For most of us, the model of the Earth as a sphere is sufficient for our needs. Geodetic scientists and others do important research to develop models that are more accurate than the simple, but clearly imperfect, spherical model of the Earth's surface. When the spherical model is used as the domain in a transformation carrying the Earth's surface to the plane, to create flat maps of the Earth's surface, further distortion is necessarily the result. These derived maps reflect both the inaccuracy of the base model and of its transformation to a different surface. It is these imperfect maps, nonetheless, that often serve as foundation material for planning and other decision-making processes that circumscribe our everyday lives. The nature of the base models which subtly envelop our lives is critical to understand: specific applications often fall from broad conceptual models. To illustrate the thought-processes developed here, we begin with a detailed analysis of a familiar surface: the sphere. Thus, the reader has that model in mind as a benchmark against which to visualize less-familiar surfaces and processes.
To navigate
a surface, be that navigation in the real or virtual world, one needs some
sort of chart and method for finding paths from here to there. On
the spherical model of the Earth, one conventional system involves the
use of parallels and meridians. To understand the nature of this
system consider a plane and a sphere in three-dimensional space.
There are two broad logical relationships between them: either the
plane does not intersect the sphere or the plane does intersect the sphere.
This relationship serves as a mathematical partition of the space:
it separates the space into mutually-exclusive, yet exhaustive, classes.
Within the second class, one might further specify the partition:
either the plane is tangent to the sphere or it is not tangent to the sphere.
In the latter instance the plane cuts the sphere, as a cutting-plane,
in a circular cross-section, much as a knife might cut into an orange.
With the "orange" idea in mind, the class of circular cross-sections can
then be further partitioned into circles containing the center of the sphere
and circles not containing the center of the sphere. A diagram illustrating
the hierarchical arrangement of this partition appears in Figure 1.
Figure 1. Hierarchical arrangement of one partition of the relationship of a plane and a sphere. |
When the sphere in the above
paragraph is specified to be a representation of the Earth's surface, then
two other points, in addition to the center of the sphere, become involved
in the system: the north and south poles. These points lie
at opposite ends of a diameter of the sphere: they are antipodal
(opposite feet). Circles containing the center of the Earth
are conventionally called great circles: they are the largest
circles possible. All other circles, those not containing the center
of the Earth, are therefore called small circles. There is an infinite
number of great circles and an infinite number of small circles.
There is, however, exactly one great circle that bisects the distance between
the poles: that great circle is called the equator.
Its role is like that of the horizontal axis in the Cartesian coordinate
system. A set of small circles, whose cutting-planes are parallel
to the cutting-plane of the equator, become grid lines on either
side of the horizontal axis. This set is called a set of parallels.
Notice, however, that it is the cutting-planes that generate the small
circles, and not the small circles themselves, that are parallel.
The parallels specify location to the north and south of the equator but
not east to west. One way to do so is to introduce a set of lines
that cut across the horizontal set in an orthogonal fashion: a set of great
circles that intersect each other at the poles function in this manner.
The halves of these great circles, from pole to pole, are called
meridians
(half circles reflecting the earth-sun relationship that on the equinoxes,
and only on the equinoxes, any full meridian spends half the day in light
and half in night). One meridian is singled out for unique characterization
as the "vertical axis" meridian; historical convention followed today in
many parts of the world is to use the meridian passing through the Royal
Observatory in Greenwich, England. This unique meridian is called
the prime meridian. This arrangement of a grid on a
sphere, often called a graticule, is shown in Figure 2. Location
of a point P on the sphere may be specified in terms of parallels
and meridians. However, different observers may create different
graticules. Thus, location is relative to graticule choice as is
shown in the animation in Figure 2: one frame shows P as one
parallel to the north of the Equator and four meridians to the west of
the Prime Meridian while the other shows the same point P as six
parallels to the north of the Equator and 24 meridians to the west of the
Prime Meridian. Both are correct; the navigation to P depends on
how the system was set up. This relative locational strategy
does not permit replication of results.
Figure 2. Location of P is relative to chosen graticule. Replication of results is not likely. |
What is needed to produce
a natural replication of results is the introduction of some standard system
of measure--to convert relative to absolute location.
Most people agree to a measure of circles that splits them into some number
of equally sized wedge-shaped pieces, measured from the center to the perimeter.
Some use degrees, some use radians, but basically the idea is the same:
transformation from one system to another is easy. For the sake of
illustation, we use degrees but the idea is the same independent of particular
choice. In either of the graticules in Figuer 2, the point P
lies 30 degrees north of the equator and 120 degrees west of the prime
meridian. The great circle passing through the two poles and the
point P contains 360 degrees:
P is located 30 degrees from
the Equator and to its north (Figure 3). This measure is called latitude.
The small circle passing through P also contains 360 degrees: P
is located 120 degrees from the prime meridian and to its west (Figure
3).
