providers can bid on individual projects. Schools and libraries must wait four weeks after their applications are posted before they can sign contracts with service providers. Once a service provider is selected and services performed, an eligible institution is only required to pay the portion of the invoice after its USF discount has been applied. The service provider bills the USF for the balance.
Q 23: Are there any exceptions to the USF bidding requirements?
A: Yes. The FCC has stated that an eligible school or library is not required to comply with the USF bidding requirements for any contract for telecommunications services that is signed after November 8, 1996, and before the competitive bidding system is operational, but only if that contract is restricted to services provided to the school or library before December 31, 1998. Contracts entered into prior to November 8, 1996, for any length of contract service are not subject to the USF bidding process. Schools and libraries may take advantage of buying telecommunications services and related equipment from contracts negotiated by the Michigan Department of Management and Budget or through collaboratives such as MiCTA within the constraints outlined above. These opportunities provide a large consortia buying power to achieve attractive pre-discount prices.
Q 24: Does the USF bidding process take the place of any state and local competitive bidding requirements?
A: No. USF applicants must adhere to all state and local procurement requirements that routinely apply in the acquisition of telecommunications services and products.
Q 25: What must state government do in Michigan before schools and libraries here are eligible to participate in the USF program?
A: All states are required to adopt a discount matrix for intrastate services that provides at least an equal benefit to schools and libraries as does the FCC matrix for interstate services. The Michigan Legislature took action this summer and Governor Engler signed legislation on August 6, 1997, which establishes the discount matrix for intrastate services.
Q 26: What must still occur before schools and libraries can apply for USF discounts?
A: The federal government must complete the preparation of USF forms, and the website must be activated where applications and descriptions of services can be posted. The FCC will issue a public notice--to be published in the Federal Register--identifying the exact date that the competitive bidding system will become operational. Immediately afterward, schools and libraries should be able to begin submitting requests for USF discounts.
Q 27: Is the USF initiative a year-to-year program?
A: Yes. Schools and libraries must apply on an annual basis for USF discounts. The FCC also may implement changes in the program from one year to the next. For example, school and library technology plans could be subjected to a more critical review in the future.
Q 28: How can schools and libraries keep informed about developments in the USF program?
A: There are a number of websites dedicated to providing information about the USF program. Two are operated by the FCC, and another is administered by the Merit Network:
http://www.merit.edu/k12.michigan/usf/
A variety of Michigan organizations, including Merit, the Michigan Department of Education, the Library of Michigan and the Office of the Michigan Information Network, are staffing a listserv dedicated to answering questions about the USF program. To subscribe, send an email message to:
In the body of the message, type:
subscribe minwg-share
Also, state agency contact people include:
Jamey Fitzpatrick, Michigan Department of Education
517/373-6331 or fitz@mde.state.mi.us
George Needham, Library of Michigan
517/373-5504 or gneedham@libofmich.lib.mi.us
Linda Schatz, Office of the Michigan Information Network
517/241-0572 or SchatzL@state.mi.us
Kathy Withrow, Michigan Department of Education, Office of Grants
& Technology
(517) 373-6331 Fax:(517) 373-3325 or kwithrow@ed.mde.state.mi.us
Go Back to Statement To Governor's Education Summit Participants