Figure 3. Absolute location. Circular measure standardizes location and ensures replication of results. |
LEVEL CURVES AND PROFILES
Level
Curves.
The term "level curve" is
one that has precise mathematical definition and is not generally in common
use. Intuitively, if one considers an arbitrary surface and puts
the surface on a base plane, the level curves of the surface are
the curves projected into the base plane by orthogonal projection of the
cross-sections of the surface generated by a set of cutting-planes parallel
to the base plane. Rigorously, ...to come...
Profiles
The term "profile" is one
that is in common use and admits a variety of definitions, including mathematical
characterization of that common use. One often speaks of a profile
of a person showing prominent features, such as a nose, clearly silhouetted
against a background.
THE EARTH: PARALLELS
AND MERIDIANS
In the spherical model of the Earth outlined above, yet another way to
think of the graticule is as a set of level curves and profiles.
Place the Earth-sphere on a plane tangent to the Earth at the South Pole
(or North Pole). The parallels are now a set of level curves.
Look at the model from the side; a meridian going from North to South Poles
is a profile of this Earth-sphere viewed as a head or face.
MOUNTAINS: CONTOURS
AND VERTICAL PROFILES
The sphere
is not an accurate replica of the Earth: it is a model and it is
a useful model. The cone is not an accurate replica of a mountain:
it is a model. The level curves of this model, when projected onto
the natural base plane, are circles. The cone's profile is a straight
line with slope identical to the climb from base to summit. This
model is much smaller in scope than is the sphere as an Earth model.
Thus, the omitted detail becomes apparent and the broad general model is
not useful in real-world applications.
Because single mountains,
let alone systems of mountains, do not generally fit nice mathematical
shapes and equations, it is not possible to begin with the equation of
a mountain and simply drop out the level curves as contours and profiles
as paths to the top. The synthetic approach, of beginning with the
whole and letting the parts evolve from the whole, is not possible--there
is insufficient knowledge. The analytic approach, of beginning with
the parts and using them to approximate the whole, is the only one available.
Level curves are generated, with considerable effort and expense, as contours
(lines of equal elevation), often by various government agencies.
Profiles, showing paths over summits and through valleys, are generated
as vertical profiles from contours. These two sets are used
to infer general three dimensional object shape, much as one may
infer spherical shape from looking at a fine mesh of parallels and meridians.
Entire systems of mountains are modeled in this fashion and these models
are made to fit with the models of the Earth using established coordinate
systems to standardize the models.
SYSTEMS OF CITIES:
ZIPF LEVEL CURVES AND PROFILES
A set of cities may be rank-ordered
according to population (or any number of other variables). When
it is, and the largest city is assigned the rank of 1, the next largest
the rank of 2, and so forth, it follows that there is an inverse relationship
between rank and population size. Zipf characterized this relationship
as the "rank-size rule" and noted that the pattern inferred from plotting
actual data corresponded to the equation xy=K. West, Brown,
Enquist, and Savage characterize this rule as:
The empirically observed regularity is that settlements of rank r in the descending (size) array of settlements have a size equal to 1/r of the size of the largest settlement in the system. In other words, when the population size of towns is plotted against their frequency on a logarithmic scale, we see an approximately straight line with an exponent of -1. This relationship is known as the 'rank-size rule'.Scholars have often debated how to restructure this equation: is rank a function of population? That idea seems raasonable since larger cities have lower ranks. Then again, one might view population as a function of rank: higher ranked cities may attract larger concentrations of people as economies of scale grow non-linearly with size. There is a great deal of recent, and not so recent, literature on this topic. Often, the Zipf rule is seen as the simplest in a set of "power laws." What we offer here is a different vantage point and a vantage point that is consistent with the process discussed above.
Thus, we consider the idea of not restructuring the equation but simply looking at xy=K and not at y=f(x) or as x=f(y). There are a couple of interesting two dimensional numerical properties of xy=K.
The branches of the hyperbola
in the 1st and 3rd quadrants may be rotated about the line y=x to
generate a surface of revolution composed of two dish or bowl-shaped objects
facing outward from the origin (Figure 4). That solid structure is
called an hyperboloid of two sheets ("sheets" is the 3-dimensional equivalent
of the 2-dimensional "branches"). Thus, the Zipf equation may also
be characterized by an hyperboloid of two sheets. When that surface
is viewed as a base surface, its profile is the Zipf curve in the xy
plane.
Figure 4. Hyperboloid of two sheets generated from rotating xy=K about the line y=x. |
![]() |
![]() |
Often, in rank-size graphs, one sees sets of curves illustrating various rank-size relationships; the curves appear at varying distances from the origin. Each of these curves could be viewed as a profile line of an hyperboloid of two sheets at the appropriate distance from the origin. Often, distance from the origin and steepness of a rank-size curve is discussed in the context of eveness of the distribution of cities or level of concentration of cities along a given curve: steeper curves, closer to the origin may have more uneven, or more concentrated, distributions of cities than do their flatter counterparts farther from the origin. To make such comparisons, as with the necessity on the globe for measurement standardization in relation to different graticules, one must have some sort of consistent agreed-upon means for measuring steepness.
Measures of steepness are often only relative measures and do not lend themselves to replication of results by different individuals. Thus, one might see a real estate developer before a planning commission arguing that the parcel under consideration for additional development has only a .5% grade because the back half is wetland and clearly undevelopable. A careful commissioner might argue, however, that in fact the parcel has a 4.5% grade when measured on its longest diagonal, independent of parcel content involving natural features. Laws may standardize how steepness is to be measured: in relation to plats or in relation to buildable area. Without such standardization, however, the developer and the commissioner are not likely to come to terms.
The same sort of problem arises in measuring steepness or slope in any arena. In the case of the Zipf curves, the slope at the rank 1 city is no doubt very different from the slope at the rank 10 city. Should one connect the dots representing cities and look at some sort of average slope? It seems important to have some sort of consistent strategy for deciding what is the slope of a Zipf curve. One such method draws on looking at the level curves of the hyperboloid of two sheets. The slope of a line tangent to xy=K is found easily. For, dy/dx = Kd(1/x)/dx = K*(-1/x2). Again, if one wishes to have a numerical value associated wtih the slope, there are an infinite number of choices. Note, though, that the level curves of the hyperboloid are circles whose planes are parallel to the plane of the line tangent to the curve at (K0.5, K0.5) where the line y=x intersects the curve. Thus, as with the case of the selection of the equator as a unique position within an infinite set, the value K*(-1/K) = -1 emerges as a unique choice for the slope of a Zipf curve within an infinite set. The use of the hyperboloid and observations about its level curves led to this determination.
If the hyperboloid of two
sheets is the GeoSurface associated with Zipf curves, then one might wish
to have an "atlas" based on this surface. We leave that to further
work; the purpose here is to identify broad, sensible geometric concepts.
SYSTEMS OF CITIES: LÖSCHIAN LEVEL CURVES AND PROFILES.
The equation x2 +
xy + y2 = K generates all central place K-values.
It also represents an elliptic paraboloid with major axis along the line
y=x,
illustrating the appropriateness of choosing the line y=x, as a
central axis, in the Fundamental Theorem cited in Fractals Take
a Central Place. The level curves of this solid are ellipses and
the profiles are parabolas. For a particular central place K-value,
the ellipse at height K will contain all the integral solutions
to the Diophantine equation: a small set of values. The level
curve itself, however, has an infinite number of points on it, each of
which could be projected into the plane as an ellipse. Thus, one
might consider K-values for real numbers, not merely for integral
values, as yet another way of looking between dimensions (especially when
coupled with the fractal approach to central place theory). Again,
that too, is an intriguing topic for substantial additional investigation
when one considers the elliptic paraboloid of Figure 5 as the GeoSurface
of central place theory.
![]() |
OTHER--chapter exploring fractal connection hinted at above.
MORE FOR eBOOK; TOBLER'S WORK ON PYNCNOPHYLACTIC SURFACES (VOLUME-PRESERVING TRANSFORMATIONS) AND GOULD'S COVER ON MENTAL MAPS---ALSO D'ARCY THOMPSON.
Pareto...
Computer software may be
quite helpful in modeling terrain from given data about elevation.
With such a model in hand, and with knowledge that contours are in fact
level curves of the terrain, it is an easy matter to flood (in a simple
way) computer-generated terrain simply by pulling, through animation, a
plane covered with water texture up through the modeled terrain.
The attached link shows
such a model based on data for the City of Ann Arbor (under construction--this
is a draft model...the reader needs to load the free download Cortona as
a browser plug-in to see the virtual reality).
Indeed, Peter Gould's fascinating cover on Mental Maps shows the human face as a topographic map (but without regard for the curvature of the underlying head). In terms of the model above, Gould's approach is similar conceptually to the idea of using a mountain-system only coordinate system, based on polar coordinate paper (as composed of level curves and profiles of a set of cones) as a way to map the mountains. That is, out of context with the basic surface on which the mountains appear. To put the face map into that context, one might imagine instead the human head as a set of level curves (parallels) and profiles (meridians) and map these into the plane carrying facial features with them and then perform a topographic analysis of the mapped points.
a variety of footnotes and
references to come, throughout.
when one curve is farther from the origin than the other, all this means is that the size of the system in terms of its population is larger ie the biggest city and all subsequent cities by rank in the higher curve are bigger than the biggest city and subsequent cities in the lower curve. If the curves cross, then this means that the distributions are more convoluted and usually in the case of the steeper curve this means that the distribution of cities is more uneven - more concentrated perhaps - than for the flatter curve.
Ill read the stuff with interest
Mike